Chapter 1: The Last E Train
The Halloway closed at six, and after that it belonged to Teddy Novak.
He liked it best in the first hour after the cleaners left, when the marble still held the smell of lemon polish and the radiators ticked like someone had left a clock running in every room. He walked the route the way Marcus had taught him six years ago: basement loading dock, the Dutch rooms, the long gallery, the sculpture court under its glass roof, up the main stair to the Americans, and then the fourth floor, where the conservation studio kept its light on later than anything else in the building.
He walked it slowly. A man his size learned early that fast was frightening. At six foot six and two hundred and forty pounds of shoulders and muscle, he had been asked to leave a china shop at the age of nineteen for doing nothing but turning around. So he moved through the Halloway the way you moved through a sleeping house, heel first, hands loose, breathing quiet. The cameras on the ceiling swung on their slow arcs above him, little black domes that panned left for forty-five seconds and right for forty-five, and he had stopped noticing them the way you stop noticing your own pulse.
What he noticed was the paintings.
There was a small Corot in the French room, a road and some trees and a woman in a red cap no bigger than a grain of rice, and a little before midnight the security lights caught her cap and made it glow. He had seen it maybe a thousand times. He still stopped.
"You always stop there."
He turned, carefully. Anjali Rao stood at the doorway with her coat over one arm and her bag across her chest, a brush stuck through the knot of black hair at the back of her head like a pin through a map. She was five foot one in her boots. The top of her head came to roughly the second button of his shirt, which he knew because she had once told him so, poking it.
"It's the red," Teddy said. "One dot of it. The whole painting's built around it."
"Mm." She came and stood next to him and looked at the woman in the cap. "Corot used to add a red accent at the very end. Like salt. Sometimes he'd do it in front of buyers, to show off."
"Did it work?"
"He was rich, Teddy."
He smiled at that. He had a big, slow, crooked smile, and she watched it happen the way she watched varnish dry: patiently, with the expression of someone filing information for later. He had noticed her watching him about two months ago. He had decided it meant nothing about two months ago, too, and had been re-deciding it every night since.
"You're early," he said. "It's not even midnight."
"I'm waiting on a solvent test. I can't look at the Hartley for another hour without wanting to throw it out the window." She tipped her head toward the stair. "Walk me down when you do the long gallery?"
"I always walk you down."
"I know," she said. "I'm being polite. Practise."
The Hartley was the reason she was here at all. It was a nine-foot landscape of the Hudson that some heir had varnished in 1952 with a product that turned brown in the light, and the Halloway had hired her two years ago to take sixty years of that brown back off without touching a single original brushstroke underneath. She worked on it in squares the size of a postage stamp, with cotton swabs on bamboo sticks she rolled herself, under a magnifier on a jointed arm. Teddy had stood in the door of the studio one night in her first month and watched her do one square for forty minutes. The sky came up under her swab like a blue morning under fog.
"You can come in," she had said, without looking up. "You're blocking my light."
"I'm sorry." He had stepped back.
"No, I mean come in and stand on the other side. You're very big and you're blocking all of it."
That had been the start. After that he timed his rounds so he came through the fourth floor around midnight and again just before one, when she packed up. He told himself it was because a woman alone in a building at one in the morning should have someone walk her to the door. That was true. It was also true that he would have done it if she'd been carrying a rifle.
Just before one he found her in the studio pulling her coat on, swearing softly at the left sleeve, which had turned inside out.
"Here."
He held it for her. She looked at him over her shoulder, then put her arm back and let him guide it in, and he settled the coat on her shoulders with two fingers on the collar. She was warm through the wool. Her hair smelled like turpentine and something sweeter, oranges maybe. He took his hands away before she could think anything about them.
"Thank you," she said. Then, "You do that very carefully."
"Do what?"
"Everything." She picked up her bag. "You hold doors like they're paintings. You put your coffee down like it's going to go off. The other night you moved a stanchion in the long gallery and it didn't make a sound. Do you know how hard it is to move a brass stanchion without a sound? I've heard Marcus drop one. It sounded like a car accident."
"Marcus has a lot on his mind."
"Teddy."
"It's the job," he said. "Everything in here is worth more than my apartment."
"Everything in here is worth more than my apartment too, and I clank." She went past him into the hall, and he turned off her lamp and followed.
The walk from the Halloway to the subway was nine minutes at her pace and four at his, so it took nine. It was October and the city had that cold, clean smell it gets for about three weeks a year, between the garbage of summer and the slush of winter. The trees along the park were going yellow under the streetlights. A man walked six small dogs across Madison as if it were noon.
"What's the worst thing anyone's ever done to a painting you worked on?" Teddy asked. It was a game. She asked him things about the night shift, he asked her about the work.
"Besides the Hartley varnish?" She thought. "A man in Philadelphia overpainted a nude so his wife would let him hang her in the dining room. He gave her a dress. A really ugly dress, Teddy. Mustard. Puffed sleeves. I spent four months taking it off her."
"Was she grateful?"
"She looked like she could breathe again." Anjali glanced up at him. "Your turn. Worst thing that's ever happened on a night."
"A raccoon got into the café in the spring."
"Stop."
"Ate a whole tray of almond croissants and then sat in the gift shop window looking at me. Like I was the one who was trespassing."
"What did you do?"
"I called animal control and sat on the floor and talked to him till they came."
She laughed, a real laugh with her head thrown back, and he felt it somewhere under his ribs. "Of course you did. What did you talk about?"
"Croissants, mainly. I told him about Vermeer."
"You did not."
"He was a good listener."
They waited at the light at Fifth and Fifty-Ninth. A cab went by fast enough to blow her coat open, and without thinking about it Teddy put out his arm and she stepped back into it, and for one second his forearm was across the front of her, his hand on her far shoulder. She was so small against him that he could have closed his hand around the whole curve of her shoulder and had fingers to spare. He felt her breathe in. He felt her not move away.
He moved away.
"Sorry," he said.
"For what?" She was looking at the traffic, not him. Her voice was very even. "Stopping me getting hit by a cab? Terrible. I'm going to report you."
The light changed. They crossed.
He had grown up in Ridgewood, over a bakery, the son of a Czech baker who was five foot seven and a Czech mother who was five foot two, and nobody in the family had ever explained where he came from. His father used to joke that the hospital had swapped him with a Polish wrestler's son. By the time he could shave, Teddy had been the biggest person in every room. By twenty he had been working doors in Manhattan, and it had taken him exactly one bad night outside a club on West Twenty-Seventh, a drunk with a broken bottle and Teddy's own hand on the man's wrist, squeezing a little harder than it needed to, to understand that the most dangerous thing in any room he walked into was him. He had heard the bones go. He had paid for the man's surgery, months of wages, and he had quit, and he had spent the thirteen years since learning to be very, very gentle.
He'd found the Halloway by accident, answering an ad. Marcus had looked at him across a desk and said, "You know anything about art?" and Teddy had said, "No, sir," and Marcus had said, "Good. Don't touch it." Six years later he could tell a Sargent from a Chase across a dark room by the way the white was put down, and he had never touched anything.
He thought about this on the stairs down to the E train while Anjali dug in her bag for her MetroCard. He thought about the way she had stood still under his arm.
"You're doing the face," she said.
"What face?"
"The thinking face. Your forehead goes like a radiator." She found the card and held it up between two fingers. "Teddy, can I ask you something?"
"Sure."
"Why do you always stop at the top of the stairs?"
He looked down. They were at the turnstiles, and he was where he always was, one step outside the bars, hands in his pockets. Behind her the platform hummed. A train was coming; he could feel it in the soles of his feet.
"I'm not going your way," he said. "I'm going back to work."
"You could come down and wait with me. It's a long wait at this hour."
"Then I'd have to go back up."
"You'd have to go back up anyway." She swiped her card. The turnstile clunked. She stood on the other side of it and looked at him through the bars with those sharp dark eyes, and there was something deliberate in the way she held still, as if she were letting him take a long look at a thing she had prepared. "You're very careful, Teddy Novak."
"You said."
"I'm saying it again. Because I'm curious." The train roared into the station behind her, all light and wind, and her hair came half out of its knot and the brush slipped, and she caught it without looking. She pointed it at him like a small sable-tipped sword. "I want to know what you're like when you aren't."
The doors opened. She stepped backward onto the train, still looking at him. The doors closed. He stood at the turnstile with his hands in his pockets and watched her go, a small woman in a dark coat holding a paintbrush, until the last car slid into the tunnel.
Then he walked back to the Halloway, which took four minutes, and stood in the French room in front of the woman in the red cap for a long time.
At a quarter past two he found the note on the guard desk. It was on a square of the museum's conservation tissue, folded twice, and it was written in pencil in a neat, slanting hand.
Camera 22, fourth floor east corridor, misses the studio door for 31 seconds of every sweep. I timed it. Tomorrow I'm going to ask you a question. You can say no. — A.
He read it three times. Then he folded it back along its creases, put it in the sketchbook in his breast pocket, and did his rounds, and he did not hear a single thing in the building for the rest of the night except his own heart.