Cover of Alpha's Dilemma

Alpha's Dilemma

Read the story

1 chapter · 1919 words · Read 1 times

Nicole Page is best friends with Austin Powell. Austin's father Logan Powell is one of the Alphas in their pack. Over the years Nicole and Logan had a connection, now that she turned 18 he finds himself wanting her as a mate. He holds back knowing that Austin wants her as a mate and knows the both of them are dating. They both try to manage their instincts, but find it harder as their wolves crave to mate. Nicole has to choose if she can mate one or the other while Austin and Logan fight or come together.

Chapter 1: Alpha's Claim Under the Blood Moon

The cold night air clung to their skin as Nicole and Austin stumbled through the back door of the pack house, laughing breathlessly. The scent of pine and damp earth rolled off them, mingling with the warmer, closed-in smells of wood polish and last night’s stew. Nicole’s blood still thrummed from the run, her senses expanded and alive. She could hear the distant, fading howls of the pack on the wind, the creak of the old porch swing, the steady, strong beat of Austin’s heart beside her.

“I told you I’d beat you to the creek,” Austin said, bumping his shoulder against hers. His blond hair was mussed, his cheeks flushed from the cold and the chase.

“You cheated. You took the low path through the brambles,” Nicole shot back, pulling off her mud-spattered boots. Her own dark hair had escaped its ponytail, strands sticking to her neck. She felt wild and free, her wolf content from the moonlit sprint.

“Strategic advantage, Page. It’s not cheating.”

The living room was dim, lit only by a single lamp beside the large armchair. And in that chair, a shadow moved. The newspaper in his hands lowered with a soft rustle.

Logan.

He was still dressed in dark slacks and a grey henley, the sleeves pushed up to his elbows, as if he’d never considered sleep. The lamp light carved the planes of his face into sharp angles, his green eyes catching the glow like a cat’s. He looked from his son to Nicole, his expression unreadable, but the air in the room shifted. It grew heavier, charged with a silent energy that made the fine hairs on Nicole’s arms rise.

“You’re out late,” Logan said, his voice a low rumble that vibrated in the quiet room.

Austin, seemingly oblivious to the sudden tension, grinned. “Full moon, Dad. Couldn’t waste it.” He draped an arm loosely around Nicole’s shoulders, pulling her into his side. He smelled of fresh air and boyish sweat, familiar and easy. “Nicole almost took a badger head-on. It was epic.”

Logan’s gaze fixed on where Austin’s hand rested on Nicole’s arm. A muscle in his jaw feathered. “I heard the commotion. The badger’s den is off-limits for a reason.”

“We were fine,” Nicole said, her voice softer than she intended. Under Logan’s stare, her pulse did a strange, skittering thing. It wasn’t fear. It was something else, a deep, primal awareness that tightened her stomach. Her wolf, so settled just moments ago, lifted its head inside her, interested.

“Obviously,” Logan said, his eyes still on her. He didn’t look at Austin.

An awkward silence stretched. Austin cleared his throat, giving Nicole a gentle squeeze before letting his arm drop. “I’m gonna hit the shower. I smell like a wet forest floor.” He leaned in, pressing a quick, chaste kiss to Nicole’s cheek. His lips were warm. “Night, Nic.”

“Night, Austin.”

He bounded up the stairs, his footsteps fading. The silence he left behind was profound, filled only by the ticking of the old grandfather clock in the hall. Nicole stood there, suddenly conscious of her dirty socks on the polished wood floor, of the leaf probably stuck in her hair, of Logan’s unwavering attention. She should go, too. Up to the guest room that had become more or less hers.

“You’re tracking mud,” Logan stated, folding the newspaper with precise, deliberate motions. He set it aside.

“Sorry.” The word was automatic. She bent to pick up her boots.

“Leave them.”

She froze, straightening slowly. He had risen from his chair, a study in controlled power. He was so much bigger up close, his presence filling the space between the furniture, the room itself seeming to shrink. He didn’t approach her like Austin did, with a loping, open gait. He moved like water finding its path—inevitable, smooth, and completely in command of the space he occupied.

“I was just going to get some water,” she said, more to break the silence than anything, and moved toward the kitchen doorway.

“Good idea.”

He followed her.

Not like Austin would have, talking the whole way. Logan’s silence was a tangible pressure against her back. The kitchen was dark, illuminated only by the pale blue moonlight streaming through the window over the sink. Nicole went to the cupboard for a glass, her movements feeling clumsy. The tap water was shockingly cold. She took a long drink, trying to settle the strange flutter in her chest.

She felt him before she heard him. The heat of him, the unique, clean scent of alpha, storm-wind and cedar and pure, undeniable strength. It enveloped her, cutting through the scents of soap and stainless steel.

Her breath hitched. She set the glass down too hard on the counter.

His hands came down on the counter on either side of her, caging her in. He didn’t touch her, not yet, but his body was a solid line of heat against her back. She could feel the hard plane of his chest, the strength in his thighs just behind her own.

“Logan…” His name was a whisper, a question.

“You let him kiss you.” His voice was a soft, dangerous thing by her ear. It wasn’t a question.

“It was just on the cheek. He’s my friend.”

“He’s not thinking of you as a friend.” One of his hands left the counter. It came to rest, large and heavy, on her hip. A claiming, possessive touch that burned through the fabric of her leggings. “And you know it.”

She did know it. She swallowed, her throat dry. “He’s your son.”

“I know exactly who he is.” His fingers flexed, digging in slightly. A low growl, so deep it was almost inaudible, resonated in his chest, transmitting through her own body. His other hand came up, his fingers pushing into her hair, tilting her head just enough to expose the line of her throat. His nose brushed the sensitive skin there, and he inhaled deeply. “You smell like the night. And like him. I don’t like it.”

His words were a spark to tinder. A flare of defiance rose in her, mingled with a thrill so sharp it was almost painful. “You don’t get to dictate what I do.”

“Don’t I?” The hand on her hip slid around, splaying across her lower stomach and pulling her back firmly, insistently, against him. The evidence of his want was hard and undeniable against the small of her back. A jolt of pure, undiluted heat shot through her. Her wolf surged forward, not in panic, but in recognition, in answer.

This was not Austin’s sweet, fumbling affection. This was a demand. A question posed with the whole body. Her own body answered before her mind could form a protest, a soft, traitorous sound escaping her lips as she arched back into him.

It was all the permission he needed.

His hand left her hair, yanking at the waistband of her leggings and her underwear, dragging them down her thighs in one rough, efficient motion. The cold air of the kitchen kissed her skin, followed immediately by the blistering heat of his palm on her bare hip. She braced her hands on the edge of the sink, her knuckles white.

“Logan, wait—” The protest was weak, dissolved by the sensation of his other hand working the buckle of his belt, the rasp of his zipper in the quiet dark.

He didn’t answer with words. He answered with the press of his body, the blunt, firm push of himself against her, and then into her. A sharp, full sensation stole her breath. He was large, stretching her, and there was a fleeting burn that made her gasp before it melted into a devastating fullness.

He went perfectly still, buried deep, his forehead dropping to her shoulder. His whole body was a cord of tensed steel. His breath was ragged in her ear. “Nicole.”

It was a curse. A prayer.

Then he began to move.

It was not fast. It was agonizingly, devastatingly slow. A long, deliberate withdrawal followed by a relentless, deep surge. Each stroke was a conquest, a claiming of territory she hadn’t known she was guarding. Her thoughts shattered. There was only this: the cold granite under her palms, the slick sound of their joining, the scent of their arousal thick in the air, the overwhelming sense of him surrounding her, inside and out.

His hand slid from her stomach up, under her sweatshirt and sports bra, covering her breast. His thumb brushed over her nipple, and she cried out, the sound swallowed by the night. He muffled his own groan against her shoulder, his teeth scraping her skin.

“This is wrong,” she panted, even as she pushed back against him, meeting his slow, deep rhythm.

“It is.” His voice was gritted, strained with the effort of his control. “It’s also the only thing that’s felt right in years.”

His pace remained measured, torturous, every push hitting a spot deep inside her that made her vision blur. She was unraveling, coming apart at the seams under the relentless, focused possession. This wasn’t just sex. It was a conversation in a language older than words. Her wolf preened, howling in triumph at being taken by the strongest one, at the sheer dominance of his hold.

He shifted his angle minutely and the world exploded into white-hot pleasure. It tore through her, wave after wave, pulling a raw, broken sound from her throat. As her muscles convulsed around him, his control finally snapped.

His arm banded around her waist, locking her to him as his thrusts lost their rhythm, becoming hard, frantic, final. A guttural snarl ripped from him, more beast than man, as he drove into her one last, shuddering time and spilled himself deep within her.

For a long moment, there was only the sound of their ragged breathing mingling in the dark. The moonlit kitchen came back into focus, the familiar shapes of the stove, the fridge, the table. Everything was the same. And nothing was.

Slowly, reluctantly, his grip loosened. He withdrew, the loss of him leaving her feeling hollowed out and trembling. She heard him right his clothes, the soft metallic whisper of his zipper a period at the end of a sentence she couldn't unsay.

She couldn’t turn around. She couldn’t face him. Shame, elation, terror, and a fierce, primal satisfaction warred within her.

His hands settled on her hips again, not as a possessor now, but as a steadier. He gently tugged her clothing back into place. The gesture was almost tender, and it confused her more than anything else that had happened.

His lips brushed the shell of her ear, his voice a raw whisper. “Now you smell like me.”

Then the heat of him was gone. She heard his footsteps retreat across the kitchen floor, pause in the doorway.

“Go to bed, Nicole,” he said, his Alpha voice back in place, layered now with something darker, more final.

She didn’t move until she heard his study door click shut down the hall. She was left alone in the blue moonlight, the scent of their transgression clinging to her skin, the ghost of his possession etched into her bones. Upstairs, the shower had stopped running. Austin was in his room, just a ceiling away, innocently waiting for tomorrow.

And she was here, forever changed, caught between the boy she thought she might love and the man who had just rewritten her destiny with devastating, silent certainty.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI