Cover of An Errant Wish

11 chapters · 36261 words · Read 0 times

Nathan, a masculine guy has a crush on his incredibly sweet best friend Molly. In an attempt to console her after a breakup, Nathan makes a wish that accidentally slowly transforms him into a female form that Molly is very attracted to. Molly's own wish will accidentally make her grow a huge cock above her pussy. The two will gently explore their new bodies, in spite of their hesitation and confusion. All characters are over the age of 18.

Chapter 2: The Transference

The cheap, sticky vinyl of Molly’s apartment door clicked shut behind them, muffling the distant city hum. The abrupt silence felt heavy, charged. Molly stumbled, giggling, clutching Nathan’s arm for balance. Her tequila breath was warm against his neck.

"Whoa there, champ," Nathan murmured, steering her towards the worn, overstuffed couch. His voice sounded wrong to his own ears. Thinner. Higher? His mind was still reeling from the pulsating chaos of the bar, the impossible heat that had roared through him after Molly’s slurred confession. ‘I wish I knew what it felt like to fuck someone like me.’ The words echoed, colliding violently with the strange, deep ache settling into his bones.

"Yeah, yeah, I'm fine," Molly waved a dismissive hand, collapsing onto the cushions. She kicked off her sparkly heels, sighing dramatically. "Just... fuzzy. Everything's kinda... spinny-warm. You feel that? Like... buzzing?" She looked up at him, her eyes wide and slightly unfocused in the soft glow of the fairy lights strung across the ceiling. Photos of them – hiking trips, beach days, ridiculous karaoke nights – watched silently from the walls.

Nathan stood frozen. He did feel it. But it wasn't just the booze. It was inside. A profound, unsettling shift. His muscles, the solid arms that felt strong catching passes on the rec field yesterday, felt… soft. Like dough slowly proofing. He flexed his bicep instinctively under his shirt. The familiar, satisfying tension was muted, replaced by a yielding pliability. Panic, cold and sharp, sliced through the lingering warmth from the bar.

"I... need some water," he rasped, needing distance, needing to see. He practically fled to Molly’s tiny kitchenette, flipping on the harsh overhead light. The reflection in the chrome kettle stopped him dead.

The face staring back wasn't entirely his. The strong jawline he’d always considered a bit too blocky was… smoothing out. Refining. Angles softening into curves beneath the skin. He ran a trembling hand along his jaw. It felt alien, the bone structure subtly retreating under a layer of new, unfamiliar softness. His throat constricted.

What the hell is happening?

He filled a glass, his movements jerky. The sensation was intensifying. A low thrum, a cellular vibration, seemed to emanate from his core. And then it hit him – a sudden, sharp tingling sensation radiating outwards across his chest. Not pain, exactly. But insistent. Unmistakable. His pecs, beneath the cotton of his t-shirt, felt… tender. Swollen. He glanced down, heart hammering against his ribs – ribs that suddenly felt more delicate. There was a definite, undeniable fullness there, a burgeoning pressure pushing against the fabric. Buds. Like the word Molly had used, drunk and laughing in that neon hellscape. Blooming.

He dropped the glass. It shattered on the linoleum, shards skittering across the floor. The sound was deafening in the quiet apartment.

"Nathan?!" Molly's voice, laced with genuine concern now, cut through the haze. Footsteps padded towards the kitchen. "You okay? Did you—" She stopped in the doorway, her bleary eyes widening as she took him in. The harsh light was unforgiving.

Her gaze flickered from his face – softer, less defined – down to his chest. The t-shirt stretched differently now, hinting at the impossible swell beneath. Her smile, the ever-present, easy smile, vanished. Replaced by slack-jawed disbelief. "Nate?" she whispered, the slur gone, replaced by raw shock. "Your... your face..." Her hand lifted, trembling, pointing. "And... oh my god. What is that?"

Nathan couldn't speak. He just stared back at her, trapped in the brutal honesty of the chrome reflection. The transformation wasn't stopping. It was accelerating. The warmth that had bloomed within him at the bar, the heat Molly had complained about between her own thighs, felt like it was consuming him from the inside out, reshaping him molecule by molecule. Sweat beaded on his forehead – not exertion sweat, but the clammy dampness of pure, unadulterated terror.

He saw his own panic mirrored in Molly’s wide, suddenly sobering eyes. The cozy apartment, the fairy lights, the photos of their easy friendship – it all felt like a sick parody, the stage set for something monstrously unnatural.

"I..." Nathan started, his voice cracking, pitching upwards unmistakably now. It sounded fragile. Almost... feminine? The word choked him. He clutched the countertop, knuckles white, feeling the strange new weight on his chest, the terrifying softness of his own arms, the relentless, tingling heat spreading outward, remaking him in the image of the stunned woman gaping at him from the doorway. He had no words. Only the horrifying, undeniable reality vibrating through every nerve ending. The momentum of the change was terrifying, unstoppable, propelling him towards an unthinkable future. He felt a fresh wave of heat, deep and unsettling, bloom low in his own abdomen.

The heat low in Nathan’s abdomen wasn’t warm anymore; it was molten, a liquid fire seeping into his bones, making his hips ache with a strange, grinding pressure. His breath hitched, sharp and thin. "Molly," he managed, the name escaping higher, softer than before, almost a wisp against the lingering chime of shattered glass.

Molly didn’t move from the doorway, rooted like one of her potted plants. Her eyes, wide and shockingly clear despite the tequila, scanned him top to trembling bottom. She saw the undeniable curve beneath his stretched t-shirt, the softening line of his jaw under the harsh kitchen light, the bewildered panic in eyes that were somehow… larger. "Nate?" she repeated, the word barely audible. "What... what is this? Did you... feel that? At the bar? That crazy heat?"

He couldn’t answer. His frame felt like it was dissolving and reforming simultaneously. The solidity of his shoulders seemed to be melting inwards, his stance shifting subtly, unnervingly. He felt lighter, less anchored to the ground, his center of gravity tilting treacherously. The pressure on his chest intensified, a persistent, insistent thrum beneath aching skin. He looked down again, helplessly drawn to the impossible swell. His shirt clung differently, fabric tenting over newly rounded flesh, sensitive and taut.

Molly took a hesitant step forward, avoiding the glittering glass shards. "Your voice," she breathed, her own voice thick with disbelief. "It sounds… different. Like…" She trailed off, unable to voice the comparison hanging between them. Her gaze locked onto his chest again, not with fear now, but with a horrified, morbid fascination. "Are you okay? Does it hurt?" Her hand lifted slowly, trembling in the air, drawn towards the undeniable change as if pulled by a magnet.

Nathan flinched, pressing himself harder against the cool countertop. The movement made the new weight shift, a jolt of unfamiliar sensation shooting through him. "Don't!" The word cracked, pitched higher, edged with raw terror. He saw the hurt flicker in her eyes, the confusion deepening. He wasn't Nate right now; he was something else, something alien and terrifying unfolding right in her cluttered kitchen, surrounded by photos of their ordinary lives. The scent of spilled water mixed with the faint, lingering aroma of lemon verbena tea felt grotesque.

"I just..." Molly whispered, her hand still hovering inches from him. The concern warred with her own drunken disorientation and the sheer impossibility of what she was witnessing. The buzzing warmth she'd felt earlier at the bar, the heat she’d complained of between her own thighs – it felt connected, a terrifying thread pulling taut. "I need to... understand. Please. Let me..." Her fingers, tentative, brushed the stretched cotton of his t-shirt.

A bolt of sensation, electric and overwhelming, tore through Nathan as Molly’s fingertips made contact with the curve of his newly formed breast. It wasn't entirely pain; it was a shocking, deep thrum of sensitivity that radiated outwards, stealing his breath, freezing them both in a moment of profound, world-shattering violation.

SHE TOUCHES HIS BREAST

He jerked back like she’d burned him, slamming his shoulder blades into the cold edge of the counter. The unexpected, searing sensitivity radiating from her touch was terrifying, alien. "Don't!" The word ripped out, thin and high, cracking with panic. He clutched his chest protectively, the strange new weight beneath his palm both unfamiliar and strangely vulnerable.

Molly snatched her hand back as if scalded, eyes wide with a mix of fear and dawning horror. "Nate, I'm sorry! I didn't... it just... what is that?" Her voice shook, the drunken haze rapidly evaporating under the shock. She stared at his chest, then back at his altered face, the softening jaw, the slightly different shape of his eyes. "Is this... is this because of what I said? That stupid, drunk thing I said?"

Nathan couldn't breathe. The pressure in his chest was immense, a constant, insistent thrum beneath skin that felt stretched too thin. But the real terror bloomed lower, reigniting that impossible, molten heat deep in his abdomen. It wasn't just warmth anymore; it was a liquid fire, coiling and spreading, settling low with a grinding pressure that made his hips feel like they were being rearranged. He pushed himself away from the counter, staggering back towards the dimly lit living room, needing space. His legs felt wrong – lighter, maybe, or just unstable.

"Feel like I'm... dissolving," he gasped, his voice definitely pitched higher, softer. It sounded wrong coming from his mouth. He stumbled past the worn couch, catching himself on the armrest. The movement sent another jolt of sensation through his changed chest and a fresh wave of that deep, unsettling heat pooling low. Sweat slicked his forehead, his temples. Photos of them grinning on a mountain peak, goofing off at the beach, mocked him from the walls. Normalcy was a distant memory.

Molly followed, her movements hesitant, clumsy. "Dissolving? Nate, you're... changing." The word hung heavy in the air, thick with disbelief. "Your face is softer. Your voice... And your..." She gestured vaguely towards his chest, unable to finish. "This isn't possible. Tequila doesn't do this." She pressed the heels of her hands against her own temples, looking lost. "That heat... at the bar... it felt weird. Like... buzzing electricity. Did you feel it too? Before this?"

He sank onto the couch, the worn fabric offering no comfort. Every nerve felt raw, hypersensitive. The heat between his legs was intensifying, a deep, pulling ache joining the fire, a sensation he couldn't name but instinctively recoiled from. His pelvis felt... different. Lighter? Wider? The solid structure he'd known his whole life seemed fluid, shifting under the relentless internal pressure. The waistband of his jeans suddenly felt too tight, too constricting against this new, confusing ache low in his belly.

"I felt it," he whispered, the admission scraping his throat. "When you said... what you said. That heat hit me. Like... like yours. Inside." He looked up at her, desperate, terrified. "It won't stop, Molly. It’s... it’s still happening. Down... down there." He gestured weakly towards his lap, a flush of shame burning his cheeks. The heat was deepening, spreading, becoming a throbbing, insistent presence unlike anything he'd ever known. It felt invasive. Wrong.

Molly stared at him, her face pale. She slowly lowered herself onto the edge of the coffee table opposite him. Her eyes were wide, sober now, scanning his altered form. "Down there?" she echoed, her voice small. The pieces clicked with chilling clarity: her drunken wish echoing in the neon haze, the shared, impossible heat, Nathan’s body visibly softening, reshaping. "Oh my god, Nate." The color drained completely from her face. "You mean... you're becoming... like me? All of me?"

Her horrified realization mirrored his own terror perfectly. The cozy room, the fairy lights, the scent of her lemon verbena tea – it all felt suffocating, a stage for this grotesque metamorphosis. The heat deep within him didn't just throb now; it pulsed, a rhythmic ache radiating outwards from his core, settling with agonizing familiarity into the cradle of his transforming hips. It wasn't just heat. It felt like... hunger. A deep, biological imperative he didn't understand but couldn't escape. He clutched his stomach, doubling over slightly as a fresh wave of that thick, cloying sensation washed through him, centering on that molten point low and deep inside. He felt invaded. Utterly transformed. The momentum of the change was now a terrifying undertow, pulling him irrevocably into depths he couldn't fathom. He groaned, a sound that was nearly a whimper, high and utterly alien.

Nathan groaned, that high, terrifying sound scraping his throat raw. The heat in his gut wasn't just fire anymore; it was a deep, grinding pull, reshaping him from the inside, making his hips ache as if bones were dissolving and reforming under unbearable pressure. Sweat beaded on his forehead, slick and cold despite the internal furnace.

"Jesus, Nate," Molly breathed, her voice tight with panic as she watched him double over on her couch. "Your skin... it looks different. Softer. Like... like mine." Her own hand flew to her cheek, touching it as if for reassurance. "This is insane. It can't be real." But the evidence sat trembling before her: Nathan’s broader frame subtly narrowing, the shocking curve beneath his stretched shirt, the undeniable feminine pitch of his pained whimpers. Her drunken wish in the neon bar – ‘fuck someone like me’ – echoed like a curse.

Another wave of that deep, liquid heat surged through Nathan, centering low and throbbing. "Feels like... tearing," he gasped, his voice thin and trembling. He clutched his stomach, fingers digging into the yielding softness that had replaced his taut abs. His jeans, suddenly impossibly tight across the hips and groin, constricted like a vise. A fresh, sharp cramp seized him, deep inside where nothing should feel like that. He cried out, the sound pure, undiluted terror.

Molly flinched at the sound, her own breath catching. Her wide eyes darted from his agonized face down to his lap, then snapped back up. "Tearing? Nate, what's tearing? Tell me!" She leaned forward, desperate, one hand instinctively reaching out again before jerking back, remembering his violent recoil in the kitchen. Her heart hammered against her ribs, a frantic counterpoint to his ragged breathing. The fairy lights cast shifting patterns on his altered face, highlighting the terrifying smoothness of his jawline, the slight, alien fullness of his lips.

"It's... inside," Nathan choked out, tears stinging his eyes. "Low. Deep. Like... wrong." He couldn't articulate the profound violation, the horrific sense of his own biology betraying him. The grinding pressure intensified, a relentless, internal rearrangement he was powerless to stop. He shifted on the couch, trying to find a position that didn't send fresh jolts of that deep, unfamiliar ache radiating through his pelvis. Every tiny movement felt alien, his center of gravity a treacherous, shifting thing.

Molly stared, horror crystallizing into a chilling certainty. "Inside? Like... like me?" The implication, the grotesque symmetry of it, slammed into her. Her drunken fantasy, spat out in a haze of tequila and neon, was physically rewriting her best friend. The buzzing warmth she'd felt at the bar, the heat she'd complained about, wasn't just shared; it was the catalyst, the terrifying bridge between her careless words and his nightmare. "Oh god, Nate," she whispered, her voice thick with horrified understanding and dawning guilt. "What have I done?"

A fresh, powerful cramp ripped through Nathan, stealing his breath. He gasped, arching slightly off the cushions, his face contorted. Simultaneously, across the small space, Molly jolted. Not from cramping, but from a sudden, sharp, involuntary contraction low in her own body. Her breath hitched. Her hand flew to the fabric covering her lap, fingers pressing against her skirt, feeling the unexpected, insistent twitch beneath the thin material. It was brief, startling, and utterly disconnected from her conscious thought – a bizarre, involuntary echo of the agony consuming Nathan just feet away.

Her eyes, already wide with terror, snapped down to her own lap, then back to Nathan’s trembling form. Confusion warred with revulsion on her face. She felt... nothing like his pain, yet her body had just reacted, an unsettling spasm mirroring his torment. Her skirt settled back against her thigh, but the phantom sensation lingered, a cold, unsettling ripple beneath her skin. The shared heat from the bar had become a grotesque, physical tether, binding their experiences in ways she couldn't begin to comprehend. She stared at her hand, still pressed flat against the denim of her skirt, her knuckles white. The silence in the apartment was deafening, broken only by Nathan’s ragged gasps and the frantic pounding of her own heart.

The silence in the apartment was deafening, broken only by Nathan’s ragged gasps and the frantic pounding of her own heart. Molly stared at her own hand, still pressed flat against the denim of her skirt where that phantom twitch had just shocked her. It felt alien, disconnected, yet chillingly linked to the agony twisting Nathan’s features just feet away on her blue couch. He writhed, another low groan escaping his throat – a sound pitched higher, thinner than it had been an hour ago in the neon chaos of the bar.

"Tell me what's happening, Nate!" Molly demanded, her voice tight, cutting through the suffocating quiet. She abandoned her perch on the coffee table, crouching shakily in front of him on the rug littered with magazines. Her own lingering tequila buzz was obliterated by cold, sharp fear. "Where does it hurt? Show me!" Her eyes darted over him, taking in the sweat-slicked skin, the unnatural flush creeping down his neck beneath the stretched collar of his t-shirt, the undeniable concave curve where his solid pecs used to be.

Her eyes darted over him, taking in the sweat-slicked skin, the unnatural flush creeping down his neck beneath the stretched collar of his t-shirt, the undeniable concave curve where his solid pecs used to be. The fairy lights cast shifting patterns on his altered face, highlighting the terrifying smoothness of his jawline, the slight, alien fullness of his lips. Every ragged breath he took seemed to ripple through the new, vulnerable shape of his torso.

"Where, Nate?" Molly pressed, voice cracking with fear that mirrored the horror twisting his features. She knelt frozen before him, unable to tear her gaze away from the impossible contortions of his body on her familiar couch. The scent of panic-sweat mixed with the lingering vanilla candle, creating a sickly sweet stench. "Show me what hurts!"

Nathan couldn't speak. His focus narrowed to the molten firestorm consuming his lower body, a grinding pressure so intense it blurred his vision. He clawed at the waistband of his jeans, desperate for relief from the agonizing constriction. His hips felt like they were being pried apart from the inside, the bones grinding and reforming under unbearable tension. Denim dug deep into soft, yielding flesh that hadn't been there hours ago. Another savage cramp tore through him, deeper than before, radiating white-hot agony up his spine. He cried out – a thin, high-pitched sound that wasn't his own – and instinctively bucked his hips against the pain, trying to somehow escape the nightmare unfolding within his own skin.

His frantic movement shifted the fabric of his jeans. The strained denim across his lap, already distorted by the shifting landscape beneath, tightened visibly. Molly’s gaze, wide with dawning, horrific comprehension, locked onto that point. She watched, breath trapped in her throat, as the prominent bulge she’d seen countless times – playing basketball, sprawled on this very couch – seemed to… waver. Like heat haze over pavement. It wasn’t shrinking in the usual way; it was dissolving, collapsing inward, the familiar shape blurring at the edges as if reality itself was erasing it.

The denim flattened. Not smoothly, but in a sudden, awful subsidence, collapsing against a newly formed concavity. The distinct outline vanished, replaced by a soft, seamless curve pressing against the worn blue fabric. It was seamless. Complete. The transformation wasn't just skin deep; the underlying structure had been utterly remade. The grinding pressure, the liquid fire, the unspeakable internal shifting – it had reached its terrible culmination. Gone. Replaced by something silent, smooth, and terrifyingly female.

Nathan gasped, a shuddering, wet sound. He stared down at his own lap, at the flat, unfamiliar plane of denim where the core of his maleness had been moments before. His hands hovered, trembling violently, inches above where that defining part of himself had simply... ceased. The heat in his gut flared one final, agonizing pulse, then settled into a deep, aching throb that felt entirely different. Foreign. Empty. His body felt horrifyingly light, yet impossibly heavy with the weight of irrevocable loss.

Silence crashed over the small apartment, thick and suffocating. The cheerful twinkle of the fairy lights felt cruel. Molly remained frozen on the rug, knuckles white where she gripped the edge of a discarded magazine. The scent of spilled water and lemon verbena tea seemed grotesquely mundane. Her own earlier phantom twitch echoed uselessly in her memory. She had watched it happen. Witnessed the impossible erasure. Her drunken, stupid wish, spat out in the neon haze of the bar, had rewritten the man she knew down to his very essence. Her mouth opened, but no sound came out. Just a faint, strangled rasp. The only movement was Nathan’s trembling hands suspended over the terrifying blankness between his transformed legs, his entire world reduced to the horrifying smoothness beneath the denim.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI