Cover of Be Careful What You Wish For

Be Careful What You Wish For

Read the story

1 chapter · 2238 words · Read 0 times

Lindsey discovers her boyfriend Cory has a thing for thick, strong woman. She decides to put on some weight and grow some muscle in the gym. She discovers that she really enjoys it, and Cory must balance his raging attraction to his growing girlfriend and her increasingly dominant muscular form

Chapter 1: The Beginning

The fluorescent light in the apartment living room hummed like a trapped insect. It cast a sickly glow over the sagging futon, the scarred coffee table, the TV that always seemed on the verge of giving up and tipping over. Cory clicked through another design mock-up, his knee bouncing a nervous rhythm against the leg of the desk. A month. It had been a month since she’d found the folder. He still felt the phantom heat of shame crawling up his neck whenever he thought about it.

The click of the lock on the front door made him jump. He minimized his screens, a reflexive gesture that felt stupid the moment he did it. As if she’d be checking his browser history again. She had bigger things to look at now.

Lindsey shouldered the door open, a gym bag slung over one shoulder. She wasn’t the girl who used to struggle with grocery bags. She dropped the bag with a solid thud that vibrated through the thin floorboards. “Hey.”

“Hey,” Cory said, swiveling his chair. His breath caught, just a little, like it did every time now.

She was flushed, a sheen of sweat still glistening on her throat and the newly defined lines of her collarbones. Her old NYU t-shirt, the one she’d stolen from him, was stretched taut across her shoulders and chest. It used to swim on her. Now the cotton clung to the gentle swell of her delts, the nascent curve of her biceps. The soft pouch of her stomach, visible where the shirt had ridden up, was no longer just softness. It was a layer over something firmer, a foundation. Ten pounds. It looked like more.

“How was it?” he asked, his voice oddly formal.

“Heavy.” She walked past him, not to the bedroom, but to the full-length mirror leaning against the wall by the front door. She stopped and just… looked. Not with vanity, but with a cool, appraising focus that was entirely new. She rolled her shoulders back, and the fabric of the shirt strained. Her hands came up, fingers flexing, and she turned slightly, watching the light play over the faint shadow that was beginning to separate her tricep from the back of her arm.

Cory watched her watch herself. The silence was thick, charged. He used to make a joke here, something to break the tension. Admiring the goods? But the joke wouldn’t land anymore. It would feel like a trespass.

“You’re staring,” she said, her eyes finding his in the reflection.

“Sorry. I just… you look different.”

“I feel different.” She turned from the mirror, facing him fully. Her gaze was direct, unnerving. The kind, slightly anxious generosity that used to animate her face had solidified into something steadier.More present. “Hungry. What’s for dinner?”

“Uh, I was thinking stir-fry? With that tofu you like.”

“Tofu.” She said the word flatly, as if tasting it and finding it wanting. “I need more protein, Cory. Real protein. Like a pound of chicken. Maybe two.”

“A pound? Linz, that’s–”

“That’s what I need.” She walked into the tiny kitchen, opening the fridge. The light illuminated her from below, highlighting the new thickness of her thighs in her leggings, the way her calves curved with a hint of new muscle. She pulled out a tub of Greek yogurt and ate a spoonful straight from the container, something her old, germ-conscious self would never have done. “The trainer said my recovery nutrition is weak. It’s holding me back.”

“Since when do you have a trainer?”

“Since today. His name is Marcus. He competes.” She licked the spoon clean, her eyes on Cory. “He said I have a freakishly good structure for it. Wide clavicles, narrow waist. Said with my discipline, I could be a monster.”

The word hung in the air. Monster. Cory’s stomach did a slow roll, a mixture of dread and a dark, thrilling pull. He looked at her standing in their shabby kitchen, a spoon in her hand, talking about being a monster. The girl who used to get excited about a new flavor of latte.

“That’s… great,” he managed.

“Is it?” She put the yogurt away and leaned against the counter, crossing her arms. The movement made her bicep bulge, just a little. A defined peak was starting to form. “You haven’t really said anything. About any of this.”

“I said you look amazing.”

“You said I look different.” She pushed off the counter and took a few steps toward him. He felt himself shrink back into his chair, not out of fear, but out of a sudden, acute awareness of the space she now occupied. Her presence had weight, a density that pressed against the air in the cramped room. “You saw what was on your computer, Cory. The women. The huge ones. The bodybuilders. Don’t pretend you don’t have a type.”

He blushed, a hot, full-body wave of it. “It’s not a type. It was just… curiosity.”

“Bullshit.” The word was calm, factual. She stood over him now. He had to tilt his head up to meet her eyes. The dynamic was so literal it made his head spin. “You’re curious about this.” She raised her arm, and with a soft, gritting effort, she flexed. The muscle bloomed under her skin, a solid, rounded hill of flesh and vein and potential. It wasn’t massive, not yet.But it was undeniable. It was a fact.

Cory’s mouth went dry. All the hidden searches, the secret tabs, the shameful, thrilling images—they were here, in his living room, made flesh by his girlfriend. His kind, generous girlfriend who was currently flexing with a look of fierce concentration on her face.

“So?” she asked, releasing the flex. The muscle softened, but the shape remained, changed forever. “Is it what you wanted?”

He couldn’t lie. Not with the evidence standing right there. A stammering, choked sound escaped him before he found words.“Yes. But… I don’t know if I wanted it… here. Like this.”

“Too bad.” She uncrossed her arms and placed a hand on his shoulder. Her grip was firm, solid. A month ago, her touch was light. Now it felt like a claim. “It’s here. I’m here. And I’m just getting started.”

She gave his shoulder a slight squeeze—a gesture that was once affectionate, now loaded with demonstration—and walked toward the bathroom. “I’m gonna shower.Order the chicken. Extra rice. And Cory?”

He looked up, his heart hammering against his ribs.

“Clean your computer more often,” she said, not looking back. “But leave that folder. I like to check my progress against the professionals.”

The bathroom door closed. The lock clicked. A moment later, the shower hissed to life.

Cory sat frozen in the humming fluorescence. He looked at his own hands, slender and familiar on the keyboard. He thought of the lean, nervous frame under his clothes. He thought of the sheer, impossible mass of the women in that folder, the ones that had stirred something in him he could never name.

And now Lindsey was naming it. She was building it, pound by pound, in their shower. The dread was still there, a cold knot in his gut. But beneath it, warmer and much, much stronger, was a current of pure, overwhelming want. It terrified him. It electrified him.

He pulled up a food delivery app, his fingers trembling slightly as he searched for grilled chicken. He added extra. Then he doubled the order.

From behind the bathroom door, over the sound of the water, he heard a grunt. Then a low, satisfied laugh. It was a sound he’d never heard from her before. It was the sound of effort. The sound of growth.

He stared at the tilting TV screen, seeing only his own pale, soft reflection superimposed over the vision of what was coming, what was already taking shape in the next room. He was hungry too, he realized. For something he couldn't quite name. Something big, and powerful, and hers.

Something big, and powerful, and hers.

Two months pass, and Lindsey grows fast.

The gentle swell of her tummy now hangs over her waistband, a soft, solid shelf of flesh that rests against the top of her leggings. The rest of her looks like a stuffed sausage when she struggles with her old clothes. Cory watches, transfixed, as she fights with a pair of her old sweatpants one Saturday morning. The fabric, stretched to a translucent thinness over the cannonballs of her glutes and the thick, pillar-like columns of her thighs, emits a threatening creak.

“This is ridiculous,” she grunts, giving a final, mighty tug. The waistband surrenders, rolling over her hips, but the seam along the inner thigh gives way with a sharp pop. A neat, two-inch split.

She doesn’t seem annoyed. She looks down at the tear, then at the profound swell of quad muscle bulging through the gap. A smile touches her lips. “Huh.”

Her arms, when she crosses them, are no longer promising. They are deliverables. Powerful and thick, veins mapping the dense terrain of her forearms when she grips anything—a fork, her shaker bottle, his wrist. Her shoulders have broadened, rounding into a permanent, imposing curve that fills doorways. She moves differently. Not with athletic grace, but with a deliberate, heavy stability. The floorboards protest her footsteps.

Cory realizes it one evening as she stands between him and the kitchen light, a monolithic silhouette asking if he wants the last of the grilled chicken. He has to tilt his head up. He cannot see over her head anymore. The top of his vision is the severe, strong line of her jaw. The mental calculation happens unconsciously, a survival instinct. The density of her, the sheer volume, the way she displaces air—she definitely outweighs him. The lean graphic designer has been quietly, rapidly outsized by his girlfriend.

“Earth to Cory. Chicken? Yes or no.”

Her voice is the same, but it comes from higher up, and it’s wrapped in a body that could plausibly lift him over her head. The thought isn’t scary. It’s a fact that sends a jolt straight to his groin.

“Yeah. Yes, please.”

She forks the entire remaining breast onto his plate. The simple act is an exhibition. The cap of her deltoid swells as she reaches, the latissimus muscle on her back flaring beneath her tank top like a wing. She turns, and her stomach, that proud, heavy curve, leads the way.

She catches him staring. Again. Always.

“What?” she asks, but it’s not a real question. It’s a challenge. Her eyes, once quick to look away, hold his. They are demanding, confident. The kind and generous girl is in there somewhere, but she’s being packed over with layers of muscle and a new, formidable patience.

“Nothing,” he stammers, looking at his plate. “You’re just… it’s working. Your program.”

“Marcus says I’m a natural hyper-responder. Myostatin levels are probably in the gutter.” She says it like she’s discussing the weather, leaning back against the counter. Her posture dominates the tiny kitchen. “He upped my calories again. 4,000 a day. Can you believe that?”

He can believe it. The evidence is breathing in front of him, a monument to protein synthesis. He pokes at his chicken. “Do you… like it? Feeling like this?”

She considers him. The hum of the fridge fills the silence. “I love it,” she says, finally. The simplicity of it is absolute. “I love feeling strong. I love taking up space. I look in the mirror and I see a project that’s going exactly according to plan.” She pushes off the counter and walks to the fridge for her gallon jug of water. As she passes his chair, her hip brushes his shoulder. It’s an accidental contact, but it feels like a nudge from a freight train. Solid. Unstoppable. “Do you? Like it?”

He swallows. His face is hot. The folder. The monstrous, glorious women. His secret, now standing in his kitchen, asking for validation. “It’s… a lot.”

“That’s not an answer.”

“Yes,” he blurts out, the word escaping like a hostage. “Yes, I like it. It’s incredible. You’re incredible.”

She smiles then, a real one, but it’s edged with triumph. She knows she’s pulled the truth from him. She unscrews the cap of her jug and drinks, her throat working. When she’s done, she places a hand on his head. It’s not a pat. It’s a weight. Her fingers, strong enough to crack a walnut, gentle enough to make his scalp tingle.

“Good,” she says. The word is a decree.

Later, on the futon, she sprawls. One of her thick legs drops across his lap, a casual, ownership gesture. The weight of it is immense, warm, and pinning. He doesn’t move it. He lets it rest there, a living blanket of muscle and will. He can feel the heat of her through his jeans, the formidable density of her quadriceps.

He looks at the TV, but he doesn’t see it. He is hyper-aware of the mass draped over him, of the new geography of the woman beside him. The journey she’s on has a velocity now, a momentum that leaves him breathless and clinging to the strap of her tank top for dear life. She’s not just building a body. She’s building a new world, and he’s living in it, under the weight of her leg, marveling at the ceiling he can no longer see.

Read on DreamPress