Cover of Brother's Keeper

Brother's Keeper

Read the story

4 chapters · 12989 words · Read 0 times

I lost my virginity at 22 to Jen, my older brother Mike's wife while he was waiting downstairs for us to finish. Let's back up a little. Mike played college football, then went to law school. He's always been handsome and popular. Jen was a college cheerleader, then went to nursing school, and after Mike's career took off she mostly trained for triathlons and looked devastatingly hot on Instagram. I'm... a little different. Identified as gifted at a young age, I went to college two years early. By the time I was 21 I had a master's in computer science and was working at a bleeding edge robotics startup in Brooklyn. Mike and Jen had both turned 30 recently and had begun to think about starting a family. After almost two years of trying without results, they received devastating news. While Jen was freakishly healthy, an old football injury meant Mike didn't produce any viable sperm. They came to me with a proposal. I'd be the "donor", but Mike was intensely insecure and didn't want to go through a clinic, he wanted this all hush hush and done at home. The natural way. I agreed.

Chapter 4: Fun and games

The scent of coffee and cinnamon pulled me downstairs, a siren song that felt grotesquely normal. I’d showered, scrubbing away the physical evidence of the dawn, but the taste of Jen lingered in my memory, a phantom flavor on my clean tongue. I dressed in what I hoped were casual Friday clothes—khakis and a plain grey t-shirt—trying to look like a brother visiting, not a lover leaving his post.

They were in the kitchen, a tableau of domestic harmony. Mike stood by the counter, already in his suit pants and a crisp white dress shirt, sleeves rolled up. He was scrolling through his phone with one hand, sipping coffee with the other. Jen was at the stove, her back to me, wearing workout leggings and a tight, cropped tank top that showed the muscles of her lower back. Her hair was damp from the shower.“Morning,” I said, the word too loud in the quiet room.

Mike looked up, and his face broke into a wide, genuine smile.He looked… lighter. The perpetual, subtle tension in his shoulders was gone.“Ron! Sleep okay?”

“Like a rock,” I lied.My eyes flicked to Jen. She didn’t turn around, but her shoulders tightened almost imperceptibly.“Great.Jen made those cinnamon rolls you like. From scratch, not the tube.” He set his phone down.“God, I feel fantastic today. That McCann case?I’m going to gut him. I can feel it.”

His energy was unnerving.It was the buzz of a man who’d won a prize. “Big day at the office?” I asked, sliding onto a stool at the kitchen island.

“Every day’s a big day, little brother.But yeah.Feeling sharp.” He winked at Jen’s back. “Really sharp.”

Jen finally turned, holding a plate with a giant, gooey cinnamon roll. Her face was composed, the perfect picture of a serene wife, but her eyes wouldn’t meet mine.She set the plate in front of me.“Here. Don’t burn your mouth, the icing is molten.”

“Thanks, Jen.”

Mike came over, grabbing his briefcase and jacket from a chair. He leaned in and kissed Jen, not a peck, but a deep, lingering kiss.His hand cupped the back of her head. She melted into it for a second, her fingers curling into his shirt, then gently pushed him away with a soft laugh.

“Go. You’ll be late.”

“Worth it.” He grinned, a boyish, carefree grin I hadn’t seen in years.He clapped me on the shoulder. “Hold down the fort, Ron. See you tonight.”

And then he was gone, the front door clicking shut behind him, leaving a vacuum of silence filled only by the hum of the refrigerator.

I stared at the cinnamon roll, my appetite vanished. Jen busied herself at the sink, scrubbing a pan that was already clean.“Why is he so… happy?” I finally asked, my voice flat.

She stiffened. Then she shut off the water and turned, leaning against the countertop, her arms crossed over her chest.A flush was creeping up her neck, blooming across her cheeks. She looked down, studying the pattern on the floor.

“I gave him a blowjob,” she said, her voice so small it was almost a whisper.The words hung in the air, vulgar and intimate. A gift she’d given her husband.After I’d been inside her.After I’d kissed her.

“Before he left for work?” I asked, though I knew the answer.

She nodded, still not looking at me.“Not… not like a quick one. A… a birthday one.” She swallowed.“The kind he likes.Deep.Messy. I let him… finish in my mouth.”

The image was instant and punishing. Jen on her knees for Mike, in this very house, hours after I’d been emptying myself into her.It wasn’t jealousy, not exactly. It was a violent recalibration.I was the stud, the biological tool.He was her husband. She was soothing him, rewarding him, keeping him pacified and connected. It was part of the deal, a part I’d never allowed myself to picture.A dark, reckless impulse took hold. I pushed the plate away. “What do I have to do to get one of those?”

Her head snapped up, her blue eyes wide with shock, then flashing with something like fury. She uncrossed her arms and marched the two steps to where I sat.She didn’t hesitate. Her fist, small but hard as a rock from years of gripping bike handles and weights, punched me squarely in the arm.“Ow! Jesus, Jen.”

“You little shit,” she hissed, but there was no real heat in it. It was the familiar, exasperated tone she’d used when I’d teased her about burnt cookies or a bad movie choice a lifetime ago. “You focus on getting me pregnant.That’s your job. Maybe if you do a good job of that,” she said, her voice dropping back to that teasing, dangerous whisper, “I’ll suck your dick someday.”

The promise, uttered as both a threat and a prize, sent a jolt straight through me. The uncomfortable moment from the dawn was gone, burned away by this new, playful friction. It was our old dynamic, but supercharged, laced with a deadly serious undertone.

I looked at her.The flush was still there, but her eyes were challenging now. Her lips, the ones I’d silenced, were pressed into a smirk. She was back in control, the teacher setting the terms.But I’d tasted her surrender.I’d swallowed her screams. The power between us was no longer hers alone.Without a word, I stood up. The stool scraped loudly on the oak floor.Her smirk faltered, replaced by a flicker of curiosity.

I stepped into her space. Before she could react, I slid one arm under her knees and the other around her back, lifting her clean off the ground. It was easier than I expected; she was all lean muscle, compact and light.“Ron! What are you—put me down!” she yelped, but her arms instinctively looped around my neck for balance.

“I’m focusing,” I said, my voice gruff. I started walking, not towards the guest room, but down the hallway towards the master suite, their room.

“This isn’t the guest room,” she protested, squirming in my grasp.It was a token struggle.Her body was pliant against mine.

“We’re not being quiet anymore, remember?He’s gone. And you said I needed to focus.” I shouldered open the door to their bedroom.It was different in the daylight. The half-drawn blinds from the night of the proposal were open now, flooding the room with a clear, honest morning light.The bed was neatly made, a stark, masculine duvet in deep blue. Mike’s reading glasses rested on his nightstand next to a legal thriller. Her nightstand held a bottle of lavender-scented lotion and a novel. It smelled like him, like her, like them.The taboo of it was a physical shock, colder and more potent than anything before. This was their sanctum.I was carrying his wife into his bed.

I set her down gently in the center of the duvet. She stared up at me, her breath coming a little faster, the blush now a full-blown crimson stain across her chest.She looked terrified. She looked electrified.“Ron, we shouldn’t…”

“You track your cycle. You wake me up at dawn. You give him birthday blowjobs to keep him sweet.” I kneeled on the bed, straddling her legs, not touching her yet.“This is for the project, right? Increased frequency.Optimal positioning.You’re the nurse.You tell me—does the environment matter? Or is it just biology?”

She licked her lips. Her eyes darted to the door, then back to me.The professional part of her brain was fighting a losing war with everything else. “Missionary… is good.For conception. It… pools the semen.”

“Okay,” I said.My hands went to the waistband of her leggings. I hooked my fingers in the fabric and peeled them down, along with the tiny black panties underneath. She lifted her hips to help, a small, unconscious surrender.I pulled the tank top over her head. Now she was naked, in their bed, in the brutal daylight. Every defined ab, every faint freckle, was exposed.She didn’t try to cover herself. She just watched me, her chest rising and falling.I undressed quickly, my own movements clumsy with urgency. When I was naked, I saw her eyes drop, widen slightly at the sight of me, already thick and heavy. The memory of the stretch, the flood, was there between us.I lowered myself over her. Our skin touched from chest to knees.Her heat was immense. I kissed her shoulder, her neck, the hollow of her throat.I avoided her mouth. That line, once crossed, was a territory we were still mapping.She let out a shaky sigh, her hands coming up to rest on my back. Her nails bit in lightly. “Just… do it,” she whispered, turning her head to the side, presenting her profile against Mike’s pillow. “Don’t make a production of it.”

But it already was a production.The most charged performance of our lives. I guided myself into her, and the sensation was even more intense without the cover of darkness or secrecy. I watched her face as I pushed past the initial resistance.Her eyes clenched shut, her lips parting in a silent ‘O’. I sank deeper, and a low, guttural moan escaped her, uncontrolled and rich. It echoed in the quiet room.I began to move. This wasn’t the slow, measured pace of the dawn.This was claiming.Possession. Each thrust drove her deeper into the mattress, each retreat was a tease.The headboard gave a soft, rhythmic tap against the wall. The sounds of our bodies connecting were lewd and amplified in the silent house.

“God… Ron…” she gasped, her hands scrabbling against my back. Her legs came up, locking around my waist, heels digging into my ass, pulling me deeper.Her professional detachment was shattered. She was here, now, with me, in her husband’s bed.

The familiar, coiling pressure began in my core, but slower this time, a deep well being filled drop by drop. I wanted to savor this, to brand this moment into both of us.Her climax built visibly. A fine tremor started in her thighs.Her breaths became sharp, panting cries. “Don’t stop… please, don’t stop…”

When it hit her, it wasn’t the silent, pillow-muffled convulsion of the early hours.It was a vocal, wrenching release. She cried out, a sharp, beautiful sound that was pure, unadulterated pleasure. Her back arched violently off the bed, her head thrown back, tendons standing out in her neck. Her internal muscles clutched at me in a series of frantic, milking pulses.That was the trigger.The well overflowed.

The first surge was so powerful it blurred my vision. I drove into her as deep as I could go, burying myself to the hilt, and let go. A broken groan tore from my own throat.It was different here. There was no need for silence, only a desperate, grunting rhythm as my body convulsed above hers.

Jen was whimpering now, oversensitive, her hands pushing weakly at my hips. “It’s… it’s too much… you’re filling me up…”

But I couldn’t stop. The ejaculation was its own entity, a relentless, automatic expulsion. I collapsed onto her, my weight pressing her down into the mattress, my face buried in the pillow next to her head.I was still pumping into her, a continuous, shocking stream. She wrapped her arms around me, holding on as the spasms racked us both. The feeling of release was intertwined with the devastating knowledge of where we were. My brother’ scent was in the fabric beneath us.His side of the bed was cold and empty.

It went on, minute after agonizing minute. The sensation of flooding her was so profound it crossed from pleasure into a kind of brutal, biological triumph. When it finally, truly ended, I was spent in a way I’d never been before—drained, hollow, my mind blank.

We lay like that for a long time, a tangled, sweaty mess on the rumpled duvet. The sun had climbed higher, a bright square of light creeping across the floor.Slowly, I pushed myself up on my elbows. Jen’s eyes were closed.Tears had traced clean paths through the faint sweat on her temples. Her hand lay splayed on her lower stomach, which was visibly, slightly distended.

I moved to pull out, and she winced, a soft gasp escaping her. A thick trickle of white immediately seeped out onto the blue duvet, a shocking stain on the fabric.

Her eyes fluttered open.She looked at the stain, then up at the ceiling. She didn’t speak.I rolled off her, onto my back. We lay side by side, not touching, staring at the ceiling fan as it made its slow, pointless rotation.

“He can’t ever know we were in here,” she said finally, her voice hoarse.

“I know.”

“I mean it, Ron.This… this can’t happen again.The guest room. That’s the boundary.”

“You didn’t stop me.”

She was silent for a full minute. “No,” she admitted, the word heavy with defeat. “I didn’t.”

I turned my head to look at her. She was still staring upwards, her face a mask of conflicted emotion.“Did it help?The… focus?”

A faint, humorless smile touched her lips. “If one of your little swimmers doesn’t find its way home after that tsunami, then they’re not trying hard enough.” She sighed, a long, shuddering breath.“Now get out. I need to clean this up before he comes home.And you… you should get to work. Isn’t that what you’re supposedly here to do?”

The dismissal was clear.The lesson was over. I was being returned to my compartment.

I got up, gathered my clothes, and dressed in silence.She didn’t move from the bed. She just lay there, a portrait of stunning ruin in the morning light, her hand still resting on the undeniable proof of what we’d done.

I walked out of their bedroom, down the hall, and into the guest room. I closed the door, sat on the bed, and opened my laptop. The screen glowed to life, filled with lines of clean, logical code. A world of absolutes, of ones and zeroes, of predictable outcomes.I tried to lose myself in it. But all I could see was the blue duvet, and the stark, white evidence slowly seeping into it, a flag planted on forbidden ground.

I pressed my palm harder against her mouth, my fingers curling against her cheek. Her muffled cries vibrated against my skin, a desperate, keening sound that traveled up my arm and into my chest. The pressure in my groin was a live wire, sizzling and coiling, a sensation so vast and inevitable it felt geological.

Her hips pistoned upward to meet my thrusts, a silent, furious demand. Her eyelids fluttered, showing the whites. She was close, and I was dangling over the edge. The rule was silence. The rule was my hand as a gag. The rule was this grim, utilitarian transaction.

I took a risk.

As the first undeniable, tectonic surge gathered in my balls, I ripped my hand from her mouth.

Her eyes flew open, wide and shocked in the dark, a silent question of sheer panic. Instead of answering, I crushed my mouth to hers. I kissed her hard, swallowing the sharp, scream-shaped gasp that erupted from her throat just as the first violent pulse erupted from me.

Her scream melted into the kiss, became a hot, shared breath. My body locked, buried to the hilt as the torrent began. It wasn’t a release. It was an occupation. A profound, liquid claiming. Her hands, which had been pushing at my shoulders, froze. Then they plunged into my hair, fisting, holding me to her as if I were lifeline and wrecking ball all at once.

We kissed like I was going off to war. It was messy, teeth clacking, lips sliding, a brutal exchange of air and sound and taste. There was no technique, only a frantic, wordless communication. Her moans were ingested by my mouth, her whimpers became fuel for my own guttural groans. I could feel everything—the hot spill deep inside her, the rhythmic, pumping contractions of my own body that seemed to have no off-switch, the clench of her internal muscles around me in ragged, continuous waves.

Eight minutes. The clock on the nightstand ticked them off with indifferent seconds. For eight minutes, we breathed for each other. My world narrowed to the dark cave of our joined mouths, the dizzying scent of her skin and sweat, and the deep, internal pulse of a seemingly endless ejaculation. My balls tightened and released, tightened and released, a mechanical, biological pump depositing what felt like a lifetime’s reserve directly against her cervix.

A profound, shuddering weakness eventually seeped into my limbs. The flow diminished from a flood to a stream, then to a slow, persistent seep. The violent need in our kiss softened, slowed, became something else—exhausted, wet, unbearably intimate. My lips brushed hers, once, twice, a whisper of movement.

I finally broke the kiss, lifting my head just an inch. Our breaths mingled in the scant space between our mouths, ragged and syncopated. Her lips were swollen, glistening. Her eyes were closed. A single tear had tracked from the corner of her eye into her hairline.

I rolled off, the separation a slick, guilty sound. We lay side by side, not touching. The gray pre-dawn light now faintly outlined the furniture, making everything real again.

Jen brought a hand to her own mouth, her fingers touching her bruised lips. She stared at the ceiling. A deep, rosy blush spread from her chest, up her neck, flooding her cheeks. She swallowed audibly.

“You shouldn’t have done that,” she whispered. The words held no force. They were air, a reflex.

“I know.”

“It was a stupid risk.” She turned her head away from me, toward the wall. Her profile was sharp, angry. But her body was still open, loose, one knee bent. The sheets between us were already damp, cooling. “What if he’d heard?”

“He didn’t.”

“That’s not the point!” The heat in her voice was sudden, a flare. She looked back at me, finally, her blue eyes glittering with confused fury. “The point is the rule. The point is control. You broke the control.”

I said nothing. I just looked at her, at the blush that contradicted her anger, at the rapid flutter of her pulse in her throat.

Her gaze dropped from my face to my chest, then away again. She shook her head, a tiny, frustrated motion. She swung her legs out of bed, wincing as she stood. The evidence of the risk, of the war, of the nearly liter of seed, immediately began to slide down her inner thigh. She froze, catching it with a hand, her shoulders tightening.

She didn’t look at me as she walked, with that familiar, stiff-hipped gait, to the bathroom. The door clicked shut, not slammed, but with a definitive finality.

I lay there in the silence, in the humid, spent air of the room. My lips still tingled. I could still taste her—citrus, salt, and something indefinably, uniquely Jen. The clinical mission was in tatters. Something else, something wild and complicating, had been seeded in its place.

The shower didn’t start. I heard only the quiet run of faucet water, a cloth being wrung out. Minutes later, she emerged, the silk robe cinched tight. Her hair was smoothed. Her face was a careful, neutral mask. The nurse was back, but she was fragile now, a shell with a hairline crack.

“You should shower too,” she said, her voice clipped. “Mike’s alarm will go off in twenty minutes. We need to be at the breakfast table. Normal.”

She left without another word. I heard her padded footsteps retreat down the hall, the soft sigh of the master bedroom door opening and closing.

I stood under the guest shower’s spray, letting the water scour my skin. It didn’t work. The feeling was in me, not on me. The feeling of her scream in my mouth, the relentless, pouring truth of my own body, the shattered look in her eyes that was more than just anger. It was recognition.

Downstairs, the kitchen was bright, sunny. Mike stood at the counter, dumping coffee grounds into the machine. He was in his suit pants and a white undershirt, his hair damp from his own shower. He looked tired but cheerful.

“Morning, brother!” he boomed. “Sleep okay? Jen said you were up early working.”

I glanced at Jen. She was at the stove, scrambling eggs. Her back was to us. She gave a slight, almost imperceptible nod.

“Yeah,” I said, my voice rough. I cleared my throat. “Couldn’t sleep. Brain was going.”

“Tell me about it.” He clapped me on the shoulder as I sat at the island. “Hey, you’re sticking around today, right? Working remote?”

“That’s the plan.”

“Good. Good.” He looked over at Jen, his expression softening into something so openly affectionate it was a physical pain in my chest. “Babe, you need help?”

“I’ve got it,” she said, her tone light, easy. The perfect wife. She turned, bringing a plate of eggs and toast to set before me. Our eyes met for a fraction of a second.

The blush was gone. Her gaze was clear, blue, and utterly impenetrable. But in that fleeting contact, I saw the ghost of the kiss. I saw the eight-minute war. I saw the damp, shocking fullness I’d left inside her just an hour ago, a secret she was now carrying into the day, into her marriage, while she served me breakfast.

She gave me a small, polite, meaningless smile.

“Eat up, Ron.”

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI