Cover of Courting the Wrong Sister

Romance

Courting the Wrong Sister

Read the story

3 chapters · 6296 words · Read 0 times

An enemies to lovers Regency romance set in the London Season of 1814. Viscount Edmund Hale has decided love is a liability, so he draws up a list and picks the most agreeable debutante of the year, Rose Ashby, as his sensible bride. He did not account for her elder sister. Meg Ashby, twenty-seven, unmarried and unbothered, overheard every word of his list from behind an orange tree, and she means to scare him off before he breaks Rose's heart. One ferocious archery match, a runaway mare in Richmond Park and a rain-soaked garden party later, the battle lines are badly smudged. Wrong sister, slow burn, banter sharp enough to draw blood. When the man you swore to defeat is the only one who listens to you, who exactly are you protecting?

Characters

  • Edmund Hale — Viscount Hale, who took over his family's estates at twenty when his father's grief for his late wife drove him to ruin. He has concluded that love wrecks sensible men and intends to marry someone pleasant, safe and entirely unthreatening to his heart.
  • Kit Hale — Edmund's younger brother, who thinks Edmund's marriage plan is the funniest thing to happen all year and is the first to notice which sister his brother keeps looking at.
  • Lavinia Ashby — Meg and Rose's widowed mother, who loves her daughters dearly and is terrified of the family's debts. A viscount for Rose would be the answer to every prayer she has said since her husband died.
  • Meg Ashby — The elder Ashby sister, who has quietly run the household since their father died and has given up on a Season of her own. She will do anything to see Rose married for love, starting with driving off the cold-blooded viscount who wants her sister for a list of sensible reasons.
  • Rose Ashby — The Season's acknowledged beauty and the family's hope. Everyone assumes she will accept the best offer, and nobody has asked what she wants.

Chapter 2: The Silver Arrow

Hale House at Richmond was not, as Mama had promised, a house with a lake. It was a lake with a house politely attached, a long white villa sitting on a slope of lawn that ran down to water so still it looked painted. Beyond the garden wall the deer park rolled away in green and bracken-brown. Somebody had set out the targets on the flattest stretch of grass: four great straw bosses faced in painted canvas, gold at the heart, then red, blue, black and white.

By noon there were sixty people on that lawn, and every one of them knew about the wager.

"Mrs. Fenwick," I said grimly, when the third lady in succession had wished me luck in a voice that suggested I would need it.

"Kit," said Rose, who sees more than people think. She nodded toward the terrace, where Lord Hale's younger brother was moving through the crowd in a waistcoat the color of a ripe apricot, notebook in hand. "He's taking bets. I heard him tell Colonel Ware the odds were five to one."

"Against me?"

Rose hesitated. "Against you."

I pulled on my arm guard and buckled it tight.

The ladies were meant to shoot at forty yards and the gentlemen at sixty. When Lord Hale came across the grass to greet us, I told him I would be shooting at sixty.

"There's no need," he said.

"There's every need. If I beat you from forty yards, you'll tell yourself it was the distance."

"And if I beat you from sixty, everyone will say I ought to have let you stand closer."

"Then you'll have to beat me very convincingly, won't you?"

He looked down at me. The sun picked out early threads of grey in his black crop that I hadn't noticed by candlelight. "Six ends of three arrows," he said. "Highest score takes the match. Gold counts nine, red seven, blue five, black three, white one."

"I know how archery is scored, my lord."

"I know you do. I was telling the colonel, who is standing behind you with his mouth open."

I did not turn round. I picked up my bow, which is a good plain yew bow my father bought me the year before he died, and walked to the sixty-yard mark.

I would like to say I shot like an angel. I did shoot well. My first three arrows went red, gold, gold, and a murmur ran through the crowd that was very sweet to hear. Then Lord Hale stepped up and put three arrows into the gold so close together you could have covered them with a teacup, and the murmur became something closer to a sigh.

He shot the way some men ride, as though the bow were simply the part of him that reached a long way. He nocked, drew, held a breath and let go, and the arrow was there before you'd finished watching it leave.

"Show-off," I said, under my breath, as we passed each other walking down to collect.

"I'm told I should beat you convincingly."

"I didn't mean it."

"You did. You always mean it. It's one of your more alarming qualities."

The second end I matched him. The third, the wind came up off the lake and pushed my second arrow into the blue, and I heard Kit Hale say "Ooh," like a man watching a horse refuse a fence. The fourth end I put all three in the gold and Lord Hale put one in the red, and when I glanced at him he was looking at the target with an expression of genuine, unguarded pleasure. Not at his arrow. At mine.

"That was beautifully done," he said.

"Don't."

"Don't what?"

"Compliment me. It's disarming and I'm sure you know it."

"Miss Ashby," he said, "I've never in my life been accused of being disarming. You may have to explain the process to me."

By the last end the whole party had gathered at the rope. I was one point ahead. I drew, and the world narrowed the way it does at those moments, to the straw and the painted gold and the feel of the string against my jaw. Gold. Gold. And then a pair of swans took off from the lake with a sound like wet sheets on a line, and my last arrow went into the red.

Lord Hale needed two golds and a red to tie me, or three golds to win.

He shot the first gold. He shot the second gold. He stood there with the third arrow on the string for so long that Kit said, "Edmund, for pity's sake," and I realized, with a peculiar drop in my stomach, that he was looking at me and not at the target.

Then he turned, drew, and put the arrow dead in the center of the gold, so precisely that it split the painted dot.

The lawn erupted. Somebody's hat went into the lake.

I unstrung my bow with fingers that only shook a little and made myself walk across the grass to him.

"Congratulations, my lord. A fortnight's truce. You have my word."

"Thank you." He wasn't smiling. He looked, if anything, oddly troubled. "Miss Ashby, your fourth end was better than anything I shot today."

"You won."

"I know. I'm only telling you what I saw."

He bowed and went to receive the crowd's congratulations, and I stood holding a bow and an arm guard and a fortnight of enforced silence, and found that what I minded most was not losing. It was that he had stood there with the last arrow and looked at me as though he were deciding something, and I didn't know what it was.

The ride was his idea. Half the party had brought horses, and Lord Hale kept a stable full of animals for guests, and after the cold luncheon he proposed a turn through the deer park before the light went. He put Rose up on a pretty chestnut mare with a white blaze and rode beside her. I was given a sturdy bay gelding and the company of Kit Hale, who had recovered his notebook and his spirits.

"I won forty guineas on you losing," he told me cheerfully. "I'd like you to know I felt dreadful about it."

"You look heartbroken."

"I'm a gifted actor. You'll notice I backed you to win the fourth end. Lost a sovereign on Edmund that time. He never shoots worse than gold when people are watching. Never. Except today." He glanced sideways at me with exactly his brother's grey eyes. "Interesting, isn't it?"

"Not in the least."

Ahead of us, Lord Hale was saying something to Rose, and she was nodding. I could not hear what. I had promised not to try. I kept my eyes on the bracken and counted the reasons I was glad I'd lost, and came up short.

The deer came out of nowhere.

One moment the park was all birdsong and the creak of saddle leather; the next the bracken on our left exploded, and a dozen fallow deer burst across the ride in a flood of dappled backs and white flags of tails. Rose's mare went straight up on her hind legs. Rose kept her seat, bless her, but the moment the mare came down she bolted, flat out down the slope toward the line of dark water where the ponds lay hidden in reeds.

I didn't think. I put my heels to the bay and went.

I am a better rider than my sister. It is the one accomplishment Mama never had to nag me into. The bay had a long stride and a willing heart, and we flew down that slope with the wind tearing my bonnet back on its ribbons. Somewhere to my right I heard hoofbeats coming up fast, and then Lord Hale's grey was alongside me, and he shouted, "Take the left!" and I understood him at once.

We came up on either side of the mare. He leaned out of the saddle further than I would have believed a man of his size could and caught the chestnut's bridle, and I crowded her from the left so she couldn't swerve, and between us we turned her in a long curve away from the water. She slowed. She stopped. Rose sat on her back, white as milk, and said in a very small voice, "Oh, goodness."

I was laughing with relief when the bay put his foot in a rabbit hole.

I remember the ground coming up green, and a great blow in the middle of my back, and then I was lying in the bracken looking at the sky, which was very blue and very far away, and I couldn't remember how breathing went.

"Meg."

Somebody was kneeling over me. Somebody was saying my name in a voice I'd never heard before. Not my family name. Mine.

"Meg. Don't move. Can you hear me? Don't try to sit up."

Air came back into me all at once, in a great embarrassing whoop. I lay there and gasped, and Edmund Hale knelt in the bracken beside me with his face gone the color of candle wax.

"The bay," I managed.

"The bay is perfectly well and eating a thistle. Kit has your sister. Tell me where it hurts."

"My pride, mostly." I tried to move, and a bright line of pain shot up from my left wrist. "And that."

He took my hand very carefully in both of his and turned it. His fingers were steady enough, but I could see a fine tremor running in them, and when he pressed the bones above my wrist and I hissed, he flinched as if he'd been the one hurt.

"Not broken, I think. Sprained." He was already tugging at his cravat. He unwound it with three hard pulls and began to bind my wrist, firm and neat, the way someone does a thing he has done before. "You rode that slope like a madwoman."

"I ride everything like a madwoman. You took the right. You knew I'd take the left."

"I knew you'd take whatever I didn't." He tied off the linen. He didn't let go of my hand. "When you went over, I thought..." He stopped.

I waited.

"My mother died when I was twenty," he said, to my wrist rather than to me. "A fever. It took her in four days. My father had loved her since the day he met her, really loved her, the way people write ballads about, and when she died he went into the library and didn't come out. Not in any way that counted. He stopped eating. He stopped answering letters. The steward robbed us blind, the roof over the east wing came in, and I came home from London to find him sitting in the dark at four in the morning with her shawl in his lap, asking me what day it was." He drew a breath. "He lasted two more years. The doctors couldn't name a cause. I could."

The bracken rustled around us. A long way off, Kit was calling and Rose was answering.

"So that's the roof," I said quietly. "And the four in the morning."

"That's the roof."

"I'm sorry. I mocked you for it."

"You mocked me for saying it about your sister. That was fair." He looked up then, finally, and his grey eyes were not cool at all. "I don't want to sit in a library in the dark, Meg. I've been very careful never to want anything that could put me there."

There was a great deal I could have said. I am not often short of words. But he was still holding my hand, and his cravat was wrapped around my wrist, and his throat was bare above his collar in a way that made me look firmly at a fern.

"You should go to Rose," I said. "She'll be frightened."

Something closed in his face, gently, like a door being pulled to by someone who doesn't want to wake the house. "Of course."

He put me up on his own grey and led it back himself, walking at its head the whole long way to the villa, and he did not speak again. Neither did I.

Mama put me to bed with a cold compress and a great deal of exclaiming. It was past nine when Rose came and sat on the end of my bed in her dressing gown.

"Lord Hale sent his own surgeon round," she said. "He's downstairs drinking Mama's brandy and saying it's a very clean sprain."

"How kind of Lord Hale."

"Meg." She turned her locket in her fingers. "He's written to Mama. He's asked leave to speak to me privately at Lady Carrow's garden party on Saturday."

The compress had gone warm. I took it off and held it.

"You know what that means," Rose said.

I knew what it meant. It meant a proposal. It meant the wine merchant paid and Mama's sleep restored. It meant my sister married to a man who would be civil to her for forty years.

And I had given him my word that for a fortnight I would not say one single thing to stop it.

I lay back against the pillow and looked at the ceiling, and the thing I felt was not outrage on Rose's behalf. I knew outrage. This was lower and sharper and much more shameful, and it had a name I had no intention of saying aloud, even to myself, even in the dark.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI