Forbidden Pleasures

Read the story

6 chapters · 17123 words · Read 0 times

Mormon girl fucks for the first time with a non Mormon guy she's just met. Turns out she loves everything about it.

Chapter 5: First Contact

She pulled him by the shoulders onto the quilt, her mouth finding his in a kiss that tasted of her own salt and his patience. Her hand slid down his stomach, fingers fumbling through coarse hair before closing around the thick, hot weight of his cock. It jumped in her grip, velvety skin stretched taut over rigid iron, and she began to move her hand, an awkward, unpracticed pump. “Is this…?” she whispered against his lips, her rhythm unsure, her thumb stumbling over the slick head.

He exhaled sharply, a controlled hiss. “Yeah, just… here.” His own hand closed over hers, not taking over, but guiding. “A little tighter, love. Just like that.” He showed her the stroke, a smooth, confident glide from root to tip that made his abdomen clench. She mimicked the motion, her determination hardening as she felt him thicken further in her grasp. A bead of moisture welled at the tip, and she smeared it down the length with her thumb, the lewd, wet sound fueling her courage. “You’re so hard,” she murmured, half in awe, half in hunger.

“It’s all for you,” he groaned, his head falling back onto the pillow, his hips giving a slight thrust into her tightening fist. She watched his face, studied the flutter of his closed eyelids, the tension in his jaw, and felt a power so immense it stole her breath. This was her doing. This beautiful, strained pleasure was hers to give. She bent her head, her hair brushing his stomach, and pressed a hesitant kiss to the throbbing vein on the underside. His whole body shuddered.

She wasn't very good, her movements too tentative, her grip inconsistent. "Slow down," he coached, his voice strained but gentle as he stilled her hand. "Use your mouth, but watch your teeth, just use your lips like this." He guided himself, gliding the broad head over her lower lip, a silent demonstration that made her ache with a sharp, mimicking need.

"Stand up," she heard herself say, the command surprising them both. He shifted, rising from the bed to stand before her on the woven rug, his cock standing thick and urgent against his stomach. The command in her own voice propelled her; she slid from the quilt to kneel on the floor between his feet, the hardwood pressing into her knees.

The position filled her with a sense of transgression so profound it stole her breath. She was kneeling, the posture of every desperate prayer she’d ever uttered, but now her eyes were level with the dark thatch of hair at the base of his shaft. The religious nature of kneeling was not lost on her—this was a blasphemous inversion, an altar of flesh. She looked up the length of his body, meeting his darkened gaze, and opened her mouth.

She took just the slick head into her mouth, her tongue flattening against the frenulum as he’d shown her. "Yeah, just like that," he breathed, his hand coming to rest lightly on her hair, not forcing, just present. She hollowed her cheeks and drew him deeper, the salty-bitter taste of pre-come and skin flooding her senses as he nudged the back of her throat. She gagged, pulling back with a wet pop, a string of saliva connecting her lips to him. "Easy," he soothed, his thumb stroking her temple. "Just go as far as you want."

She wanted all of it. The need was a frantic, devouring thing inside her. She took him again, deeper this time, letting him fill the hot, tight channel of her mouth, her world narrowing to the rhythm of his shallow thrusts and the obscene, sucking sounds she made. Her own wetness, a slick reminder of the ruin he’d made of her minutes before, trickled down her inner thigh. She was worshipping, and the temple was profane, and the prayer was the choked sound he made when she swallowed around him.

Her mouth moved with new purpose, learning the shape of him, the rhythm that made his thighs tense. She relaxed her jaw, letting him slide deeper, her tongue lapping at the sensitive ridge beneath the head with each retreat. Her fingers, which had been clutching his hips, drifted lower, exploring the tight, wrinkled heat of his scrotum. She cupped the weight of his balls gently, then with more pressure, rolling them in her palm as she sucked, and the guttural “fuck” that ripped from him was her reward.

“Just like that, Christ, yes,” he rasped, his fingers tangling in her hair but still not forcing. She felt him swell, the veins in his shaft pulsing against her lips, and a fierce pride obliterated her last shred of hesitation. She took him deep, her nose pressed into his skin, her throat working around him until tears beaded in her lashes. The sounds were filthy, wet, and utterly compelling.

The sounds were filthy, wet, and utterly compelling. A deep, instinctual throb between her own legs demanded attention, and her free hand slipped from his thigh to between her own, her fingers sliding through her slick folds with a frantic, circular pressure that mirrored the rhythm of her mouth. She was lost in a feedback loop of sensation, each soft cry he made vibrating through his cock and into her mouth, each desperate grind of her own fingers pushing her closer to another shattering edge.

"Eliza, I'm gonna—" he choked out, his voice strangled and tight, his hips stuttering.

The warning, raw and immediate, sliced through her haze. Where was she supposed to—? A bolt of pure, logistical panic fired through her nerves. She jerked her head back with a wet gasp, releasing him just as his body convulsed.

The first hot, pearlescent stripe landed across her cheekbone, warm and shocking. The next pulse hit her lips, the taste salty and profound. He groaned, his hand fisting himself as he painted her, thick ropes spattering across her chin, her neck, the slope of her bare breast. She knelt frozen, eyes wide, feeling each jet hit her skin like a brand. The final drops landed on her trembling lower belly.

He breathed hard, looking down at her ruined, glistening face. "Fuck," he panted, a shaky laugh escaping him. "You okay?" She didn't answer, just raised a trembling finger to her cheek, staring at the opaque fluid on her fingertip. The silence in the room was absolute, broken only by their ragged breaths.


He lifted her from the floor and laid her back on the rumpled quilt, the blue stitches scratching her sensitized skin. They settled into a tangled quiet, his spent body a heavy, warm line against her side, his fingers tracing idle patterns on her stomach. “That was…” he began, his voice a sleep-roughened murmur near her ear, but he didn’t finish, as if no word fit.

Her own orgasm felt like a distant quake, a tectonic shift in her personal geography that had left canyons in its wake. His, however, was a sticky, present reality cooling on her skin. She focused on the specific sensations: the tacky stripe on her cheek had tightened, a faint pull with every movement of her jaw. The spill across her breast had pooled in the hollow of her clavicle, a warm, viscous weight that seemed to pulse with the memory of his release.

A slow, shocking heat began to bloom low in her belly again. It was the obscenity of it, the absolute filth of being painted like this, that fanned the embers. She felt marked, claimed in a way that went deeper than any promise. Her own slickness, renewed and insistent, mingled with the drying streaks on her lower belly, a cocktail of salt and sex.

His breathing evened out beside her, his hand stilling on her hip. The complete, trusting weight of him pressed her into the mattress. Her own hand, moving with a will of its own, drifted from his chest, down over her own ribcage, through the valley of her waist.

She paused, her fingertips just brushing the sticky mess he’d left on her skin. A sharp, electric jolt went through her. She dragged her fingers through it, feeling the unique, gelatinous texture, and brought them to her nose, then her lips, tasting him again. A low, involuntary sound escaped her throat.

Her other hand slid decisively between her own legs, fingers parting slick folds still swollen and sensitive from his mouth. The touch was a revelation, a circuit closing. This was her hand, her cunt, her raging need, all connected without intermediary. She rubbed slow, firm circles over her clit, her hips shifting against her own touch, the wet sounds loud in the quiet room.

The wet, rhythmic sound of her own fingers working her cunt was the only thing she heard until his breathing changed. Jake stirred beside her, his sleepy gaze focusing on the movement of her arm, the desperate arch of her hips into her own hand. "Fuck, Eliza," he murmured, his voice thick with sleep and sudden, raw interest.

He was hardening again against her thigh, the thick length of him stirring to life as he watched her. She turned her head, her fingers never ceasing their frantic circles, and stared at his cock as it lifted, heavy and full, from its nest of dark hair. The sight was profoundly erotic, a visceral demand that made her own need sharpen into a single, focused point.

She kept touching herself, her eyes locked on that rigid flesh, watching a fresh bead of moisture well at the tip. Her breath came in short, sharp pants, each stroke of her fingers syncing with the throbbing pulse she could see in his shaft. "I want it," she said, the words leaving her in a rush, not a question but a declaration that hung in the air between them.


Jake’s eyes, dark and liquid, held hers. His voice was low, a rough scrape of sound. “You’re sure?” He didn’t move, letting the question linger in the charged space between her spoken desire and the inevitable act. “Earlier, you said just… other things. That was the line.”

Her fingers stilled between her legs, but the ache there was a relentless, pounding drum. She nodded, her hair catching on the dried streaks on her cheek. “I am sure.” The words were clear, devoid of the hesitation that had laced every interaction before tonight. “I want you. Inside me.”

A muscle flexed in his jaw. He shifted onto his elbow, his gaze tracing the tension in her body. “Okay. Hell, yes.” He ran a hand through his hair. “Condom? I don’t have one on me.”

The practicality of it felt absurd, a bureaucratic hurdle in the middle of a wildfire. “I do not have one,” she said, the formal phrasing a stark contrast to the naked hunger on her face. Her hips gave a small, involuntary roll against the mattress, seeking friction.

“Shit.” He blew out a breath, his cock lying heavy and full against her thigh. “I could… I could pull out. It’s not perfect, it’s not safe, but I could try.” The offer was tense, his own desire warring with a responsibility he clearly felt.

Eliza’s eyes didn’t leave him. “Try?” The word was a sharp blade. “What does that mean?” Her voice was quiet, but it cut through the humid air of the room. She needed the mechanics, the cold facts to ground the fever in her blood.

Jake let out a long breath, his thumb stroking her hip. “It means I pull out before I come. It’s not a guarantee. Pre-cum can have sperm in it. And in the moment… sometimes it’s harder to stop than you think.” He was being blunt, his gaze steady on hers. “It’s a risk. A real one.”

She processed this, her mind flickering through a dozen silent warnings from youth lessons about the sacred power of procreation. Here it was, stripped of divinity: biology, slippery and fallible. Her gaze drifted back down his body, past the tense planes of his stomach, to where his cock lay against her thigh. It was a living thing, pulsing with a heat she could feel through her skin.

It was so profoundly male. The thick, blue vein tracing its underside, the flushed, broad head still glistening from her mouth and his own release. She was obsessed with its shape, its potential, the sheer obscene weight of it in her hand earlier. She wanted to feel that weight inside her, stretching her, claiming the hollow, aching space his fingers had found. The lust was a physical taste, metallic and urgent on her tongue.

“The risk is mine,” she said, the words final. It was a calculation, a trade. Her virtue, her potential future, for the visceral truth of this feeling. She was choosing the feeling. “Just… try. Please.”

He studied her face for a long moment, looking for any ghost of doubt. Seeing only resolve, he nodded. “Okay. Your rules. You tell me to stop, I stop. You tell me to pull out, I pull out.” It was a pact, sealed in the quiet.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI