Cover of Fumbled Hearts

Fumbled Hearts

Read the story

1 chapter · 2374 words · Read 0 times

A slow romance about a professional football running back named Drake, 26, once an upcoming superstar star after a devastating injury and two bad seasons he gets traded to the worst team in the league the Huntington Highlanders which also happens to be his home city, as he gets traded and meets the team he runs into Mandy, 25, a old high school sweetheart who is now one of the physical trainers for the team and happens to be engaged to the quarterback of the team, as he sees her again old feelings surface

Chapter 1: Knee Deep in the Past

The ice pack was a cold, skin-numbing lie against his knee. Drake leaned back on the peeling vinyl bench, its cushion deflated by a decade of bigger men, and stared at the exposed pipes snaking across the ceiling. The Highlanders’ training facility smelled of bleach, stale sweat, and the faint, metallic tang of old hope. A fluorescent light in the corner of the weight room buzzed and flickered, stuttering its pale glow over the rust-specked leg press machine.He remembered this place. He remembered it when the paint was fresh and the racks gleamed and his name was whispered in these halls like a promise.

Now, it just felt like a cage for ghosts.His ghost.

He pressed the ice harder into the intricate map of scars around his left patella.The surgeon had done good work. The physical therapist had been a relentless saint.But some damage was metaphysical.The knee was fine, they said. Stronger than before. But the moment his cleat had caught in that damn artificial turf, the loud pop echoing in his own skull before the crowd’s gasp even registered—that moment lived in his muscles, in his dreams.It was the split-second divide between before and after.

The door at the far end of the room swung open with a tired sigh.

Drake didn’t look up. Probably the night janitor, or some eager rookie looking to put in extra time where extra time didn’t matter.The Highlanders were a landfill for broken toys and bad contracts. He was both.Footsteps clicked on the concrete, purposeful, clean.Not rubber soles. A sharp, familiar scent cut through the dank room—citrus and clean linen. His spine stiffened a fraction before his brain could even process why.He looked up.

She stopped halfway to the glass-walled office, her silhouette framed by the dirty hallway light.Clipboard held tight against her chest. Honey-blonde hair pulled back in a severe, perfect ponytail. Her hazel eyes were wide, the professional calm shattered for one breathtaking, vulnerable second.Mandy.

Time didn’t just slow; it folded. The eight years between now and the last time he’d seen her—really seen her, not in a tabloid blur beside her quarterback—collapsed into the space of a held breath.She was sharper now. Her face had lost its softness, honed into a structured, beautiful severity.But her eyes… they were the same.Still the color of summer oak leaves.

“Drake.” His name from her lips wasn’t a greeting.It was an accusation. A statement of fact, cold and hard.

“Mandy Collins.” He kept his voice flat, removing the ice pack.The skin underneath was angry and red. “Or is it something else now?”

She didn’t flinch.Her professionalism snapped back into place like a visor slamming down. “It’s still Collins.For now.” She gestured with the clipboard toward his knee. “Early assessment?You weren’t due until Monday.”

“Couldn’t sleep. Thought I’d get reacquainted with the scenery.” He stood, testing his weight. A dull throb, nothing more.“Heard the team hired a new head of physical training.Congratulations. Didn’t realize it was you.”

“You would have, if you ever read the memos they send you.” She walked past him to the office, her shoulder brushing the air a good foot from his.He caught another wave of her scent. It unlocked a vault of memories: grass stains on her jeans, the way she’d yell play-by-play from the stands, her fingers laced with his under a sticky multiplex table.He shoved them back down.

She flipped on the office light, a warmer, kinder glow.“Come in. Let’s get the baseline, since you’re here.”

He followed, the familiar ritual a strange comfort.The office was ruthlessly organized. Kinesiology textbooks, a model skeleton, a tablet charging. And on the desk, in a simple silver frame, a photo of Mandy and Chase Hendricks, the Highlanders’ golden-boy quarterback, smiling on a sun-drenched golf course.His arm was around her. Her smile didn’t reach her eyes.Drake looked away, focusing on a poster about proper hydration.

“How’s the knee, really?” she asked, her voice all business. She hadn’t looked up from her tablet.“It’s fine.”

“Your medical file says you favor it.Compensate. That’s how you get hurt again.”

“My medical file’s a novel written by people who’ve never taken a hit.”

She finally looked at him. “I’ve read the chapter on the hit you took.The LCL, the meniscus, the microfractures. I know the biomechanics better than you do.”

“Yeah, well, knowing it and feeling it are different.” He leaned against the doorframe, crossing his arms. “You look good, Mandy.”

The statement hung there, clumsy and too honest. She froze for a second, then tapped her screen with more force than necessary.“Sit on the table. Range of motion first.”

He obeyed, the paper crinkling under him. Her hands were clinical as they guided his leg, her touch firm, impersonal.But her fingers were warm.He remembered how warm they were. “So, you and Hendricks, huh?”

“Yes.” A single, clipped syllable.

“Good for you.Safe choice.”

Her head snapped up.“What’s that supposed to mean?”

“Nothing. He’s a franchise QB.Stable.Secure. Not a guy who gets traded to the laughingstock of the league for a bag of deflated footballs.”

She measured the flexion of his knee, her gaze fixed on the goniometer. “He’s a good man.”

“I’m sure he is.”

The silence that followed was thick enough to chew. She moved to the other side, checking his hamstring strength.“Why are you here, Drake? Really?”

“They traded me.”

“You could have fought it. You have a no-trade clause.”

He shrugged, a movement that felt hollow. “Maybe I wanted to come home.”

A bitter, quiet laugh escaped her.“Home?You couldn’t wait to leave this place. You told me it was a graveyard for ambition.”

“I was young and stupid.”

“You got that right.” She put the tablet down, finally meeting his eyes fully. The professional mask had slipped again, revealing the raw, unfiltered hurt underneath.“You left.You didn’t call. You didn’t write.You just… vanished into your bright new future. And now you’re back because your future dimmed.Don’t tell me you wanted to come home.”

He had no answer. She was right.Every word was a direct hit. He’d been running toward something so fast he never looked back, until the thing he was running toward crumbled beneath him. Now all that was left was the place, and the person, he’d run from.

Her pager buzzed on her hip.She glanced at it, a flicker of annoyance crossing her face. “I have to go.Chase needs some pre-practice work.Your baseline looks… adequate. Don’t push too hard. Don’t be a hero on day one.” She grabbed her clipboard, her movements stiff.“Mandy.”

She paused, one hand on the door.“I am sorry. For all of it.”

She didn’t turn around. Her shoulders rose and fell with a steadying breath.“Sorry doesn’t rebuild ligaments, Drake. Or trust.”

And then she was gone, her footsteps fading down the hollow hall.

Drake sat alone in the silent office, the ghost of her touch still warm on his skin, the echo of her words colder than ice. He looked at the photo of her and Chase again.The safe choice.The stable future.

He stood, a sudden, reckless energy crackling through him. He walked back into the empty weight room, toward the leg press. He loaded the rack with more plates than he should, the iron clanging like a bell in the quiet.He wasn’t here to be stable.He wasn’t here to be safe. He was here, in the ruins of everything, with a busted knee and a busted past. And the only thing left was to push. To push until something, or someone, broke.

The weight shifted with a deep, metallic groan.Drake positioned himself under the cradle, his bad knee protesting already. He’d show adequate.He’d show fine.He’d push until the machine itself screamed.

“Whoa, easy there, Hulk. Save some for the actual practice.”

The voice was smooth, practiced, and came from the doorway. Drake let the weight settle back onto the safety catches with a deafening clang and sat up, wiping sweat from his brow.

Chase Hendricks leaned against the doorframe, arms crossed over his pristine, logo-emblazoned training shirt. He was everything Drake wasn’t at that moment: clean, un-sweaty, perfectly composed. His smile was a media-trained thing, all white teeth and calculated warmth that didn’t touch his eyes.

“Heard you were in early,” Chase said, pushing off the wall and walking in with an easy swagger. “Mandy mentioned it.”

Just the sound of her name in his mouth sent a jolt through Drake.“Just getting a feel for the place,” Drake said, standing. He was an inch shorter than Chase, but broader. “Don’t worry, I’m not trying to steal your thunder.Just your leg press.”

Chase chuckled, a hollow, friendly sound. He ran a hand through his perfectly tousled hair.“All yours, man. This old equipment’s probably nostalgic for you. Heard you pumped iron here back in the glory days.” He said it without a hint of malice, which somehow made it worse. “Welcome home, by the way.Wild that they brought you back.”

“Wild,” Drake echoed, grabbing his towel.

“Seriously, though. That knee.” Chase’s gaze dropped to Drake’s leg, his head tilted with performative concern.“Mandy’s the best. She’ll get you right.Just listen to her.She knows what she’s doing.”

There it was. The territorial marking, soft as a velvet glove.My fiancée.My trainer.My domain.

“She always did,” Drake said, the words coming out rougher than he intended.

A flicker of something—curiosity, suspicion—passed behind Chase’s eyes. The charming smile didn’t slip.“Right.You two went to high school together, she said. Small world.”

“Tiny.”

The air in the room, already thick, turned viscous. The flickering light buzzed like a trapped insect.

“Well,” Chase clapped his hands together once, the sound sharp in the quiet.“I’m off.Mandy’s waiting for me. You know how it is—gotta keep the franchise arm in working order.” He turned to leave, then paused, looking back over his shoulder.His expression was all friendly advice.“A word to the wise? The press here… they can be brutal.They’ll be looking for a story. The fallen local hero, the tragic return.Don’t give them one. Just keep your head down and hit the holes they open up. We’re glad to have you.”

It was a masterclass in passive-aggressive dismissal.Know your role.You’re a supporting character now. Before Drake could form a response, Chase gave a final, effortless nod and was gone, his footsteps retreating down the hall.

Drake stood alone in the center of the worn-out room, the echo of Chase’s presence clinging to him like a bad scent. The weight on the leg press seemed to mock him.He wasn’t pushing against iron anymore. He was pushing against the entire, immovable weight of the past—Mandy’s hurt, his own failures, and now Chase Hendricks’s perfectly secure, grinning future.He stared at the empty doorway. A cold, sharp clarity cut through the regret.This wasn’t just about football anymore. It was about everything he’d let slip through his fingers. And the man who now held it all was waiting down the hall, expecting him to just keep his head down and hit the holes.

Drake’s hands tightened into fists at his sides.

Drake’s hands tightened into fists at his sides. The clang of the weight stack settling still seemed to vibrate in his teeth. He grabbed his bag, slinging it over his shoulder with a force that tugged at his scar tissue, and pushed out into the corridor.

The hall lights were mostly off, leaving him in a tunnel of shadows punctuated by the occasional safety exit’s green glow. His footsteps were too loud. Everything felt too loud—the hum of the refrigeration unit for the cryotherapy chamber, the drip of a leaky faucet in a sink somewhere. He needed air that didn’t smell like industrial cleaner and regret.

The player’s parking lot was mostly empty, just a few luxury trucks and his own beat-up sedan. The night had turned cold, a sharp wind cutting across the vast asphalt field.It felt good.It numbed the surface.

He leaned against his car door, fumbling for his keys, and let his head drop forward.The quiet out here was different. It wasn’t peaceful; it was waiting. His knee gave a definitive, unhappy throb, a personal, intimate rebuttal to his earlier defiance. He could still feel the ghost of Mandy’s hands, clinical and sure, and the slick, patronizing pat on the back from Chase.

“Just hit the holes they open up,” he muttered to the darkness, the words frosting in the air.Is that all he was now?A rented tool? A hometown novelty act for the fans to pity?

A train whistle sounded in the distance, a long, lonely cry that seemed to slice through the valley.It was the same sound he’d heard from his childhood bedroom window, dreaming of escape. Now it just sounded like it was leaving without him.

He unlocked the car and was about to slide in when a shift of light caught his eye.Movement. Across the lot, near the staff entrance, a car door closed. The interior light flashed for a second, illuminating a profile he knew in his bones.Mandy.

She was just standing there beside her car, a sleek grey sedan that looked sensible and reliable.She wasn’t looking at him. She was looking at the building, at the flickering light in the weight room window. Her arms were crossed, clipboard now doubtless tucked away in the passenger seat.Her breath plumed in the cold air in short, faint clouds.

She was completely still.Drake froze, one foot in his car, one on the asphalt. He knew he should get in, drive away, preserve the shred of dignity he had left. But he was rooted, watching her watch the place where he’d just been.Where they’d just been. Her professional mask was gone out here in the dark. Her shoulders weren’t squared for battle; they were just… carrying weight.The set of her jaw was soft, thoughtful.Almost sad.

What was she thinking? Was she remembering the kid he used to be, the one who promised her everything on that same cracked concrete where they’d sat after curfew? Was she calculating his muscle recovery rates?Was she regretting walking away, or relieved she had?

The wind picked up, whipping a stray piece of paper across the lot.She didn’t move. She just watched the dim, buzzing window, a silent sentinel to a past he’d ruined and a present that was a mess for them both.

MANDY WATCHES SILENTLY.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI