Chapter 2: Knowing You, Knowing Us
Graham built a spreadsheet.
Of course he did. He sent it to me at nearly midnight on the Sunday before we left, under the subject line MARLOW, G. & T. (WORKING DRAFT). It had five tabs: Origin Story, Preferences, Conflicts, Known Unknowns and Exit Plan.
"Conflicts?" I said, somewhere on the long climb out of Montrose, with my bare feet on his dashboard and my laptop balanced on my knees. His pickup was old enough to have a tape deck and clean enough that I felt guilty about the feet. I left them there anyway. Wives do that.
"Every marriage has them," Graham said, eyes on the road. "Nobody believes a couple who never fight. I gave us three. You load the dishwasher like a raccoon. I leave cabinet doors open. And we disagree about whether cereal is a soup."
"It's obviously not a soup."
"See? Realistic."
"How did we meet?"
"You spilled a drink on me at a wedding you were running."
"I have never spilled anything at an event in my life."
"Which is why it was memorable. Cell C4."
I scrolled. "And the proposal. Oh, no. I proposed?"
"In a hardware store. Aisle nine. You were holding a box of drywall anchors and you said, 'I think we should just do it,' and I said, 'The shelf?' and you said, 'No, Graham.'"
I stared at the side of his face. A muscle in his jaw was doing something suspicious.
"That's actually good," I said.
"I had five hours of insomnia and a strong opinion about drywall."
"Under Preferences it says you love cilantro. I told the whole office you hate cilantro."
"Then I hate cilantro." He flicked the indicator, though there wasn't another car for miles. "I'll suffer. It's what husbands do."
"Also you snore."
"I do not snore."
"You do now. Priyanka worries about your sinuses."
He drove for a while in silence. Then he said, very seriously, "Tell Priyanka I'm seeing someone about it," and I laughed so hard I had to close the laptop.
Kindred Pines sat at the end of a gravel road that went on long enough to make you wonder about your life choices. Then the aspens opened, and there it was: a log lodge with a green tin roof, a scatter of cabins in the trees, and Larkspur Lake below, so still and so dark it looked like someone had poured it out of a bottle. Red canoes lay belly-up along the dock like a row of sleeping animals.
Graham turned off the engine and didn't move.
"You okay?" I asked.
"Fine." He took his hands off the wheel. The cracked watch caught the light. "It's smaller than I remembered."
"From when?"
But he was already out of the truck, and a small woman with a long white braid was coming down the lodge steps toward us, with a steel whistle bouncing against her flannel shirt.
"Marlows?" she called. "You're last. Phones in the basket."
The basket sat on a stump by the door. It was wicker, full of everyone's phones, with a hand-painted sign that said LATER.
"I'm June," she said. She looked at me and then at Graham, and her gaze stayed on him one beat longer than it needed to. "Walt's the tall one carving a duck by the fire pit. Don't ask him about the duck. Dinner's at six. The quiz is at seven. Cabin's Bluebell, up the hill on the left."
"Quiz," I said faintly, as she walked off.
Graham put his phone in the basket and then held out his hand for mine. When I gave it to him, his fingers brushed my ring, and he said, very low, "Don't touch it tonight."
Marjorie met him on the lodge porch. She had swapped the pantsuit for linen and a straw sun hat so wide it had its own weather, and she looked Graham up and down the way she looked at a venue she suspected of having mice.
"So," she said. "You're the husband."
"I'm the husband," Graham agreed, and offered his hand. "Graham. Tess talks about you constantly."
"Does she." Marjorie shook it. "She never talks about you at all."
"She's protective," said Graham, and put his hand on my shoulder, lightly, as if he did it every day. "I'm not good in crowds. She's spent three years making sure I never have to be." He looked down at me. "Haven't you, Tess."
It was the first time he'd used my name without the Ms. in front of it. I felt it somewhere just under my collarbone, and I didn't like that at all.
"Somebody has to," I said.
Corbin and Lila arrived in matching quarter-zips and stood beside us, and Corbin squinted at Graham for a long moment.
"Have we met?" he said. "You look really familiar."
"I have one of those faces," Graham said.
He did not have one of those faces. Nobody had one of those faces. But Corbin let it go, mostly because Lila had spotted the Phoenix couple, Brent and Dana Kessler, coming up from the dock in identical fleeces, and needed to tell him about it urgently.
The quiz happened in the great room of the lodge, in front of a stone fireplace big enough to park a car in. Six couples sat on benches with small chalkboards on their knees. June stood in front of the fire with a stack of index cards.
"Write your answer," she said. "Don't look at each other. Hold your boards up when I blow the whistle. I've been doing this fifty years, so don't bother cheating, I can smell it."
The first few were easy because the spreadsheet had covered them. Where did you meet. Who said "I love you" first. (Him, Cell D2, on a ski lift, by accident, while I was screaming about the height.)
"What does your spouse order at a coffee shop?"
I wrote BLACK COFFEE, because Cell B7 said black coffee, and I held it up at the whistle.
Graham's board said: OAT MILK CORTADO, EXTRA SHOT. ASKS THEM TO WRITE A FAKE NAME ON THE CUP.
The room murmured. Lila said, "Aww."
I turned to him slowly. "How do you know that?"
"You brought one to the pitch," he said. "The cup said Dolores."
"Dolores is my coffee name."
"I know," he said. "Black coffee is mine. Well done."
June made a mark on her clipboard and didn't say anything, which felt like a review.
The Kesslers got every question right, in unison, like a pair of synchronized swimmers. Corbin wrote that Lila's favorite movie was a romantic comedy, and Lila wrote a documentary about deep-sea fish, and they spent the next two questions not speaking.
Then June turned over the last card and read it out in exactly the same flat voice as the others.
"What is your spouse most afraid of?"
I knew this one. Cell B12 said HEIGHTS, and I'd already established it with the ski lift. I wrote it in big letters and held it up at the whistle.
Graham's board said: BEING FOUND OUT.
There was a short, uncertain silence. Marjorie lowered her glasses. Across the room, Corbin tilted his head like a dog hearing a whistle only dogs can hear.
Graham didn't look at me. He picked up the chalk and wrote underneath, in smaller letters: THAT SHE CRIES AT EVERY PROPOSAL VIDEO ON THE INTERNET. SHE THINKS NOBODY KNOWS.
The room laughed in relief. Lila said, "Oh, me too," and put her head on Corbin's shoulder, and the moment rolled past.
I sat very still on the bench, because it was true. I do. Every one. I had never told a living soul, and I had absolutely not put it in the spreadsheet.
The trust fall was on the second morning, off a waist-high stump at the edge of the meadow. June called it Falling Practice, because she said "trust" was a word people used to sell insurance.
I stood on the stump with my back to Graham and my arms crossed over my chest like a mummy, and I did not fall.
"Any time, Mrs. Marlow," June said from the grass.
"I'm preparing."
"She'll go like a filing cabinet," Graham said, conversationally, behind me. "Straight down, all corners."
"I am not a filing cabinet."
"You've already planned the angle, the speed, and the possibility that I'm secretly a terrible person who wants to drop you in front of your boss."
I had. All three.
"Tess," he said, quieter. "I'm not going to let you hit the ground. That's the whole deal."
I closed my eyes and fell like a filing cabinet. He caught me well before the halfway point, steady, his hands firm under my shoulders, and for a second I was looking straight up at him against a sky so blue it seemed fake.
"See," he said. "Got you."
"You could have dropped me," I said, slightly breathless, which I blamed on the altitude.
"I could have," he agreed, and set me on my feet, and let go a little later than he needed to.
Bluebell cabin had one window, one woodstove, one rag rug, one bed with a blue quilt and a screened sleeping porch with a camp cot.
We had both seen the bed on the first night. We had both decided not to discuss it in daylight. So on the second night, after a canoe drill that ended with Marjorie's sun hat floating serenely toward Utah, we stood in the porch doorway and argued about who got the cot.
"I'll take the porch," Graham said.
"You're six foot something. You'll take the bed and I'll take the porch."
"I'm not letting my wife sleep on the porch."
"I'm not your wife."
"Then I'm definitely not letting a stranger sleep on the porch. That's worse manners."
He won, in the end, because he simply carried the spare quilt and the spare pillow out to the porch cot and closed his eyes, and it is very hard to argue with a man who is pretending to be asleep.
I turned off the lamp. The woodstove ticked. Somewhere out on the lake a loon called, a long, wavering sound that seemed far too sad for such a pretty bird.
"Graham," I said, into the dark.
"Mm."
"What did you mean, smaller than you remembered?"
For a while I thought he'd actually fallen asleep. Then the porch cot creaked as he shifted.
"My parents were married on that dock," he said. "June married them. There's a photograph of the two of them on it, laughing, with their shoes off. It's the only picture I have where they're both laughing at the same time." He paused. "They died within a year of each other, not long after I started the firm. I came up here alone afterward, once. I didn't stay."
I lay there holding the edge of the quilt.
"If Phoenix gets it," he said, "that dock is a boat launch for a hundred and forty condominiums. And the photo is just a photo of a place that doesn't exist."
"Graham, I'm so sorry."
"Don't be. Be convincing." I could hear the almost-smile in it. "Go to sleep, Mrs. Marlow."
I didn't. I lay awake for a long time listening to the porch cot creak, very quietly, under a man who did not snore at all, which I was going to have to lie about to Priyanka.
Sometime after the loon gave up, there was a knock on the cabin door.
Graham was on his feet before I'd sat up. He opened it. June stood on the step in a parka with a lantern in her hand, as if she'd been out walking the shoreline in the dark, which I was beginning to suspect she did every night.
"You two will skip the sunrise hike," she said. "My porch. Seven sharp. Private counselling."
"Just us?" I said.
"Just you." She held the lantern up a little, so it lit Graham's face, and studied him the way she'd studied him at the basket. "I've only got questions for the people who need them."
Then she went off down the hill, and the lantern swung away through the pines, and Graham stood in the doorway with his hand on the frame.
"She knows," he said.