Cover of Mind Over Monogamy

Mind Over Monogamy

Read the story

4 chapters · 16039 words · Read 0 times

Tony and Jeannie Nelson have a marriage people dream of. They're deeply in love and have a solid partnership. For Tony and Jeannie's fifth anniversary party, they meet their friends at the Nirvana nightclub. Jimmy Nelson, Dee & Dale Gale, Sofia & Larry Lawrence, and Lauren & David Jensen are all there for the celebration & dancing. For an hour, the celebration is perfect with stories, laughing, and dancing. Then the local NFL quarterback, Max Glover, comes to the table. Max is all charm and asks for the honor of a dance with Jeannie. The friends try to distract Tony, Jimmy, and David, all of whom are less enchanted with Max and the 'experience' the rest of the friends think is a wonderful once-in-a-lifetime event. Drinks and more jokes flow, but Tony, Jimmy, and David keep one eye on Jeannie. One dance turns to three, then Jeannie, Max, and the wingmen spend another 20 minutes at the bar. Jeannie finally returns to the table alone, all smiles and affectionate with Tony. After a half hour, Max and his wingmen move away from the bar and head for the exit. Not long after, Jeannie and the rest of the women take a bathroom break that Jeannie never returns from.

Chapter 2: The Intervention

The distance closed in a series of hyper-real images: the splintered light on Max's grin, the press of jeering, sweat-damp strangers, the bass a physical shove against his chest. Tony moved through it like a diver under pressure, silent and intent. Jeannie’s head was tilted back, throat exposed, and Max was whispering into that vulnerable space. His right hand was a dark star against the scarlet silk of her dress. The shot glasses gleamed like discarded weapons.

Tyler Johnson and Jordan Briggs saw him coming. They didn’t step forward so much as they widened, inflating their already massive frames to fill the space between the bar and the club at large. They were a barricade of meat and muscle in designer shirts.

Tyler, his face a mask of practiced reason, held up a placating hand. The cold, appraising look he’d given Tony earlier was gone, replaced by the smooth, schmoozy charm of a bouncer paid to de-escalate.

“Hey man, relax,” Tyler’s voice boomed, fighting the music without seeming to raise his volume. “No need for any tension. Let me buy your table a round. Top shelf, all night. It’s a celebration, right? Anniversary. We can all be cool here.”

Tony stopped just outside the personal space the two men occupied. His eyes were not on Tyler, nor on Jordan. They were fixed on Max, over Tyler’s shoulder. He saw Max’s face register his approach, saw the flicker of irritation, the mild annoyance of a king interrupted.

“You’re in my way,” Tony said. His voice was a low, clear statement. It didn’t carry far, but Tyler and Jordan heard it perfectly. “Move.”

Jordan’s thick neck swelled. A vein pulsed at his temple. His was the simpler fury, the straightforward aggression of a man who solved problems by turning them into paste. “You’re the one who needs to move, little man. Back to your sad little table.”

Tyler cut in, leaning closer, the offer turning sharp. “Don’t be stupid. You got no play here. Take the free drinks and go find yourself a pity fuck somewhere. This ain’t your table anymore.”

Tony’s gaze finally slid to Tyler. And he smiled. It wasn’t a kind smile. It was a predator’s smile, revealing the hunter beneath the calm.

He didn’t look around. He didn’t have to. He gestured loosely with his chin at the air around them. “Haven’t you idiots figured it out yet? Look up.”

Tyler’s eyes flickered, involuntarily. Around them, the throng was no longer just dancing. A ring had formed, a loose semicircle of onlookers with their phones raised. The screens were a constellation of cold white light, pointed squarely at the confrontation. Some were filming. Some were livestreaming.

“There are at least two dozen phones on us right now,” Tony continued, his tone conversational, almost bored. “Most of them are picking up every word. You two are celebrities. He’s a celebrity.” He nodded toward Max. “And I’m just a guy asking for a word with his wife. But see, I don’t actually have to win a fight here. I just have to make sure you lose one.”

He let the words hang, letting the implication coil around the two massive men.

“Career-ending injuries happen in bar fights all the time,” Tony finished softly. “An ACL tears. A knee blows out. A jaw gets wired shut. Really unfortunate accidents. You think your team lawyers can ND-A the entire internet? You think those brand managers for your sports drink deals will like the clip of you beating up a civilian for talking to his own wife?”

Jordan’s patience, already a frayed thread, snapped. Logic was Tyler’s department. His department was violence. With a guttural roar that cut through the music, he lunged.

It wasn’t a punch from a trained fighter. It was a haymaker, a huge, looping right arm designed to decapitate. It was terrifying in its power and its stupidity. Tony watched it come, seeing the telegraph in the hitch of Jordan’s shoulder, the shift of his weight. The club’s strobe lights made it look like a series of frozen, clumsy frames.

Tony didn’t block. He didn’t dodge backwards. He simply moved in. As Jordan’s fist whistled past the space where his head had been, Tony stepped forward, inside the arc of the swing, his body flowing like water around a stone.

His left hand came up to cup and guide Jordan’s tricep, not to stop the blow but to keep it going, to unbalance the man further. At the same moment, his right arm shot forward, palm open, fingers relaxed, powered not by his arm but by the forward surge of his entire body. The heel of his palm landed directly on the center of Jordan’s solar plexus.

The impact made a sound like a heavy sack of grain being dropped from a height. A hollow, sickening thump.

All the air left Jordan Briggs’s lungs in a voiceless whoosh. His eyes bulged, shock obliterating rage. He didn’t double over. He simply lifted off his feet, propelled backwards by the focused, concussive force. He crashed into a group of empty high-top tables near the dance floor, the plastic and metal shattering under 295 pounds of stunned, breathless muscle. He lay in the wreckage, gasping like a fish on a dock, clutching his chest, utterly incapable of moving.

Silence didn’t fall. The music still thumped. But in the immediate circle, the silence was deafening. The phone screens wavered, then steadied, zooming in.

Tyler stared, his mind racing to process what his eyes had just seen. His brother Jordan, a professional athlete who trained daily to take hits from 300-pound men, had been felled by one open-handed strike from a man half his width. The calculation in his eyes shifted from containment to genuine, sudden alarm.

With a snarl born more of instinct than thought, Tyler charged. He didn’t swing. He went for the clinch, the bear hug, aiming to wrap his tree-trunk arms around Tony and crush the life from him.

Tony turned to meet him, his movements unhurried. As Tyler’s arms encircled him, starting to squeeze with terrifying force, Tony didn’t struggle against the grip. Instead, he dropped his center of gravity, rooting his feet to the floor. His right arm bent at the elbow, folded tight to his body. Then, as Tyler heaved, Tony twisted his torso violently to the left, a coil of power unleashing.

His right elbow pistoned backward. It was a short, brutal strike, no more than eight inches of travel, but it carried the torque of his hips and the immovable strength of his rooted stance.

The point of Tony’s elbow connected perfectly with the hinge of Tyler Johnson’ s jaw.

There was a wet, sharp crack, audible even over the music. Tyler’s head snapped to the side. His eyes rolled back white. The immense pressure of the bear hug vanished instantly, replaced by total muscular failure. All 325 pounds of him went limp. He slid down Tony’s impossible body, a puppet with its strings cut, and crumpled to the polished concrete in a heap. He did not get up.

Tony straightened his suit jacket with a single, crisp tug. He hadn’t even broken a sweat.

He turned. The path to the bar was clear.

Max Glover stood frozen, his charismatic mask shattered. He’d watched his human shields evaporate in seconds. Jeannie was pressed against the bar, her hands over her mouth, her eyes wide with a chaotic mix of terror, shock, and a dawning, horrifying clarity. The two wingmen were broken toys scattered on the floor.

Tony walked the last few steps. He didn’t look at Jeannie. Not yet.

Max, seeing that cold, patient gaze land on him, threw his hands up in a gesture of surrender. “Whoa, whoa, hey man! It’s not what you think! We were just talking, having some drinks! It’s a club! It’s harmless!” His voice was a frantic warble, the smooth baritone gone. “She wanted to dance! She’s an adult!”

Tony stopped in front of him. He finally glanced at Jeannie. Her face was pale, tear-streaked. The giddy light in her eyes was gone, replaced by a shame so profound it was almost physical. She opened her mouth, but no sound came out.

Tony looked back at Max. For the first time, he let a fraction of the storm inside show on his face. It wasn’t rage. It was disgust.

“You don’t get to tell me what my wife wanted,” Tony said, the words so quiet Max had to lean in to hear them over the bass. He did lean in, a reflex of fear.

As Max leaned, Tony’s hand moved. It wasn’t a strike. It was a gesture. He reached out and, with two fingers, tapped Max sharply on the center of his forehead. It was less a hit than a punctuation mark.

“You’re a cockroach,” Tony said, his voice still low. “And I don’t waste time on cockroaches.”

Max flinched back as if scalded, his hand flying to his unmarked forehead. The indignity of it, the sheer dismissiveness, was a different kind of violence.

Tony turned his back on the quarterback completely. He looked at his wife. “Jeannie. We’re going back to the table, now.”

It wasn’t a question. It was a statement of fact, as immutable as the laws of physics. He held out his hand, palm up, not to help her from the stool, but as a simple point of departure. The decision was hers. The consequences were already written.

Jeannie stared at his outstretched hand as if it were a venomous snake. A tremble moved through her entire body, starting deep within and rippling out to her fingertips where they clutched at the cold marble bar top. The gaudy club lights painted her face in flashes of horror-struck blue and sickly gold.

She looked past Tony to the crumpled forms of Tyler and Jordan. One was groaning, trying to push himself up from the debris. The other was ominously still.

A choked sob finally broke from her lips. She slid off the stool, her legs buckling. She caught herself, her gaze darting between Tony’s impassive face and the carnage he’d caused without even seeming to try.

He didn’t move his hand. He just waited. The phone lights around them were blinding, a hundred silent witnesses.

Her hand, cold and damp with sweat, slipped into his. The contact was electric with shame. He closed his fingers around hers, his grip firm, steadying, devoid of any punishing pressure. He simply turned and began leading her back through the parted sea of gawkers.

They walked through the wreckage of tables, past Jordan who was now sitting up, wheezing. Jimmy was there, materializing at Tony’s side without a word. He had his phone up, but he was filming the wingmen, the bar, Max’s pallid face. Gathering evidence.

Tony didn’t stop. He guided Jeannie through the pulsing crowd, which shrank back from him now with a new, instinctive fear. The path to their VIP table was a quiet corridor in the middle of the chaos.

David was already on his feet, his chair knocked over behind him. Lauren stood beside him, her face pale. Dale, Dee, Larry, and Sofia were a tableau of stunned silence, mouths slightly agape. Their eyes were huge, moving from Tony and Jeannie to the distant commotion.

“Jesus Christ, Tony,” David breathed as they reached the table. He looked his friend up and down, searching for injury, for any sign of the storm that had just passed.

Tony released Jeannie’s hand. She stood there, swaying slightly, wrapping her arms around herself.

Jeannie’s eyes swam with tears as she looked at the faces of her friends, her husband. Her voice was a fractured whisper, crushed by the weight in the air. “I… I’m so sorry.” She dragged a shaking hand across her wet cheek. “To all of you. Tony… I don’t… I don’t know what came over me.”

She looked at Tony, her gaze pleading for an explanation he couldn’t possibly give. “It’s like… I remember him asking me to dance. The lights, his smile. Then everything gets warm and fuzzy and fast. I remember the shots. I remember laughing. But it’s like watching a bad movie.”

Her breath hitched. She looked toward the bar, her eyes wide with genuine terror. “Then I saw you. And I saw that huge man, Tyler, just… drop. Like a stringless marionette. And it all just… shattered.”

The table was stone quiet. Even Dee had no quip. The reality of the violence, the raw confusion in Jeannie’s voice, it leached all the celebratory sheen from the night.

Jeannie swallowed hard, forcing a trembling, awful smile. “Can… can we please just get back to it?To us? To our night?” Her voice was desperate. “It’s our anniversary. I can’t let it end like this. Please.”

It was a plea to Tony, but also to the group. A bid for normalcy, however impossible.

Dee snapped into action first, the lawyer in her recognizing a narrative that needed immediate repair. “Yes. Absolutely. Of course we can.” She forced a bright, brittle laugh. “Honestly, Jeannie, you just had a celebrity moment. That’s all. It’s over now.”

Sofia leaned in, her voice a soothing murmur. “Tony handled it. Like a total badass, by the way.” Her eyes flicked to Tony, who had taken his seat again, saying nothing. “He protected you. It’s actually… really hot.” The last part was barely audible, but Lauren heard it and shot her a shocked look.

Lauren, chastened and fearful, chimed in softly. “David, sit down. Let’ s just… try to have a drink. For Tony and Jeannie.”

The party reconvened with the hesitant, clumsy energy of a bomb squad trying to defuse a device. Glasses were refilled. Stiff smiles were pasted on. Larry mumbled something about getting more fries. Dale clapped Tony too hard on the back.

Tony watched it all from his throne of quiet detachment. His eyes periodically scanned the club floor.

Three more massive men—Chad, Jacob, and Logan—had arrived. They hauled Jordan and a semi-conscious Tyler to their feet with rough, efficient motions. Max was there, his face a twisted mask of fury, snarling instructions at them. He kept glancing toward Tony’s table, his expression shifting from rage to something like baffled fear. One of the new wingmen went to the bar, threw down a wad of cash, and collected a bottle. Then, as a unit, they shouldered their way toward the exit, a battered convoy retreating from a battlefield they didn’t understand.

For the next thirty minutes, a thin veneer of celebration was painstakingly applied. Jeannie was the primary architect. She became effusive, overcompensating with a torrent of physical affection. She clung to Tony’s arm, kissed his cheek repeatedly, ran her fingers through his hair. She laughed too loudly at every mumbled comment from Dale or Larry.

Tony accepted it all. He allowed the touches, the kisses. He even draped his arm around her shoulders. But his responses were minimal. A faint smile. A nod. A soft “thanks” when she refilled his water glass from the bottle on the table. His calm was a deep, still lake, and her frantic pebbles of affection disappeared into it without a ripple.

Dee and Sofia were fascinated, leaning in with glittering eyes whenever there was a lull. “Tony, that was… incredible,” Dee breathed, her professional curiosity overtaking her earlier spin. “Where did you learn to move like that?”

“Just some stuff my grandfathers taught me,” Tony said, taking a sip of water. His tone was flat, a door gently but firmly closed.

“That wasn’t ‘some stuff,’” Sofia pressed, her voice husky. “That was… surgical. Did you see their faces?”

Tony looked at her. Just looked. His hazel eyes held no pride, no anger, no invitation. “I saw they were in my way,” he said simply, and turned to answer a question from Larry about the golf outing next week.

The rebuff was polite, absolute, and frustrating. Dee finally sighed, exchanging a glance with Sofia. She looked at Jeannie, whose mascara had bled into dark smudges under her eyes from her earlier tears, creating a sad, raccoon-like mask over her forced gaiety.

“Okay, ladies,” Dee announced, standing up. She leaned down and put a gentle hand on Jeannie’s shoulder. “Sweetie, your makeup’s a little… celebratory. Let’s go fix you up.” Her tone was light, but it was a command. A regrouping.

Jeannie looked up, then at Tony. He gave a small, permissive nod. “Go ahead.”

All four women—Jeannie, Dee, Sofia, and Lauren—rose and wove their way through the tables toward the corridor that housed the restrooms. The sway of their dresses, the click of their heels, felt like a retreat.

David watched them go, his expression darkening again. He slumped back in his chair with a loud, disgusted groan. “Great. Just great. Now they’re going to have a debrief. We’ll be lucky if we see them before dawn.”

The remaining men—Tony, Jimmy, David, Dale, and Larry—let out a low, collective chuckle. It was a hollow sound, devoid of real humor. A release of the unbearable tension.

Tony’s chuckle faded first. He watched the dark mouth of the corridor where the women had vanished. His fingers tightened almost imperceptibly around his water glass.

He watched the empty corridor for three full seconds after the last swish of fabric disappeared. Then his eyes flicked to Jimmy, who had been silent throughout the entire awkward recovery.

Jimmy met his brother’s they instantly communicated volumes. Without a word, Jimmy casually checked his phone, then gave Tony a slow, almost imperceptible nod. He hadn’t just been filming the confrontation. He’d been recording audio the whole time they’d been back at the table.

Tony’s gaze returned to the dark corridor. The music thumped on, oblivious. The party around them was a chaotic, colorful oblivion. But in that corridor, a different kind of silence was unfolding.

The women's heels clicked a frantic tattoo on the tile as they pushed through the heavy door into the ladies’ lounge. The noise from the club muted to a dull, invasive throb. The air here was cooler, scented with harsh floral cleaner and the lingering ghosts of expensive perfume. A long mirror, bordered by cruel, bright bulbs, reflected four faces stripped of the club’s energetic pretense.

Jeannie stumbled to the sink, gripping the cold porcelain. She stared at her reflection—the smeared mascara, the blotchy cheeks, the wide, lost eyes. A dry sob wracked her shoulders.

Dee was immediately behind her, a pillar of fierce practicality. She dug into her clutch, producing makeup wipes and a compact. “Okay, honey. Deep breaths. Let’s get you cleaned up.”

Sofia perched on the edge of a velvet lounge chair, watching Jeannie with an unnerving intensity. Lauren hovered near the door, wringing her hands, her own face etched with worry.

“I don’t understand,” Jeannie whispered to the mirror, her voice shredded. “I was just… gone. It was like I was drunk, but I only had two drinks all night before the shots. I wanted to dance, and then I just… wanted whatever he wanted.”

She turned to them, her eyes desperate. “Did you see Tony? Did you see what he did? He didn’t even… fight them. They just… fell over.”

“I saw,” Dee said, her voice low. She wiped gently at the mascara stains. Her lawyer’s mind was churning, reassessing every variable. “I also saw a roomful of phones recording it. That’s the only thing that matters now. Optics.”

“Optics?” Lauren echoed, incredulous. “David’s right. She was assaulted!”

“That's nonsense,” Sofia cut in, her soft voice slicing through Lauren’s panic. “What we saw was Jeannie having a great time with a famous athlete, and Tony, displaying a previously unknown capacity for extreme violence, dismantling two men in public.” She leaned forward. “That’s the story that will stick if we don’t control it.”

Jeannie flinched. “It wasn’t like that. I wasn’t having a ‘great time.’ I was… I wasn’t me.”

“Exactly,” Dee said, finishing with the wipes and beginning to reapply powder. “So that’s our narrative. You were overwhelmed. You had a weird reaction to the excitement or the champagne. You were frightened by the situation and are so grateful Tony was there to protect you. You barely remember the details because you were in a state of shock.”

She framed Jeannie’s face with her hands, looking her squarely in the eyes. “That is the truth you tell Tony, you tell the police if it comes to that, you tell anyone who asks.Understood? It’s the only truth that keeps you from looking like a willing participant and keeps Tony from looking like a jealous lunatic.”

Jeannie’s eyes filled with fresh tears. “But… the things I felt…”

“Were not yours,” Sofia stated flatly. She stood and walked to the mirror, studying her own reflection, then Jeannie’s. “They were manipulations. By a predator. Tony recognized that. He saved you from… whatever the fuck that was.”

A heavy silence filled the room, broken only by the thump of bass through the walls. Sofia's words hung in the air, chilling and undeniable.

Lauren hugged herself. “What do we do now?”

Dee took a final, assessing look at Jeannie’s repaired makeup. It was flawless, a mask of calm. “Now,” she said, her voice regaining its sharp, decisive edge, “we go back out there. We own the rest of this night. We are happy, grateful, celebratory. We make this the story.” She turned to Sofia. “We need to know what Tony knows. What he’s capable of. This changes… everything.”

Sofia nodded slowly, a strange, heatless smile touching her lips. “Yes. It certainly does.”

Jeannie looked from one friend to the other, the gears in her mind turning sluggishly through a fog of confusion and residual dread. She saw their resolve, their quick, silent planning. A part of her clung to it, to their certainty. It was easier than the abyss of her own fractured memory.

“Okay,” she whispered, her voice barely audible.

Dee gave her a final, bolstering squeeze.“Good. One more thing. The physical stuff with Tony? Dial it back. He’s not accepting it. It looks desperate. Be warm, be present, but give him space. His head is somewhere else right now.”

They left the ladies' room, a united front walking back toward the pulsing chaos. Jeannie held her head higher, the makeup a shield. Dee led, a general returning her troops to the field. Sofia’s mind was a whirl of recalculated fantasies and newfound danger. Lauren trailed, her loyalty to David warring with a dawning, terrible fear that her friends had unleashed something they could never put back in its box.

As the women left the ladies' room, They heard a man clear his throat from the other direction, near the back exit. Tyler and Jordan leaned against the wall flanking a heavy fire exit door marked ‘VIP/STAFF ONLY’. Tyler stood whole, unharmed, a mountain of smug malice. His eyes, small and dark, locked onto the four women with predatory interest.

“Well, look what stumbled down the wrong hallway,” Tyler rumbled, pushing off the wall.

Jeannie gasped, taking a step back. “Leave us alone.”

“Your boy Max didn’t get the ‘leave alone’ memo,” Tyler said, grinning. He nodded toward the steel door behind him. “He’s right outside. In the limo. Engine’s running. He said to tell you the offer for the night still stands. Says a woman like you shouldn’t be punished for having a pussy husband.”

Tyler's smirk grew as he focused his ability. The Push wasn't something that anyone could see, but he felt it sink into Jeannie like rain in a parched desert. It had already locked in. He had already psychically shifted her to Max as her new master. Even the husband wouldn't be able to bring her back this time! It was like an epiphany hitting Jeannie's consciousness. The celebrity moment had been revived, like a live ember exposed to pure oxygen, and ignited a hundredfold more powerfully than before. Jeannie's smile was brighter and more beautiful than ever.

“No,” Lauren said firmly, stepping forward. “Jeannie, don’t you dare. This ends now. We’re going back.”

“You see?” Jeannie said, her voice trembling with a perverse excitement. She looked at Dee and Sofia, her eyes pleading for them to understand the script she was following. “He still wants me. It’s fate. This is how it’s supposed to happen.”

“Jeannie, for Christ’s sake, he’s a predator!” Dee hissed, her lawyerly composure cracking. “Tony just dismantled his guard dogs! You go out that door, you burn your marriage to the ground. Actually burn it. You understand that?”

“Don't talk about my man like that, Dee!" Jeannie said, the delusion solidifying in real-time, more real to her than the concrete under her feet. “If you're so worried about Tony, you go fuck him. I'm with Max now!”

She turned to her friends, a beatific, selfish resolve on her face. “Tell him. Tell Tony I love him and it was great, but I'm upgrading.”

She moved toward the door. Dee and Sofia were solely invested in stopping Jeannie. As they argued with Jeannie, they lost track of Lauren.

“The hell you are!” Lauren spat. She turned on her heel to march back to the table, to get David, to get Tony.

Tyler moved with shocking speed for a man his size. He was in front of her, blocking the corridor, his massive body filling the space. He looked Lauren up and down, a slow, vulgar appraisal that felt like being stripped.

“Hold up, gorgeous!” he said, his voice a low, amused growl. “You don’t want to spoil the fun, do you? Nah, I can see it in your eyes. You want your own fun. Lucky for you, I love what I see.” Tyler looked Lauren over with the eyes of a starving wolf as the Push washed over Lauren. Tyler found this one was strong, maybe the strongest-willed woman he'd ever found, but she had a deep, dark crack in her will. Something she never admitted. Something Tyler had in spades!

Lauren’s jaw went slack. Her breath hitched. She had always been subtle in checking out men when no one was looking, appreciating a good build, a confident walk. She was well aware of the average size of a man’s penis. She was also intimately aware that David, and each of the men in their friend group, was more than generously endowed. But Tyler, his cock was a monster! It looked like a python ready to strike. She couldn't take her eyes off the massive tent in this giant's pants. That thing had to be fourteen inches, at least! It was the crack in her will, and the Push flowed through that crack like water through a flood gate. She stood in shocked horror, unable to move, unable to look away as she thought what it would feel like to have that glorious cock in her eager pussy or mouth. God help her, how would it feel in the one place she never allowed any man, not even David. How would it feel buried to the hilt in her virgin ass?

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI