Cover of Mistaken Identity

Mistaken Identity

Read the story

2 chapters · 7417 words · Read 1 times

It was 5 am in the morning and the sun wasn't up yet, but it appeared her husband was. 47 yr old Karen Casey rolled and gave what she thought was her husbands cock a loving squeeze, "Some one's up early this morning" she murmured, in the dark room. She slid south kissing her way down until she reached his rapidly hardening cock, taking him into her mouth he continued to grow, and grow "Jesus Tim!" she said, needing to pull off him, but still stroking his cock which now, in the dark, felt twice as big. 5 seconds later he grunted "Oh Fuck" and painted Karen's face with cum, the stuff was everywhere. the only problem was, it wasn't Tim

Chapter 1: The Wrong Cock at Dawn

The first thing Karen became aware of was the weight. A solid, warm pressure across her hips, pinning her comfortably to the mattress. She smiled sleepily into her pillow. Tim must have rolled over in his sleep again. The second thing was the scent. Not Tim’s familiar, clean soap smell, but something muskier, younger. Male.

A flicker of wrongness brushed her consciousness, but sleep was a heavy blanket. She shifted, expecting the weight to adjust. It didn’t. It pressed down firmer. A hand, large and slightly rough, slid from her waist to her stomach, slipping beneath the worn cotton of her nightshirt. Her eyes fluttered open in the amber gloom.

That wasn’t Tim’s hand. Tim’s hands were softer, smaller.

Her breath hitched. The room came into focus piece by piece: the faint stripe of dawn at the edge of the heavy curtains, the dust motes dancing in the lamplight from Tim’s side of the bed, the familiar crack in the ceiling. And the feel of a hard, hot length pressed against the back of her thigh through thin fabric. Much too hard. Much too big.

“Tim?” Her voice was a dry croak.

The body behind her stirred. A low, sleep-thickened groan vibrated against her spine. Not Tim’s groan. This was younger, deeper. The hand on her stomach stilled, then flexed, fingertips digging lightly into the soft flesh of her mummy tummy.

Heart hammering against her ribs, Karen slowly twisted her head on the pillow.

Messy blonde hair. A sharp jaw dusted with stubble. The curve of a cheekbone she’d seen a thousand times across the dinner table.

Sam.

Her stepson. Asleep. In her bed. His face nestled against the back of her head, his breath hot on her neck.

A cold wave of pure shock washed over her, freezing her in place. What the hell? How? Why? Her mind scrabbled for logic. Tim was away. The business trip. Sam had stayed over last night after helping with the gutters. He’d had a few beers. He must have… wandered in? Sleepwalked? The guest room was down the hall.

But the press of him against her was no accident. It was a full, deliberate spoon. And he was hard. Gods, he was so hard. The sheer, obscene size of him, even through layers of cloth, was a reality she could not process.

Before she could move, could shove him away and scream, his hips gave a slow, unconscious roll. That monstrous ridge ground against the cleft of her ass, a blunt, shocking demand. A sound escaped her—not a shout, but a strangled gasp. Heat, sudden and entirely unwelcome, pooled low in her belly.

His hand moved again. Not away. Down. His palm slid over the gentle curve of her lower abdomen, fingers tracing the edge of her cotton panties. He mumbled something incoherent, his face nuzzling into her hair. His other arm was tucked under her, his hand coming up to cup the soft weight of her breast through her shirt. He squeezed, a lazy, possessive knead.

“Sam,” she whispered, sharper now. “Sam, wake up.”

He didn’t wake. He dreamed. And in his dream, he rutted against her. The friction was maddening. The thin barrier of her nightshirt and panties felt like nothing. She could feel every insistent pulse of him. Her own body, traitorously, was responding. A slick heat grew between her thighs, a primal echo to his grinding. Shame burned her face. This was her stepson. A boy. But he wasn’t a boy, was he? He was a man, with a man’s desires, and he was showcasing them against her backside with a terrifying simplicity.

His questing fingers dipped below the waistband of her panties. The touch of his skin on hers, on that private curve, was an electric jolt.

“No,” she breathed, but her hand flew down not to push him away, but to grasp his wrist. To stop him. Or to feel him. She wasn’t sure. Her fingers circled his lean forearm, the muscle corded and tense. She could feel his pulse hammering against her thumb.

The contact seemed to rouse him. His breathing changed. The lazy grinding stopped. He froze.

Then, with a slow, dawning horror that mirrored her own, he withdrew his hand from her panties as if burned. The arm around her chest loosened. She didn’t let go of his wrist. She held it, trapped against her stomach, both of them locked in a stunned paralysis.

“Karen?” His voice was cracked with sleep and disbelief.

She finally found the strength to move. She rolled onto her back, the sheets tangling around her legs, and looked up at him. He was propped on one elbow, his face pale in the low light, his eyes wide with a horror that was rapidly being chased by something else. His gaze dropped from her eyes to her mouth, to where the neck of her nightshirt had gaped open, revealing the deep cleft between her slightly sagging breasts. He stared, his mouth slack.

Her own eyes were dragged downward, past the hem of his t-shirt, to the pronounced, staggering tent in his sweatpants. The fabric was strained to its limit, outlining a thick, long shaft that curved up toward his navel. The head was a prominent bulge, already dark with moisture. Eleven inches. The number, some stupid thing she’d overheard him boasting about to a friend in the backyard last summer, flashed in her mind. It hadn’t been real then. It was devastatingly real now.

“What…” she started, but her voice failed.

“I… I thought you were…” he stammered, not finishing. His eyes were glued to her body. He made no move to get up, to cover himself. The air between them was thick, charged with the smell of sleep and sweat and that faint, metallic newness.

She saw his Adam’s apple bob as he swallowed hard. His cock gave a visible twitch under the grey cotton.

Without thinking, driven by a curiosity so profound it obliterated shame, Karen released his wrist. Her hand, moving of its own volition, hovered for a heartbeat in the space between them. Then she touched him. Not directly, but her fingertips brushed the heated, cotton-clad ridge.

Sam gasped, a sharp intake of breath. His hips jerked forward, pushing his hardness into her tentative touch.

That was all the permission her body needed. The last thread of restraint snapped. A low moan crawled from her throat as she wrapped her hand around him, fully, through the fabric. The size was impossible, awe-inspiring. Her fingers didn’t meet. He was hot as a brand, and rock-solid.

“Fuck,” Sam hissed, his eyes squeezing shut for a second. When they opened, the horror was gone, replaced by a dark, desperate hunger. “Oh, fuck, Mom.”

Hearing her name on his lips like that, in that tone, did something to her. It melted the last of her resistance into a pool of pure, wet need. She yanked at the waistband of his sweatpants, shoving them down over his hips. His cock sprang free, slapping against his stomach with a heavy, audible thud.

She actually whimpered. It was a monster. Thick and veined, with a purplish, swollen head that glistened with pre-cum. It looked both brutal and beautiful. All thought of Tim, of motherhood, of decency, vanished. There was only this, here, now.

“I need…” she panted, not knowing what she needed, but her body did. She shoved her own panties down, kicking them off her ankles. She was soaked, her blonde thatch slick. “Sam…”

He understood. He moved over her, his weight settling between her spread thighs. He didn’t kiss her. They stared into each other’s eyes, a silent communication of shock and raw lust. He positioned the blunt, massive head of his cock at her entrance. It felt like a knock at the door of her very self.

“You’re so wet,” he murmured, awed.

“Just… do it,” she commanded, her voice husky.

He pushed.

The stretch was instantaneous and immense. A burning, full-to-bursting pressure that made her cry out. Her eyes watered. She was tight, hadn’t taken anything like this in decades, maybe ever. He paused, buried only an inch inside, his body trembling with the effort to hold still.

“Am I hurting you?” The concern in his voice was genuine, layered over the animal need.

“Yes,” she gasped. “Don’t stop.”

He groaned, a deep, feral sound from his chest, and shoved forward again.

This time, the burn flared into a blinding white pleasure as he stretched her open, filling a void she never knew she had. He bottomed out, his hips pressed flush against hers, his full, impossible length seated inside her. She felt utterly speared, impaled, claimed. She could feel him in her womb. The sensation was so overwhelming she saw stars.

“Oh my God,” Sam choked, his forehead dropping to her shoulder. “You’re so fucking tight. Jesus Christ.”

He began to move. Short, sharp strokes at first, letting her adjust. Each withdrawal was a sweet loss, each thrust a breathtaking reclaiming. Then his strokes lengthened, deepened. He fucked her with a focused, relentless intensity. The bed, the old oak frame, began to rock against the wall with a rhythmic thump.

The sounds were obscene. The wet, sucking noise of her cunt taking him, their ragged breathing, the slap of his skin against hers. Karen raked her nails down his back, clutching him to her. She wrapped her legs high around his waist, heels digging into his ass, pulling him deeper. He grunted with each drive, his messy hair falling into his eyes.

“You like that, Mom?” The word slipped out, twisted, wrong. It wasn’t familial. It was filthy. A power play.

It tipped her over the edge. A climax ripped through her with shocking violence, her internal muscles clamping around his invading shaft in a series of brutal pulses. She screamed, a raw, unattractive sound, her body arching off the bed.

Feeling her convulse around him was too much for Sam. He drove into her one last, deep time, hilting himself, and roared. She felt the hot, urgent splash of his release deep inside her, jet after jet, filling her up. It seemed to go on forever, each pulse of his cock triggering a smaller, answering quake in her own.

He collapsed on top of her, spent, his weight a crushing, comforting anchor. They lay there, glued together by sweat and cum, gasping for air in the sickly amber light.

The thumping of the headboard ceased. In the sudden quiet, the world rushed back in. The faded floral wallpaper. Tim’s empty side of the bed. The crack in the ceiling.

Sam’s breath was hot on her neck. His softening cock was still inside her, a sticky, intimate plug.

Her mind, clear now and cold with dread, began to work. What had they done?

He shifted, finally sliding out of her with a wet, parting sob of flesh. A gush of his seed followed, warm on her inner thigh. He rolled onto his back beside her, staring up at the ceiling, his chest heaving.

Neither spoke for a long minute. The room smelled of sex now, sharp and potent, overriding the old wood and dust.

“Fuck,” Sam whispered to the ceiling, the word holding a universe of complication.

Karen closed her eyes. The evidence was cooling on her skin, inside her. There was no going back. A line had been crossed, violently and forever. And as the dawn light grew stronger at the window, she knew, with a terrifying certainty, that this was only the beginning.

The smell of him, of them, filled her nostrils—musky, salty, alive. It was the smell of a crime scene, and she was both victim and accomplice. The evidence was cooling inside her, a filthy truth she couldn’t scrub out.

Sam lay beside her, utterly still. She could feel the heat radiating from his skin, hear the gradually slowing hammer of his heart. She didn’t look at him. She stared at the faint water stain on the ceiling she’d meant to point out to Tim months ago.

Her body was a traitorous chorus of sensations. A deep, throbbing ache between her legs that was not entirely pain. The ghostly stretch of her muscles around a shape they’d never known. The slickness on her inner thighs. Her breast still tingled where his rough palm had gripped her.

She was ruined. And part of her, a shameful, secret part she’d buried for twenty years, felt more alive than it ever had with Tim.

“Fuck,” Sam whispered again, this time laced with a tremor. Not regret. Fear. Awe.

The word jolted her into motion. She swung her legs over the side of the bed, the cool morning air hitting her damp skin, making her shudder. She grabbed her discarded nightshirt from the floor and pulled it on, not bothering with her panties. The cotton felt abrasive against her sensitive flesh. She stood, legs unsteady, and faced the window, pulling the curtain back an inch. The world outside was grey and indifferent.

She heard the rustle of sheets as Sam sat up. Felt his eyes on her back, on the hem of the shirt that did nothing to cover her ass. She could picture the look on his face—the same dazed, hungry look he’d had when he’d stared at her tits.

“WHAT ARE YOU DOING HERE AND WHERE IS YOUR FATHER?” SHE EVENTUALLY ASKED, the question ripping from her throat, too loud in the quiet room. It was a wife’s question. A mother’s question. It sounded hollow, ridiculous, after what they’d just done.

“Dad’s in Cincinnati,” Sam said, his voice rough. “You know that. The conference. I… I crashed here last night. After the beers. I must have…” He trailed off. They both knew “must have” was bullshit. The guest room was down the hall, made up and waiting. He’d walked past its open door to get to this one.

“You must have what, Sam?” She turned now, crossing her arms over her chest. He was sitting up in the wrecked bed, the sheet pooled around his waist. His torso was lean, defined in a way his father’s hadn’t been in years. His cock, soft now, lay against his thigh, still glistening with her fluids. She forced her eyes to his face. It was flushed, his lips swollen.

He didn’t answer. He just looked at her, and the air thickened again. His gaze dropped to her legs, to the faint tremor in her knees.

“I had a dream,” he muttered, not looking at her eyes anymore. He was looking at her mouth. “A really fucked-up dream. And then I woke up, and you were right there, and you felt so… and you touched me.”

“You were on me,” she countered, but the heat was back in her cheeks.

“You grabbed my dick, Mom.” His use of her name, not ‘Mom’, was a deliberate strike. “You wrapped your hand around it and you fucking moaned.”

She had no defense. It was the truth. The physical truth was an incontestable wall between them. The emotional truth was a quicksand pit.

“This can’t happen,” she said, the words automatic, empty.

“It already did.” He shifted, and the sheet fell lower. His hand, almost absently, went to his cock, giving it a slow, idle stroke. A claim. Her breath caught. He was half-hard again already, just from talking about it, just from looking at her. The sight of his hand on himself, after where it had been, sent a fresh bolt of pure, undiluted lust straight to her cunt. She felt another treacherous trickle of wetness.

“Stop that,” she whispered, without conviction.

“Why?” he challenged, his strokes becoming more deliberate. He was fully hard again in moments, that monstrous thing rising thick and angry from his lap. “You liked it. You came harder than I’ve ever felt anyone come. You clenched around me like you were trying to milk me dry. And you took all of it. Every fucking inch.”

Each crude word was a violation. She hated bad language and despised disrespectful men and right now her son was doing and being both.

“Get your hand off that thing and listen to me,” she said, her voice dropping into a register he’d never heard. It wasn’t a mom-voice. It was stone and ice.

His hand froze, but he didn’t look cowed. He looked challenged, his eyes gleaming in the gloom.

“You think this is a game?” she continued, stepping closer to the bed. The floorboards were cold under her feet. “You think you just stumbled into some porno? That was my bed. My body. And you were inside it.” She pointed a trembling finger at the stained sheets between them. “Look at that. Look what you did. What we did. That’s a line that doesn’t get uncrossed, Sam. Ever.”

He flinched at that, finally. His gaze flicked to the glistening patch on the linen, then back to her face. The arrogance in his posture faltered.

“You think because you’re hard and you’re young and you’ve got that… that weapon between your legs, that you’re in charge?” A harsh, brittle laugh escaped her. “You’re a kid. A boy who got lucky because his stepmom was half-asleep and lonely and fucked up enough to let it happen. That doesn’t make you a man. It makes you an opportunist. A disrespectful little shit who took advantage.”

Each word was a precise, deliberate slap. She saw them land. His hard-on began to wilt, not from lack of desire, but from a dawning, sickening shame. He pulled the sheet over himself, a defensive gesture that gave her a surge of grim satisfaction.

“I didn’t mean to—” he started, his voice small.

“Bullshit,” she cut him off, sharp as a blade. “You meant to grind against me. You meant to put your hands on me. You meant to push inside me. Don’t you dare hide behind some sleepwalking crap now. You wanted it. And so did I. That’s the ugliest part of all this. But wanting doesn’t make it right. It makes it a fucking tragedy.”

Sam looked down at his hands, clenched on the sheet. The room was utterly silent except for the ragged sound of their breathing. The predatory energy had drained from him, leaving a slumped, guilty figure. He looked exactly what he was: a twenty-one-year-old boy who’d just shattered his family.

“I’m sorry,” he mumbled to his lap. The words were thick, choked. “Karen… Mom… I’m so sorry. It was fucked up. I’m fucked up. I don’t know what I was thinking.”

“You weren’t thinking,” she said, but the fury had bled out of her voice, leaving something hollow and tired. “That’s the point.”

She turned away from him, from the pathetic sight of his remorse. The adrenaline was fading, leaving a deep, aching exhaustion in her bones. She walked toward the bathroom, each step a conscious effort. She could feel his eyes on her back, on the swing of her hips, on the jiggle of her ass where the hem of the nightshirt barely covered her. She didn’t hurry. Let him look. Let him see what he’d had and what he was losing.

Her hand was on the cool porcelain doorknob when she stopped. She didn’t turn around. She spoke to the wood of the door, her voice quiet, perfectly clear.

“So if you ever want it to happen again,” she said, the words hanging in the foul, sex-heavy air, “I expect you’ll treat me like a lady.”

She heard the sharp intake of breath behind her.

She glanced over her shoulder, meeting his wide, stunned eyes. Her breast swayed with the movement, the nipple pressing against the thin cotton. A faint, knowing smile touched her lips.

“After all,” she said, her tone a bizarre, soothing melody of absolute control. “I am your mother.”

She opened the door, stepped into the brighter light of the bathroom, and closed it softly behind her, leaving him alone in the wreckage of the bed, with an apology dying on his lips and a new, impossible demand taking root in his desperate, hungry mind.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI