Chapter 1: Turn That Off
The first thing Grady Brandt ever said to me was, "Turn that off."
In fairness, I was pointing a ring light at his face. In further fairness, it was nine in the morning and he'd just walked off a plane from Halifax into the kind of Fort Lauderdale September where the air feels like a wet towel someone is holding over your mouth, and then into the Florida Tarpons practice facility, where I was waiting in the lobby with the ring light, a gimbal, a printed list of questions, and a smile I'd been practising in the car.
"Hi! Welcome to Florida!" I said. "I'm Theo Castillo, social media. We're just going to grab a quick hello for the fans. Five seconds. Just look into the—"
"Turn that off," said Grady Brandt.
He was enormous. I mean, I knew he was big. I'd watched about nine hours of his highlights the night before. On a screen, in pads, every hockey player looks like a refrigerator wearing a helmet. In person, in a navy wool peacoat that was frankly a personal attack on the climate, with a duffel bag over one shoulder and a beard he'd clearly stopped negotiating with, he blocked out the light from the front doors. His hair was dark and too long at the back. There was a streak of silver in his beard right at the point of his chin, like someone had flicked white paint at him and missed the rest of his face. His eyes were a cold pale blue and they were looking at my ring light like it owed him money.
"It's literally just a hello," I said.
"No."
"You can say it however you want. You can say it grumpy. Grumpy plays great online. People love a—"
He walked past me. Not rudely, exactly. More like weather. He went around me the way a cold front goes around a palm tree, and I stood there with my ring light glowing at the back of his peacoat as he disappeared down the hallway toward the dressing room.
Behind me, at the front desk, Bernadette the receptionist said, "Oof."
"It's fine," I said. "It's day one. Day one is a soft open."
"Honey, that was a soft close."
To understand why I was standing in a lobby with a ring light at nine a.m., you need to know two things.
The first is that the Florida Tarpons had finished last in the league two seasons running, played in a half-empty arena forty minutes from the beach, and were known mostly for a mascot named Finn who had once fallen off the glass during a promotional bit and been carried off on a stretcher to a standing ovation. Our social accounts, before me, were a series of blurry warmup photos captioned "Game day!!" I'd been hired eighteen months earlier to fix that. I had fixed that. We had a following now. We had a running series where our goalie, Luc Thibodeau, rated the snacks in visiting dressing rooms. People loved it. Luc had a fan account. I had made Luc a star, and I was very proud of it, and I wanted it on my tombstone.
The second thing you need to know is the clip.
Everybody had seen the clip. In March, the Halifax Admirals had played an outdoor charity game on a temporary rink by the harbour, in front of a sellout crowd, in the middle of what the local news called a "weather event" and what the video made clear was a horizontal sleet storm. Halifax lost. Afterward, a reporter from a national sports show caught Grady Brandt, the Admirals' captain, coming off the ice, soaked and grey-faced, and asked him how it felt to play an outdoor game at home.
And Grady Brandt looked into the camera and said: "Honestly? I'd rather be anywhere but here."
That was the clip. Six seconds. Somebody cut it, somebody captioned it "Halifax's captain: I'd rather be anywhere but Halifax," and by morning it had been watched by everyone in Canada with a phone and their aunt. He was a Nova Scotian. He'd grown up a couple of hours up the coast. He'd been the hometown boy, captain at twenty-five, face on the side of a bus. And he'd stood on the Halifax waterfront and said he'd rather be anywhere else, and he'd never apologized, and never explained, and never said one word about it since. Halifax took the C off him in April. In August they traded him to us for a second-round pick and a defenceman with a bad hip.
He'd signed a one-year deal. In it, according to my boss, there was a media clause that said the Tarpons could use him for promotional content "within reason."
"I want him likeable by Christmas," said my boss, Denise Ortiz, that afternoon, in her office, which had a view of the parking lot and a framed photo of Finn the mascot on the stretcher. "Fans in this market don't know him. Fans everywhere else hate him. I want a redemption arc. I want him at a beach. I want him holding a baby turtle."
"You can't hold baby turtles. It's illegal. They're endangered."
"Then I want him standing near a baby turtle looking sorry." Denise looked at me over her glasses. "Theo. You're the best I've got. You made people care about our backup goalie's opinions on trail mix."
"Luc's opinions on trail mix are very nuanced."
"Make people care about Brandt."
"He told me to turn off my ring light."
"So make him laugh. You make everybody laugh." She went back to her screen. "He's a walking PR disaster, Theo. You're a walking PR miracle. Go fix him."
Our first video shoot was two days later, after practice, in the corner of the dressing room I'd dressed up with a Tarpons backdrop and a potted palm I'd stolen from the lobby. The series was called Get to Know a Tarpon. It was meant to be easy. A string of fast questions. Favourite food, favourite movie, beach or pool, describe yourself in three words. We'd done it with every guy on the roster. Luc's had run nine minutes because he'd spent six of them describing his grandmother's tourtière.
Grady sat down in the chair across from me like it was a dentist's chair and folded his arms. He'd showered after practice. His hair was wet and pushed back and he was wearing a plain grey T-shirt, and I'll be honest, from a purely professional standpoint, the camera loved him. The camera loved the bone structure. The camera was very into the silver streak. It was a crime what the camera would do for this man if he'd let it.
"Okay," I said brightly. "We're rolling. Favourite food?"
"Food."
"Like, a specific food."
He thought about it with real effort. "Warm food."
"Love that. Okay. Beach or pool?"
"Rink."
"That's not one of the options."
"It's my answer."
"Favourite movie?"
"I don't watch movies."
"You've never seen a movie."
"I've seen movies. I don't have a favourite."
"Describe yourself in three words."
Grady Brandt looked at me for a long moment with those pale wolf eyes. "Not doing this."
"That's three words," I said. "Technically. I'll take it. That's the best answer we've ever had."
Something happened at the corner of his mouth. It was there and gone so fast I thought I'd imagined it. Then his face went flat again and he looked at the clock on the wall.
We did all the questions. It took four minutes. The footage was unusable, unless we were going for a documentary about a hostage situation. At the end of it, I stopped recording and looked at him.
"Can I ask you something off camera?"
"You just did."
"Do you want people to hate you? Like, is that the plan? Because I can work with it. I'll make you a villain. We'll lean into it. Villains get followers."
He stood up. He was so tall that I had to tip my head all the way back to keep looking at him, and I refused to stand up, out of principle.
"I don't want anything," Grady said. "I want to play hockey. I'm here because nobody else would take me. Make whatever videos you have to make. Just don't make me pretend to be somebody I'm not."
And he walked out.
On the way out, he stopped by the door where Earl, the ice crew guy who'd been driving the resurfacer at the Tarpons rink since before the Tarpons were the Tarpons, was taping a sheet to the wall. Earl was seventy-one and moved slowly. Grady stopped, held the corner of the sheet flat for him while Earl got the tape on, said something too low for me to hear, and Earl laughed and clapped him on the arm. Then Grady was gone.
I sat there with my ring light and my stolen palm and thought: huh.
That night I went home to my apartment in Wilton Manors, ate leftover arroz con pollo standing over the sink, and opened the clip again on my laptop.
I'm good at my job because I'm thorough. I'd made a whole folder on Grady Brandt. His stats. His old interviews, which were short and boring and polite. His charity work with the Halifax food bank, which nobody talked about. A local Nova Scotia paper's profile from when he was named captain, with a photo of him in a fresh Admirals sweater with the C stitched on, grinning like an idiot.
I'd watched the six-second clip probably thirty times. Tonight I went looking for the full broadcast, because I'm thorough, and because of Earl and the tape.
It took me an hour. The national show had only ever posted the short version. But the game had been carried by a local Halifax station, and their website had an archive, and in their archive there was a full postgame segment, nineteen minutes long, uploaded in March and viewed three hundred and six times.
I found the moment. Grady coming off the ice, soaked through, ice in his beard. The reporter, the question. How does it feel to play an outdoor game at home?
And Grady Brandt, squinting into the sleet, said:
"Honestly? I'd rather be anywhere but here, right now, in this. The guys are frozen. We've got a back-to-back. Half the room's got the flu. We should've been inside. But look at those fans." He turned and pointed, and the camera swung with him, to the stands, which were full of soaking-wet people in Admirals toques, screaming, holding up homemade signs. "They sat through that for two and a half hours. For the food bank. That's Halifax. There's nowhere else in the world like this. I'd play out here every night for them."
The segment cut back to the studio.
I sat in my kitchen with my fork halfway to my mouth.
He'd known. He had to have known. Somewhere out there was the full sentence, the one where he said there was nowhere else in the world like home, and he'd let a whole country call him a traitor for six months and never once pointed anyone to it.
I looked at the timestamp. Three hundred and six views. One of them, I'd bet my job, was him.