Cover of Pretty Little Lies

Pretty Little Lies

Read the story

10 chapters · 32459 words · Read 0 times

At twenty-two, Aria Montgomery wakes up with two lives inside her. One belongs to Aria: Alison DiLaurentis disappeared after they turned eighteen, and Aria, Spencer, Hanna, and Emily stayed together and attended the same local college. That was when A began—the threats, secrets, betrayals, and constant reminders that someone was watching them, ruining their relationships and turning their lives upside down. The other belongs to a modern woman who watched Pretty Little Liars and remembers exactly how the story was supposed to end. Except this isn’t that story. Charlotte DiLaurentis is A—and she never dies. After discovering her half-sisters Spencer and Alex Drake, Charlotte brings Alex and Mona Vanderwaal into her inner circle. Alex initially wants Spencer to know the truth about their family, but eventually becomes fascinated by Aria. Charlotte grows genuinely attached to Spencer, becoming fiercely protective of all her sisters. The Liars never discover who A really is. When the game finally appears to end, Charlotte and Mona quietly become part of their post-college world, accepted as friends without anyone knowing they were behind it. The Liars believe they’ve escaped A while unknowingly remaining surrounded by the people who shaped their lives. Their lovers know the truth. Ezra works with A to protect Aria. Toby protects Spencer. Caleb protects Hanna. Alison discovers Charlotte is her sister and eventually joins A to protect Emily. Alex and Ezra both adore Aria obsessively, neither seeing the other as competition. By graduation, Aria has genuinely fallen for Alex and discovered her attraction to women. To everyone else, Aria and Ezra are the couple, while Alex is their close friend and roommate. Their friends know all three are together. Beneath the perfect life is a darker reality: their love is possessive, obsessive, and justified as protection. This is the same for all the liars’s partners. Then Aria’s modern memories return. She knows this world was never supposed to exist. But she also remembers the years of love, happiness, and genuine feelings she found here. Eventually, rather than destroy the life she’s been given, Aria chooses to live it. A dark psychological coercive romance about obsession disguised as devotion, love tangled with control, and a perfect life built on secrets.

Chapter 6: The Editor's Revenge

The click of the ‘send’ button echoed in the quiet office. Aria stared at the confirmation screen. Message Delivered. Leo Vance’s literary ego, dissected with such cold efficiency, was now winging its way back to him. She felt nothing. No guilt, no petty triumph. It was a task completed, a minor threat neutralized through the appropriate channel. Professional, not personal.

Her body told a different story. Between her legs was a soaked, aching reminder of the personal. The thin cotton of her sleep shorts was damp, clinging to her. The ghost of Alex’s mouth was a brand. Finish your letter. Then come find me.

Aria pushed back from the desk. The house was silent, a waiting silence. She walked down the hall, her bare feet silent on the polished wood. The door to the primary bedroom was ajar. Candlelight spilled out, casting a dancing oblong of gold.

She pushed it open.

The room had been transformed. The usual jasmine candles were there, but more of them, clustered on every surface so the air swam with heat and shifting shadow. The velvet drapes were drawn tight. In the center of the room, two wingback chairs had been pulled from the reading nook. Ezra sat in one, dressed in dark slacks and a white shirt, sleeves rolled to his elbows. He looked like a professor awaiting a thesis defense. Alex stood beside the other chair, wearing only a pair of black lace panties and a predatory smile. On the seat of the empty chair lay two items: a long, black silk scarf and a small, narrow velvet box.

“Close the door,” Ezra said, his voice neutral.

Aria did, the latch catching with a soft, final sound. The room felt pressurized.

“Come here.” Alex pointed to the space on the rug between the two chairs.

Aria walked forward, the scent of wax and their shared skin enveloping her. She stopped on the designated spot, feeling like an exhibit.

“You sent the letter?” Ezra asked.

“Yes.”

“Good. That chapter is closed. But the feeling it gave you… the power of it… that’s worth examining.” He leaned forward, elbows on his knees. “You enjoyed wielding that control. Destroying his work from a position of authority.”

“It was necessary,” Aria said, but her pulse jumped.

“It was,” Alex agreed, circling her. “But necessary and arousing aren’t mutually exclusive. I could smell it on you in the office. You were wet the second you started typing those cutting little remarks.” She stopped behind Aria, her breath on her neck. “Admit it. You got off on it.”

Aria swallowed. “Yes.”

“Say it clearer.”

“I was aroused. By… by dismantling him.”

Ezra nodded, a small, approving gesture. “Power is an aphrodisiac. But unfocused power is dangerous. It needs a container. A purpose.” He gestured to the chair. “Sit.”

Aria moved to the empty chair. Alex picked up the black silk scarf. “Lean forward. Forearms on your knees.”

Aria complied. Alex moved behind the chair. The silk whispered over Aria’s eyes, a cool slip before it settled into darkness. The knot at the back of her head was secure, not tight, but inescapable. The world vanished. Sound amplified: the crackle of a wick, Ezra’s steady breathing, the soft rustle of Alex moving.

“The purpose is us,” Ezra said, his voice now coming from directly in front of her. “Your power serves our safety. Our happiness. Your pleasure is ours to grant, and yours to receive from our hands. Do you understand?”

“Yes.”

“We’re going to play a game,” Alex whispered from her right. A hand, warm and familiar, landed on Aria’s thigh, sliding her shorts up. “A sensory game. You don’t move unless we tell you to move. You don’t come unless we tell you to come. You take what we give you. Your only job is to feel. And to guess.”

“Guess what?” Aria’s voice was small in the dark.

“What we’re using on you. And who is using it.”

The first touch was a shock of cold. A smooth, hard cylinder, metal, traced from her collarbone down between her breasts. Aria gasped.

“Guess,” Alex murmured.

“A… a candle?” Aria ventured.

The cold metal tapped her nipple, once, twice. “No.”

It was lifted away. A moment later, a new sensation: something soft, dragging, ticklish. It traced the same path. A paintbrush? A feather? Before she could speak, it was gone.

Then, a touch of heat. Not burning, but warm, liquid. It dripped onto her sternum, a single heavy bead that slid down her skin. Wax. Candle wax. She flinched at the sudden heat, but it cooled almost instantly into a taut, thin shell.

“Good,” Ezra said. His voice was close. “One point.”

His hands—she knew the shape and weight of them—slid her camisole up and over her head. The air touched her bare breasts. Then his mouth was on her, his tongue laving a nipple, his teeth grazing it to a stiff peak. She moaned, her back arching off the chair.

“Don’t move,” Alex reminded her, a sharp slap on her other thigh. The sting blended with the pleasure from Ezra’s mouth.

He sucked hard, then pulled away. The loss was a physical pain. Something else replaced it. Smooth, cool, spherical. Glass. A small, heavy perfume bottle, perhaps. It rolled over her wet nipple, the cold a shocking contrast.

“What is it?” Alex asked.

“Glass. A bottle.”

“What’s in it?”

Aria inhaled. Jasmine. Their jasmine. “Our oil.”

The bottle moved away. Then came a sensation that stole her breath: the flat, unmistakable chill of a knife blade. The back of it, smooth and deadly, laid against the slope of her breast. It didn’t press, just rested. A promise. Aria went utterly still, a primal fear shooting through her veins, immediately tangled with a sharp, illicit thrill.

“Who has it?” Ezra asked, his voice low.

Her mind raced. Alex was more volatile, more physical. Ezra was more… precise. “Ezra,” she breathed.

The blade flipped. The faintest, whisper-soft edge of the sharp side grazed the same path. It didn’t cut. It hovered on the threshold of pain. “Correct,” he said, and the knife vanished.

She was panting now, every nerve ending shrieking, hypersensitive in the dark. She heard the click of the velvet box opening. Something was removed. Something whirred softly to life. A vibrator. But not a normal one. The sound was deep, invasive.

“Open your legs,” Alex commanded.

Aria spread her knees. The shorts were tugged down her legs and discarded. She was completely exposed, blindfolded in the center of the room.

The vibrator touched her inner thigh. It wasn’t the buzzing head she expected. It was broad, flat, pulsing. A wand. It climbed her thigh with torturous slowness. When it finally nudged against her clit, she cried out, her hips jerking instinctively.

“I said don’t move,” Alex snapped. A hand, sharp and sudden, landed on the sensitive skin of her ass cheek. A spank, crisp and bright. The pain made her clench, which drove the vibrator harder against her. A filthy feedback loop.

“Please,” Aria whimpered.

“Please what?” Ezra asked.

“Please… let me come.”

“No,” Alex said simply. The wand moved away, leaving her throbbing and empty. “You haven’t earned it. You’re too greedy.”

Something replaced the wand. Fingers. Two, slick with her own wetness, sliding inside her with no preamble. They curled, stroking a spot that made her see stars behind the silk. “Who?” Alex grunted, fucking her with her hand.

“Alex.” It was a sob.

“Good girl.” The fingers pistoned, rough and perfect. Aria was cresting, the coil pulled taut. At the last possible second, the fingers withdrew. She made a broken sound of protest.

She heard movement, the sound of a belt buckle, fabric shifting. Then hands—different hands—gripped her hips and hauled her off the chair. She was lowered onto her knees on the rug, then pushed forward until her chest and cheek were pressed against the seat of the warm chair. Her ass was in the air, exposed.

A thick, blunt pressure pressed against her from behind. Ezra. He pushed into her cunt in one long, continuous stroke, filling the desperate emptiness. He felt enormous inside her, a solid, claiming weight. He set a deep, measured pace, each thrust rocking her whole body against the chair.

“Now the game changes,” Alex said. Her voice came from nearby. A hand fisted in Aria’s hair, pulling her head up and back. “Open your mouth.”

Aria obeyed. Something wider, softer than a cock pressed against her lips. It was damp, swollen. Alex’s cunt. She lowered herself onto Aria’s face, grinding down, smothering her. Aria’s world narrowed to two points of penetration: the relentless, pounding fullness below, and the suffocating, musky wetness above. She couldn’t scream. She could barely breathe. She could only taste and be fucked.

Ezra’s rhythm began to fracture. His thrusts became harder, faster, losing their academic precision. “Whose are you?” he demanded, his voice ragged.

“Yours!” she tried to say, the words muffled against Alex’s flesh.

“Louder.”

Alex lifted herself slightly, allowing a gasp of air. “Say it so the house can hear you.”

“I’m yours!” Aria screamed. “I’m yours, I’m yours, I’m—”

Ezra slammed into her, his body locking, a raw, guttural shout torn from him as he emptied himself deep inside her. The feeling of him coming, of being claimed so absolutely, tipped her over the edge. Her orgasm was a silent, seismic event, a clamping, fluttering paralysis that seized her around his still-pulsing cock. She shook, sobbing open-mouthed against Alex.

Alex wasn’t finished. She shifted, positioning herself, and sank back down onto Aria’s mouth with a final, ruthless grind. “Make me come,” she ordered, her voice tight. “Use your tongue. Now.”

Aria, obliterated and obedient, found the strength to move her tongue. She licked and sucked, a messy, desperate service. Alex’s thighs trembled on either side of her head. A sharp, bitter flood hit Aria’s tongue as Alex climaxed with a sharp cry, her body convulsing.

Then, stillness. Heavy breathing. The smell of sex and sweat and wax.

Ezra withdrew. Aria slumped off the chair, a boneless heap on the rug. The blindfold was gently untied. The candlelight was blinding for a moment. Her lovers looked down at her, their expressions a mix of satiated hunger and profound possession.

Alex knelt, wiping Aria’s face with her own discarded camisole. “You did so well,” she murmured, almost sweetly.

Ezra extended a hand and helped Aria to her unsteady feet. He guided her to the bed, where they lay in their familiar tangle. The questions, the memories of another life, the fear of the orchestrated world… they were distant echoes, drowned out by the immediate, bodily truth.

As she drifted into a heavy, sore sleep, cradled between them, one thought floated, clear and unambiguous: She had guessed correctly every time. She knew their touches. She knew their instruments. In the dark, she knew them absolutely.

They were her world. And she was, irrevocably, theirs.

And she was, irrevocably, theirs. The truth of it hummed in her bones, a low frequency of belonging that vibrated beneath her skin days later. She moved through the quiet house with a new equilibrium, the soreness between her legs a pleasant, persistent reminder. The manuscript for Whispering Canyons gathered digital dust in a forgotten folder.

“You’re humming,” Alex noted from the kitchen island. She was dissembling a small, sophisticated camera, its parts laid out on a microfiber cloth.

“Am I?” Aria hadn’t noticed. She was pouring coffee, watching the steam rise.

“Like a little engine. It’s annoying.” Alex’s tone was fond. She didn’t look up from her work. “What’s the plan today?”

“Editing a romance novel. The hero is a lumberjack with a heart of gold and a vocabulary improbably sourced from a thesaurus.”

Alex snorted. “Sounds flammable. Save me the dirty bits.”

The domestic bubble held, perfect and sealed. Ezra was at the college for office hours. The morning sun cut bright lines across the floorboards. Aria’s phone, face-down on the counter, buzzed. The sound was an intrusion, a fly against a windowpane. She glanced at the screen. Hanna.

Aria’s thumb hovered. Answering would be a crack in the seal. Letting it go to voicemail was a statement. She looked at Alex, who was now meticulously cleaning a camera lens, her expression giving nothing away. Aria answered.

“Hey, Hanna.”

“Finally! I’ve been texting. Did you ghost me after our lunch?” Hanna’s voice was bright, amplified. “You seemed off. Everything okay?”

“Everything’s fine. Just busy.” Aria walked toward the window, turning her back to Alex’s silent presence. “What’s up?”

“It’s Spencer. She’s throwing one of her infamous ‘think tank’ parties at the Hastings barn Friday night. Semi-formal, obnoxiously intellectual, open bar. You have to come. You’ve been a hermit.”

A fist of cold anxiety clenched in Aria’s stomach. Spencer’s parties were landmines of old acquaintances, probing questions, and performative nostalgia. The entire fragile ecosystem of her current life felt imperiled by the very idea.

“I don’t know, Han. I’ve got a deadline pile—”

“Nope. No excuses. You’re coming. I’ll pick you up at eight. Bring that mysterious energy you’ve been cultivating. It’ll be fun!” The line clicked dead. Hanna’s decisiveness was a force of nature.

Aria lowered the phone. The silence in the kitchen was now brittle.

“A party.” Alex’s voice was flat. She hadn’t moved. “At the Hastings barn.”

“It’s just Spencer being Spencer.”

“It’s a gallery of everyone from before. A petri dish.” Alex finally looked up, her eyes sharp. “You don’t want to go.”

It wasn’t a question. Aria shook her head. “No. I really don’t.”

“Then you won’t.” Alex slid off the stool. She walked to Aria, plucked the phone from her limp hand, and placed it on the counter. Her fingers, still faintly smelling of lens cleaner, traced Aria’s jaw. “You think we can’t handle a RSVP?”

“It’s not that. It’s… it’s easier to just not engage.”

“Easier isn’t always better.” Alex’s thumb pressed against Aria’s lower lip. “Sometimes you have to walk through the gallery to remember why you prefer the private collection. We’ll be your escorts.”

The thought of Ezra and Alex moving through that crowd, a united front beside her, sent a dizzying mix of terror and dizzying pride through her. “You’d do that?”

“We’re doing that.” Alex’s kiss was hard, possessive. “But first, you need to get out of your head. You’re thinking too loud. I can hear the gears grinding from here.”

She took Aria’s hand and led her from the kitchen, down the hall, not toward the bedroom but to Alex’s own space. It was sparser, cooler, a reflection of her mind: a large bed with grey linen, a wall of monitors dark now, a shelf of technical manuals and legal texts. The air smelled like ozone and sandalwood.

“On the bed. On your back.”

Aria obeyed, the linen cool through her thin t-shirt. Alex didn’t join her immediately. She went to a polished wooden cabinet and opened it. The contents weren’t visible from the bed. When she turned, she held a pair of steel handcuffs, not the fuzzy novelty kind, but police-issue, cold and heavy-looking.

“You remember the rules from the other night?” Alex asked, walking forward, the cuffs dangling from her index finger.

“Don’t move unless you say. Don’t come unless you say.”

“Good.” Alex sat on the edge of the bed. “Give me your hands.”

Aria lifted her wrists. The steel closed around her right one with a definitive, chilling click. Alex guided her cuffed hand to the wrought-iron headboard, securing it to a post with a second, smaller lock. The metal was shockingly cold. Her left wrist was left free. She was tethered, but not completely helpless. The ambiguity was its own kind of torment.

“Comfortable?” Alex asked, her head tilted.

Aria tested the bond. It held firm. The cold seeped into her bone. “Yes.”

“Liar.” Alex smiled. She climbed onto the bed, straddling Aria’s hips. She was still fully dressed in jeans and a tight tank top. She leaned down, her dark curls forming a curtain around their faces. “You’re terrified. And you’re so fucking wet already I can feel it through your jeans.” She ground her pelvis down to prove her point, and a shock of sensation made Aria gasp.

“Please,” Aria whispered.

“Please what? Use your words.”

“Please touch me.”

Alex’s hand snaked between them, popping the button of Aria’s jeans, dragging the zipper down. She didn’t pull them off. She just shoved her hand inside, beneath Aria’s panties. Her fingers were blunt and direct, sliding through the slickness, circling her clit with a rough, delicious friction.

“You’re ours,” Alex stated, her eyes locked on Aria’s. Her fingers plunged inside, curling. “This cunt is ours. This fear is ours. This party is ours. You understand? Nothing touches you that we don’t allow. Nothing.”

Aria could only nod, her hips lifting off the bed, chasing the deep, corkscrewing motion of Alex’s fingers. The cold metal of the cuff bit into her right wrist, a stark counterpoint to the building heat in her core. The duality was the whole point: the restraint, the permission.

“Come for me,” Alex commanded, her voice guttural. “Come on my fingers. Show me you know who you belong to.”

The permission was the final trigger. Aria’s orgasm tore through her, a silent, breathless convulsion that arched her back against the bed. Her free hand fisted in the grey linen, her cuffed arm pulling taut against the headboard with a rattle of metal. Alex rode it out with her, fingers working, drawing every last pulse from her.

As the waves subsided, Alex slowly withdrew her hand. She brought her glistening fingers to Aria’s mouth. “Clean them.”

Aria did, tasting herself, her tongue lapping at the salty, intimate proof. Alex watched, her breath coming harder now. She unbuttoned her own jeans, shoving them and her underwear down just enough. She positioned herself over Aria’s face.

“Now me. And don’t you dare be gentle.”

Aria lifted her head, her free hand coming up to grip Alex’s thigh, and put her mouth to work. She licked, sucked, dove deep with her tongue, following the hissed instructions and curses from above. Alex’s hips rolled, her fingers tangling in Aria’s hair, controlling the pace. It was messy, brutal, and efficient.

Alex came with a sharp cry, her body stiffening, a rush of bitter fluid flooding Aria’s mouth. She collapsed sideways, breathing heavily. For a long moment, there was only the sound of their breath in the cool room.

Then Alex sat up, pulled her clothes back into place, and retrieved the small key from her pocket. She unlocked the cuff from the headboard, then from Aria’s wrist. The skin beneath was marked with a red band. Alex pressed her lips to the faint imprint.

“See?” she murmured against the skin. “The world out there is all chatter and chaos. In here, it’s just truth. Simple. Clean.”

Aria flexed her wrist, feeling the phantom grip of the steel. The anxiety about the party hadn’t vanished, but it had been transformed. It was no longer her fear to manage alone. It was theirs to control. She felt a disturbing, powerful clarity.

That evening, when Ezra returned, they told him over dinner.

“Spencer’s party,” Aria said, pushing peas around her plate. “Friday. Hanna’s insisting.”

Ezra took a sip of wine, considering. He looked from Aria’s resolute face to Alex’s defiant one. “Then we’ll attend,” he said simply. “It will be instructive to see the landscape.”

Later, in the shared darkness of their bed, Ezra’s hand found the marked skin on Aria’s wrist. He traced the faint line. “She used the cuffs.”

“Yes.”

“Good.” He pulled her closer, his body a solid wall of heat at her back. “Wear something that covers this. Let’s keep our proofs private.”

Aria nodded against the pillow. As she drifted off, the last conscious thought was not of guest lists or party dresses, but of the delicious, secret weight of the mark beneath her sleeve, a hidden anchor in the coming storm. The gallery awaited. And she would walk through it, flanked by her keepers, a consecrated object in a world of fragile glass.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI