Chapter 1: The Larches
Everyone in London has an opinion about Lena Marsh. I've heard them at dinner parties and in taxis and once, memorably, from a woman cutting my hair, who held the scissors very still against my neck while she explained that rich people always get away with it.
Here is what everyone agrees on.
Six years ago, on the night of the fifth of October, a neighbour on Swain's Lane in Highgate heard a woman scream, once, and called the police. They found the front door of the Marsh house unlocked and the lights on in the studio at the back, a converted coach house with a glass roof and an iron spiral stair that climbed to a gallery where the canvases were stored. Edmund Hale, forty-four, financier, collector, the man the newspapers liked to call the husband of the decade, was lying at the foot of that stair. His neck was broken. Lena was standing over him.
Her hands were red to the wrist. It was paint. That was the first thing the police got wrong, and the last thing anybody remembered.
She didn't speak to them. She didn't speak to the duty solicitor, or the psychiatrist who assessed her, or the judge who found her unfit to plead and sent her to a secure hospital in the Midlands. She didn't speak when her father, Conrad Marsh, who owns more of the world's container ships than any other single human being, used a great deal of money and some very expensive lawyers to have her moved to a private clinic in Hertfordshire. She hadn't spoken since. Not to anyone. Not one word in six years.
What she had done, before the silence, was paint.
The police found the canvas on her easel, the paint still tacky. A self-portrait, life-size, the colours so raw and bright that the first photograph of it in the papers looked like a mistake in the printing. Lena, standing, in a white smock, her mouth closed, holding a lit match between her finger and thumb as if she were offering it to whoever was looking. On the back of the stretcher, in charcoal, she had written a title.
2 October.
Not the fifth. The second. Three days before her husband died.
Her gallerist hung it in Cork Street the following spring. Forty thousand people queued around the block to see it. Every critic in Europe had a theory about the date. None of them had ever asked her, because she wouldn't have answered. And Lena Marsh, the painter who'd stopped speaking, became the most famous woman in Britain who'd never given an interview.
Like everyone, I first saw it in a newspaper.
I'm telling you that because it's true. I want to start with something true.
The Larches sits behind a high brick wall at the end of a lane outside Potters Bar, in grounds that used to belong to a Victorian brewer. From the road you'd take it for a country house hired out for weddings. From the inside, you notice the windows don't open more than four inches, and that every door has two locks, and that the cheerful paintings in the corridors are screwed to the wall at all four corners.
"We don't call them patients," said Dr. Miriam Okafor. "We call them residents. Their families prefer it, and their families pay for it."
She was the clinical director, a tall woman in her fifties with close-cropped grey hair and reading glasses she took off whenever she wanted to look at you properly, which was often. Her office overlooked the lawn. There was a single orchid on the windowsill that was either very healthy or very good plastic.
"I'll be honest with you, Daniel," she said, "because you'll find out anyway. I didn't want to hire you."
"I gathered."
"You had one of the best private practices in Marylebone. You published. You lectured. Then three years ago you closed your practice, sold your flat and spent a year doing locum work in prisons. Then you applied to us, for half what you used to earn, and your covering letter mentioned Lena Marsh in the second paragraph." She put her glasses on the desk. "Every forensic psychotherapist in the country wants to be the one who gets her to talk. It would make a career. I've turned down nine applications like yours."
I let that number pass without comment, though I noticed it. "Why didn't you turn down mine?"
"Because she's had four therapists here in six years and none of them got so much as a nod. Because her father pays our fees, and her father is getting impatient. And because you're the only applicant who didn't promise me results." Miriam studied me. "Why did you close the practice?"
"My marriage ended," I said. "I found I didn't want to sit in a nice room listening to wealthy people describe their problems any more. I wanted to sit somewhere the problems were real."
It was the answer I'd given at the interview, and it was true, as far as it went.
"Did you ever meet Edmund Hale? Socially, I mean. You'd have moved in some of the same circles."
"London's a big city," I said.
She looked at me for a moment longer than was comfortable. Then she put her glasses back on and reached for the phone. "Jonah will take you through. Two sessions a week, fifty minutes, supervised through the glass for the first month. Don't touch her. Don't bring her anything. And Daniel. Don't take it personally when she doesn't look at you. She doesn't look at anyone."
Jonah Pell was the charge nurse on the women's wing, a broad, soft-spoken man in his thirties with a shaved head and a tattoo of a swallow on the back of each hand. He walked me through three sets of locked doors and talked the whole time, mostly about football.
"She's no trouble," he said, when I asked. "That's what nobody gets. They expect, you know. Screaming. Throwing things. She's the easiest resident on the wing. Eats what she's given. Walks the garden at two every day, same route, round the pond and back. Reads. Sleeps." He keyed in a code. "Doesn't paint, though. Hasn't touched a brush since she got here. The art therapist tried for a year. She'd just sit there with her hands in her lap."
"Does she write anything? Notes, gestures?"
"Nothing. If she wants something she points. If she doesn't want something she just doesn't do it." He pushed the last door open. "You'll see. It's like sitting with a closed book."
The therapy room had been designed by someone who had read a brochure about calm. Pale green walls, two armchairs angled toward each other, a box of tissues, a low table, a window looking onto a grey-gold stretch of lawn and a single big plane tree just beginning to drop its leaves. Behind me, a long panel of mirrored glass. I sat in the chair that faced the door, put my notebook on my knee, and waited.
They brought her in at five past two.
I'd seen hundreds of photographs. None of them had prepared me for how still she was. She was tall, almost my height, in grey drawstring trousers and a navy jumper with the sleeves pushed up, and she moved the way people move in churches, without wasting anything. Her hair had been the famous copper red in all the old photographs. Now it was cut short, almost cropped, and it had faded to the colour of a fox in winter. Across the back of her left hand, from knuckle to wrist, ran a narrow white burn scar, old and smooth and shiny as a seam in glass.
She sat in the other chair. She folded her hands in her lap. She looked at the window.
"Hello, Lena," I said. "My name is Daniel Reeve."
Nothing.
"I'm not going to ask you to talk to me," I said. "Everyone else has done that and I imagine you're bored to death of it. I'm going to sit here twice a week for fifty minutes. If you want to say something, I'll listen. If you don't, I'll sit here anyway. That's the whole arrangement."
Her eyes didn't move from the window. They were a very pale grey, almost colourless in that light. I wrote nothing in the notebook. I've always believed that the first thing a patient learns about you is what you choose to write down, and I didn't want her to learn anything yet.
So we sat. The plane tree let go of a leaf. Somewhere down the corridor a trolley rattled past. My watch ticked louder than I had ever noticed it ticking, and I sat with my hands still on the notebook and I did not fill the silence, and neither did she.
At forty-one minutes, something happened.
She looked at my hands.
Not my face. My hands, resting on the closed notebook. She looked at them for a long time, with a painter's attention, the kind that seems to be measuring the light on a thing rather than the thing itself. Then she looked at the window again. And then, very deliberately, she stood up, took hold of the arms of her chair, and turned it ninety degrees, so that it no longer faced me at all. It faced the glass, and the plane tree, and the lawn.
She sat back down. She folded her hands.
When Jonah came to collect her at the end of the hour, she rose and went with him without a backward glance.
"She moved the chair," Miriam said. We were in her office. She had watched the whole session through the mirror. "That's the first voluntary action she's taken in a therapy room in six years. What did you do?"
"Nothing."
"Don't be modest, it doesn't suit you."
"I mean it. I did nothing. I think that's why." I leaned forward. "Everyone who's sat in that room with her has wanted something. A word, a breakthrough, a paper in a journal. She can feel it. I don't think she's refusing to speak. I think she's refusing to be used." I paused. "I want to give her paints."
"No."
"Not in the art room. In her own room. Leave them there. Don't ask her to use them. Don't mention them."
"She hasn't painted in six years, Daniel. The last time she painted, her husband ended up dead at the bottom of a staircase." Miriam took her glasses off. "Her father's instructions are very clear. No materials. He thinks it upsets her."
"Does it upset her, or does it upset him?"
Miriam was quiet for a long moment. Outside her window it was getting dark, and the security lights along the wall were flickering on one by one.
"One box of watercolours," she said finally. "The cheapest kind. Nothing she could hurt herself with. And if she so much as looks at them the wrong way, they're gone."
Jonah rang me at six the next morning. I was already awake. I hadn't slept much. I've never slept well in October.
"You'd better come in," he said. "She didn't go to bed. Night staff say she was up at the desk the whole time with the lamp on. She's painted something." He hesitated. "I don't know what it is. It's a room."
I drove to Potters Bar in the half-dark with the radio off.
She'd done it on the back of a sheet of the clinic's headed paper, in the cheap watercolours, and still somehow it glowed. A room. Tall sash window, white shutters folded back. Outside the window, the upper branches of a plane tree, and behind them the pale front of a Georgian terrace. A green leather armchair with its back to the viewer, and over the top of it, just visible, the crown of a man's head. On the wall beside the window, a small carriage clock with a brass face, its hands at four.
Jonah was watching me. "Mean anything to you?"
"No," I said.
I knew that window. I'd looked out of it for nine years. I'd bought that clock in an antiques shop on Marylebone High Street the week I opened my practice, and I'd sold it with everything else the week I closed it.
I hadn't told Miriam about that room.
I haven't told you either.