Cover of The Assistant Dilemma

The Assistant Dilemma

Read the story

2 chapters · 6507 words · Read 1 times

27 yr old Tyler Mathieson needed a new assistant, but when his wife Lauren, then his stepmother Megan and finally his mother in-law Karen, all show interest in the position, he knows he has to do everything by the book. So he hires a consultant to help with the decision, Sreeta Pabari-James is an expert in what she does, but one thing is clear, this is going to be one very tough decision

Chapter 1: Dinner & Desires: A Feast of Temptations

The mahogany table gleamed under the chandelier, a dark sea of polished scars topped by an unnervingly white linen cloth. Tyler traced a fork scratch with his thumb, the ridge familiar as a fingerprint. The air hummed with the after-echo of laughter from a joke now forgotten, thick with the scent of roast chicken and anticipation.

“So, big news from the office,” Tyler said, his voice cutting through the gentle clink of silverware. He kept his eyes on his plate, pushing a piece of asparagus around. “Jessica’s leaving. Moving to Portland. Which means, as of next Friday, I’m without an assistant.”

Lauren, to his right, stopped mid-sip of her Pinot Noir. She set the glass down with a soft, precise clink. “That’s sudden.”

“It is.” Tyler finally looked up, meeting the circle of faces. His wife’s intelligent, assessing gaze. His stepmother Megan’s bright, immediately intrigued expression. Karen’s, his mother-in-law, gentle but suddenly attentive. “I’ll need to start interviewing. It’s a crucial role. Handles everything from my calendar to client liaison. Chaos if it’s empty for too long.”

A beat of silence, filled only by the distant hum of the refrigerator.

“What about me?”

Lauren’s question wasn’t sharp, but it landed with a solid weight. She leaned back, her dark hair brushing her shoulders. The physical contrast to her natural blonde still sometimes startled him—a bold, smoldering change from the sunlit girl he’d married. “I’m between projects. I know your business, I know you. I could streamline things you don’t even realize are wasting your time, and we could spend some more time together.”

Under the table, her thigh pressed firmly against his. It was a claim, warm through the fabric of his trousers.

“Well, hold on now,” Megan chirped, her laughter like breaking glass. At forty-eight, she radiated a restless, youthful energy that often blurred the lines of their dynamic. She reached for the salt cellar, her arm stretching across Tyler’s field of vision. As she pulled back, her hand, laden with rings, brushed over the front of his pants—a fleeting, unmistakable pressure that made his breath catch.

“Oops! Clumsy me,” she said, not sounding sorry at all. Her grin was wide and knowing. “But seriously, Ty. You need someone with a little more… administrative experience. Someone who isn’t afraid to manage the inbox from hell. I’ve been running a household for twenty years. A CEO’s schedule would be a vacation.” She winked, her freckled cheeks dimpling.

Tyler’s face felt warm. He took a gulp of water, the ice clicking against his teeth.

“It’s a wonderful opportunity,” Karen said softly. Her voice was a warm blanket, a contrast to the sharpening edges in the room. She leaned forward to gather the empty serving platter, her movement deliberate. The neckline of her blouse gaped, offering a sudden, unignorable view of the soft, tanned curve of her breast and the stark white line of a tan line. She held the pose a second too long before straightening, her blue eyes wide and innocent. “I’ve been looking for something to really sink my teeth into. The kids are grown. I’m organized, I’m personable. I think I’d be quite good at it.”

Three pairs of eyes were fixed on him. Three smiling mouths. Three separate silences, each screaming. Both Tim, Karen's husband and Jason, Megan's husband were smiling at each other, knowing Tyler had kicked over a hornets nest as he was about to get bitten.

Lauren’s foot hooked around his ankle under the table, a proprietary lock. Her smile was thin, competitive. “It makes the most sense, Tyler. No learning curve. And we’d get to have lunch together every day.” The implication was clear: I am your wife. This is mine.

Megan swirled her wine, watching the legs slide down the bowl. “A fresh perspective can be invaluable, sweetie. Someone from outside the… marital bubble.” Her toe, clad in a sheer stocking, found his shin and began a slow, rubbing motion up and down.

Karen sighed contentedly, sitting back and placing her hands in her lap. “I’d just be so grateful for the chance to be useful again. To be part of something dynamic.” Her gaze drifted to Tyler’s, held it, and then dropped to his mouth before she looked away, a faint blush on her cheeks.

Tyler’s mind whitewashed. The roast chicken turned to ashes in his mouth. He saw the next month unfolding in a terrible slide: the jealous snipes masked as office advice, the accidental touches in the supply room, the minefield of choosing who got to sit in the adjoining office with the connecting door. He saw his professional sanctuary dissolving into a harem of familial tension.

“It’s… a big decision,” he managed, his voice strangled. “I need to think about what’s best for the company. Objectively.”

“Objectively,” Lauren repeated, the word a small, cold stone dropped on the table. Her thigh remained a hot, immovable pressure against his.

“Of course, darling,” Megan purred, her foot still making lazy arcs on his leg.

“We all just want what’s best for you,” Karen added, her tone so soothing it felt like a threat.

The chandelier light seemed to fracture then, splintering into a thousand sharp points over the silver and crystal. The table was no longer a place for family dinner. It was a tribunal. A negotiation. A velvet-lined battlefield. Tyler looked at the three women—his wife, his stepmother, his mother-in-law—all smiling with varying degrees of warmth and desperation, and understood, with a sinking clarity, that no matter whom he chose, he had already lost. The silence stretched, taut and humming, waiting for him to break it.

The silence stretched, taut and humming, waiting for him to break it.

Jason, Megan’s husband, cleared his throat. “More wine, anyone?” The question hung in the air, useless and ignored.

“The thing is,” Lauren said, her voice slicing through the quiet, “you need someone who truly understands the pressure you’re under. The late nights. The stress.” Her hand, which had been resting on her own thigh, slid onto his, her fingers applying a gentle, possessive pressure. “I know what you need before you even ask.” Under the table, her other hand found his inner thigh, giving a slow, intimate squeeze that made his muscles tense. “In every way.”

Megan clucked her tongue, a sound of gentle reprimand. “That’s just it, sweetie. Sometimes familiarity breeds… complacency. You need someone who’ll keep you on your toes.” She stood, picking up her plate and his, her full hips brushing deliberately against his shoulder as she moved to clear. Leaning over to gather his cutlery, the neckline of her dress fell forward, giving him an eyeful of her heavy, freckled breasts before she straightened with a coy smile. “A little… stimulation during the workday never hurt anyone. Keeps the mind sharp.”

Karen let out a soft, melanchoric sigh. “I just remember how supportive I was for Lauren’s father when he was building his practice. A man needs a… calming presence.” She reached for the butter dish, her movement languid, and as she stretched, her foot slid from its shoe and the sole of her stockinged foot found its way onto his instep, rubbing slowly back and forth. “Someone steady. Someone who knows how to… soothe the aches.” Her gaze dropped to her own chest, then back to him, a flicker of something unspoken in her eyes.

Tyler felt a bead of sweat trace a path down his spine. The room, once comfortable, was now oppressively hot. The cloying sweetness of Megan’s perfume mixed with Lauren’s citrus scent and Karen’s lavender, creating a suffocating cocktail.

“This potatoes au gratin is divine, Karen,” Megan said, sitting back down with a thud that jarred the table. “You’ll have to give me the recipe. I’m always looking for new ways to… satisfy a man’s appetite.” She directed this last part at Tyler, holding his gaze as she took a deliberate, slow bite, her lips closing around the fork.

“I think Tyler’s appetite is just fine,” Lauren said icily, her nails now digging into the fabric of his trousers. “And he gets the best of everything at home.” She turned to him, her smile not reaching her eyes. “Don’t you, darling?”

“I… it’s not about that,” Tyler stammered, shifting in his seat, which only caused Lauren’s hand to press more firmly and Karen’s foot to slide higher up his calf. “It’s a professional decision. I need to consider skill sets. Compatibility with the team.”

“Compatibility is so important,” Karen agreed softly, her foot now stroking his shin. “A harmonious… fit. A rhythm.” She took a sip of wine, leaving a faint lipstick stain on the rim. “I’m a very good listener.”

Megan reached for the water pitcher, her arm draping across Tyler’s chest, her breast pressing against his bicep. “Oh, I’m terrible at listening,” she laughed, her breath hot near his ear. “I’m much more of a… hands-on problem solver.” She let her hand trail across his shoulders as she pulled back, her fingers brushing the nape of his neck.

Tyler’s mind whirled. He saw spreadsheets dissolving into images of lingerie, board meetings interrupted by petty arguments, his sleek office becoming a stage for a covert, three-act play of seduction and rivalry. He felt like a piece of meat slowly being pulled apart by three very determined, very connected birds of prey.

Lauren leaned in, her lips almost touching his ear, her voice a low, dangerous purr meant only for him. “Hire me, and I’ll make sure you never have to… take care of yourself in the executive washroom again.” The graphic, private promise hung between them, a grenade with the pin pulled.

Just then, Megan’s hand “slipped” beneath the table, landing squarely on his thigh, her fingers giving a firm, exploratory knead before she withdrew with a giggle. “These tablecloths are so slick!”

Karen, seeing the covert maneuvers, simply let her blouse gap open once more as she reached for her napkin, her eyes holding Tyler’s with a placid, challenging expression.

The walls were closing in. The chandelier’s light seemed to pulse with the frantic rhythm of his own heartbeat. He looked at the three faces—each beautiful, each familiar, each now a source of profound, inescapable dread—and knew, with absolute certainty, that there was no longer a safe choice. There was only the choice of which kind of hell he preferred. The silence returned, thicker now, choked with perfume and intention, waiting for him to drown in it.

The silence returned, thicker now, choked with perfume and intention, waiting for him to drown in it.

He cleared his throat, the sound too loud in the quiet. He pushed his chair back an inch, just enough to break the simultaneous contact of thigh, hand, and foot. The loss of their touch felt like surfacing from deep water.

“Look,” Tyler said, his voice steadier than he felt. He folded his hands on the linen, a conscious pose of neutrality. “I’m… honestly flattered. All of you. That you’d even want to step into that chaos.” He offered a weak, inclusive smile that felt like a crack in plaster. “And of course, I’d be happy to sit down with each of you for an initial interview. To hear your ideas.”

Lauren’s eyes narrowed a fraction. Megan’s predatory grin softened into something more alert. Karen tilted her head, listening.

“But,” he continued, the word a dam holding back a flood, “the final round, the actual hiring decision… that has to go through a professional HR consultant. It’s a new board policy. For objectivity.” He shrugged, a gesture meant to convey helpless bureaucracy. “We used a firm last year for the V.P. hire. An Indian woman, actually. Incredibly sharp. The board was thrilled with her process. So it’s out of my hands, ultimately.”

The air in the room shifted, cooling several degrees. The shared fantasy of direct access to him, to his days, evaporated like steam from the cooling plates.

“A consultant?” Lauren repeated, her voice flat. "but you can give a recommendation?"

“It’s standard practice, Lauren. For exactly this reason.” He held her gaze, pleading silently for her to understand the out he was giving them both. “No appearance of favoritism.”

Megan sniffed. “So we’d be jumping through hoops for some stranger in a pantsuit.”

“You’d be going through a proper hiring process,” Tyler corrected gently. “Like any other candidate., as Lauren said, I am able to give my recommendation for the position”

Karen was the first to smile, a fragile, understanding thing. “Well, that’s very fair, Tyler. Very proper.” She withdrew her foot, slipping it back into her shoe under the table with a final, soft sigh.

The ride home was wrapped in a taut, loaded quiet. The city lights streaked past the car windows, painting Lauren’s profile in intermittent flashes of gold and shadow. Her hand rested on the center console, not touching his.

Through the front door, the click of her heels on the hardwood was a decisive tempo. She dropped her purse on the hall table, the sound like a period.

“A consultant,” she said, not turning around.

“It was the only way out, Lauren. You saw them. It was a feeding frenzy.”

She turned then. The dark hair framed her face, her eyes unreadable in the dim entryway light. “You’ll still give me the first interview.”

“Of course.”

“And you’ll tell the consultant I’m the best candidate.”

“I’ll tell her you’re a highly capable candidate. Because you are.”

A slow smile touched her lips, but it didn’t warm her eyes. It was a calculated, private thing. She stepped out of her shoes, one then the other, her movements languid and deliberate. She walked toward him, stopping only when the tips of her toes touched his. She placed her palms flat on his chest, feeling the quickened beat of his heart beneath the crisp cotton of his shirt.

“You handled that,” she whispered, “like a diplomat.” Her hands slid down, over his stomach, coming to rest at his belt. “Diplomats deserve rewards.”

She took his hand and led him up the stairs, not to the bedroom, but past it, into the master bathroom. The cool, polished marble underfoot was a shock. She turned on the shower, letting steam begin to fog the mirrors before facing him. Her eyes held his as she unbuttoned his shirt, pushed it from his shoulders. Her fingers worked his belt, the button of his trousers, the zipper.

“Mmm, someone's excited” she said, her voice low.

The steam had thickened, wrapping them in a warm, private cloud. Lauren’s eyes never left his as her hands finished their work, pushing his trousers and boxers down his hips in one smooth motion. His erection sprang free, already fully hard and straining upward. She guided him backward into the shower's spray, the hot water instantly plastering his dark hair to his head and streaming down his neck and shoulders.

Her own dress, a simple black sheath, was already soaked through and clinging to every curve. She reached behind her back for the zipper, the sound a faint metallic whisper beneath the drumming water. She shimmied her shoulders, and the damp fabric slid down her body, pooling at her feet on the marble floor. She stood before him, water cascading over her full breasts, her dark nipples peaked and tight, down the gentle slope of her stomach, and over the thatch of blonde curls at the junction of her thighs.

“Much better,” she murmured, her voice husky with promise and possession. She took his hand again, her grip firm, and led him fully under the showerhead. The water beat down on them, a tropical rain inside their own glass-walled world.

Then, without breaking eye contact, she sank gracefully to her knees before him on the smooth, wet tile. The hot spray soaked her dark hair instantly, sending rivulets running down her temples and cheeks. She placed her hands on his hips, her thumbs stroking the defined ridges of his pelvis.

She didn’t hesitate. Leaning forward, she opened her mouth and took the broad, plum-colored head of his cock inside. A low, guttural groan ripped from Tyler’s throat, his head falling back against the cool glass wall. Her tongue was hot and expert, swirling around the sensitive corona, licking away the beads of pre-cum that already dotted the tip. She made a soft, appreciative sound in the back of her throat, the vibration traveling straight through him.

Her hands slid from his hips to cradle his balls, rolling the heavy weight of them gently in her palms as her mouth began to work downward. She took him deeper, her lips stretching to accommodate his thickness. Tyler looked down, his breath catching at the sight. Her eyes were closed in concentration, water droplets clinging to her long dark lashes. Her cheeks were hollowed with the effort of taking him, the rhythm of her head beginning to establish a slow, devastating pace.

She pulled back until just the tip remained between her lips, her tongue flicking rapidly over the frenulum, a move she knew drove him wild. Then she plunged forward again, taking him deeper this time, her nose pressing into the coarse hair at his base. One of her hands left his balls and slid up the length of his shaft, her fingers meeting her lips as she established a tight, twisting motion, working him in tandem with the suction of her mouth.

The sounds were obscene and magnificent—the steady drum of the shower, the slick, wet noises of her mouth on him, his own ragged breaths echoing in the steam-filled enclosure. She varied her pace, sometimes fast and hungry, other times agonizingly slow, savoring him as if he were the last thing she’d ever taste. She looked up at him then, her blue eyes locking with his through the haze of steam and water, and the possessiveness in her gaze was as intense as the physical pleasure. This was her claim, stamped in the most intimate way possible.

Her other hand wandered, sliding behind him to grip the firm muscle of his buttock, pulling him incrementally deeper into her throat. A powerful tremor ran through his legs. He tangled one hand in her wet hair, not to guide her, but to feel the connection, the anchor in the rising storm of sensation. His hips began to move of their own accord, a shallow, thrusting rhythm that met her every descent.

"Lauren..." he gasped, a warning and a plea.

She doubled her efforts, her head bobbing faster, her throat relaxing to take him even deeper on each pass. The coiling tension in his gut tightened unbearably, a spring wound to its breaking point. With a final, choked cry, he erupted into the hot, wet depths of her mouth. She held him there, swallowing diligently, her throat working around him until the last shuddering pulse subsided.

Slowly, tenderly, she released him, pulling back and licking her lips clean with a final, slow swipe of her tongue. She rested her forehead against his damp stomach for a moment, catching her breath, the water sluicing over both of them.

She finally rose, her knees slightly red from the tile, her body glistening and beautiful. She reached past him to turn off the water, leaving them in a sudden, dripping silence. The only sound was their shared, heavy breathing fogging the glass.

She picked up a plush towel and began to dry him with a strange, focused tenderness, starting with his face and working her way down. When she was done, she dried herself quickly, then wrapped the towel around her own body.

She stood before him, her expression now unreadable, the earlier fire banked to embers. “You’ll recommend me,” she stated softly, not a question. It was the quiet aftermath of the war she’d just waged with her body, the terms of surrender clearly dictated.

Before he could formulate any answer, she turned and walked out of the bathroom, leaving him alone in the cooling, steam-fogged chamber. Tyler stood there, water dripping from his chin, the phantom sensation of her mouth still imprinted on his skin, and knew with absolute certainty that the interview process had just begun, and he had already, irrevocably, failed the first test.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI