Cover of The Benefactor's Dilemma

The Benefactor's Dilemma

Read the story

4 chapters · 10788 words · Read 0 times

Joe finished signing the documents on his desk that would donate $150 million to Habitat for Humanity, and another for homeless shelters across the country. He smiled up at his lawyer, a vivacious and fit brunette whose business attire did little to hide her athletic build and huge breasts.

Chapter 2: The Message That Changes Everything

The leather sighed under him as the Mercedes glided through the pre-dawn city, streets slick from a recent rain. Joe stared at his reflection in the tinted window, not recognizing the man superimposed over passing brick and neon. He flexed his hand, watching the corded muscle in his forearm shift and roll beneath skin that looked too smooth, too tightly drawn. It felt like wearing a wetsuit two sizes too small, a constant, humming awareness of a vessel that was both his and profoundly not.

He’d cancelled his morning training session. The thought of facing the gym, of lifting weights that now felt like balsa wood, of the awed, fearful stares from his staff—he couldn’t. Not today.

His phone, face-down on the seat beside him, buzzed.

A text. He knew it was her before he looked. A sick, sure knowledge settled in his gut.

He flipped it over.

Izzy: I saw you.

Three words. The air vanished from the car. The hum of the engine became a distant roar in his ears. His heart, a powerful, sluggish drum now, thudded once, hard, against his sternum.

Saw what? His mind raced, a torrent of panicked images. The impossible leap across the construction site last week to catch a falling beam? The unconscious squeeze that had shattered a crystal tumbler in his boardroom? The way he’d absentmindedly bent a steel door handle into a pretzel yesterday, hiding the evidence in his desk drawer?

How much had she seen? When?

His thumbs hovered over the screen. He typed, deleted, typed again.

Joe: Saw me?

He hit send. The wait was agony.

The car turned onto the parkway. Karl, his driver of twenty years, glanced in the rearview. “Everything alright, Mr. Harding? You’re quiet.”

“Fine, Karl. Just tired.”

The phone buzzed.

Izzy: Last night. In the garage. After I left.

The garage. Relief, immediate and dizzying, washed over him. She meant the women. Marissa. The secretaries. The parade. Not the other thing. Not the… change.

But the relief was bitter, followed by a sharper shame. That’s what she’d taken from their moment. That’s what she thought he was offering, just another transaction in a gallery of beautiful things.

Joe: It’s not what you think.

Even as he sent it, he hated the cliché of it.

Izzy: It never is.

Her reply was instantaneous. A finality to it.

“Damn it,” he muttered, the word a low growl that seemed to vibrate in his expanded chest. He looked at his reflection again. The face was still kind, still etched with experience, but it was mounted on a monument. A god in a tomb of his own making. He wanted to explain, but the truth was a greater madness. I’m becoming something else, Izzy, and I’m terrified, and you’re the only real thing in a world that’s starting to feel like paper.

He couldn’t say that.

He typed slowly, forcing himself to be careful, the phone feeling fragile in his grip.

Joe: The wine was a better offer. I meant that. Can we talk? Not over text.

The typing dots appeared. Disappeared. Appeared again. The car crossed the bridge, the river below a sheet of dark mercury in the morning light.

Izzy: There’s a 9:30 foundation meeting. The architects for the youth center are presenting.

A professional deflection. Perfect.

Joe: Before. My office. 8:45.

He made it a statement, not a question. He was still the client. He still had that card to play, even if it felt like a betrayal.

The dots lingered.

Izzy: Okay.

Just that. Okay.

He put the phone down, the brief exchange leaving him more drained than a thousand lifts. He leaned his head back. The city streamed by, a blur of grays and glass. He wondered what she saw when she looked at him now. The generous billionaire. The lonely old man. The collector of beautiful people. Or something new, something straining against the seams of his tailored shirt.

At 8:42, he was pouring two coffees from the carafe, his hands steady despite the storm inside. The door to his office opened precisely at 8:45.

Izzy walked in, all business. A charcoal gray suit, hair in a severe knot, the same leather folio under her arm. She looked like she hadn’t slept.

“Joe,” she said, a neutral acknowledgment.

“Izzy. Coffee.” He pushed a cup toward the edge of the desk.

“Thank you.” She took it but didn’t drink. She remained standing. “We should review the architect’s proposal points before the full meeting. There are some zoning variances they’re taking for granted that could be problematic.”

He ignored her. Came around the desk. He saw her tense, just a slight tightening around her eyes. He stopped, leaving a good four feet between them. The morning sun caught the dust motes swirling in the air.

“I’m not a saint, Izzy,” he said, his voice quiet. “I have flaws. A lot of them. The world I built… it attracts certain people. And sometimes, it’s easier to just let the scenery be scenery. It doesn’t mean anything.”

She took a sip of coffee, buying time. “You don’t owe me an explanation.”

“I think I do.” He ran a hand through his hair. “That moment… before the phone rang. That meant something.”

She looked at him then, really looked, and her lawyer’s mask slipped. He saw confusion, and hurt, and a flicker of the same attraction he’d always felt from her, now tangled with disappointment. “It did. And then the elevator opened, and it was just another part of the scenery. I was the one who felt foolish for thinking it might be different.”

“It is different.” The frustration bubbled up, hot and urgent. He needed her to understand, to see him. Without thinking, he gestured toward the window, toward the city. “All of this, it’s… it’s becoming background noise. You’re not.”

He took a step closer. She didn’t retreat. Her eyes searched his face, and he saw a new curiosity there, a dawning confusion that had nothing to do with the women in the garage.

“Joe,” she said slowly, her gaze dropping to his chest, his arms, then back to his eyes. “Are you… are you okay? You look different.”

His blood went cold. She saw. Not everything, but she saw the change. The physical impossibility of it.

“I’ve been training harder,” he said, the lie ash in his mouth. “Trying to… keep up.”

She nodded, but the doubt didn’t leave her eyes. “Right.” She set her coffee down on the desk with a soft click. “We should go to the meeting.”

“Izzy.”

“The meeting, Joe.” Her voice was firm, but it held a tremor. She was compartmentalizing, pushing the personal—the confusing, the frightening—into a box to be dealt with later. It was what he’d always admired about her. Now, it felt like a door closing.

He nodded, defeated. “Lead the way.”

As she turned, her suit jacket pulled tight across her shoulders. He saw the strength in her frame, the climber’s latent power. A different kind of strength. One he had always admired from afar.

Now, as he followed her out, his own monstrous strength feeling like a curse, he realized the true distance between them had nothing to do with age or wealth. It was the chasm between what was human and whatever he was becoming. And he had never felt more powerless.

The foundation meeting was a forty-three minute exercise in exquisite torture.

Joe sat at the head of the polished table, the morning sun now harsh and clinical through the glass wall. The architects’ voices buzzed like distant flies, their renderings of hopeful, glass-walled youth centers blurring into meaningless shapes. He nodded at appropriate intervals, his responses a series of low, non-committal grunts that everyone mistook for thoughtful consideration.

All his focus was tunneled on Izzy, seated two chairs down.

She was electric, engaged, dismantling a zoning issue with surgical precision. “The setback variance on page seven assumes a historical precedent that was overturned in the Mercer case,” she said, not even looking at her notes. Her finger tapped the document. “If we proceed on this assumption, the whole third phase becomes litigation bait. We need the planning department’s interpretation in writing before we whisper this to a contractor.”

The lead architect, a man half Joe’s age with aggressively stylish glasses, blinked. “We… we can certainly look into that.”

“Don’t look,” Izzy said, offering a tight smile that held no warmth. “Get it. Or redesign the west wing.”

Joe watched her. This was the woman he knew. The brilliant, relentless force of nature. The woman whose fingers had brushed his with a charge that now felt like a memory from someone else’s life. Her suit jacket strained slightly across her shoulders as she leaned forward, and he remembered the feel of granite under his own palms, the way he’d crushed a stress ball into silicon dust during a conference call yesterday.

His own body was a silent, screaming counterpoint to the civilized discussion.

The numbers on the apartment doors just sort of skipped over the one she’d occupied.

The thought slammed into him, unbidden and violent, a rogue wave from a buried memory. Cathy. He hadn’t allowed himself to think that name in weeks. The memory of that first, frantic day of searching was a black hole in his mind, sucking in all logical light.

He’d stood in the carpeted hallway of her building, a cold dread seeping through him. The doors were numbered 408, 410, 412… and then 416. No 414. He walked the length of the hall twice, his fingers brushing the wall where her door should have been. It was a solid, unbroken expanse of beige paint. The floor above had the correct number of units. The floor below was normal. Only Cathy’s home had been neatly snipped from reality, the world sutured closed behind it without a scar.

No one in the building management remembered her. Her name evoked polite, blank stares.

In this boardroom, surrounded by the trappings of his immense power, that same feeling of erasure returned. He was becoming a door that didn’t exist, a number skipped in the sequence of humanity. The women, the transformations—they were just symptoms. A side effect of something fundamental breaking inside him, or around him.

“Joe?”

Izzy’s voice cut through. Everyone was looking at him. The young architect had asked him a direct question about budget allocations.

“Sorry,” Joe said, his voice a graveled rumble that seemed to startle the room. “Say that again?”

Izzy’s eyes held his for a second too long. They weren’t just assessing his inattention. They were diagnosing it. “Michael asked if you’re comfortable with the potential cost overrun on the sustainable materials package. It’s a ten percent premium.”

“Do it,” Joe said, waving a hand. The gesture felt too broad, too forceful. He saw a junior analyst flinch slightly. “Whatever it takes. Just build it right.”

The meeting bled to a conclusion shortly after, the architects gathering their tablets with a mix of relief and confusion. The room emptied until only Joe and Izzy remained, the silence now a physical presence between them.

She didn’t look at him as she slotted papers into her folio. “You were a million miles away.”

“Closer than you think,” he murmured.

He stood, needing to move. He walked to the window, his back to her. The city sprawled, a circuit board of life. He had tried her office after the apartment. Same thing. The directory, the floor plan, the collective memory of the firm—all contained a smooth, logical gap where Catherine Ellis should have been. It was as if she’d been digitally removed from a photograph, the background filled in with plausible pixels.

Finally, he’d gone to the pub.

“That first day,” he said, the words leaving him softly, aimed at the skyline. “After Cathy vanished, I went to the pub where we’d had our last drink.”

He heard the rustle of her folio stop. She was listening.

“I sat in the same booth.” He could smell the stale beer and polish, feel the sticky vinyl under his palms. “I was finishing my second beer, just drowning in this… this quiet panic, when I noticed the glances.”

All of the women were stealing glances at him. He’d looked at his shirt, thinking he’d spilled. But no. Their eyes were hungry, fixed. It was a new kind of attention, raw and magnetic. It felt nothing like the respectful recognition he was used to. This was primal.

“A redhead came over,” he continued, the memory playing out on the glass before him. “She asked to join me. I don’t even think I spoke. I just nodded.”

What followed was a warm, blurring cascade. Her apartment. The shocking, effortless synergy of their bodies. Her roommates, drawn by the noise—a blonde and an African-American woman—joining without a word of discussion, as if it were the most natural thing in the world. The redhead had smiled and made space, sharing him without a shred of jealousy. It had been a night of tangled, groaning pleasure, a stamina that felt endless and foreign to him.

He turned from the window to face Izzy. She was perfectly still, her professional armor fissured by stark disbelief and dawning horror.

“They changed, Izzy,” he said, his voice flat, emptied of emotion. “When we woke up. They were taller. More… defined. More beautiful. They were thrilled. Elated. And I… I did it again. It was like a compulsion. A feedback loop.”

He took a step toward her, and she didn’t retreat. She was anchored by the sheer impossibility of what he was saying.

“It kept happening. One woman would hand me off to another, like a… a beneficial pathogen. They’d get stronger, smarter, more confident. And I’d just… continue. It felt like filling a hole that couldn’t be filled. Like I was generating this… this transformative energy, and sex was just the release valve.”

He finally said the words he’d been avoiding since the garage. “The women you saw? That’s not a harem. It’s a symptom. I’m sick, or I’m broken, or I’m something else entirely. And I am so, so tired of being a chemical that improves everyone’s life but my own.”

Izzy’s lips were parted. Her sharp, analytical mind was visibly grappling with the story, trying to fit it into a framework of mental breakdown, or lies, or metaphor. But her eyes kept tracing the impossible width of his shoulders, the way his dress shirt seemed woven from thinner, tighter cloth than anyone else’s.

“Joe…” Her voice was a whisper. “What are you saying?”

“I’m saying Cathy is gone, and the world forgot her. I’m saying I bend steel without trying. I’m saying I look in the mirror and see a monument.” He took a final, closing step, now within arm’s reach. He could see the pulse in her throat. “And I’m saying that in your office, when you brushed my hand, it was the last real, human thing I felt before this… this current started running through me. You’re the only connection I have left to before. And I am terrified of what happens if I lose that, too.”

She lifted a hand, not to touch him, but as if to ward off the sheer magnitude of his confession. Her fingers trembled.

“You need help,” she said, but the statement was hollow, devoid of its usual professional conviction.

“From who?” A bleak, almost soundless laugh escaped him. “A doctor? A priest? Who exactly has a diagnosis for this?”

Before she could answer, his phone buzzed in his pocket. The sound was like a nail gun in the quiet room. He ignored it. It buzzed again. And again. Insistent.

Reluctantly, he pulled it out. The screen showed a cascade of notifications. Texts. From numbers he didn’t know.

Unknown: Joe. It’s Lacey. From the coffee shop? I aced my bar exam!

Unknown: Mr. Harding. Marissa. My chronic back pain is gone. Totally gone.

Unknown: It’s Chloe. My sister saw me and she says she wants to meet you. When are you free?

He stared at the glowing screen, a wave of nausea rising in his gut. The proof was leaking out, spreading through the city in a silent, joyous pandemic of his own making.

Izzy was watching his face, reading the devastation there. Her own phone chimed—a soft, professional tone. She glanced down at it automatically, then went very still.

Her breath hitched.

Slowly, she looked from her phone screen back to him, her eyes wide with a new, profound shock. She turned the screen toward him.

It was a text from a fellow lawyer in her firm, a woman named Vanessa.

Vanessa: Izzy. You’re working with Joe Harding, right? This is so weird, but my skin condition… the psoriasis I’ve had for years? It cleared up overnight after I ran into him at the charity gala last week. Just wanted to say… he’s a miracle worker. Can you tell him thanks?

The air left the room.

Izzy’s hand fell to her side, the phone dangling from her fingers. The last barrier of professional doubt shattered. The evidence was no longer just his word. It was in her own world, on her own device.

“Oh, God,” she breathed, not a prayer, but a surrender to a new, terrifying reality.

Joe’s phone buzzed once more in his hand. This time, it was a calendar alert for a dinner he didn’t remember making.

With a woman whose name he didn’t recognize.

The momentum was no longer his. It was the world’s, and it was pulling him forward into a future he couldn’t control, leaving Izzy standing amidst the wreckage of everything she believed was possible.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI