Cover of The Birthday Gift

The Birthday Gift

Read the story

5 chapters · 13433 words · Read 1 times

Cara and Aidan had been close friends with Dana and Pete for over 20 years. They’d holidayed together many times. Pete’s huge cock was a running joke and Cara somehow was the one who kept the jokes alive. Aidan always wondered whether her interest was more than just humour and one day Dana asked Cara ‘Care, you do mention Pete’s dick a lot, do you hve a thing for it?” Cara denied of course but did blush. Two months later it’s Cara’s birthday. Dana and Pete hand her a present and when she opens it, it’s a dildo. Cara asks “what’s this?’ Dana and Pete both chuckle and Dana says ‘you seem so fascinated by Pete’s dick, I had an exact mould made of it for you’ (tell the story about Cara using it privately without Aidans knowing, every chance she could get, then how this leads to Aidan becoming a cuckold and letting her fuck the real thing and how Aidan becomes a willing cum slave for Cara Pete and Dana)

Chapter 3: The Submission

The silence wasn’t peaceful. It was thick. Saturated. Heavy with the smell of sweat, sex, and something sharper – shame, maybe, or the ozone crackle of crossed wires. Pete sagged off Cara, collapsing onto his side beside her, his chest heaving. A sheen of sweat covered him, catching the low light. He wouldn’t look at Aidan. Cara lay still, staring at the ceiling, her body humming, every nerve ending singing a discordant anthem of satisfaction and disbelief. Her skin felt raw, oversensitized, the phantom imprint of Pete’s weight, his size, still a tangible pressure deep inside her.

Aidan remained frozen where Dana had held him upright. Tremors ran through him, visible shudders. His pajama pants pooled around his ankles, the evidence of his own humiliating climax starkly visible on his hand and belly. His face was chalk-white, eyes wide and unfocused, staring past the bed, past everything. The geography of his humiliation was mapped in semen and slick on the sheets between Pete and Cara.

Dana moved first. She hadn't broken a sweat. Her eyes, sharp as flint, swept the scene – Pete’s spent exhaustion, Cara’s stunned euphoria, Aidan’s shattered stillness. A slow, satisfied smile touched her lips. It wasn’t warm. It was the smile of a chess master surveying a perfectly executed endgame. She stepped forward, her boots silent on the carpet, stopping beside the bed. She looked down at the mess glistening on Cara’s inner thighs, the trails leading back to Pete’s softening cock.

"Look at that," Dana murmured, her voice cutting through the heavy air. She nudged Pete’s thigh with her toe. "Making a mess of my best friend." Her gaze shifted, landing like a weight on Aidan. "Clean it up."

Aidan flinched as if struck. His eyes snapped into focus, wild with disbelief. "What?"

"You heard me." Dana’s tone was flat, implacable. "Kneel. Clean your wife. Clean him." She jerked her chin towards Pete.

Pete made a low, uncomfortable sound, shifting slightly, trying to angle himself away. "Dana, Jesus, come on..."

Dana ignored him. Her eyes remained locked on Aidan, pinning him in place. "You watched it happen. You got off on it." Her gaze flickered pointedly down to his exposed state. "Now be useful. Clean up your mess."

A wave of nausea rose in Aidan’s throat. His legs felt like water. He wanted to run. To scream. To disappear. The coppery tang of blood filled his mouth where he’d bitten his lip. But beneath the revulsion, the utter degradation, that treacherous current still pulsed. The memory of Cara’s cries, the sight of Pete claiming her, the raw power of Dana’s command… it warred with the sickening reality now demanded of him. His gaze flickered to Cara.

She was watching him now. Her eyes, wide and dark, held his. He saw no pity there. No apology. Just a flickering intensity, a deep, unsettling curiosity. And something else – a spark of the same dark thrill that had ignited when Pete first entered her. Her lips were slightly parted, her breath still coming fast. Her hand, resting on her stomach, trembled faintly.

"Kneel, Aidan," Dana repeated, her voice dropping lower, hardening. "Or get out. Now. And don’t come back."

The ultimatum hung in the air. The sanctuary was gone. The familiar walls seemed to press in. To leave would be to shatter everything, immediately, irrevocably. To kneel… was to step into the abyss he’d already glimpsed. His legs gave way. Not gracefully. He crumpled to his knees beside the bed, the carpet rough against his bare skin, his spent cock brushing the floor. He kept his eyes down, focused on the pattern of the rug, the dust motes dancing in a stray beam of light. Anything but the glistening evidence inches from his face.

A faint, musky-sweet scent, uniquely Cara mixed with Pete, filled his nostrils. His stomach clenched. Dana’s shadow fell over him.

"Start with her," Dana commanded, her boot tapping Cara’s ankle.

Aidan closed his eyes for a second. Then, with a trembling hand, he reached out. His fingertips brushed the sticky warmth high on Cara’s inner thigh. She gasped, a tiny, involuntary sound. Her legs shifted slightly, opening a fraction more. The contact sent a jolt through him – revulsion mixed with a terrifying jolt of arousal. He leaned in, his breath hitching. The scent intensified. He pressed his lips to her skin.

It was warm. Salty. The taste was complex, unfamiliar – her arousal, Pete’s release, the faint metallic tang of blood maybe from the intensity. He licked tentatively, a slow, hesitant stroke. Cara moaned, soft and low, her hand coming down to rest lightly on the back of his head, not pushing, just… resting. Her touch burned. He licked again, more purposefully this time, tracing the wet trails upwards, his tongue flat against her skin, cleaning the outer folds, avoiding the swollen, glistening core. Her fingers tightened slightly in his hair. He heard her breath catch, felt the subtle tremor run through her. He didn’t look up.

"Good," Dana purred, watching. "Now him."

Aidan froze. His head snapped up, eyes wide with renewed horror. Pete was staring at the ceiling, his jaw clenched, a flush creeping up his neck. His cock lay flaccid against his thigh, glistening wetly.

"No," Aidan whispered, the word cracking.

Dana leaned down, her face close to his. Her eyes were hard. "Do it. Or this ends. Now. Permanently."

Cara’s hand tightened in his hair again, not painful, but insistent. She didn’t speak. Her eyes, when he risked a glance, held a silent command that mirrored Dana’s. A demand. A need to see him submit completely.

Aidan’s shoulders slumped. The fight drained out of him, leaving a hollow ache. He turned his head slowly, mechanically, towards Pete. The intimacy was grotesque. The sheer wrongness of it choked him. He shuffled on his knees, turning fully to face Pete’s hip. The scent here was sharper, muskier, undeniably male. Pete flinched as Aidan got closer.

"Christ," Pete muttered, turning his face away.

Aidan closed his eyes. He leaned forward. His nose almost touched Pete’s skin. He could feel the heat radiating off him. With a shuddering breath that felt like his last, Aidan opened his mouth and pressed his tongue to the base of Pete’s softening cock. The taste exploded on his tongue – salt, musk, a bitterness underneath, the undeniable biological reality of another man’s release. He gagged, his throat convulsing, but forced himself to lick upwards, following the smear of fluid. The skin was soft, vulnerable. Pete hissed, his hips jerking minutely away, then forcing themselves still. Aidan licked, his tongue moving in short, rough strokes, trying to be clinical, dispassionate, but every sensation was magnified, branded onto his consciousness. The texture. The taste. The sheer submission of it. When he reached the head, slick and soft, he paused, then swept his tongue over it, cleaning the last remnants.

He pulled back, gasping, saliva slick on his chin. He kept his eyes squeezed shut, unable to look at anyone. The taste lingered, corrosive. His stomach roiled.

"Good boy," Dana said, her voice thick with dark approval. "Very thorough."

Aidan felt like he might vomit. Or pass out. He stayed on his knees, head bowed, trembling uncontrollably.

Cara pushed herself up onto her elbows. Her eyes, bright and feverish, were fixed on Dana. Not on Aidan. Not on Pete. On Dana. The orchestrator. The woman who had seen her deepest, most forbidden desire and not just acknowledged it, but weaponized it. Gratitude warred with a fierce, burgeoning need. Her fingers, still trembling, reached out, not towards the men, but towards Dana’s leg resting near the edge of the bed. She touched the rough denim of Dana’s jeans, just above her boot.

Dana looked down, her eyebrow arching.

Cara’s touch slid higher, tentative at first, then gaining confidence, tracing the curve of Dana’s calf. Her voice, when it came, was a raw whisper, thick with the aftermath of pleasure and the intoxicating pull of newfound power. "Dana... what you did... what you made happen..."

Dana didn’t move. She watched Cara’s hand climb her thigh. "Made happen?" she echoed softly, a challenge in her tone. "Or just... let happen?"

Cara’s fingers reached the hem of Dana’s sweater. She slipped her hand underneath, finding warm skin, the firm muscle of Dana’s stomach. Her gaze locked with Dana’s, a current of pure, unspoken electricity crackling between them. "Both," Cara breathed. Her other hand joined the first, both sliding up under Dana’s sweater, pushing the fabric up, revealing the smooth plane of her abdomen, the bottom curve of her breasts encased in black lace. "You knew. You always knew."

A slow smile spread across Dana’s face. Triumphant. Possessive. She reached down, her fingers tangling in Cara’s sweaty hair, not gently. "I did. And I gave it to you." Her gaze flickered to Aidan, still kneeling, head bowed, then to Pete who was watching them, his expression unreadable. "Along with an audience." Her fingers tightened in Cara’s hair, pulling her head back slightly, forcing her to look up. "But you don't just want him, do you, Cara? Not anymore. You want the game. The power." Her thumb brushed Cara’s lower lip. "You want... everything."

Cara’s breath hitched. Dana’s touch, possessive and demanding, sent a fresh jolt of desire through her, different from the raw physicality with Pete. This felt like claiming. Like stepping into her own strength, guided by Dana’s ruthless hand. Her fingers dug into Dana’s sides, pulling her closer. "Show me," she whispered, her voice trembling not with fear, but with hunger. "Show me everything."

Dana’s smile widened. She released Cara’s hair and grabbed the front of her own sweater, pulling it off in one swift movement. Her black lace bra gleamed in the dim light. She leaned down, her lips brushing Cara’s ear. "Then watch," she murmured, her voice a low, dangerous promise. She straightened, her gaze sweeping over her husband and Aidan. "Again. Now." Her eyes fixed on Pete. "Get hard." Then, to Aidan, still kneeling, adrift in his shame: "Clean him. Get him ready for her. Do it properly this time."

Pete groaned, shifting uncomfortably. Aidan’s head snapped up, his eyes filled with fresh horror. But Cara just watched Dana, her lips curving into a slow, answering smile of her own. The game wasn’t over. It had only just begun. And she was no longer just a player. She was becoming a force. Dana’s words echoed in the charged silence, the command hanging over the wreckage of their old lives. Again. Now. The momentum was unstoppable.

Pete flinched at Dana’s command, a low groan escaping him. He looked exhausted, spent, yet a flicker of unwilling response stirred beneath the surface. His hand drifted down almost apologetically, fingers brushing his own slack flesh. Aidan, still kneeling on the rough carpet, recoiled as if scalded. "Get him ready?" His voice was sandpaper on stone, disbelief warring with a sickening thrum of arousal deep in his gut. The taste of Pete still coated his tongue. "Dana, please..."

"Please what?" Dana snapped, turning her icy gaze fully on him. She hadn’t moved from beside Cara, who watched, transfixed, her fingers still tracing Dana’s waistband. "You licked my husband’s cum off my best friend. Off your wife. Cleaned him like a good little servant." She leaned down, her voice dropping to a venomous whisper. "Now get him hard again so Cara can ride him properly. Use that mouth for something useful." Her boot nudged Aidan’s bare knee, not hard, but the implication was a physical blow. "Move."

Aidan’s throat closed. The cold tile memory of the bathroom floor seemed to seep up through the carpet into his bones. He looked at Pete, who avoided his eyes, staring fixedly at the ceiling, a muscle jumping in his jaw. Aidan’s gaze dropped lower. Pete’s cock lay flaccid against his thigh, looking vulnerable, almost innocent, despite everything. The thought of touching it, of making it hard… it was a violation beyond anything. Yet, Dana’s threat pulsed in the air: Do it or this ends. Now. Permanently. He swallowed hard, nausea rising again. Cara’s quiet gasp drew his eyes. Her hand was fully under Dana’s sweater now, fingers splayed possessively on her friend’s bare stomach. Her eyes, when they met Aidan’s, held no pity. Only a dark, fascinated hunger. Do it, her look seemed to say. Show me what you are now.

A tremor started deep inside Aidan, vibrating through his core. He shuffled forward on his knees, the movement awkward, humiliating. The scent of sex and sweat, Pete’s unique musk, filled his nostrils again. He hesitated, inches away. Pete’s breath hitched, a tiny, suppressed sound. Aidan closed his eyes. Block out the face. Block out the twenty years of barbecues and birthdays. Just the flesh. Just the task. He leaned in, his breath warm against Pete’s skin. He felt the flinch ripple through Pete’s body. With a shuddering breath that felt like surrender, Aidan opened his mouth. His lips touched the soft, warm skin of Pete’s inner thigh, just below the crease. He kissed it. A dry, hesitant press. No taste yet, just heat.

Pete gasped, a sharp intake of air. His hand flew down, not to push Aidan away, but to grasp his own hip, knuckles whitening. Aidan felt the subtle tension coiling in the muscle beneath his lips. He did it again, kissing higher, closer. The skin was smoother here, hotter. His tongue flicked out, a tentative, wet touch. Salty skin. Sweat. He traced upwards with his mouth, following a faint vein, his lips brushing the base of Pete’s cock. Pete’s hips jerked minutely. A low, involuntary sound rumbled in his chest.

"Look at him," Cara breathed, her voice thick, mesmerized. Her other hand joined the first under Dana’s sweater, pushing the fabric higher, revealing the black lace bra fully now. "Look at Aidan working."

Dana’s hand slid into Cara’s hair again, tightening possessively. "He’s learning his place," she murmured, her gaze fixed on Aidan’s bowed head. "Finally." She shifted her hips subtly against Cara’s exploring fingers. "Do it properly, Aidan. Stop teasing."

The command was a lash. Aidan flinched. He opened his mouth wider, taking the soft, vulnerable head of Pete’s cock between his lips. It felt alien. Heavy. Warm skin yielding against his tongue. He sucked gently, experimentally. The response was immediate. Pete groaned, a deep, guttural sound of reluctant pleasure. His cock twitched, swelling slightly against Aidan’s tongue. Encouraged by the visceral reaction, by Dana’s watchful eye, by the sharp intake of breath from Cara, Aidan sucked harder. He hollowed his cheeks, drawing more of the thickening flesh into his mouth. He used his tongue, swirling it around the head, mimicking actions he knew brought Cara pleasure, feeling the slight ridge beneath the crown. Pete’s hips bucked slightly off the bed. "Fuck..." Pete hissed, his hand abandoning his hip to grip the sheets, twisting the fabric. "Oh god..."

Aidan felt the change. The softness was gone. Pete’s cock hardened rapidly, filling his mouth, stretching his lips. It was thick. Unbelievably thick. A surge of panic threatened to overwhelm him. He couldn’t breathe. He pulled back slightly, gasping, saliva slicking his chin and Pete’s shaft. He looked up. Pete’s eyes were squeezed shut, his face a mask of agonized pleasure, jaw clenched. Aidan looked at Cara. She was watching him, her lips parted, eyes wide and dark, her fingers tracing circles on Dana’s bare skin. She licked her lips. Dana’s hand tightened in her hair, pulling her head back further, exposing her throat. Dana leaned down, murmuring something against Cara’s ear that made her moan, a low, needy sound.

"He’s ready," Dana stated flatly, her gaze flicking to Pete’s now fully erect cock, glistening with Aidan’s saliva. Her eyes were hard diamonds. "Again, Cara." She released Cara’s hair and gave her a small, deliberate shove towards Pete. "Take what you want. Show him who owns that cock now."

Cara didn’t hesitate. The shock, the guilt had burned away, replaced by a fierce, primal craving amplified by Dana’s command and Aidan’s abject performance. She pushed herself off the bed, moving with a new, predatory grace. She stood over Pete, her naked body gleaming faintly in the dim light, the mess Aidan had cleaned already forgotten. She placed one knee on the bed beside Pete’s hip, then the other, straddling him. Pete’s eyes snapped open, wide and dark, fixed on her face as she loomed above him. He looked dazed, overwhelmed, his chest heaving.

She reached down, her fingers wrapping around his slick cock. Aidan, still kneeling beside the bed, watched her hand close around the thick base – his handiwork. Cara guided Pete to her entrance. She didn’t look down. She looked at Pete’s face, then at Aidan, then finally at Dana, who stood watching with crossed arms, a faint, satisfied curve to her lips. Cara lowered herself slowly, deliberately, her eyes locked on Dana’s. She sank down onto Pete’s cock with a deep, controlled motion, a low groan escaping her as she took him, inch by impossibly thick inch, her body stretching to accommodate him once more. She didn’t cry out this time. Her jaw was set, her eyes blazing with ownership. She paused when he was fully sheathed, breathing hard, feeling the profound fullness, the heat. Then her gaze snapped down to Aidan.

"Watch," she commanded, her voice husky but clear, echoing Dana’s earlier words. Her hands came to rest on Pete’s chest, fingers splaying possessively. "Watch me take it all." She began to move. Slow, deliberate rises and falls at first, grinding down against Pete’s hips. "Watch how deep he goes." Pete groaned, his hands flying up to grip her hips, helping her, lost in the sensation. Aidan couldn't look away. The sight of Cara moving, riding Pete with fierce concentration, Pete’s large hands guiding her, holding her… it was hypnotic. Degrading. Arousing beyond reason. His own spent cock gave a traitorous throb.

Dana stepped closer to the bed, standing over Aidan. Her shadow fell across him. "You see it now, don't you?" she murmured, her voice dangerously soft. "She doesn't need your cock anymore. She needs his." She crouched down beside Aidan, her face level with his. Her perfume, sharp and expensive, cut through the musk of sex. Her eyes bored into his, seeing every flicker of shame and unwelcome desire. "She needs this." She gestured vaguely at the scene on the bed, Cara picking up speed, her breaths becoming sharp gasps, Pete’s groans louder, more urgent. "Your purpose now…" Dana’s hand reached out, not touching him, but pointing towards the joining of Cara and Pete, glistening with exertion. "...is to serve her pleasure. However she requires." Her lips curved into a cruel smile. "However I require."

Cara cried out, a sharp sound of building tension. Her rhythm became frantic, desperate. Pete thrust upwards to meet her, his grip on her hips bruising. Dana’s smile widened. She leaned closer to Aidan, her breath hot on his ear, her whisper slicing through the sounds of coupling. "Get closer, Aidan. Kneel right there." She pointed to the floor directly between Cara’s spread legs. "Open your mouth. Be ready."

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI