Cover of The Cathedral of Cramped Spaces

The Cathedral of Cramped Spaces

Read the story

6 chapters · 12168 words · Read 1 times

Midnight Mass AU, after the events of the main storyline. Everyone lives, nobody dies. Father Paul Hill, who was once John Pruitt and has decided to commit to his new name, has finally come to terms with is own awful mistakes and wants to start a new life away from life in the church. The angel died in the final confrontation with Bev and the zealots who wanted its power for themselves. Frankly, Bev was furious that Paul and a few others got to reap the benefits of the blood and still living free of its risk while others were left painfully mortal. Bev learned that Paul is gay. And she used her awful influence to run him out of town with hateful speech and threats to his life that almost came true. If it were not for Riley Flynn being there, being the irritated and jaded and tired atheist who has come to be a friend, Paul surely would have been stabbed to death. And now, Paul is no longer a part of the church and live so the mainland with Riley, who also hates the island and decided to leave before things got worse. They live in a small apartment, and Paul works now at a library with some grace of luck, and Riley tries to start his life again by studying psychology. There is some tension between them at times (and Paul can’t blame Riley- Paul did convert Riley to vampirism against his will so it makes sense that Riley is pissed at him), but now there is a new awkwardness between them. They are more comfortable spending time together. They do not go to church at all. They bake and remodel and make their cramped place their home. And it feels like more of a cathedral than any holy building.

Chapter 3: Nesting Instinct

The first tremor hit Paul mid-morning, a sudden slick warmth between his legs that made him gasp and drop the book he was shelving at the library. It wasn’t pain, not exactly. It was a deep, pulsing ache, a hollow yearning that radiated from his core and made his knees buckle. He knew the signs. Every third month, like clockwork, a remnant of the angel’s ruin still echoing in his rewritten biology. His human body, reshaped by vampirism and then reshaped again, was never meant to feel this kind of need. It was a biological imperative, magnified a thousandfold into something utterly consuming.

He stumbled home, the world narrowing to the path back to the apartment, to the nest. He barely managed to kick the door shut before his hands were tearing at his clothes, the wool of his sweater scratching like sandpaper against oversensitized skin. He needed softness, warmth, safety. He dragged every spare blanket from the linen closet, the quilt from the couch, the heap of pillows from Riley’s side of the bed. He built it all on his side, a chaotic, fragrant fortress smelling of their shared sleep, of Riley’s shampoo, of home. He pulled on the pair of thin pink stockings, the silk a familiar comfort against his shaking calves, then fastened the delicate pink collar around his throat—the one Riley had clicked shut weeks ago with a look of such stark possession that Paul had wept. He belonged. The metal was cool against his feverish skin.

Then the fog descended fully. He collapsed into the nest, naked save for the stockings and collar, his mind dissolving into a single, pounding thought: Riley. Need. Full. He moaned, a low, broken sound, and pressed his face into a pillow that smelled of them. His hips jerked instinctively, grinding his wet, exposed cunt against the soft bulk of a folded comforter. It was a pathetic mimicry of what he craved. Tears of frustration leaked from his screwed-shut eyes. “Riley,” he whimpered into the fabric, the word a prayer and a curse. “Please, please, please.”

Riley’s key turned in the lock just after three, the mundanity of his psychology textbook a dull weight in his bag. He stepped into the apartment and froze.

The air was thick with it. Sweet, cloying, a scent like vanilla extract spilled over old parchment paper, underscored by something musky, fertile, and desperately needy. It hit the back of his throat, flooded his sinuses. Paul. But Paul times a thousand. Paul unmasked, raw, in the throes of the heat he’d only hinted at, the one that came from the years of being something that wasn’t meant to breed.

“Fuck,” Riley groaned, a shudder of pure, visceral reaction racking his frame. His cock, which had been a passive part of him all day, hardened to a painful ache in his jeans in an instant, a thick, heavy demand. The predator in him, the one he’d caged to study in textbooks, snapped its jaws. Mine. In need. Fix it.

He dropped his bag, the thud loud in the silent apartment, and followed the scent, a moth to a primal flame. He pushed their bedroom door open.

The sight pinned him to the doorway. Paul, a vision of beautiful, abject wreckage. Curled in the mountain of bedding, skin sheened with a fine sweat that caught the grey afternoon light. The pink silk of the stockings was a shock against his pale thighs, which were parted, trembling. The pink collar was a stark claim around his slender throat. He was humping the pillow beneath him in a frantic, unrhythmic motion, a low, continuous keen escaping his lips. Tears streaked his temples, dampening his dark hair.

Paul’s eyes fluttered open, glassy and dark with need. He saw Riley and a fresh sob broke from him. Not of sadness, but of sheer, overwhelming relief. He didn’t speak. He just looked, his body still moving, inviting, begging.

Riley knew. This was the permission. It was in the air, in the tears, in the way Paul’s body opened toward him even as he hid his face in shame.

“I’ve got you,” Riley said, his voice rougher than he intended. He crossed the room in three strides, shedding his own clothes with jerky, impatient movements. Jeans and boxers shoved down, shirt pulled over his head and tossed aside. His cock sprang free, fully erect, thick and veined and already leaking. He didn’t give Paul time to think, to doubt. He climbed into the nest, covering Paul’s body with his own, enveloping him in heat and muscle and the scent of his own arousal.

The feeling of Riley’s skin against his was an electric shock that grounded Paul. He moaned, a deep, guttural sound, and his head fell back, baring his throat, the collar on display. Riley kissed him. It wasn’t gentle. It was a claiming, a searing press of lips and tongue that tasted of salt and desperation. Paul kissed back with equal fervor, his hands coming up to clutch at Riley’s back, his short nails digging into the skin.

“Need you,” Paul gasped against his mouth, the words slurred. “Riley, please, I’m so empty.”

“I know. I’m here.” Riley kissed down his jaw, his throat, lingering over the collar, before moving lower. He took one of Paul’s nipples into his mouth, sucking hard, laving it with his tongue. Paul arched off the bed with a sharp cry, his back bowing. “So sensitive,” Riley murmured, switching to the other, tugging and suckling until Paul was sobbing, his hands fisted in Riley’s hair.

Riley settled between Paul’s thighs, which fell open willingly, desperately. The sight of Paul’s cunt, slick and flushed and glistening, made Riley’s mouth water. He lowered his head and licked a broad, slow stripe from his entrance to his clit.

Paul screamed. The sensation was too much, a direct line to the blinding need in his core. Riley didn’t tease. He ate him out with a focused, brutal efficiency, burying his face in Paul’s pussy, using his tongue to fuck into him, to circle his swollen clit. He was mapping him, learning the sounds he made, the way his thighs quivered when he hit a particular spot. Paul babbled, a stream of “yes” and “more” and “right there” and fractured, half-remembered Latin prayers that dissolved into moans.

When Riley finally rose up, his lips and chin wet, Paul was a shuddering mess. Riley positioned himself, the broad, blunted head of his cock nudging against Paul’s dripping entrance. He looked into Paul’s eyes, holding his gaze.

“This is mine,” Riley growled, voice low and possessive. “This heat. This need. This perfect, tight little pussy. All mine.”

“Yours,” Paul breathed, his eyes wide, earnest. “Always yours.”

Riley pushed in.

The stretch was immense, breathtaking. Paul’s mouth fell open in a silent cry, his body arching, accommodating the thick, relentless invasion. Riley didn’t stop, couldn’t stop, sheathing himself to the hilt in one long, smooth thrust that pressed the air from Paul’s lungs. They were joined, fully, irrevocably. Riley was so deep, Paul felt filled in a way he hadn’t known was possible, the ache transformed into a piercing, perfect fullness.

“Oh God… Riley…” Paul whimpered, his walls fluttering wildly around the massive intrusion.

“Fuck, Paul… you’re so tight,” Riley gasped, forearms trembling as he held himself still, letting them both adjust. He leaned down and captured Paul’s lips again, the kiss softer now, reverent. “So perfect for me.”

Then he began to move.

He started slow, pulling back almost all the way before sinking back in with a deep, rolling grind that made Paul see stars. Each stroke dragged against every nerve ending. Riley set a devastating pace, each thrust measured, deep, aiming for the very core of him. The room filled with the sound of skin slapping against skin, of Riley’s grunts and Paul’s high, broken cries, of the bedframe creaking a steady protest against the wall.

Paul wrapped his legs high around Riley’s waist, locking his ankles, trying to pull him in even deeper. He was mindless, a creature of pure sensation. Every thrust pushed a new sob or moan from his throat. He chanted Riley’s name like a litany.

Riley felt the coil of tension in his gut beginning to tighten, but he ignored it. He shifted, hooking Paul’s legs over his shoulders, bending him almost in half. The new angle was brutal, perfect. He drove into him harder, faster, losing the rhythm to pure, frantic need.

“Gonna come,” Riley warned, his voice a ragged scrape. “Gonna fill that pretty womb up, make it take every fucking drop.”

“Yes! Please, please, fill me up!” Paul begged, his own climax coiling, threatening to shatter him. Riley’s hand slipped between them, his thumb finding Paul’s clit and rubbing hard, quick circles.

That was all it took. Paul’s orgasm ripped through him with a violence that stole his vision. His cunt clamped down on Riley’s cock in a series of fierce, milking spasms, his back arched off the bed, a raw, screaming cry tearing from his throat.

The intense squeezing pushed Riley over the edge. With a final, deep grind, he buried himself as far as he could go and came. A hot, seemingly endless flood of cum pulsed into Paul’s depths, jet after jet, filling the desperate hollow. Riley groaned, long and low, his body shuddering through the release. He collapsed forward, careful to keep his weight on his elbows, keeping them joined.

They lay there, panting, sweaty, connected. Riley nuzzled into Paul’s neck, breathing in his scent, now mingled with sex and his own release. He could feel his cum already beginning to leak out around where they were still joined, a hot trickle against Paul’s thigh.

The heat, however, was not satisfied. It was a banked fire, waiting for more fuel.

Riley softened inside Paul, but he didn’t pull out. He shifted them gently onto their sides, spooning Paul from behind, his cock still nestled inside the warm, slick clutch of his body. He pulled the blankets over them, creating a warm, dark cave.

“It’s just starting,” Riley murmured into Paul’s hair, his arms a tight band around his waist. He kissed his shoulder. “I’m not going anywhere.”

Paul, boneless and saturated, could only make a soft, grateful sound. He reached back a hand, finding Riley’s hip, holding on. The frantic edge had been blunted, replaced by a heavy, profound drowsiness. His belly, pressed against Riley’s forearm, already felt fuller, warmer.

The cycle held them. Riley’s cock, through some inhuman persistence of his own changed biology, never fully softened. It stayed semi-hard, a constant presence inside Paul, a live wire of connection. They dozed in fits and starts. An hour later, Paul began to shift restlessly, a new wave of need building. Riley was already hard again, fully, achingly so. He simply began to move, a slow, rocking motion that built in intensity until they were fucking again, lazy and deep in the nest of blankets.

He came again, another massive, gushing release that made Paul whimper at the sheer volume of it, the hot spill deep inside him.

This was their world for three days.

They barely left the bed. Riley fetched water, protein bars, which they consumed in a daze. He carried Paul to the bathroom, fucked him gently against the sink before cleaning him and carrying him back to their nest. The pink stockings stayed on, the silk growing frayed and damp. The collar never left Paul’s throat.

Riley was obsessed. In the lulls, he would worship Paul’s body. He would lay between his legs for what felt like hours, playing with Paul’s swollen clit, kissing his inner thighs, whispering filthy, adoring things. “Look at this perfect little cock,” he’d say, before sucking it gently, making Paul jerk and cry out. He was devoted to Paul’s breasts, cupping their soft weight, sucking the nipples until they were peaked and rosy, marveling at them. “So beautiful,” he’d murmur, over and over. “All for me.”

The defining change was Paul’s stomach. By the second day, it had taken on a soft, rounded curve. It wasn’t pregnancy—it couldn’t be—but it was the unmistakable swell of being perpetually, overwhelmingly full of Riley. Of his cum, his claim, his essence. Riley would splay his big hand over the gentle dome, pressing lightly, feeling the liquid warmth within, and a possessive, feral satisfaction would roll through him.

“Look at that,” he’d growl, nipping at Paul’s ear. “Look what I did to you. You’re full of me. Plugged with my come. Can you feel it?”

Paul could. It was a heavy, warm, constant presence. A physical truth. He would look down at his own altered shape, at the collar on his neck, at Riley’s hand possessive on his belly, and he would cry. Not tears of sorrow, but of a staggering, overwhelming relief. The body that had been a site of trauma, of monstrous transformation, of guilt and shame, was now a site of unimaginable pleasure and belonging. It had finally, finally, accepted the truth his soul had known for months.

On the third afternoon, the fever broke. The desperate, clawing need subsided, leaving in its wake a profound, saturated exhaustion and a deep, humming peace.

They were facing each other. Riley was sheathed inside Paul still, moving with a tender, languid rhythm that was more about connection than climax. The frantic fucking was over. This was something else. This was love, raw and admitted in the silence.

Paul reached up, his hand trembling slightly, and cupped Riley’s jaw. His eyes, clear for the first time in days, searched Riley’s.

“I love you,” Paul whispered, the words quiet but absolute, shattering the last wall between them. “I have for so long.”

Riley stilled inside him. He closed his eyes, a muscle in his jaw ticking. When he opened them, they were bright with an emotion too vast for words. He leaned forward and kissed Paul, softly, a seal upon the confession.

“I love you, too,” he breathed against Paul’s lips. “My Paul. Mine.”

He began to move again, this final joining a slow, sweet culmination. When they came, it was together, a shared crest that was less an explosion and more a sunrise, warming them from the inside out.

After, Riley finally, carefully, slipped out. A flood of pearly release followed, staining the sheets beneath Paul, a final testament. Riley fetched a warm cloth and cleaned him with infinite tenderness, then rebuilt the nest around them with fresh blankets.

Paul, his body humming with spent pleasure and his heart so full it ached, curled into Riley’s chest. Riley’s arms came around him, holding him as if he were something priceless and fragile. The pink collar was cool against his throat. The roundness of his belly pressed against Riley’s.

Outside, the world continued. In their sunlit, messy sanctuary, there was only the sound of their breathing, syncing, and the unshakable knowledge that after everything—after the blood, the guilt, the monstrous night—they had somehow, impossibly, built this. A first and second and third chance, all wrapped in the warm, safe blanket of each other.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI