Chapter 2: Safe Shelf
The engagement party was a success, in the sense that nobody fainted and Grant Reyes dropped his champagne flute.
Poppy wore blue. Callum's hand rested at the small of her back for three hours, exactly where they had agreed it would in the car, and not once did it drift. When his cousin crossed the terrace toward them with his fiancée and his wide, expensive smile, Callum said, "Grant. I'd like you to meet my fiancée," and the flute hit the flagstones and burst like a firework.
"Your assistant," Grant said, once the catering staff had swept up the glass.
"My fiancée," Callum said. "She also happens to be the best assistant in Chicago. I'm a lucky man."
"An assistant." Grant twisted the signet ring on his little finger and looked Poppy over the way he might have looked over a used car. "How efficient of you, cousin."
Poppy smiled the smile she used on investors who thought they were funny. "He's very busy. I made it easy for him."
In the car afterward, Callum stared out at Lake Shore Drive for a full mile before he spoke. "You made it easy for me."
"Too much?"
"No." The streetlights slid across his face, silver and gone. "It was exactly enough."
They married two weeks later at the Cook County clerk's office in the Daley Center, between a couple in matching hockey jerseys and a pair of retired librarians renewing their vows for the paperwork.
That was what Poppy told herself, at least. That it was paperwork. She wore a cream wool dress with long sleeves and a high neck, because it was February and because it was not a wedding dress, and she told herself that too. Her father wore his good suit and cried from the moment they walked in. Ruth Okafor stood as Callum's witness in a navy coat and checked her watch twice, as if she were timing something.
The officiant was a tired woman with reading glasses on her head and a stack of forms. She read the words with the efficiency of someone who had read them four hundred times that month. Callum said "I do" like a man answering a question in a deposition: clearly, once, with no hesitation. Poppy said it slightly too fast.
"You may kiss the bride."
They had discussed this. Term three. Agreed in advance where possible. They had agreed on a brief kiss, closed-mouth, cheek or lips at Callum's discretion, nothing that would look rehearsed on a phone camera.
Callum took her right hand instead. He turned it over, lifted it, and pressed his mouth to the back of her fingers, just above the ring that had been his grandmother's. He held it there one second longer than a gesture needed.
Behind them her father blew his nose like a ship's horn.
"That wasn't what we agreed," Poppy said in the elevator going down.
"No." Callum watched the floor numbers. "You said agreed in advance where possible. It wasn't possible."
"Why not?"
The doors opened onto the lobby before he could answer, and Ruth swept them both out into the cold, and Poppy spent the ride to the penthouse turning the ring around and around her finger with her thumb.
Callum had expected sharing his home to feel like an invasion. He had lived alone on the top two floors of a limestone building on the Gold Coast for seven years, and in that time the only other person who had spent the night was his grandfather, twice, both times after too much brandy at the club.
He had not expected it to feel like the lights coming on in rooms he had forgotten were there.
She had taken the guest suite on the upper level, at the opposite end of the hall from his room, which was correct. She kept the door closed, which was also correct. She labeled things. By the end of the first week his pantry had a shelf marked SAFE in her neat block capitals, and every item on it had been cross-checked against a manufacturer's allergen statement she had printed and filed in a folder in the drawer by the stove.
"You already had nothing with nuts in it," she said, when he found the folder.
"Then why the folder?"
"Because now when I buy you something, I'll know."
He found her in the kitchen at two in the morning on the ninth night. He had been awake anyway, reading a merger report that refused to make sense, and he followed the smell of cardamom down the stairs like a man in a fairy tale.
She was at the island in an old bakery sweatshirt and his grandmother's ring, her bob tucked behind her ears, rolling dough with a wine bottle because he did not own a rolling pin. Flour had settled on her forearms like snow on a windowsill. Her father's battered recipe box sat open beside the sink.
"I couldn't sleep," she said, without turning around. "Your oven runs fast on the left side, by the way. You should get someone to look at it."
He realized he had never once used the oven. "I'll have it seen to."
"Sit down. These need another four minutes."
He sat. He watched her twist strips of dough into knots, brush them with something from a small bowl, and slide the tray in with the confidence of someone who had done it in her sleep, possibly literally.
"No almond paste," she said. "My mom's version uses it. I swapped it for brown butter and orange zest. Sunflower seeds on top, for the crunch. I checked the bag. Twice."
When she put the plate in front of him, the bun was still too warm to hold. He tore a piece off anyway and ate it, and for a moment he simply sat there with his eyes closed.
"Callum?" She sounded alarmed. "Is your throat—"
"I'm fine." He opened his eyes. "I haven't eaten anything from a bakery since my grandmother died. Everything has nuts in it, or might. It was easier to stop wanting it."
Poppy looked at him across the island, flour on her cheek, the dough scraper still in her hand. Then she slid the whole tray toward him.
"Well," she said. "You can want it now."
He ate three. She pretended not to count. Neither of them mentioned term four.
The Reyes Media Foundation Gala was held every year in the Harrow Conservatory, a Victorian glasshouse on the North Side where palm fronds brushed the iron ribs of the roof and the air smelled like wet earth and money. Six hundred guests. A string quartet hidden behind a wall of orchids. Every board member, every major advertiser, and at least four journalists who would have sold their grandmothers for a photo of Callum Reyes's new wife doing something interesting.
Poppy did not intend to be interesting. She wore a long-sleeved column dress in dark green velvet, laughed at the right moments, and answered every question about the proposal with the same story, which was true in every detail that mattered: he had asked her in his office, early in the morning, over coffee.
"How romantic," said the wife of the chief financial officer, sounding doubtful.
"He signed something," Poppy said. "For Callum, that's practically a sonnet."
Dinner was served at round tables under strings of tiny lights. They were seated with Grant, his fiancée, and two board members whose votes Callum needed. The first course arrived on white plates: burrata, roasted tomatoes, and a bright green swirl of sauce.
Poppy looked at the sauce. She leaned slightly toward Callum's plate, as if to admire it, and caught the scent. Basil, garlic, parmesan. And under it, faint and buttery, the thing she had been reading menus for four years to catch.
She did not hesitate. She laid her hand on his wrist, smiled at the table, and said, "Darling, you took mine. I asked for the one without dressing," and swapped their plates in one smooth motion. Then she raised her hand for a server, murmured a word in his ear, and a fresh plate arrived without the green swirl ninety seconds later.
The board members noticed nothing. Grant's fiancée noticed nothing.
Callum noticed. He set down his fork and looked at her with an expression she had never seen on his face in four years of seeing his face every working day. It was not gratitude, exactly. It was the look of a man who has just realized the floor he's standing on was built by hand.
"Pine nuts," she said quietly. "In the pesto. The kitchen swore the gala menu was nut-free. I called them on Tuesday."
"You called them on Tuesday," he repeated.
"And on Thursday. Eat your burrata."
Later, the quartet played something slow, and Callum held out his hand without consulting term three. She took it. He danced the way he did everything, with complete attention and no wasted motion, his palm warm and steady between her shoulder blades.
"How long," he said into her hair, low enough that no one else could hear, "have you been reading menus for me?"
"Since the Waverly fundraiser."
"That was four years ago. That was your second week."
"You turned grey at the table and walked out like nothing was wrong, and I found you in the coat check stabbing yourself in the leg with an auto-injector." Her voice came out steadier than she felt. "I decided it wasn't going to happen again on my watch."
He didn't say anything. His hand pressed, very slightly, into her back.
Grant cut in for the next song. He danced well and talked worse.
"I've been wondering," he said pleasantly, turning her under the glass roof, "what someone like you costs. Ballpark. For my own planning."
Poppy kept her smile on through sheer muscle memory. Over Grant's shoulder she saw Callum standing at the edge of the dance floor, very still, the way the lake goes still before it freezes.
"More than you have," she said, and stepped out of his arms at the end of the bar, and walked back to her husband.
Her phone rang the next morning at seven, while she was in the back seat of Callum's car on the way to the office and he was beside her pretending to read the business section while actually watching her eat a sunflower-seed bun.
Unknown number. She answered it anyway; assistants always answered.
"Ms. Lane? Or is it Mrs. Reyes now?" A man's voice, bright and fast and pleased with itself. "Dev Mahajan, Chicago Ledger. I'm standing outside Butter & Lane in Logan Square. Can you comment on the foreclosure notice that was taped to its back door until last month?"
The bun turned to sand in her mouth.
"Or," the reporter went on, "on the fact that the full balance was wired in from an account belonging to your husband the morning of your wedding?"