Cover of The Choice: Whipped to Death

The Choice: Whipped to Death

Read the story

4 chapters · 0 words · Read 0 times

I’m at my sentencing hearing where I’ve been found guilty of murder. The judge is leaving the sentence of punishment up to me based on two choices - either death by hanging or death by whipping. Either punishment will be carried out in the public square by Silas, a brute of a man. His arms are as thick as tree trunks, tattooed. His thick black mustache and beard make him look dangerous. I’m afraid of my sentence but given its my last - I choose whipping with the hope that Silas will fuck me during the punishment before he lays on the last of the lashes that finish me.

Chapter 1: Introduction

The courtroom was a cathedral of justice, a place where the echoes of fate reverberated off the cold, unyielding walls. The air hung heavy with the scent of old parchment and the whispered secrets of the law. The wooden benches bore the weight of countless souls who had stood where Jim now did, their hearts pounding in their chests as they awaited judgment.

Jim Vance, a young man with fiery red hair and eyes that burned like emeralds, stood before the bench, his gaze locked onto the stern face of Judge Thornton.

The judge's silver hair was swept back, his expression as hard and unyielding as the gavel that rested beside him. His eyes, a cool blue, held a hint of curiosity amidst the cold judgment.

The courtroom was eerily silent, save for the occasional rustle of papers as the clerk shuffled through the docket. The gallery was filled with anonymous faces, their whispers muted by the heavy atmosphere. Jim's defiance was palpable, a spark in his eyes that refused to be snuffed out by the grim proceedings.

Judge Thornton looked down at Jim, his voice a measured, authoritative baritone.

"Jim Vance, you have been found guilty of the crime of murder in the first degree. The court must now decide the manner of your execution. You have two choices: death by hanging, or death by whipping. Which will it be?"

Jim's eyes flicked up to the stern portraits of past judges, then back to the judge. He knew what the judge expected, the easy, straightforward choice. But Jim wasn't feeling straightforward. He felt a strange mix of fear, desperation, and a curiosity that was almost thrilling. He glanced at the courtroom artist, a stern woman with a notepad, capturing the scene.

His eyes then moved to the guard standing by the door, a burly man with a thick mustache, eyes boring into him. Jim's heart pounded in his chest, his palms sweating. He felt an inexplicable pull, a raw desire he couldn't deny. He licked his lips, his voice steady as he met the judge's gaze.

"Whipping," he said, his voice barely above a whisper, yet it echoed through the chamber, silence following his choice like a ripple effect. The judge's eyebrows shot up, a flicker of surprise in his eyes. Jim held his gaze, refusing to look away.

A faint smirk tugged at the corners of his mouth. "Whipping," he repeated, his voice steadier this time.

Judge Thornton's eyes narrowed, and he leaned forward, his voice low and stern. "Are you aware of what you're asking for, Mr. Vance?"

Jim smirked, his eyes gleaming with a mix of defiance and raw desire. "I am, Your Honor. I'm asking for something... different, to set an example for others.”

The judge sat back, his expression inscrutable. "Very well. Your execution will be carried out by Silas Blackwood - he will strip you naked and bullwhip you 500 lashes or death, whichever comes first!” Jim shuddered at the thought, a strange mix of terror and excitement coursing through his veins. Silas Blackwood was a legendary figure in these parts, a man who was as feared as he was respected.

“I understand, Your Honor,” Jim said, his voice barely above a whisper.

The judge banged his gavel, the sound echoing through the courtroom. “Court is adjourned. Mr. Vance, you will be transferred to the executioner immediately.”

The guards moved swiftly, their heavy boots echoing on the cold floor as they approached Jim. He was handcuffed and led away, his heart pounding in his chest.

The guards were rough, their hands gripping his arms tightly as they marched him through the courthouse. He could feel their eyes on him, judging, condemning. But there was something else in their gazes too, a spark of interest, of curiosity.

They led him down a narrow, dank corridor, the air heavy with the scent of sweat and fear. The sound of his boots echoed off the stone walls, his breath coming in quick, shallow gasps. He knew what was coming, what he had asked for. But the fear and the excitement were a potent mix, coursing through his veins like a drug.

“Sir, before I’m whipped, I’d like to request a last wish,” Jim asked. “I’d like to be paddled on my bare ass in the public square. You may determine the number of seats I should receive, but I’m recommending 109 - one for each crime I’ve committed.” Jim smirked, his green eyes gleaming with defiance. The guards exchanged glances, their grips tightening on his arms.

Judge Thornton’s expression darkened, his voice a low growl. “You think this is a game, boy? You’re about to be stripped bare and flogged within an inch of your life. Do you really want to add public humiliation to your sentence?”

Jim’s smirk didn’t waver. “I do, Your Honor. I want the whole town to see what happens to men like me.”

The judge’s jaw tightened, but after a long moment, he nodded. “Very well. You’ll receive your paddling in the square before the whipping.

“And to be clear, Silas,” paddle this fucker hard until his ass is purple!” The judge commanded Silas. “And let’s teach him a real lesson - he’s asked for 109 swats. His crimes are much more than that, though. Paddle him 500 swats!” Judge Thornton’s voice boomed through the courtroom, his cold blue eyes locked onto Jim’s defiant gaze. The words hung in the air like a curse, heavy and unyielding. The guards tightened their grip on Jim’s arms, their fingers digging into his flesh as they dragged him toward the door. His heart hammered against his ribs, a wild, reckless rhythm that matched the fire in his veins.

The corridor was dim, the flickering torchlight casting long, jagged shadows on the stone walls. The air smelled of damp stone and something sharper—fear, sweat, the metallic tang of anticipation.

The guards dragged Jim through the narrow corridor, their boots scuffing against the uneven floor. His wrists burned where the cuffs bit into his skin, but he didn’t flinch. Instead, his mind raced, replaying the judge’s words like a taunt.

*You asked for this.*

A door creaked open ahead, revealing a dimly lit chamber. The walls were bare, save for a single iron ring bolted into the stone. A wooden bench sat in the center, its surface worn smooth by time and use. The air was thick with the scent of leather and something muskier—something that made Jim’s pulse quicken.

Silas Blackwood stood waiting.

A mountain of a man, his broad shoulders barely contained by the rough linen of his shirt, his arms corded with muscle beneath the rolled sleeves. His face was a mask of indifference, but his dark eyes burned with something darker—something that made Jim’s stomach twist. The executioner’s reputation preceded him. They said he was a man who took pleasure in his work, that he could make a man scream for mercy before the first lash even landed.

The guards shoved Jim forward, and he stumbled, his bare feet slapping against the cold stone. His wrists were still bound, the metal cuffs biting into his skin. The room was small, claustrophobic, the air thick with the scent of sweat and leather.

The wooden bench in the center of the room was worn smooth from years of use, its surface stained dark in places. The flickering torchlight cast long, jagged shadows across the stone walls, making the room feel even more oppressive.

Silas Blackwood stood in the center of the room, his massive frame barely contained by the rough linen of his shirt. His arms were crossed over his chest, his dark eyes locked onto Jim with an intensity that made the younger man’s pulse quicken. The executioner’s reputation preceded him—he was a man who took pleasure in his work, a man who could make a man scream for mercy before the first lash even landed.

And now, Jim was about to find out if the rumors were true.

Silas Blackwood stepped forward, his boots thudding against the stone floor. His voice was a low growl, rough as gravel. "You're a brave one, aren't you, boy?"

Jim swallowed hard, his throat dry. "I didn't ask for mercy."

Silas smirked, his dark eyes flicking over Jim’s body with a slow, deliberate hunger. "No, you didn’t." He reached out, his thick fingers brushing against Jim’s jaw, forcing his head up. "But you will."

The guards stepped back, their presence forgotten as Silas’ dominance filled the room.

His fingers dug into Jim’s jaw, tilting his head up, forcing him to meet those dark, unreadable eyes. The executioner’s breath was hot against his skin, smelling of whiskey and something darker—something primal.

"You think you can handle this, boy?" Silas growled, his voice rough like gravel underfoot. "You think you’re tough enough to take what I’m about to give you?"

Jim’s pulse hammered in his throat, his cock twitching against the rough fabric of his prison pants. He should have been terrified. He *was* terrified. But beneath the fear, there was something else—something hot and insistent, something that made his mouth dry and his skin burn.

He licked his lips, his green eyes locked onto Silas’ dark, unyielding gaze. "I can handle it," Jim said, his voice rough with defiance. "I asked for this, didn’t I?"

Silas’ smirk deepened, his fingers tightening on Jim’s jaw before dragging down his throat, tracing the line of his collarbone. "You asked for a whipping," he corrected, his voice a low, dangerous purr. "But first, you asked for a paddling. And I don’t do things halfway, boy. You’re gonna learn that real quick."

The guards had already left, the door clicking shut behind them, leaving Jim alone with the executioner.

The air between them was thick with tension, the kind that made Jim’s skin prickle with anticipation. Silas Blackwood loomed over him, his massive frame casting a shadow that seemed to swallow the dim torchlight. His dark eyes burned with something primal, something that made Jim’s stomach twist in a way that wasn’t entirely fear.

Silas’ fingers tightened around Jim’s jaw, his thumb pressing into the soft flesh beneath his chin. "You’re a brave little bastard, aren’t you?" he growled, his voice rough like gravel. "Asking for this. Begging for it, even."

Jim swallowed hard, his throat working against the pressure of Silas’ grip.

The executioner’s fingers were rough, calloused from years of wielding the whip, and they dug into his skin with a possessive force that sent a shiver down his spine. The air between them was thick with the scent of sweat and leather, the flickering torchlight casting long, sinuous shadows that seemed to writhe along the stone walls.

"You think you can take it?" Silas repeated, his voice a low, dangerous growl. His dark eyes bored into Jim’s, searching for any hint of hesitation, any flicker of doubt. But Jim refused to look away. He refused to show fear.

Silas walked across the room and opened a large metal chest. He pulled out the paddle - the word Justice inscribed on one side and No Mercy on the other.

Its surface was worn smooth from years of use, the wood dark with age and the stains of countless punishments. The sight of it made Jim’s stomach clench, his cock twitching against the rough fabric of his prison pants.

Silas turned back to him, his dark eyes gleaming with something primal. "You asked for 500 swats, boy," he said, his voice rough as gravel. "But I don’t think you understand what that means. I don’t think you understand what I’m going to do to you." "I understand," he said, his voice barely above a whisper.

"I asked for this."

Silas smirked, his dark eyes flickering with something dangerous. "Oh, you don’t understand yet," he said, stepping closer, his boots thudding against the stone floor.

The executioner’s fingers traced the line of Jim’s jaw, rough and calloused, sending a shiver down his spine. He could feel the heat radiating off Silas’ body, the musk of sweat and leather clinging to him like a second skin.

“Pull your pants and underwear down and bend over the bench,” Silas commanded.

“You’re about to learn what real punishment feels like.”

Jim swallowed hard, his fingers trembling as he fumbled with the rough fabric of his prison-issued pants. The cold air of the chamber bit at his bare skin as he stripped, his cock already half-hard, betraying his body’s traitorous response to the situation. He stepped out of the fabric, kicking it aside, then turned to face the wooden bench.

Silas watched him with dark, hungry eyes, his massive frame barely contained by the tight leather of his executioner’s uniform. The paddle in his hand was a thick, heavy thing, its surface worn smooth by years of use, the wood dark with age and the stains of countless punishments.

“You see this paddle has two sides,” Silas snickered. “The justice side is smooth but hard made from the toughest wood. The No Mercy side, however, is rough and texture - made purposely for gripping and tearing skin.”

Jim’ s anticipation and dread was growing. He wanted Silas to beat him - dominating him.

“Guess which side I’m going to use on you,” Silas said

with a dark chuckle. “You’re about to find out, boy.”

Jim’s breath hitched as he bent over the bench, his bare ass exposed to the cold air of the chamber. The wood was rough beneath his palms, the grain biting into his skin as he braced himself. His cock was already hard, thick and throbbing between his thighs, betraying his body’s traitorous response to the situation. He could feel the weight of Silas’ gaze on him, hot and heavy, like a physical touch.

The executioner stepped closer, his boots thudding against the stone floor. Jim could smell him now—sweat and leather and something darker, something that made his pulse quicken.

The executioner’s breath was hot against the back of his neck, his massive frame looming over him like a storm about to break.

"Last chance to back out, boy," Silas growled, his voice rough as gravel. "Once I start, I don’t stop. Not until you’re screaming, not until you’re begging, not until your ass is raw and bleeding."

Jim clenched his jaw, his fingers digging into the rough wood of the bench. "I’m not backing out," he spat, his voice trembling just enough to betray the fear coiled tight in his gut. "Do it. Paddle me with the No Mercy side, sir”

Silas chuckled, low and dark, the sound vibrating through Jim’s bones.

"You’re eager, aren’t you, boy? Eager to feel the sting of my paddle on your pretty little ass."

Jim’s breath hitched. "I asked for it, didn’t I?"

Silas’ hand came down hard on Jim’s bare ass, the smack echoing through the chamber. The impact sent a jolt of pain through Jim’s body, his cock twitching against the rough wood of the bench. "That’s just a taste," Silas growled. "Now let’s see how you handle the real thing."

The executioner stepped back, the paddle held loosely in his massive hand.

The flickering torchlight caught the rough, textured surface of the *No Mercy* side, the grain of the wood dark with age and the stains of countless punishments. Jim’s breath came in short, ragged gasps, his fingers digging into the rough wood of the bench as he braced himself.

Silas’ dark eyes gleamed with something primal, something that made Jim’s stomach twist in a way that wasn’t entirely fear. The executioner’s voice was a low, dangerous growl as he spoke. "You want this, boy? You want to feel the sting of my paddle on your bare ass?" Silas growled, his voice rough as gravel. "You want to know what it's like to be broken in by a real man?" "I asked for it," he said, his voice barely above a whisper. "You asked for a paddling," he corrected, his voice a low, dangerous purr.

The executioner stepped closer, his massive frame looming over Jim, his breath hot against the back of his neck.

“Alright then - let’s get started. For your crimes, and by order of the court, Jim Vance, it will be my great pleasure to paddle you 500 swats,” Silas announced!

“And I’m going to make sure you feel every single one of them.”

Jim’s breath hitched, his fingers tightening around the rough edge of the bench. His ass was already burning from the initial slap, the skin flushed red and sensitive.

The executioner’s fingers traced the line of Jim’s spine, rough and calloused, sending a shiver down his spine. “You’re a brave little bastard, aren’t you?” Silas growled, his voice rough as gravel. “Asking for this. Begging for it, even.”

Jim swallowed hard, his throat working against the pressure of Silas’ grip.

Silas stepped back, his dark eyes burning with something primal. "You want this, boy?" he growled, his voice rough as gravel. "You want to feel the sting of my paddle on your bare ass?"

Then without warning, Silas raised the paddle and brought it down squarely on Jim’s ass - the sound of the crack hitting flesh echoed in the room.

The pain was instant and searing, spreading like wildfire across his skin. Jim gasped, his fingers digging into the bench, his body jerking forward from the impact. The rough texture of the *No Mercy* side had torn into his flesh, leaving behind a burning, stinging sensation that made his cock twitch against the wood.

Silas didn’t pause. He raised the paddle again, and this time, he brought it down harder, the crack of wood against skin louder, more brutal. Jim’s breath left his lungs in a sharp hiss, his body tensing as the pain radiated through him. His ass was already turning a deep, angry red, the skin hot and swollen beneath the executioner’s relentless assault.

Each strike of the paddle sent a fresh wave of pain crashing through him, his breath coming in ragged, desperate gasps. The rough texture of the *No Mercy* side tore into his flesh, leaving behind welts that throbbed with a dull, insistent ache.

Silas didn’t slow down. He was a machine, his massive arms flexing with every brutal swing, the paddle landing with a sickening *thwack* against Jim’s bare ass. The sound echoed through the chamber, mingling with Jim’s sharp, gasping breaths.

"Fuck—!" Jim hissed, his fingers clawing at the bench, his cock throbbing painfully between his thighs.

The paddle landed again, harder this time, the rough wood tearing into his already raw flesh. He could feel the heat radiating from his ass, the skin hot and swollen beneath the relentless assault. he gasped, his body jerking forward, his cock twitching against the rough wood of the bench. The pain was intense, a searing, burning sensation that spread like wildfire across his skin. But beneath the pain, there was something else—a dark, twisted pleasure that made his cock throb with need.

Silas chuckled, low and dark, the sound vibrating through Jim’s bones. "You like that, don’t you, boy?"

“We’re only at 50 - I’m going to give you something that will really make you hard you little fucker!”

Silas, determined to make Jim scream and squirm, picked up the speed and intensity he delivered with each swat.

The paddle came down again and again, the rough, textured side of the wood tearing into Jim’s already raw ass with brutal efficiency. The sound of flesh meeting wood filled the chamber, a rhythmic, brutal symphony of punishment.

Jim’s breath came in ragged gasps, his fingers clawing at the bench as he fought to stay in place.

Silas leaned down, his breath hot against Jim’s ear.

Read on DreamPress