Cover of The Curious Case of Hillary and Dana

The Curious Case of Hillary and Dana

Read the story

2 chapters · 4918 words · Read 1 times

Hillary and Dana are a lesbian couple who are both bisexual. After hearing that Bryan has a huge cock from Shay, they decide to trick or convince them into showing it to them. Astounded by the size of it, they take turns playing with it, measuring it, and attempting to deep-throat it unsuccessfully.

Chapter 2: Dana's tongue darts out to catch the slick mixture of Hillary's juices and Bryan's precum dripping from their pounding connection. The taste makes her moan as she redoubles her efforts, sucking Hillary's clit while fingering herself frantically.

The brutal, slapping rhythm of Bryan’s hips against Hillary’s ass filled the kitchen, a raw counterpoint to her choked gasps. Dana’s tongue was a wet, relentless pressure beneath them, lapping at where they joined, tasting Hillary’s arousal mixed with the sheer stretch of his penetration. A high, sharp whine built in Hillary’s throat, tightening into a fractured scream as her orgasm detonated, a violent seizure of muscle that clamped viselike around the massive invader. “FUCK! IT HURTS! DON’T STOP!” she shrieked, her body a taut bow of agony and ecstasy, her nails scraping grooves into the laminate.

He felt her cinching down on him, a torturous, perfect friction, and Dana’s hand tightened possessively around his balls, tugging in time with his thrusts. He grunted, a low animal sound, and drove into her convulsing heat even harder, each plunge sending her into a new, wordless shriek. The pressure in his groin coalesced, a hot stone of inevitability, and with a final, jaw-clenched roar, he erupted deep inside her, pulse after thick pulse flooding her depths. He pulled out slowly, his spent cock glistening with their combined fluids. Dana immediately attacked it with her mouth, sucking the length clean with noisy, worshipful swallows.

“My turn,” Hillary panted, pushing herself upright on trembling legs. She turned, hoisted herself onto the counter’s edge, and spread her glistening thighs wide. “Lick me clean. Every drop.” Dana didn’t hesitate, burying her face between Hillary’s legs, her tongue delving deep to reclaim the hot, salty spill of Bryan’s cum from inside her. Hillary watched, a faint, possessive smile on her flushed face. She then laced her blood slick into Dana and pulled

her from mid-suck. A thick string of saliva and cum snapped between Dana’s lips and Bryan’s softening shaft.

“Come up here,” Hillary murmured, her voice ragged but commanding. Dana rose, her face glistening, and Hillary claimed her mouth in a deep, tasting kiss, sharing the proof of what she’d just cleaned.

A low, appreciative growl from Bryan pulled their attention. He was hard again, impossibly quick, his heavy cock already flushed and rigid from watching them. His grey eyes, dark with predatory focus, fixed on Dana. “Hands on the counter,” he ordered, his voice a rough scrape.

Before Dana could fully obey, he closed the distance. He bunched the velvet of her short black skirt in his fist, yanking the fabric up around her waist. His other hand hooked into the lace of her panties, tearing them down her thick thighs with a quick, impatient jerk.

She gasped, exposed, and he guided the massive, slick head of his cock to her entrance. She was already wet from watching, from tasting them, but her body was different—a tighter, more resistant channel than Hillary’s. He pushed, and her breath hitched, a sharp, pained sound escaping as he forced the first brutal inch past her clinging rim.

“Fuck, she’s so tight,” Bryan grunted, the sensation white-hot, and he pushed deeper, feeling her virginal muscles clench in a fierce, hot vice around him.

“Harder,” Hillary commanded from her perch, her green eyes flashing. “Slap her ass, Bryan. Make her take it.”

He needed no further encouragement. His palm cracked against the full, pale curve of Dana’s ass, a sharp, stinging slap that left a red handprint blooming on her skin. She cried out, her body jolting forward, and he used the motion to drive himself to the hilt in one relentless, stretching plunge, burying every impossible inch inside her gasping, clenching heat.

The red recording light from Shay’s camcorder burned a steady, unblinking dot in the dim room, capturing everything.

Bryan’s hips pistoned back and slammed home again, each brutal thrust punching a wet, choked sound from Dana’s throat. “Oh god, oh fuck, it’s so deep,” she whimpered, her fingers scrambling for purchase on the smooth countertop as he split her open, her body yielding to the monstrous thickness.

“Listen to that,” Hillary sneered from her perch, her voice dripping with malicious delight. “You love this, you pain slut. You love getting wrecked by a real cock.” She leaned forward, her fingers finding Dana’s swollen, neglected nipples. She pinched one hard, twisting the sensitive bud between her sharp nails.

A ragged scream tore from Dana, her back arching violently as pain and overwhelming pleasure collided. Her internal muscles clenched in a sudden, vice-like spasm around Bryan’s driving length, and her eyes rolled back, showing white. A guttural, sobbing moan broke from her as her orgasm ravaged her, her body shaking uncontrollably against him.

“Stop,” Hillary commanded, her voice cutting through Dana’s cries. Bryan froze, buried to the hilt, a low, frustrated growl rumbling in his chest. The denial was a physical ache; he needed to finish. “Pay up, Dana. You lost the bet. You couldn’t take it all down your throat.” Hillary’s smile was venomous. “Now he’s going to take your ass instead. Get on the floor. On your back.”

Dana slid bonelessly from the counter, her knees hitting the cold laminate with a soft thud. She obeyed, lowering herself onto her back, her ripped lace panties still tangled around one ankle like a surrendered flag. Her chest heaved, the red handprint on her ass a stark contrast to her pale skin.

“Legs up. Open.” Hillary’s voice wasn’t a request.

Dana hooked her hands behind her knees, pulling them toward her shoulders, exposing herself completely to the room’s humid air and the camcorder’s unwavering eye. The position was profoundly vulnerable, her tight, untouched hole clenching instinctively at the exposure. Bryan loomed over her, his cock gleaming with her own slickness from moments before, looking impossibly thicker under the harsh kitchen light.

“No lube,” Hillary said, her green eyes glittering. “Just spit. You made the mess, you clean it up.” She nudged Dana’s head with her foot. “Do it.”

Dana craned her neck forward, her tongue extending to wet the swollen, brutal head of his cock. She coated it in a pathetic, thin layer of saliva, her own taste bitter on her tongue. It was a futile gesture against his monstrous girth. Bryan positioned himself, the broad, insistent crown pressing against her clenching resistance.

“Now,” Hillary whispered.

He pushed, a steady, inhuman pressure. Dana’s breath seized in her throat as the ring of muscle burned, stretched, then tore with a sharp, internal rip. A silent scream contorted her face as he sank an inch into the blinding, seizing heat. Bryan grunted, his jaw a granite line, and pushed deeper, feeling her body fight and fail to accommodate him. Her hands scrambled against his thighs, not to push him away, but to hold on as he filled a space never meant to be filled.

Her body gave, a soft internal tear yielding to the relentless pressure as he sank another brutal inch into the blinding heat. "Fuck, she's tight," Bryan grunted through clenched teeth, his sweat dripping onto her trembling stomach. Dana's cry was a raw, shattered thing, her back arching off the floor as the pain mutated, transforming into a shocking, full-bodied electrification that short-circuited her nerves.

"Look at her face," Hillary murmured, crouching beside them, her voice a husky whisper of fascination. Dana's eyes were wide, unseeing, her mouth a perfect 'O' of stunned revelation as her body learned this new, punishing geography. "You feel that, baby? Every fucking inch."

Bryan pulled back, the drag an exquisite agony, and Dana's hands flew to his hips, her nails biting into his skin. "No, don't—" she begged, the contradiction visceral. He drove back in, harder, burying himself fully now, the dense nest of his pubic bone grinding against her ravaged entrance. A guttural, approving sound rattled in his chest as he began a relentless, punishing rhythm, each thrust carving a deeper channel into her clenching, surrendering heat.

Shay’s camera zoomed in on the obscene, glistening join, the red light reflecting in the sheen of sweat and fluid. "The internal sphincter is giving way," she narrated softly, clinically. "Watch the abdominal distention with each deep thrust."

"Come on, soldier," Hillary taunted, her fingers tangling in Dana's black hair, yanking her head back. "She can take more. HE FORCES IT DEEPER." Planting his hands on the floor by her shoulders for leverage, Bryan shoved downward with his full weight, angling his hips to drive himself into a previously unreached depth. A silent, breathless scream locked in Dana's throat as her eyes rolled back, her body accepting the ultimate violation, her consciousness fraying into pure, white sensation.

The silent scream shattered, exploding from her lungs in a raw, deafening wail that scratched her throat. “FUCK! IT’S TEARING ME APART!” she shrieked, her voice fracturing as he ground deeper, the burning stretch a live wire in her core.

Hillary’s laugh was a dark, thrilled sound. “Yes, it is! Scream for it, you filthy whore.” Bryan’s rhythm became mechanical, a brutal in-and-out that punched the air from Dana’s lungs, transforming her cries into choked, rhythmic gasps.

Her hands, which had been clawing at his thighs, now spasmed and fell open, palms up, a surrender. The pain didn’t recede, but it blossomed into something else, a deep, fulminating fullness that started to spark. “Oh god… oh fuck…” she sobbed, the words mangled. “I can feel it in my stomach.”

Shay’s camera zoomed closer, the lens fogging slightly from the heat. “Incredible. Look at that anatomical displacement with each thrust.” Bryan’s grunts were sharp, feral punches of air.

He leaned down, his sweat dripping onto her collarbone. “You take it so good,” he growled, the praise dark and gruff, before sinking his teeth into the tender flesh of her shoulder. The sharp pain was a bright counterpoint to the deep, throbbing wreckage below, and her body convulsed in a shockwave of sensation.

“Don’t you dare come yet,” Hillary commanded, slapping Dana’s inner thigh hard. “You don’t get to until he’s finished filling that ass.” The sting focused her, the layers of sensation—burning, bruising, piercing, stretching—coalescing into a terrifying peak. Her screams melted into a continuous, wordless keen, a sound of utter ruination that was also, unmistakably, one of absolute, shattered pleasure.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI