Cover of The Dare That Broke the Silence

The Dare That Broke the Silence

Read the story

2 chapters · 3347 words · Read 0 times

Ender is 23 years old and has long curly purplish white hair and pale skin covered in freckles and scars, he's normally very shy, and hides his sounds of pleasure from his boyfriends which they're okay with because it's been their entire relationship, Ender's boyfriends Gene and Zenix were both older, and Gene had short black hair, dark blue eyes and pale skin while Zenix had shaggy black hair, deep hazel eyes and pale skin, and both are very dominating and possessive men who love Ender completely. Ender took a dare from Zenix early in the morning that he couldn't hide his moans and cries if he and Gene managed to Ender needy enough to come to them for sex first and Ender agreeing thinking they'll forget about it, but later that night Ender finally got needy enough to come for them for sex first, and the moment he tried to hide a quiet whimper Gene pinned his hands, grinned and said "Remember the dare?" And almost immediately after Gene spoke Zenix's hands began greedily exploring Ender's body while Gene sucked and bit marks into his throat and upper chest, both men relishing on the moans, gasps and cries coming from their shy boyfriend

Chapter 1: The Dare Before Dawn

The sun cut through the half-open blinds in long golden bars, striping the butcher-block island where Ender's coffee cup sat abandoned, its contents gone lukewarm an hour ago. Steam no longer curled from the rim. The kitchen smelled like burnt toast and the spiced tea Gene had steeped at dawn, and underneath that, something else—the musky tang of sweat and sex that clung to the walls like a secret the house refused to keep.

Ender stood at the counter, barefoot, wearing only a pair of Gene's old sweats that pooled around his ankles. His hair—all those ridiculous purple-white curls—hung in his face as he reached for a piece of cold toast.

"Leaving that there?"

Gene's voice came from the doorway. Low. Amused. Ender didn't turn around.

"It's just a cup."

"It's been there since seven." Gene crossed the kitchen, his footsteps deliberate on the tile. He picked up the mug, sniffed it, wrinkled his nose. "Cold."

"I'll wash it."

"You'll wash it." Gene set the cup down with a soft clink. "That's what you said about the pan from Tuesday. The pan is still in the sink."

Ender bit into the toast. It was stale and he didn't care. "The pan has character now."

Gene laughed—that quiet, rumbling thing that lived in his chest—and reached past Ender to grab an apple from the bowl. His arm brushed Ender's hip, casual, but Ender felt it everywhere. That was the problem lately. Everything Gene did felt like it happened directly to Ender's nervous system. A hand on his shoulder. A knee against his under the table. The way Gene looked at him sometimes, dark blue eyes half-lidded, like he was cataloging every place Ender was trying not to react.

Four months they'd been doing this. All three of them. And in four months, Ender had never once—not once—let them hear him.

It wasn't a decision he'd made, exactly. It was more like a reflex. The first time Gene had pressed him into the mattress, Ender had caught the sound in his throat before it could escape, swallowed it down like something shameful. He'd bitten his lip until it bruised. Held his breath until his chest burned. Gene had paused, frowned, asked if he was okay. Ender had nodded. Said he was fine. And Gene, because he was Gene, had let it go.

But Zenix had noticed. Zenix always noticed.

The front door banged open. Ender heard keys hit the hook, shoes hit the floor, and then Zenix was in the kitchen, all sharp angles and sharper grins, still wearing his jacket from wherever he'd been.

"Morning, loves." Zenix kissed Gene on the cheek, then Ender on the forehead. He smelled like cold air and cigarettes. "What'd I miss?"

"Ender's cup is still on the counter," Gene said.

"My cup is commemorating its third hour of being ignored."

Zenix snorted. He pulled himself up onto the island, legs swinging, and grabbed the toast out of Ender's hand. Took a bite. Made a face.

"This is terrible."

"It's character-building."

"It's cardboard."

"Same thing."

Zenix tossed the toast back at him. Ender caught it one-handed, which felt like a small victory until Zenix leaned down, way down, until his mouth was right against Ender's ear. His breath was warm. His voice was soft.

"You know what I've been thinking about?"

Ender's stomach did something complicated. "What."

"This thing you do. Where you don't make a sound." Zenix's lips brushed the shell of Ender's ear, featherlight. "Gene and I were talking about it last night. After you fell asleep."

The room tilted. Ender kept his eyes fixed on the toast in his hand. "You were talking about me while I was sleeping?"

"Among other things." Zenix pulled back just enough to meet Ender's eyes. There was a dare in them, bright and dangerous. "I bet you couldn't stay quiet if we made you desperate enough. I bet you'd break."

Ender's heart stuttered. "I wouldn't."

"You would."

"I wouldn't."

"Prove it." Zenix's grin sharpened. "Next time we're all home together—whenever you decide you want us—you have to come to us first. You have to walk through that door and ask. And if you're needy enough by then, you won't be able to help yourself. You'll make noise. You'll beg."

Gene had gone very still by the sink. Ender could feel his eyes on them both, that patient, appraising stare. When Ender glanced over, Gene raised an eyebrow. Not a question. A challenge of his own.

Ender's mouth was dry. He should've said no. He should've laughed it off, called them both ridiculous, gone back to his cold toast and his quiet morning. Instead, he shrugged.

"Fine," he said. "Whatever."

Zenix's eyebrows shot up. "Whatever?"

"Whatever. You'll forget by tomorrow anyway."

Zenix and Gene exchanged a look. Ender pretended not to see it. He took a bite of the toast—charcoal and dust—and chewed slowly, like a man who hadn't just agreed to something he couldn't possibly win.

That was nine hours ago.

Now, the hallway was dark. The bedroom door was closed, a thin strip of amber light bleeding from underneath. Ender stood there, barefoot on the hardwood, his pulse hammering somewhere in his throat. His skin felt too tight. His whole body hummed with a heat that had been building all day—slow at first, then all at once.

He'd been fine this morning. Fine at noon. Fine while he was doing laundry, folding Gene's shirts, reorganizing the bookshelf. But then the afternoon had dragged on, and with it came the thoughts. Zenix's mouth against his ear. Gene's hands on his hips. The way they looked at him—hungry, patient, relentless. He'd spent an hour sprawled on the couch, pretending to read, while his mind ran the same three images on a loop until his thighs were pressed together and his breath came shallow.

And now.

Now he was standing outside their bedroom, because that was the rule. He had to come to them first.

His hand hovered over the doorknob. He could turn back. He could go to his own room, take care of it himself, pretend this never happened. Zenix would tease him tomorrow. Gene would smile that slow, knowing smile. And Ender would die of embarrassment, but at least he'd have his dignity.

Except.

Except his dignity was a small, cold thing compared to the ache low in his belly. He wanted them. He wanted them so badly his hands were shaking.

He opened the door.

Gene was on the bed, propped against the headboard, a book open on his lap. He wasn't reading it. His eyes tracked Ender's bare feet, his too-big sweats, his ridiculous curls. Then his mouth curved, just a little.

"Well," Gene said. "Look who finally showed up."

Ender's voice came out thin. "You said to come to you."

"I did."

Zenix appeared in the bathroom doorway, toothbrush in hand, shirtless. His chest was a map of dark moles and faint scars, and Ender wanted to trace every one. Zenix spat, rinsed, and grinned at Ender in the mirror's reflection.

"What'd I tell you?" he said. "Three days, tops."

"It's been nine hours," Ender said.

"Close enough."

Gene set his book aside. He patted the mattress. "Come here."

Ender's feet moved before his brain caught up. He crossed the room, climbed onto the bed, let Gene pull him into the space between his legs. Gene's chest was warm against his back. Gene's arms wrapped around his waist, loose but absolute.

"Remember the dare?" Gene murmured against his ear.

Ender's throat was dry. "I didn't forget."

"I know." Gene's lips touched his jaw, soft. "That's why you're here."

Zenix climbed onto the bed in front of them, settling cross-legged, his grin softening into something warmer. Something sharper. He reached out and brushed a curl off Ender's forehead.

"How you feeling, love?"

Ender swallowed. "Fine."

"Liar."

"I'm not—"

Gene's hands slid under Ender's sweatshirt, palms flat against his stomach. Ender's breath hitched. He clamped his mouth shut, teeth clicking.

Zenix watched him. "There it is. That thing you do."

"I don't do anything."

"You do. You just did." Zenix leaned closer, so close his nose almost brushed Ender's. "You went all tense. Held your breath. Like you're afraid someone's gonna hear you."

Ender's eyes burned. "I'm not afraid."

"Then let go."

"I can't."

"Why not?"

Because it's shameful. Because I've never—because the sounds I make are ugly and needy and I don't want you to hear them. Because if you hear them, you'll know exactly how much I want you, and that's terrifying.

Ender didn't say any of that. He just shook his head, jaw tight.

Gene hummed. His thumbs traced small circles on Ender's hipbones. "That's okay," he said, low and easy. "We'll wait."

"We're very patient," Zenix added.

They were. That was the worst part. They'd been patient for months—never pushing, never demanding, never making Ender feel broken for the silence. They'd let him hide. And now they were letting him choose.

But Ender had already chosen. That's why he was here.

Gene's mouth found the junction of his neck and shoulder, hot and open. Ender's spine arched before he could stop it. A whimper rose in his throat—he swallowed it back, but not fast enough. Not before Zenix heard.

"Almost," Zenix whispered. He cupped Ender's face in both hands, tilting it up. "You're so close, baby. Just let it out."

Ender's eyes stung. His whole body was trembling now, a fine shudder that he couldn't control. Gene's teeth scraped his pulse point. Gene's hands slid lower, fingers dipping beneath the waistband of the sweats.

"Come on," Gene murmured. "Let us hear you."

And Ender—caught between them, burning alive, so tired of holding his breath—finally did.

The sound that escaped him was small at first. A cracked whimper, barely audible. But it was enough. It was a beginning.

Gene's low laugh vibrated against his throat. "Good boy," he said. "That's one."

Zenix's grin went wide and wild. "Now let's see how many more we can get."

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI