Cover of The Forbidden Fruit Next Door

The Forbidden Fruit Next Door

Read the story

4 chapters · 14465 words · Read 0 times

On the computer screen I watched the woman I was housesitting for being devoured as dshe struggled on the bed with her lesbian neighbor, both putting up a decent fight. I'd accidentally stumbled upon their secret sex tape, and it made me yearn for the woman next door. I called Emma over and confronted the older woman with the footage. She freaked out at first, but when she realized how hot I was for her, things took a horny turn. The dirty blonde challenged me to fight bent me over the desk and did to me what I watched on screen, using her experienced fingers and mouth to satisfy my urges. She loved having a younger, submissive she could use for her own pleasure, and she dragged me down to the floor so that I could please her in every naughty way she desired, no matter how lewd. She wanted me to go everywhere, and I was happy to oblige.

Chapter 1: The Bed of Sin

The air in Carol’s bedroom always smelled like jasmine and money. Sarah flopped backward onto the enormous bed, the cream-colored duvet puffing up around her like a cloud. She’d been coming in here to water the monstera plant for three days now, but the sheer scale of the room still didn’t feel real. It was like housesitting for a celebrity from an old movie.

Velvet curtains the color of midnight draped the windows, blocking the last of the afternoon sun. An antique dresser held a collection of perfume bottles that caught the dim light. Everything was polished, silent, and deeply adult. Sarah, in her university hoodie and jeans, felt like a kid who’d broken into a museum.

She rolled onto her stomach, reaching for the sleek remote on the nightstand. Carol had said the sound system was complicated, but Sarah figured she could at least find some music. She pointed the remote at the entertainment console across the room and pressed ‘power.’

The massive television screen flickered to life. But it wasn’t the menu screen.

It was a video feed. High-definition, crisp. The angle was from high in the corner, looking down on the very bed Sarah was lying on.

And on the screen, the bed wasn’t empty.

Carol was on it. Naked. Her fit, toned body was arched, her head thrown back against the pillows. Her short, silver-blonde hair was messy. A woman with dark, flowing hair—Emma, Sarah guessed—was above her, one hand braced on the headboard, the other tangling in Carol’s hair. The image was silent for a heartbeat, just a stark, moving painting.

Then the sound unmuted with a soft click.

A ragged, desperate moan filled the room, coming from the television’s surround sound speakers. It was Carol’s voice, but a version Sarah had never heard—raw, utterly unraveled.

Sarah froze. Her muscles locked. The remote slipped from her fingers and sank silently into the duvet.

On screen, Emma’s mouth was at Carol’s neck, whispering something. Carol’s hands scrabbled at Emma’s back, her nails leaving faint, pink trails. The camera angle was intimate, clinical, and utterly immersive. It wasn't some pixelated, online thing. This was here. This was now. This was the fabric under Sarah’s own palms, the indentation in the mattress where Carol’s hip was currently straining on the screen.

Her pulse wasn’t pounding in her ears; it was a frantic, hummingbird beat in her throat, her wrists, behind her eyes. She should look away. She should scramble off the bed, turn the system off, pretend she never saw it.

She didn’t move.

She watched, her breath shallow. She saw the way Carol’s confidence transformed into complete surrender. She saw the focused intensity on Emma’s face. It wasn’t porn. It was too specific, too real. The sound of skin on skin, the creak of the bedframe, Carol’s broken, pleading utterances that weren’t quite words.

A heat that had nothing to do with embarrassment spread through Sarah’s chest and down her stomach. It was a strange, twisting sensation—voyeuristic shock tangled with a dawning, unsettling fascination.

The sequence on screen changed. Emma rolled onto her back, pulling Carol on top. Carol laughed, a low, throaty sound of pure power and pleasure, and took control.

Sarah’s own body gave a tiny, involuntary jerk. Her hand pressed flat against the comforter. This was Carol. Her neighbor who brought over zucchini bread and talked about fertilizer. The woman who paid her sixty dollars a day to water plants and collect mail.

This was also Carol. A goddess in her own temple, utterly unashamed.

The video continued for another minute, maybe two. Time had become sticky and slow. Finally, the feed ended, cutting abruptly to the blue system menu screen. The sudden silence was louder than the moans had been.

The hum of the central air conditioning clicked on.

Sarah sat up, slowly. The room looked the same, yet completely alien. The four-poster bed was no longer just a piece of furniture. It was a set. A witness. Every detail—the faint scent of perfume and sweat she now noticed, the particular grain of the headboard wood she could see in perfect clarity in her mind’s eye—was charged with new meaning.

She stood up, her legs unsteady. She walked to the foot of the bed, staring at the spot where, on screen, Carol had…

“Holy shit,” she whispered to the empty, opulent room.

Her phone buzzed in her pocket, making her jump. She fumbled it out. A text from her friend Maya.

Maya: Hey, you alive in that mansion? Party at Jake’s tonight. You in?

Sarah stared at the message. The thought of a crowded, beer-smelling house, of shouting over terrible music and making idle chitchat, felt impossible. Juvenile. Her whole world had just tilted on its axis, right here in this quiet, perfumed room.

Her thumbs hovered over the screen. She looked back at the blank television, then at the bed.

She typed a reply.

Sarah: Can’t. Things to do here.

She put the phone away, screen-down, on the dresser. She walked back to the bed and sat on the edge, precisely where the video had ended. She ran her hand over the duvet, her touch now deliberate. A strange, rebellious calm was settling over her. The quiet, unassuming girl was still there, but she was sharing space with someone new. Someone curious.

She lay back down, staring at the ceiling where the hidden camera must be. She didn’t look for it. She didn’t need to see it.

She knew it was there. And she wondered, with a thrilling, terrifying chill, what else it had seen.

And she wondered, with a thrilling, terrifying chill, what else it had seen.

The remote was a cool, slender rectangle in her hand. She hadn’t consciously picked it back up, but her fingers had closed around it of their own accord. The logical part of her brain, the one that got straight A’s and always watered the plants on time, was screaming at her to leave the room. To go downstairs, watch TV, and forget any of this happened.

She didn’t listen.

Her thumb found the button she’d pressed before—a small, unmarked silver circle near the top. She pressed it. The blue menu screen vanished, replaced by a grid of thumbnails. Dozens of them. All timestamped. All silent.

Her breath caught. This wasn’t an accident. This was a library.

The most recent thumbnail showed the scene she’d just witnessed. Carol and Emma, a tangle of limbs on cream linen. Sarah scrolled back, her pulse a steady drum in her ears. A week ago. Two weeks. A month. Different angles, sometimes. The bed, the chaise lounge by the window. Always the same two women.

She stopped on a thumbnail from three months prior. The preview image was darker, the contrast sharper. Carol was on her knees beside the bed, her back to the camera, Emma’s hands fisted in her hair. It wasn’t a pose of submission; it was a snapshot of sheer force.

Sarah clicked it.

The video loaded instantly, filling the screen with a kind of hungry silence before the audio kicked in. It was the same room, the same bed, but the atmosphere was a live wire. Carol was struggling. Not to get away, but to get closer, her movements fierce and demanding. Emma was holding her back, an arm braced across Carol’s collarbone, her other hand gripping Carol’s wrist so tightly the tendons stood out.

“No,” Emma was saying, her voice a low, ragged command. “You don’t get it that easy.”

Carol’s reply was a raw, guttural sound that was half laugh, half sob. She twisted, muscles cording in her back, and slammed Emma against the headboard. The impact was a thick, wooden thud that resonated through the speakers. There was no playful laughter here, no slow transformation. This was a contest. A claiming.

Sarah could see the strain in every line of their bodies. Carol’s nails dug into Emma’s thigh, not in passion, but in a sharp, angry punctuation. Emma retaliated by sinking her teeth into Carol’s shoulder, not hard enough to break skin, but with a deliberate, punishing pressure that made Carol cry out—a sharp, shocked noise that dissolved into a desperate moan.

It was violence and need all twisted together. A struggle where every push was a pull, every bite was a kiss, every curse was a prayer. The sounds were different. Less melody, more percussion. Grunts, sharp breaths, the slick slap of skin, the relentless creak of the bedframe under a frantic, driving rhythm.

Sarah found she had pressed her own knees together, her hand clenching the duvet. The heat in her core was no longer just curiosity; it was a mirror to the tension on screen, a coiled, aching thing. She watched, utterly paralyzed, as Carol finally gained the upper hand, pinning Emma down with her full weight, their faces inches apart, both of them flushed and furious and breathless.

“Mine,” Carol snarled, the word distorted, fervent.

Emma stared up at her, chest heaving, and spat back, “Prove it.”

The video ended there, cutting to black so abruptly it left Sarah dizzy. The silence rushed back in, now heavy and charged, like the air after a thunderclap.

She sat very still on the edge of the bed, the remote loose in her damp palm. The quiet house around her felt like a lie. The perfectly arranged furniture, the serene artwork, the gentle hum of the refrigerator downstairs—all of it was just a cover for this hidden, throbbing heart of the place.

She looked at the blank screen, then down at her own trembling hands. The unassuming girl was gone, left behind in the first shocking flash of the initial video. What remained was someone else entirely. Someone who had just peered into a world where love looked like a battle, and desire like a verb you had to fight to conjugate.

Slowly, she placed the remote back on the nightstand, lining it up perfectly with the edge. She stood, her legs steady now, purpose settling into her bones. She had five more days housesitting. Five more days in this museum of secrets.

She walked to the bedroom door, pausing to look back at the bed one last time. A slow, unfamiliar smile touched her lips—not sweet, but curious and sharp.

The plants could wait.

The plants could wait.

Sarah stood in the center of the silent, opulent bedroom. Her eyes were drawn back to the blank screen, but her mind was replaying the last few seconds of that darker video. The raw struggle of it. The way anger and passion weren’t separate tracks but braided together, a single, furious current.

It wasn’t like anything she’d ever seen, or even imagined. The guys she’d been with, the fumbling in dorm rooms, the polite, apologetic interactions—they were a different species of event entirely. This was a collision.

Watching the two naked bodies struggle together, woman to woman—a fight? Anger? Passion?—it triggered something in Sarah. A recognition, sharp and disorienting. It wasn’t that she wanted to be Emma, or Carol. It was that she wanted the certainty they possessed. The unapologetic hunger. The courage to want something so fiercely you’d wrestle it from the world, or from each other.

Her own life felt soft by comparison. Polite. Muted.

She walked to Carol’s walk-in closet and flicked on the light. Rows of clothing, meticulously organized, breathed out a scent of cedar and that same jasmine perfume. Her hand brushed past silks, fine wools, a leather jacket that felt like butter. She stopped at a simple item: a sleeveless black sheath dress, cut from a dense, matte fabric. It looked like a weapon.

Without really deciding to, she slipped off her hoodie and jeans. The cool air of the house raised goosebumps on her skin. She slid the dress over her head. It was too long, of course, and pooled slightly at her ankles. The waist was a little loose, but the fabric hugged her ribs, a strange, firm embrace. She turned to the full-length mirror.

The person reflected was both familiar and alien. The dress aged her, simplified her lines into something more severe. She looked… potential. She ran her hands down her sides, feeling the difference.

Back in the bedroom, she didn’t look at the television. She went to Carol’s vanity, a gorgeously carved piece of furniture littered with pots and brushes. She picked up a tube of crimson lipstick, unscrewed it, and stared at the bullet of color. She never wore red. She went for glosses, tints, anything that whispered.

She applied it directly, without a mirror. The sensation was waxy and decisive. She blotted her lips together, then turned to the mirror on the wall.

The effect was jarring. The bold slash of color on her face changed everything. It pulled the curiosity from her eyes into something more like a challenge. The quiet girl was still there, but she was now a secret the quiet girl was keeping.

Her phone buzzed again from the dresser. She walked over, her movements slower in the unfamiliar dress. It was Maya.

Maya: Seriously? You’re bailing for HOUSESITTING? You’ve officially become a grandma. RIP your social life.

Sarah picked up the phone. She looked at the text, then at her reflection—the stolen dress, the stolen lips. A wild, impulsive thought crystallized.

She typed back, her thumbs sure.

Sarah: Jake’s is lame. Meet me at The Nighthawk. 10.

She sent it before she could think. The Nighthawk was a bar downtown, all dim lighting and vinyl booths. She’d been there once with her older cousin. It felt like a place for people who had stories, not just exam schedules.

Maya’s reply was almost instant.

Maya: ? Who is this and what have you done with Sarah? Nighthawk is 21+. They card at the door.

Sarah smiled, a strange sensation with the new weight on her lips.

Sarah: I know. See you at 10.

She put the phone down. The adrenaline was buzzing now, a clean, electric current. She had five hours. She padded back into the closet, found a pair of Carol’s sheer black tights and rolled them on, then slipped back into her own scuffed ankle boots. The juxtaposition—tough boots, elegant dress, dramatic mouth—felt right. It felt like a costume for the person she might become for one night.

She spent the next few hours in a state of focused calm. She did water the plants, each pour feeling like a mundane ritual before a journey. She ate toast standing at the kitchen island. The silence of the house was no longer oppressive; it was a cocoon.

At 9:30, she called a ride. Standing in the foyer, she checked her reflection in the hall mirror. She looked like a version of herself from a few years in the future. Or like a stranger.

The car arrived. She slid into the back seat, the leather cool through the tights.

“The Nighthawk, on 5th,” she said, her voice steady.

The driver, an older man, glanced in the rearview. “You got ID, young lady?”

“Yes,” Sarah said, and it wasn’t entirely a lie. She had her college ID. She had the lipstick. She had the memory of Carol’ fierce, wanton snarl—Mine—echoing in her bones. It would have to be enough.

The city lights slid past the window. Her heart was a steady, determined drum against her ribs. She wasn’t going to find a fight, or a struggle. But maybe, just for tonight, she could stop being so quiet. Maybe she could find out what her own hunger sounded like.

The car pulled up to the curb under a flickering neon sign of a bird in flight. Sarah took a deep breath, the jasmine scent from the dress mixing with the city smell of exhaust and rain-damp pavement.

She got out, smoothed the unfamiliar dress, and walked toward the door, where a large man with a clipboard stood under the glow of the neon, his expression bored. She didn’t hesitate. She walked right up, met his eyes, and felt the ghost of a confident, borrowed smile touch her lips.

The bouncer’s eyes, flat and assessing, scanned her from the boots to the red lips. He didn’t look at the dress. He looked at her face. “ID.”

Sarah’s hand was steady as she pulled her university ID from the small clutch she’d found in the closet. It was a black velvet thing, too elegant for her. She held it out, the plastic gleaming under the neon.

He barely glanced at it. The date was right there. He knew. He looked back at her eyes, at the set of her shoulders under the black straps. A beat passed. The noise from the bar leaked out—a low thrum of bass, the clink of glass, a burst of laughter.

“Slow night,” he grunted, and unhooked the velvet rope. “Don’t cause trouble.”

The wave of sound and warm, beer-scented air hit her as she stepped inside. It was darker than she remembered, the light coming mostly from vintage-style bulbs in wire cages and the cool blue glow of the backlit liquor shelves. It was busy, but not packed. Conversations wove through the music, a syncopated hum.

She spotted Maya almost immediately, perched on a stool at the far end of the bar, craning her neck toward the door. Maya’s eyes, wide with confusion, then shock, then dawning disbelief, locked onto her.

Sarah moved through the room, feeling the strange swish of the dress around her calves. She was aware of glances. A man at a high-top table tracking her progress. A woman in a blazer giving her a slow, appreciative once-over. The attention was a physical touch, a current. It didn’t feel invasive. It felt like confirmation.

“What. The. Actual. Hell.” Maya breathed as Sarah slid onto the stool beside her. Maya was dressed for Jake’s party—ripped jeans, a cute tank top. She looked like yesterday. Sarah felt like tomorrow. “Sarah? Is that you under there? Did you rob a bank? Or a… a sexy widow?”

“I’m housesitting,” Sarah said, and the simple truth of it sounded like a lie. She caught the bartender’s eye, a woman with a shaved side of her head and intricate tattoos winding up her arm. “Gin and tonic, please. Double.”

“Since when?” Maya asked, her voice dropping to a whisper. “Since when do you drink doubles? Since when do you wear…” She gestured vaguely at all of Sarah.

“Since today.” The drink arrived fast. Sarah took a sip. The gin was crisp, a botanical shock that cut through the bar’s warmth. It was bracing. Good.

Maya leaned in. “Okay, spill. Did something happen? Did you find, like, a secret stash of cocaine in that old lady’s house?”

Sarah almost laughed. A secret stash. If only she knew. “No. I just… needed a change of scenery.” She took another, longer sip. The alcohol was a tiny fire in her stomach, feeding the one that was already there.

“Well, mission accomplished. You look… intense.” Maya sipped her vodka cranberry, studying her friend. “It’s a good look. Kinda scary. But good. So, what’s the plan? We just sit here looking cool?”

Before Sarah could answer, a man’s voice cut in from her left. “That’s a serious drink for a serious look.”

He was older, maybe late thirties, with the relaxed posture of someone who belonged in the dim light. He wore a simple grey henley, sleeves pushed up. He wasn’t slick. He was just there, his gaze direct but not aggressive.

Maya’s eyebrows shot up. She mouthed ‘oh my god’ over her glass.

Sarah turned on the stool to face him. The movement felt different in the dress. “Is there another kind?”

He smiled, a small crease at the corner of his eye. “Lots of other kinds. Most of them are louder.” He nodded at her glass. “That’s quiet. I appreciate quiet.”

He wasn’t hitting on her. Not in the way guys at college parties did, with their boisterous energy and wandering hands. This was a conversation. An observation.

“Quiet can be deceptive,” Sarah heard herself say. Carol’s face, fierce and desperate, flashed behind her eyes.

“The best things usually are.” He held up his own drink, a tumbler of something amber, in a slight toast. “Enjoy your night.” And then, surprisingly, he turned back to his friends at a nearby table, releasing her from the exchange as easily as he’d begun it.

Maya exhaled. “What was that? He was like, a grown-up. A hot grown-up.”

Sarah felt a ripple of something—not disappointment, but a shift in the atmosphere. The interaction was a closed loop. Complete. It hadn’t demanded anything from her. It had simply acknowledged the persona she was wearing, and found it interesting. The power of that acknowledgment settled into her bones, warmer than the gin.

For the next hour, they talked. Or, Maya talked, and Sarah listened, adding comments that felt sharper, less filtered. She ordered another drink. The noise of the bar began to feel like a cocoon, a blanket of anonymous energy. She watched the interactions around her—the lean-ins, the touches, the practiced smiles. She saw the mechanics of it all, and for the first time, she felt like she was outside the machine, holding a manual she’d just found.

She was in the bathroom, reapplying the red lipstick with a focus she usually reserved for exams, when the stall door behind her opened.

A woman walked out to the sink next to her. She was tall, with a sharp black bob and eyes lined in kohl. She washed her hands, her movements efficient. Their eyes met in the mirror.

“That color is brutal on you,” the woman said. Her voice was low, matter-of-fact.

Sarah paused, the lipstick hovering. “Brutal?”

“A compliment. It’s not pretty. It’s a statement. Most people can’t carry that.” She dried her hands on a paper towel, still looking at Sarah’s reflection. “You’re carrying it.”

She dropped the towel in the bin and left, the door swinging shut behind her.

Sarah stared at her own face. Brutal. The word echoed. It didn’t feel like an insult. It felt like the truth she’d been groping for all night. She wasn’t here to be pretty. She was here to… make a statement. Even if she was the only one who knew what it meant.

When she returned to the bar, Maya was texting furiously. “Jake’s party is apparently ‘epic’ now. Some guy brought a keg of some local IPA. The pressure is mounting.” She looked up, pleading. “Just for an hour? I need to be seen. Then we can come back to your den of sophistication.”

Sarah felt the pull of the familiar. The easy script of a college party. It would be simple to slip back into it, to let this night become a weird anomaly.

Then she felt the brush of the too-long dress against her legs. She tasted the waxy crimson on her lips.

“You go,” Sarah said. The decision was calm, final. “I’m going to finish my drink.”

Maya looked stunned, then concerned. “You’ll get home okay?”

“I have the app. I’m fine.”

After a flurry of hugs and promises to call tomorrow, Maya disappeared into the night. Sarah sat alone at the bar, swirling the ice in her glass. The emptiness beside her was expansive. It was a space she’d never consciously occupied before.

The man in the grey henley was leaving with his friends. He caught her eye on his way out and gave her that same slight, acknowledging nod.

The bartender with the tattoos placed a fresh glass of water in front of her. “On the house. For the professional sitters.”

Sarah thanked her. The crowd was thinning. The music seemed lower. The adrenaline that had carried her through the door was fading, leaving a deep, humming clarity in its wake. She wasn’t the same person who had watched that screen, her body rigid with shock. That girl had been shattered. This woman, sipping water in a black dress, was what was taking shape in the cracks.

She paid her tab with cash from Carol’s clutch.

Outside, the night air was cold. She hugged herself, the velvet of the clutch soft under her fingers. Her ride was two minutes away.

She looked back at the flickering neon bird. It had felt like a destination, but it was just a threshold. The real unknown was back in that silent, perfumed house. The library was still there. The bed was still there. The question wasn’t whether she would watch again.

The question was what she would look for.

The car pulled up. As she slid inside, giving the address, she finally let herself lean back. She closed her eyes. Against the darkness of her lids, she didn’t see the bar, or Maya, or the man’s smile.

She saw a hand, fingers splayed, pressing hard into the small of a back. She heard a whisper that was also a command.

Prove it.

The car carried her through the sleeping streets, back toward the secret heart of everything. The ghost of the smile on her lips was no longer borrowed. It was hers.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI