Cover of The Freshman's Dilemma

The Freshman's Dilemma

Read the story

2 chapters · 7504 words · Read 0 times

An erotic comedy about an obscenely wealthy, beautifully busty lesbian with an impregnation and pregnancy fetish, the male college freshman who rents a room from her, and his fiancee who lives with him.

Chapter 1: The bedroom negotiation

The knock on Leo’s bedroom door was too soft, almost hesitant, which was how he knew it wasn’t Chloe. Chloe knocked like she was announcing a police raid. He marked his place in his economics textbook and swung his long legs off the bed, the old floorboards groaning under his weight.

“Come in?”

The door opened, and Sera leaned against the frame. She wasn’t in her usual daytime attire of designer athleisure. She wore a silk robe, crimson, tied loosely at her waist. Her blonde hair was down, spilling over her shoulders. “Hey, neighbor. Got a minute? We need to… discuss your rent situation.”

Leo’s stomach did a slow, cold twist. Rent. The one thing that could upend this fragile miracle. They’d been here three weeks, and the sheer scale of the mansion still stole his breath. He’d been waiting for the other shoe to drop. “Yeah. Yeah, of course. Is everything okay?”

“Everything’s fine. Just come to my room when you’re ready. More privacy.” She gave him a smile that didn’t quite reach her eyes and disappeared, the scent of her jasmine perfume lingering behind.

Privacy. That word rattled around his skull as he walked the endless, carpeted hallway. His and Chloe’s room was in the west wing, Sera’s domain was the entire east wing. The grand piano in the central foyer was silent now. The only sound was the whisper of central air and the frantic beat of his own heart.

Her bedroom door was ajar. He pushed it open.

“Close it behind you,” Sera’s voice came from the sitting area by the fireplace.

Leo closed the door and turned. The air left his lungs in a rush.

Sera stood by the mantel, but the robe was gone. She wore a negligee of sheer black lace, so transparent it was like a shadow on her skin. The curves of her breasts were fully visible, the dark nipples taut and clearly outlined against the lace. The garment ended high on her thighs. She watched him, her expression unreadable.

“Sera, I… what’s…” Leo’s voice cracked. He felt his face burn. He’d never seen a woman dressed like that, not in person. He forced his eyes to the Persian rug.

“The rent, Leo,” she said, her voice low and even. “We need to negotiate it. I think we can come to a… mutually beneficial arrangement.”

“I have the money from the library job,” he stammered. “It’s not much, but…”

“I don’t want your money.”

He finally looked up, confusion cutting through his embarrassment. “Then what do you want?”

She took a step toward him. “I want you to fuck me.”

Leo actually took a step back, his shoulder blades hitting the solid oak door. He shook his head, a quick, birdlike motion of disbelief. “No. I’m engaged. You’re a… you’re gay. This isn’t funny.”

“It’s not a joke.” Another step. He could see the faint dusting of freckles across her chest now. “And your fiancée is fully aware.”

As if on cue, the door to Sera’s en-suite bathroom opened. Chloe walked out.

She was wearing a matching negligee in deep emerald green, her flame-red hair a shocking contrast against it. She looked at Leo, her gaze steady, but he saw the faint tremor in her hand as she pushed her hair back.

“Chloe?” The name was a plea.

“It’s okay, Leo,” Chloe said, her voice softer than he’d ever heard it. She walked to Sera’s side, but her eyes stayed locked on him. “We talked. Sera and I.”

“Talked about what?” he demanded, a spike of anger piercing his shock. “About you… and her… and me? What the hell is this?”

Sera slid an arm around Chloe’s waist, a possessive, casual gesture. Chloe pulled away, but not enough to actually dislodge Sera's hand. “We talked about futures,” Sera said. “I showed Chloe the trust funds I could set up. The portfolios. The house in Tuscany. The security. A life where neither of you ever has to worry again. Where you can focus on school, on each other, on a family of your own someday. All of it, guaranteed. Ironclad.”

“And the price is this?” Leo gestured weakly between them.

“The price,” Sera continued, “is a service. A biological service. I am a lesbian, Leo. The sight of a naked man, his cock, his balls, the very idea of his semen… it is, frankly, revolting to me.” She said it with such clinical detachment that Leo flinched. “I like you. You’re a sweet kid. But romantically? Sexually? You are as appealing to me as a used bandage.”

He stared, utterly lost.

“However,” she continued, her hand stroking Chloe’s hip, but her eyes fixed hungrily on his crotch, “my revulsion is completely and utterly surpassed by my desire to have a child. Several children. As many children as my body can handle. I have the resources to raise them in unparalleled luxury. What I lack is the necessary biological component. You have it. You are tall, healthy, genetically sound. You are kind. You are, for my purposes, ideal.”

Chloe finally moved, crossing the space to him. She put her hands on his chest, feeling his heart hammering beneath her palms. “Listen to me,” she whispered, her voice fierce. “I love you. Only you. I am as icked out by her caressing my ass like that as she says she is by your cock. This is a transaction. She gets what she wants from your body. We get a future. A real one. When we leave here, we leave. I am with you. Do you understand me?”

Leo looked into her green eyes, seeing the fear, the determination, the brutal pragmatism he’d always admired and sometimes feared. He thought of the two jobs he worked, the loans mounting, the tiny, roach-infested apartment they’d almost taken. He thought of the shooter outside the movie theatre a year ago, of throwing himself on top of Chloe, of the terror that he wouldn’t be enough to protect her. Here was a different kind of protection, offered in a way that made his skin crawl.

“She doesn’t want me, Leo,” Chloe whispered, her lips close to his ear. “She wants this.” Her hand slid down, palming him through his jeans. He was, to his horror and shame, already half-hard. “And I want you to have a future with me. So we’re going to go over there, and you are going to give her what she asked for.”

She took his hand and led him, a man shaped like a giant but feeling like a child, to the massive four-poster bed. Sera was already reclining against the pillows, her negligee now completely open. She watched them approach, her gaze analytical.

“Good,” Sera said. “Clothes off, Leo. Let’s not waste time.”

With clumsy fingers, Leo undressed, his cheeks burning. He felt grotesque under her dispassionate stare. Chloe helped him, her touches familiar and comforting, a stark contrast to the surreal nightmare of the situation. When he was naked, Sera’s eyes flicked over him, pausing on his cock, which was now fully erect, caught between instinct and anguish.

“Adequate,” she said, without warmth. “Chloe, kiss him. Get him ready for me.”

Chloe obeyed, pulling Leo into a deep, hungry kiss. It was their kiss, full of love and fear and a desperate kind of solidarity. As their tongues met, Sera moved behind Chloe, her hands coming around to cup Chloe’s breasts through the green lace. Sera nuzzled Chloe’s neck, her eyes closed, a genuine smile of pleasure on her face. “See?” Sera murmured against Chloe’s skin. “This is what I like. This softness. This taste.”

She guided Chloe down onto the bed, so Leo was kneeling between them. “Now,” Sera said, lying back and spreading her legs. Her expression shifted, the clinical look burning away into something hungry and focused. “Fuck me, Leo. Fuck a baby into me.”

The vulgarity, the stark command, jolted him into action. He moved over her, bracing himself on his arms. He hesitated at the entrance, looking down at her face. Her eyes were blazing with a fervor that had nothing to do with him.

“Do it,” she hissed, and reached down to guide him inside.

She was wet. That was the shock. Physically ready. As he sank into her, a tight, hot sheath, she let out a gasp that sounded not of pleasure, but of triumph. “Yes! That’s it. Give it to me. Pump it deep.”

He began to move, a clumsy, awkward rhythm. Chloe curled beside them, her hand on his back, her lips on his shoulder, whispering, “It’s okay, I’m here, I love you, just do it.”

Sera’s hands clutched at his hips, her nails digging in. Her head thrashed on the pillow. “Your cock is so fucking big, you’re going to rip me open with it, fill my womb up,” she chanted, the words filthy and fervent. “I can feel it, you’re going to knock me up, you’re going to make me so fucking pregnant. Breed me, Leo. Breed me like the good stud you are!”

Each crude word was a lash. He felt used, hollow, but his body, traitorously, responded to the relentless, rhythmic clenching of her, to the visual of Chloe watching him with love and Sera beneath him lost in her breeding fantasy. The heat coiled tightly in his gut.

Sera’s eyes were squeezed shut, her fantasies playing out behind her eyelids. “I can feel it, you’re getting close,” she panted. “Don’t you dare pull out. You shoot every fucking drop in me, you understand? I want to feel you come. I want to feel it hit my cervix.”

Her orders, the intense physical pressure, Chloe’s pleading whispers—it was too much. With a broken groan, Leo buried himself as deep as he could and came. It was a release that felt more like a collapse, waves of pleasure utterly entangled with shame.

He shuddered through it, and Sera wrapped her legs high around his back, locking him in place, milking him with intense, pulsing contractions. “Yes,” she breathed, a sound of pure satisfaction. “Yes. Good. Give it all to me.”

When he was spent, he collapsed to the side, pulling Chloe against him, needing her scent, her reality. Sera lay still, her legs still raised, a pillow shoved under her hips. A practical, procreative afterthought.

For a long minute, the only sound was their ragged breathing.

Sera finally sat up. She looked at the two of them, curled together, Leo’s semen already leaking from between her thighs. There was no affection in her gaze, but there was a kind of grim approval.

“This will be ongoing,” she stated, wiping her thigh with a corner of the sheet. “There’s no guarantee I caught the egg this time. Even if I did, I want a big family. I have the money for as many children as you can give me. We’ll establish a schedule. Ovulation is most efficient, but consistent frequency improves overall odds.”

Leo could only stare, numb.

Chloe found her voice first, thick but steady. “We understand.”

Sera nodded. She stood, walking naked to her bathroom, not a hint of modesty or post-coital intimacy. She paused at the door, glancing back. “You can sleep here tonight if you like. The sheets are Egyptian cotton. They’re clean.”

Then she disappeared, closing the door behind her. The sound of a shower starting soon followed.

Leo turned his face into Chloe’s hair. He was trembling. “What have we done?”

Chloe held him tighter, her own body shaking. “What we had to do,” she whispered, but in the dark, opulent silence, it sounded like a question neither of them could answer.

Leo’s breathing eventually evened out, deepening into the slow, heavy rhythm of sleep. His arm was a dead weight across Chloe’s waist, his face pressed into her hair. She lay there for a long time, staring at the intricate pattern of the canopy above them, feeling the residual heat from his body and the unfamiliar chill of the room’s air conditioning on her skin.

Carefully, she extracted herself. He murmured, his brow furrowing, but didn’t wake. Exhaustion had finally claimed him, a mercy. She pulled on Sera’s discarded silk robe, tying it tightly, and padded barefoot out of the bedroom.

The mansion was a cathedral of silence at this hour. Her footsteps were swallowed by the hallway runner. She found Sera not in her sitting room or an adjacent lounge, but in a smaller, windowless room she hadn’t been shown on the tour. It looked like a cross between a home gym and a sterile clinic.

Sera was lying on an incline table, her head lowered toward the floor, her feet strapped into padded rests high in the air. She was completely naked, her arms folded over her stomach, staring at the ceiling with focused concentration. It was so absurd, so blatantly practical, that Chloe stopped in the doorway, her anger momentarily derailed by the sheer spectacle of it.

“It improves the odds by maybe eight percent,” Sera said, without looking over. Her voice echoed slightly in the tiled room. “Gravity. You want to use every tool you have.”

“Are you kidding me?” Chloe’s voice was flat.

“You underestimate my obsession. I am even more in its thrall than Leo now finds himself. The difference is I embrace it.” Sera’s head lolled to the side to look at her. “Did he fall asleep?”

“Yes.”

“Good. He’ll need his rest. We’ll try again in the morning before his morning class. Sperm count is highest upon waking.” Sera shifted slightly, a faint, uncomfortable adjustment. “Are you backing out of the deal?”

“No.” Chloe stepped into the room. The air was cooler here. “I’m here to renegotiate the terms.”

Sera let out a short, humorless laugh. “The terms are non-negotiable. The money is transferred on the first of every month. The clause for child support and trust funds is already notarized. My lawyers—”

“I don’t give a fuck about your lawyers,” Chloe interrupted, her voice low. “The deal stands. But you need to find a way to make it work for him. Not just for your womb. You can’t treat him like a… a fucking syringe. Not if you want this to last for the months or years it might take. He’s not a machine. What happened in there…” She gestured back toward the bedroom. “That was traumatic for him.”

Sera was quiet for a moment. “Was it?”

“You know it was. You were watching. Don’t play stupid.”

“I’m not playing. I’m assessing.” Sera closed her eyes, then opened them. “It was efficient.”

“Efficient.” Chloe repeated the word like it was poison. She walked closer, until she was standing next to the inverted woman. “Was any of what you said in there true? All that… filth. Was it just a performance?”

Sera’s gaze was contemplative, fixed on a point on the far wall. “It was all true.”

“You feel lust for him? For a man?”

“No.” The answer was immediate, definitive. “Not lust. Not attraction. The concept of male sexuality, as an object of desire, does nothing for me. It’s aesthetically uninteresting at best. But my… fixation. It’s more than strong enough to replace lust. I was dead serious when I said you underestimate the strength of my obsession. My body,” she said, with a note of clinical surprise, “even relished the physical sensations. The fullness. The… potential. But my mind was on the results. The process is just biology. A very direct, very effective form of plumbing. Though I will admit, there is also a degree of enjoyment I hadn't anticipated.”

Chloe absorbed this, her stomach turning. It was somehow worse than if Sera had just been a predatory bisexual. This was colder. More absolute. She was using Leo to service a need, and hadn't bothered to learn how to care for her tools before using them. “Then that’s all the more reason. If you feel nothing for him, then you have to work harder to make sure he doesn’t break. You have to build in some… humanity. Some kindness. Or you’ll get your first positive test and he’ll be a hollowed-out wreck, and I won’t let you have a second.”

Sera’s lips thinned. “He’s a big boy. He agreed.”

“He agreed because he loves me and I told him to, and because we’re poor, and he’s terrified of failing me. That’s not consent, that’s coercion with a smiling face. You want a healthy donor? Act like it.”

“I’m not a therapist. I’m a client. He’s the service provider.”

Chloe leaned down, placing her hands on the cold metal rails of the incline table. She brought her face close to Sera’s upside-down one. Her voice dropped, each word clear and sharp as an ice chip.

“You saw the scars. The two on his back. Left side.”

Sera’s eyes flickered. A slight tell. “I did.”

“One bullet went through his lung. The other nicked his spleen. Because he unhesitatingly stepped between me and a man with a gun. I kept him alive for fifty-seven minutes on that sidewalk waiting for the ambulance. For fifty-eight minutes I was terrified I'd already lost him until the paramedic found his pulse. I used my sweater, my hands, I talked to him, I screamed at him not to leave me. Then, at the hospital, when they said the specialist wasn’t available and the on-call would have to do, I shouted down an entire hospital board and a goddamn US senator who was there for a photo-op until they got him the surgeon he needed. I fought for every breath he took after that. So right now, he’s confused and stressed, and I can deal with that. That’s my job, and I agreed to this deal. But if you, with your money and your tables and your fucking efficiency, end up hurting him? Breaking something inside him that I can’t stitch back together?”

Chloe didn’t raise her voice. It was worse than a scream. It was absolute zero.

“He's my everything and I owe him everything. The deal won’t matter. The money won’t matter. I will tear you apart with my bare hands if I need to. And I will do it slowly. Do you understand the plumbing of that, Sera?”

The room was utterly silent. The hum of the fridge holding various medical supplies seemed to grow louder. Sera, inverted, held Chloe’s gaze. For the first time, something in her perfectly composed, analytically dismissive façade shifted. It wasn’t fear, exactly. It was a recalculation. A reassessment of a variable she had profoundly underestimated.

She blinked slowly. “I understand.”

“Good.” Chloe straightened up, her knuckles white where she’d gripped the rail. “Hire a kinky life coach. Talk to someone about how to have sex with a man without terrifying him. Convince yourself a happy donor has higher quality sperm. Hell, that's probably true. But figure it out. By morning, if you want to try again right away, or otherwise before the next 'payment.' Because I will be there, and I will be watching.”

She turned and left Sera there, suspended in the dark, a ridiculous monument to her own desperate wanting. The silence Chloe left behind was different now. It was no longer just empty. It was charged, and waiting.

Back in the bedroom, the empty space beside him had grown cold. Leo stirred, his hand patting the expanse of Egyptian cotton where Chloe should have been. A low-grade panic, the kind that lives in the bones of anyone who has almost lost someone, flickered behind his sternum. He pushed himself up on one elbow, blinking into the gloom.

The door opened, a sliver of hallway light cutting across the floor, then vanishing as it closed.

“Chloe?”

“Shhh. It’s me.” Her voice was a warm balm. He heard the soft shush of the robe being dropped, saw her silhouette move toward the bed. The mattress dipped as she slid in, her skin cool from the air-conditioned halls. She molded herself against him, her back to his front, and his arms instinctively wrapped around her, pulling her tight. He buried his nose in her hair, inhaling the familiar scent of her apple shampoo underneath Sera’s clinging jasmine.

“Where’d you go?”

“Bathroom.” It was the truth. She had used the ornate, gold-fixtured bathroom two doors down before her detour to the gym. The rest of it sat on her tongue, a bitter pill she swallowed whole. “My stomach’s a little weird.”

He made a sympathetic noise, his large hand splaying over her abdomen. The silence that followed was thick. It wasn’t the easy quiet they usually shared. This one vibrated with everything that had happened, with everything she had just said in the other room, not that he would ever know about that particular conversation.

Her hand came up to cover his, lacing their fingers together. She shifted then, turning in his arms to face him. In the faint ambient light from the window, her eyes were dark pools, serious. She searched his face.

“Tell me,” she whispered.

“I feel… dirty,” he admitted, the words ripped from a raw place. “And used. And… I don’t know. Like I left part of myself in her. It doesn’t feel like it’s mine anymore.”

Chloe listened, her thumb stroking his cheek. She didn’t offer hollow platitudes. She knew better.

“It’s still yours,” she said finally, her voice firm. “She rented it for a few minutes. That’s all. The deed is yours. The title is yours. I’ve got the papers right here.” She took his hand and pressed it firmly over her heart. “See?”

A choked sound, half-sob, half-laugh, escaped him. He leaned his forehead against hers. “I love you so much it scares me sometimes.”

“Good,” she breathed. Then she kissed him.

It wasn’t like Sera’s calculated performance. It was Chloe—insistent, deep, claiming. A reclamation. Her tongue swept into his mouth, and he met it with a desperate hunger of his own. This was the taste he knew, the rhythm he craved. Not a transaction, but a conversation.

Her hands slid down his chest, over the flat plane of his stomach, and wrapped around his cock. He was soft, spent, overwhelmed. She gentled her touch, stroking him slowly, patiently, her lips moving from his mouth to his jaw, to the shell of his ear.

“This is us,” she murmured, her breath hot against his skin. Her other hand guided his to her breast, the full, heavy weight filling his palm, her nipple pebbling against his touch. “This is real. She doesn’t get this. She never will.”

Under her steadfast attention, his body began to respond. It was a different kind of arousal, slower, rooted in comfort and a desperate need for connection rather than frantic biology. He rolled her onto her back, looming over her, but she pulled him down, wanting his weight, his solidness.

When he entered her, they both sighed. It was home. Hot, familiar, tight in a way that welcomed rather than constrained. He moved inside her with a slow, rolling cadence, his eyes locked on hers.

“Look at me,” she commanded softly, her hands framing his face. “Just me.”

He did. He saw the love, the fierce pride, the lingering shock, and the steely resolve. He saw the partner who had fought for his life and was now fighting for his soul. He moved deeper, losing himself in the green of her eyes, in the soft, breathy sounds she made that were for him alone.

The pace built, not to a violent crescendo but to a profound, swelling peak. There were no filthy chants, only his name on her lips, gasped against his shoulder as she clenched around him. His release this time was a quiet unfolding, a warm flood of relief that left him shuddering, not with shame, but with a weary, grateful surrender.

He collapsed beside her, then immediately turned and buried his face in the soft valley between her breasts. The scent of her skin, the steady beat of her heart beneath his ear, the gentle weight of her hand coming to rest on the back of his head—it was a sanctuary. He could almost pretend the last hour hadn’t happened. Almost.

She knew he was pretending. He knew she knew. The fact that she let him, that she held him through the charade, was its own kind of devastating truth. It was part of why he loved her.

His breathing slowed, deepened, became the heavy, even rhythm of sleep. Chloe stared at the ceiling, her fingers absently stroking through his dark hair. The fear she’d carried back from the gym—the cold, calculating look in Sera’s upside-down eyes—began to recede, soothed by the living, breathing weight of the man in her arms.

Sleep crept up on her quietly, a dark tide pulling her under. Her hand stilled in his hair, coming to rest softly on his temple. In the lavish, silent bedroom, they were a tangled island in a sea of someone else’s making, asleep, together, for now.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI