Chapter 3: The Assessor
Ewan put the paper down on my kitchen table, very gently, next to Thessaly. Then he walked out without a word, ducking under the lintel, and I heard his boots go up the hill, steady, not hurrying, until the wind took the sound.
Doll looked at the door. She looked at me.
"Well," she said. "That's island business, then."
"Doll, you don't have to..."
"Your gran mended my father's nets for forty years for nothing but a fish supper, and the Library took that off her with a ledger." Doll folded her arms. "I'm not having some Assembly clerk do the same to her granddaughter with a poster. Island business."
By evening the whole harbour had a plan. It was not a good plan. It mostly involved everyone swearing blind that net jam was an old family recipe, Tobin's or Hobb's or Doll's own grandmother's, depending on who you asked, and me wearing a knitted hat pulled down over my ears until the Assessor's boat had gone.
"It's a very nice hat," said Mrs Tarrant, who had knitted it in an afternoon. It was orange. It had a bobble.
"Thank you," I said, and meant it, and went home and started packing the crate.
"You're running," said Pilcrow.
"I'm being sensible."
"You're running. There's a boat back to the mainland at noon tomorrow. You're going to put the crate on it and yourself beside it and leave all these people holding a story about their grandmothers' jam, and the Assessor will see straight through them, because they are fishermen and not actors, and Tobin Hask goes red when he lies about the weather."
I stopped, a book in each hand. "If I'm not here, there's nothing to find."
"There's a jam shop to find. There's a rope sign that says JAM. There's a harbour full of clean nets." The fern's fronds drooped, very slightly. "And there's a man on that hill who found out the worst thing he could about you this morning, and you're going to let that be the last thing."
I didn't have an answer for that. I was still standing there when someone knocked on the door.
It was full dark. The wind had dropped, which on Gull Island is so unusual it feels like holding your breath. Ewan stood on my step with a wheelbarrow behind him and a lantern hooked over one handle.
"There's a root cellar under my shed," he said, without any greeting. "Dug into the rock. Dry. My mother built one just like it on Skerrin. Nobody on this island knows it's there."
I stared at him.
"The crate," he said, a little impatiently. "Unless you've got a better place."
"Why?"
He looked past me, at the half-packed crate by the hearth, the books stacked beside it. He was quiet for a moment.
"Because she would have," he said.
We loaded the crate into the barrow together. It was heavier than I remembered, or I was more tired. He wheeled it up the hill in silence and I walked beside him carrying the lantern, and neither of us said anything at all until the trapdoor in his shed floor had closed over it and he'd kicked straw across the boards.
"I'm still angry," he said, at the shed door.
"I know."
"Good." He looked at the orange hat, which I'd put on without thinking. Something happened at the corner of his mouth, and was firmly suppressed. "That hat's ridiculous."
"Mrs Tarrant made it."
"I know. She made me one too. Mine's purple." He turned away. "Go to bed, Maren."
It was the first time he'd ever used my name.
The Assessor came on the noon boat on Thursday.
She was not what any of us had expected, which was a large man with a ledger. Linnet Grieve was narrow, neat and quiet, with red hair braided so tightly it looked painful, and a charcoal coat with a white armband, and a locked case under one arm. She stepped off the boat onto the jetty and looked at the harbour the way I used to look at a shelf somebody else had reorganised: slowly, missing nothing, quietly appalled.
She went boat to boat. She looked at the nets. She asked questions in a soft, level voice and wrote the answers down. Tobin told her the jam was his grandmother's recipe, went the colour of a boiled crab and had to sit down. Doll told her it was her own grandmother's recipe and dared her, with her eyes, to say otherwise. Linnet wrote that down too.
Then she walked up the path to my grandmother's cottage, under the rope sign that said JAM, and came in.
I was behind the counter in the orange hat. Pilcrow was on the windowsill, playing a fern, which it did badly because it couldn't stop its fronds from twitching.
"Good afternoon," said Linnet. She set her case down on the counter and looked at the rows of jars. "Are you the proprietor?"
"I make the jam," I said. "It's an old island recipe."
"So I'm told. Several grandmothers, all with the same recipe. Remarkable family resemblance." She picked up a jar of net jam and turned it in the light. Then she put it down, and turned, and looked at the windowsill.
Her face changed.
"That fern," she said slowly. "I know that fern. It sat in the west window of the Restricted reading room. I used to copy indexes next to it, before I joined the Assembly. It told me my handwriting was adequate." She looked back at me, and her pale green eyes went, very deliberately, to my hat. "It was the nicest thing anybody said to me in six years."
"Your handwriting was adequate," said Pilcrow faintly. "I stand by it."
Nobody moved.
And then the door opened behind Linnet, and Ewan Garrow ducked inside, breathing hard, as though he'd run all the way down the hill.
"The jam's mine," he said.
Linnet turned. "I'm sorry?"
"The jam. It's my mother's working. Skerrin hedge-charm for nets. She taught it to me." He didn't look at me. He kept his eyes on Linnet, steady. "Miss Quill sells it for me. She doesn't know how it's made."
"Mr..."
"Garrow."
"Mr Garrow. You understand the penalty for unlicensed spellwork under the new decree is a fine of a hundred marks and forfeit of property." Linnet's voice didn't change at all. "Do you own property on this island?"
"A hill," said Ewan. "And some berries."
I watched him say it. The hill he'd built out of nothing, rock by rock, over six years. The walls. The seaweed and the gorse. The rows his mother would have known.
I took off the hat.
"He's lying," I said. "He's a terrible liar, he just hides it better than Tobin. It's my jam. I made it, out of his berries, which I stole, and a working out of a book that I also stole, from the Restricted Stacks of the Great Library on the night it burned." My voice was shaking. I let it. "I'm the junior librarian on your poster. That's my streak. I'm the one you want."
Ewan said, "Maren," very low, like a warning, or a plea.
"But I didn't steal the books from anyone," I went on, before I could stop. "I stole them from a fire. They're the last copies. Some of them were collected from places like this, from people like his mother, and then locked up so nobody could use them without paying the Library. I know that. I didn't know it properly until I came here, and I'm sorry. But burning them doesn't give anything back. It just means nobody gets them."
Linnet Grieve looked at me for a long time.
"And what," she said, "would you have me do with them?"
I'd been thinking about that since Tuesday. Since a seed packet. Since a man stood in my kitchen and said my mother's spells are probably in that crate.
"Your decree," I said. "I read it. It was posted at the harbour office, so I read it four times, because I'm a librarian and that's what we do. Section six. Folk workings practised for household or trade use within a community, registered with a local registrar, are exempt from licensing." I took a breath. "You wrote it to break the Library's hold on magic. Not to stop people like Doll and Tobin from keeping their nets clean."
"Section six requires a registrar," said Linnet.
"Doll's the harbourmistress. That's a public office. It counts."
"It does count," said Linnet, after a moment. She sounded almost surprised. "And the books?"
"A library," I said. "A real one. Here. Free. Open to anyone who wants to come in and read, no seals, no licences, no ledgers. Anyone in the Sorrel Isles who wants their family's workings back can come and copy them out. You can inspect it whenever you like. I'll even let you sit next to the fern."
Pilcrow made a small noise of outrage. Nobody paid it any attention.
Linnet looked at me, and at Ewan, and at the clean jars in their rows. Then she unlocked her case, took out a form and a pencil, and began to write.
"Gull Island," she said, as she wrote. "One household preserve trade, registered under section six with the local harbourmistress. One public lending library, newly established, open to inspection." She paused. "The junior librarian sought for questioning was not found on the island. Several residents described a fair-haired woman leaving on an earlier boat." She signed it, blotted it and looked up. "I'm not the only Assessor, Miss Quill. The next one may not have copied indexes for a living. Register everything. Keep that hat."
"Thank you," I said. It came out a whisper.
"Don't thank me." Linnet closed her case. At the door she stopped and looked back at the windowsill. "Adequate," she said, to the fern, and something in her neat narrow face very nearly smiled. Then she was gone.
I found Ewan in the rows at dusk.
He was standing at the far wall, looking out at the sea, which had gone the colour of pewter with a long line of gold where the sun was going down. He didn't turn round when I came over the wall. But he moved along a little, to make room.
"You could have lost the hill," I said.
"You could have lost everything."
"I don't have everything. I have a crate and a fern."
"You have a library now. Apparently." He was quiet for a moment. "I went down to the cellar last night, after. I asked Pilcrow which layer." He reached into his oilskin and brought out a thin book bound in green cloth, the Library seal faded on its cover. "Workings of the Strait Islands. Collected. Number four thousand and something. It's got a net charm from Skerrin. Same words she used. I'd forgotten half of them." He turned it over in his purple-stained hands. "Somebody copied it out properly. Every word. Somebody thought it was worth keeping."
"It was."
"I know." He looked at me, finally. "I'm sorry I walked out."
"I'm sorry I didn't tell you. Not explaining. Sorry."
"I know the difference." The corner of his mouth went. This time he let it. "I fixed your roof," he said, "because I wanted you to have a reason to stay. That's all. I'm no good at saying things. So I fixed the roof."
"I kept the seed packet."
He stared at me. "You what?"
"It's in my coat. Inside pocket." I could feel myself going red, and didn't care. "Saucepans are for cooking."
Ewan Garrow, who did not laugh, laughed. It was a startled, rusty, wonderful sound, and it went out over the berry rows and the dry-stone walls and the sea. Then he stepped closer, and put one stained hand very carefully against my cheek, as though I were a cane he was tying in against the wind, and kissed me.
The wind tugged at my coat. Somewhere below us, a gull complained about something, at length.
When we broke apart, he rested his forehead against mine, just for a breath, and said, "Stay."
"I wasn't going anywhere," I said. "I've just opened a library."
From the top of the wall, where I had set its pot down out of the wind, Pilcrow cleared its throat with a sound like pages turning.
"This is lovely," it said. "Truly. And I'd hate to spoil it. But somebody really ought to tell him about the second crate."
Ewan went very still. "The what?"
I closed my eyes.
"Ah," I said. "Yes. About that."