Cover of The Only One That Ever Mattered

The Only One That Ever Mattered

Read the story

1 chapter · 3115 words · Read 0 times

Title Concept: Fallback The Characters & Setup Nikki Martinez: A fiery, curvy Mexican-American Literature major with hazel eyes and blue-to-purple curly hair. Guarded after past heartbreak, she’s trying to navigate college life safely. Harry Styles: Star soccer player, popular frat boy, and Nikki’s long-time crush. The High School Crew: Nikki and Harry share a tight-knit group of friends from high school: Liam Payne & Spencer Hastings, Niall Horan & Hanna Marin, Louis Tomlinson & Aria Montgomery, and Zayn Malik & Emily Fields. The Dynamic: The five boys are best friends, fraternity brothers, and teammates on the university soccer team. The five girls are an unbreakable squad. Because of this shared history, avoiding each other is impossible. The Plot 1. The "Casual" Trap Wanting to protect her heart, Nikki agrees to a secret Friends-With-Benefits dynamic with Harry. The chemistry is electric, but Harry constantly cancels their late-night plans whenever a prettier sorority girl gives him attention. Nikki pretends not to care around Aria, Spencer, Hanna, and Emily, but she secretly hates being his safety net. 2. The Breaking Point After a major soccer win, Harry ditches Nikki to flirt with another girl at a frat party. Furious and heartbroken, Nikki confronts him in a dimly lit dorm hallway. Their fiery argument turns into a hot, angry make-out session pushed against the brick wall, charged with months of unsaid feelings. Nikki pulls away abruptly, teary-eyed, and cuts him off: "I'm done being your fallback, Harry." 3. The Realization Nikki draws a firm boundary, focusing on her studies and going on real dates. Harry spirals without her. Watching her move on snaps him into reality—he realized he hid behind the "casual" label because he was terrified of losing her for real. 4. The Confession Harry corners Nikki outside the campus library, dropping his cool frat-boy persona completely. When Nikki insists she won't be second best, Harry steps close, desperate: "You were never a fallback, Nikki. You were the only one that ever mattered." Nikki is left torn—wondering if he has genuinely changed, or if he's simply too late.

Chapter 1: The Hoodie Rebellion

The fairy lights strung above my bed twinkled like cheap, distant stars. They did nothing to cut through the gloom settled in my chest. The clock on my nightstand ticked past 10 PM. I was sprawled across the messy comforter in a black lace bralette and soft gray sweatpants, my body a live wire of stupid, hopeful anticipation.

An hour. I’d been waiting for an hour.

My phone screen, dark and silent, felt like a personal insult. The air in my dorm room was thick with the scent of my lavender shampoo, the stale dregs of my afternoon coffee, and the cloying sweetness of the melting cookie dough ice cream puddled in the pint beside my knee. My poetry books—Bukowski, Plath, a battered Neruda—lay stacked and ignored. All my sharp words, all my defenses, melted into this pathetic, hopeful goo inside me.

The buzz was a physical shock against my thigh.

I fumbled for it, my heart doing a humiliating little leap. Harry. The green bubble of his message bloomed on the screen.

Can’t make it tonight, babe. The boys are hitting Theta’s party. Last minute thing. Catch you tomorrow?

The words didn’t compute at first. Babe.Tomorrow. They were casual, effortless. Dismissive. The knot in my stomach tightened, cinching until I couldn’t breathe. I typed back, my thumbs clumsy.

Fine. Have fun.

I sent it. Three words that tasted like ash. I stared at the screen, waiting for something more. An apology. A ‘wish you were here.’ A fucking smiley face. Nothing.

“You are such a fucking cliché, Martinez,” I muttered to the empty room. My voice sounded strange.

I opened Instagram, a masochistic reflex. Spencer’s story was at the top. A five-second video. Thumping bass, strobe lights, a sea of red plastic cups. The camera panned, shaky and bright, and there he was.

Harry.

His head was thrown back in a laugh, his curls damp with sweat at his temples. His arm was slung around the shoulders of a blonde in a tiny Theta Rho silk tank top. She was leaned into him, her face tipped up toward his, smiling like she’d just won a prize. The caption read: Celebrating the win!

The win. The soccer game. Yesterday. He’d said he was tired. He’d said he just wanted to crash.

Something sharp and final shattered inside my ribcage. It wasn’t a breaking heart—it was colder than that. It was the sound of the last illusion I’d been clinging to hitting the floor and turning to dust.

A calm, dark clarity washed over me.

I shoved the ice cream pint away. It tipped over, a creamy river staining my Neruda. I didn’t care. I reached behind my back, my fingers deft and furious on the clasp of the bralette. I yanked it off, the lace snapping against my skin, and flung it across the room. It landed on my desk lamp, a sad, black flag of surrender.

I pulled on an old, oversized hoodie—the one from his soccer playoffs two years ago, the fabric soft and worn. I stared at it for a second, then I put it on. I wanted to wear the relic of who he used to be, the ghost of a guy who might have cared, while I buried the current one.

My phone buzzed again in my hand. The group chat with my girls.

Spencer: Theta party is mid. Too many bros in polos. Liam is debating the offside rule with a wall. Send help.

Hanna: Niall just tried to do a keg stand and almost took out the DJ table. I’m documenting for blackmail. You coming, Nik?

Aria: The energy here is… aggressive. Louis is winning at beer pong but losing at human decency. We need your commentary.

Emily: Zayn says the music is trash. He’s not wrong. Where are you?

I looked at the photo Spencer had posted still burning behind my eyes. I saw his hand on that girl’s shoulder. His easy smile.

My thumbs flew over the screen.

Nikki: Change of plans. I’m going out.

Spencer: ?

Hanna: YES. Wear the black dress. The one that makes you look like a vengeful goddess.

Nikki: Already on it.

I wasn’t. I was standing in the middle of my room, breathing hard. But the plan was already forming, cold and calculated. I wouldn’t hide. I wouldn’t cry into my melted ice cream. I would walk right into the belly of the beast. I would let him see me. I would let him watch me not giving a single, solitary fuck.

I stripped off the sweatpants and the hoodie. I went to my closet and pulled out the dress Hanna mentioned. It was tight, short, and black as a moonless night. The fabric clung to every curve. I swiped on dark red lipstick, smudged kohl around my hazel eyes until they looked sharp and dangerous. I left my hair down, the blue-to-purple curls a chaotic cascade around my shoulders.

I looked at my reflection. I looked hard. I looked like someone who could break a heart instead of having one broken.

“Watch me,” I whispered to the ghost of him in my room.

The door slammed behind me with a finality that echoed down the empty hall. The thump of bass from the Theta house three blocks away was already a pulse in the night air, a summoning drum. I started walking, my heels clicking a sharp, steady rhythm on the pavement.

The party was a living organism, spilling out onto the lawn. I pushed through the crowded doorway, the heat and the smell of beer and cheap perfume hitting me like a wall. My eyes scanned the room, a predator’s cool sweep.

I saw my friends first. Liam and Spencer by the keg, deep in debate. Niall and Hanna by the dance floor, laughing. Aria and Louis near the stairs, his hand on her lower back. Emily and Zayn leaning against a wall, judging everything with identical amused smirks.

Then I saw him.

Harry was by the makeshift bar, a red cup in his hand. The blonde from the photo was still attached to his side, her hand on his arm. He was smiling, but it didn’t reach his eyes. They looked distracted, bored even.

Good.

I didn’t go to him. I walked straight to the center of the dance floor where the bodies were packed tight and the music was a physical force. I started to move, letting the rhythm take me. I closed my eyes, tipped my head back, and just felt it. I knew the exact moment he saw me. I felt it like a change in atmospheric pressure.

When I opened my eyes, he was staring. The smile was gone. The blonde was saying something to him, but he wasn’t listening. His green eyes were locked on me, wide, confused. A flicker of something that looked like panic.

I smiled. I let my gaze slide over him like he was a stranger, a mildly interesting piece of decor. Then I turned, giving him my back, and swayed deeper into the crowd.

A hand landed on my hip. Not his. Someone else’s. I looked over my shoulder. It was a guy from my Lit seminar. Ben. Tall, broad-shouldered, with a nice smile and zero baggage.

“Hey, Nikki,” he shouted over the music. “Didn’t expect to see you here.”

“Yeah,” I said, turning to face him. “Last minute decision.”

His eyes traveled down my dress, appreciative and warm. “It’s a good decision.”

He was closer now. The space between us vanished. His body was solid against mine as we moved. I could feel his heat through the thin fabric of my dress. I let my hands rest on his shoulders. I laughed at something he said, a bright, empty sound. I could feel Harry’s stare burning a hole between my shoulder blades.

The heat from Ben's hands on my hips was a tangible counterpoint to the ice in my veins. I let my head fall back, my curls brushing his chest, and laughed again—a sound too loud, too sharp. I could map Harry's exact location by the intensity of that stare, a laser tracking my every move.

"Want another drink?" Ben murmured, his lips close to my ear.

"God, yes."

He took my hand, his fingers lacing through mine, and led me through the throng. I didn't look back. We pushed up to the sticky kitchen counter, where some frat pledge was haphazardly mixing vodka with bright blue concoctions. Ben got us two cups. I downed half of mine in one burning gulp.

"Easy there," Ben chuckled.

"Thirsty," I said, meeting his eyes. They were brown, warm. Safe. Nothing like the stormy, confused green currently dissecting me from across the room.

Out of the corner of my eye, I saw Spencer detach from Liam and stride toward Harry. Her expression was pure thunder. Good. Let her rip into him. But then Liam was following, catching her arm, saying something low. The mediator. Always. My chest tightened.

"Hey." Ben tilted my chin back toward him. "You okay? You seem... somewhere else."

I forced a smile. "Just enjoying the view."

I leaned in and kissed him. It wasn't gentle. It was a claiming. A statement. His mouth was surprised but willing, tasting of cheap vodka and mint gum. His arms wrapped around me, pulling me flush against him. I poured every ounce of my performance into it, hoping to God it looked real from twenty feet away.

When we broke apart, I was breathless. Ben’s eyes were darkened with genuine desire. “Your room or mine?” he asked, voice rough.

The word was on my tongue. Mine. A clean break. A new memory to overwrite the old ones.

“Nikki.

The voice cut through the muffled bass and the rush in my ears. It was low, taut, and it belonged to only one person. I didn’t need to turn to know Harry was standing there, close enough that I could feel the heat of his body disrupting the air around me.

Ben’s hands slowly dropped from my waist. I stepped back, putting an inch of space between us, and turned.

Harry stood with his shoulders set like he was braced for a hit. His green eyes were locked on me, dark and unreadable in the strobe-lit chaos. The easy charm was gone, stripped away, leaving something raw underneath. The blonde from earlier was nowhere in sight.

“What?” My voice came out flat, a challenge.

“We need to talk.” He didn’t shout, but the words carried over the music like they were wired directly into my bones.

Ben cleared his throat. “Hey, man, we were kinda in the middle of—”

“It’s fine, Ben.” I didn’t look away from Harry. “Give me a second.”

Ben’s smile faltered. He shrugged, shot Harry a wary look, and melted back toward the kitchen. The space he left felt charged, too big and too small all at once.

Harry moved then. He closed the distance in two strides, his hand wrapping around my wrist. His grip was firm, almost painful. “Outside. Now.”

I could have yanked free. I could have told him to go to hell. But the heat of his skin against mine, the sheer audacity of him after that text, after that photo, lit a fuse inside me. I wanted to see this play out. I wanted to crack that cool exterior and see what spilled.

“Fine.” I let him pull me through the crowd.

He shouldered through bodies without apology, his path a straight line to the back door. We spilled out into the alley behind the house. The sudden quiet was a shock, broken only by the thud of bass through the walls and the distant hum of the city. The air was cool, smelling of damp concrete and garbage.

He didn’t let go. He backed me against the rough brick wall, his body caging me in. “What was that?”

“What was what?” I kept my voice even, bored. “I was dancing.”

“You were grinding on some fucking Lit major you’ve mentioned twice.” His breath hit my face, tinged with beer and mint. “You were letting him put his hands all over you.”

“And?” I tilted my head. “You were busy. I found other entertainment. It’s not complicated.”

His jaw clenched. A muscle ticked in his cheek. “You’re doing this to punish me.”

I laughed, a short, harsh sound. “Punish you? Harry, you flatter yourself. I was having a good time. Something you clearly didn’t want to be a part of.”

“That’s bullshit.” He leaned in closer, his free hand coming up to brace against the wall by my head. “You knew I’d see. You wore that dress. You came here.”

“Maybe I just like the dress.” I shifted, my chest brushing against his. I saw his eyes drop, saw the hunger flicker there before he masked it. “Maybe I just wanted to get laid by someone who doesn’t cancel last minute with a shitty text.”

His control snapped.

His mouth crashed down on mine. It wasn’t a kiss; it was a collision. All teeth and desperation, a brutal claiming. He tasted like rage and regret and cheap whiskey. I bit his lip, hard, and he groaned, deepening the kiss, his tongue forcing its way into my mouth. My hands came up, not to push him away, but to fist in the fabric of his shirt, pulling him closer. The anger between us was a live wire, sparking into something hotter, more destructive.

He broke the kiss, breathing ragged. “You want to get laid?” His voice was a rough scrape against my ear. “Then let’s go.”

He didn’t wait for an answer. He grabbed my hand again and pulled me down the alley, away from the party. We didn’t speak. The night air whipped against my heated skin. My heels clicked a frantic rhythm on the pavement, matching the pounding in my chest. He led me to his house, a run-down brownstone a few blocks from campus that he shared with Liam and Niall.

The living room was dark, empty. He barely paused, pulling me up the narrow stairs to his bedroom. He kicked the door shut behind us.

The room was all him—messy, familiar. Soccer gear piled in a corner, band posters on the walls, the bed unmade. The only light came from a streetlamp outside, casting long shadows.

He turned to me, his chest rising and falling. “Last chance to walk away.”

I stepped out of my heels. I reached for the hem of my dress and pulled it over my head in one fluid motion. I stood there in just my black lace panties, the cool air raising goosebumps on my skin. “Shut up, Harry.”

A raw sound tore from his throat. He crossed the room in two steps, his hands grasping my hips, fingers digging into my flesh as he backed me toward the bed. His mouth found mine again, softer now but no less hungry. He kissed me like he was starving, like he was trying to consume me whole. I pushed his jersey up, my nails scraping over the hard planes of his stomach, and he broke away long enough to yank it over his head.

His skin was hot under my palms. I traced the familiar lines of his torso, the definition earned on the soccer field. He fumbled with the button of his jeans, shoved them down along with his boxers. His cock sprang free, thick and fully hard, and he kicked his clothes aside.

He looked at me, his eyes burning in the half-light. “On the bed. Now.”

I lay back, the sheets cool against my skin. He followed, his weight settling over me, his knees pushing my thighs apart. He didn’t tease. He didn’t ask. He positioned himself at my entrance, the head of his cock nudging against me. I was already wet, aching, my body betraying every smart thought I’d ever had.

“Look at me,” he said, his voice gravel.

I met his gaze. In that second, I saw past the fury—the fear, the vulnerability he hid from everyone. Then he pushed inside.

It was a slow, relentless invasion, stretching me, filling me completely. A gasp ripped from my throat. He held himself there, buried to the hilt, his body trembling with the effort of restraint.

“You feel that?” he whispered, his forehead against mine. “That’s me. Not him. Me.”

I hooked my legs around his waist, my heels digging into his back. “Then fuck me like you mean it.”

He withdrew almost all the way and drove back in, hard. A cry tore from my lips. He set a brutal, punishing pace, each thrust slamming the bed into the wall with a rhythmic thud. There was no tenderness, just raw, grinding need. The pleasure was sharp, almost painful, coiling tight in my core with every deep stroke.

His mouth was on my neck, sucking marks into my skin that I’d have to hide tomorrow. One hand tangled in my hair, holding my head in place. The other slid between our bodies, his thumb finding my clit, circling it with rough, perfect pressure.

“You’re so fucking tight,” he grunted, his breath hot against my ear. “Always so good for me. Come on, Nikki. Come for me.”

His words, his touch, the overwhelming fullness of him—it was too much. The coil snapped. My orgasm hit me like a shockwave, violent and blinding. My back arched off the bed, a silent scream on my lips as I convulsed around him, my inner muscles clenching rhythmically on his cock.

The sight of me coming undid him. His rhythm fractured. With a guttural groan, he buried himself deep and stilled, his whole body shuddering as he pulsed inside me. Heat flooded my core.

He collapsed on top of me, his weight solid, his sweat-slick skin sticking to mine. We lay there in the silent, dark room, the only sounds our ragged breaths and the distant echo of the party we’d left behind.

Slowly, he rolled to the side, taking me with him, tucking me against his chest. His heart hammered under my ear. His fingers traced idle patterns on my bare shoulder.

The emptiness returned, colder now. The anger had burned out, leaving only ashes and the stark reality of his come leaking inside me. He’d won. Again.

I closed my eyes, listening to his breathing even out. Tomorrow, there would be words. There would be consequences. But for now, in the dark, I let the numbness settle in, a familiar shield against the hope that was already, stupidly, trying to spark back to life.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI