Chapter 2: Building Tension
The dorm room was a stark contrast to Bethany's, smaller and more cluttered. Posters of classic rock bands adorned the walls, their faded edges a testament to their longevity. The scent of cheap cologne was omnipresent, lingering in the air like an uninvited guest. A red velvet strap-on, a mischievous secret, hung from a peg on the wall, its presence both menacing and alluring.
Josh stood nervously in the doorway, his knuckles white from gripping his backpack straps.
Bethany had warned him to be discreet, but the mere act of knocking on her door had sent a shiver down his spine. He was new to this, and the unfamiliarity of the situation made his heart race even faster.
Bethany opened the door, her eyes scanning him from head to toe. “Hey, Josh. Come on in,” she said, her voice warm and inviting. She stood to the side, allowing him to enter the small dorm room.
Josh stepped inside, his eyes darting around the room, taking in the posters and the strap-on dangling from the peg on the wall.
He looked down at the floor, his cheeks flaming with embarrassment. "Hi," he mumbled, his voice barely above a whisper.
Bethany closed the door behind him, a soft click signaling their privacy. She walked over to him, her hips swaying gently, and placed a hand on his shoulder. "So Tyler told you about me huh?"
Bethany said, her voice playful as she guided Josh to sit on her bed. She sat down beside him, close enough that he could feel the warmth radiating from her body.
Josh nodded, his eyes flicking to the strap-on before quickly looking back to Bethany. "Yeah, he said… he said you were good at making people feel… comfortable."
Bethany laughed softly, brushing a strand of hair away from Josh's face. "That's one way to put it," she said, her eyes sparkling with amusement.
Josh noticed Beth's roommate on the other side of the room snort. "I see you have fresh meat Beth." Mia called out from across the room, twirling a lock of her pink hair around her finger.
Bethany rolled her eyes playfully. "Mia, be nice. Josh, this is Mia, my roommate."
Josh looked over at Mia and offered a shy wave. "Hi Mia."
Mia smiled back, her eyes scanning Josh appreciatively. "Hey Josh, it's nice to meet you." She paused, then added, "You're new here, right? I don't think I've seen you around before."
Josh nodded. "Yeah, I'm a freshman." Just started this semester," Josh replied, his voice still soft but gaining a little more confidence.
Bethany smiled warmly at him. "Don't worry, we'll make sure you feel right at home." She turned to Mia, a mischievous glint in her eye. "Mia, why don't you help Josh get comfortable while I get things ready?"
Mia raised an eyebrow but complied, walking over to Josh and sitting down next to him. She nudged him playfully. "So, Josh, what brings you to Bethany's door?"
Josh hesitated for a moment before answering.
"Well, I... I heard Tyler talking about Bethany’s sessions. He said she... she pegs guys, and I, uh, I thought it might be something I’d be interested in trying."
Mia’s eyes widened in surprise. “Pegging? You’re a freshman and you’re already into that? You’re braver than I thought.” She leaned in closer to Josh, her voice dropping to a conspiratorial whisper. “Don’t worry, though. Bethany’s great at it. She’ll make sure you feel good.”
Josh nodded, appreciation in his eyes.
"Thanks, Mia. I guess I'm just curious about things. I want to explore and...experience new things."
Mia grinned, "Well, you've come to the right place then. Bethany is all about new experiences." She looked over at Bethany, who was now slipping on the harness, her movements fluid and practiced. "She's really good at what she does, you know. She knows how to make a guy feel totally at ease."
Josh looked back at Bethany, his eyes taking in her confident movements. "She seems like she knows what she's doing."
Mia laughed, "Oh, she definitely does.
Now, Josh, let's get you a bit more comfortable. Mind if I make myself at home while Bethany does her thing?" She patted the bed beside her, inviting him to sit.
Josh nodded, his heart pounding in his chest as he scooted over to make room for her. "Sure, that's fine," he said, his voice barely a whisper.
Mia settled in next to him, her shoulder brushing against his. She turned to face him, her eyes sparkling with mischief. "So, tell me, Josh. What do you like?
What are your fantasies?" Mia asked, her voice low and playful.
Josh blushed, looking down at his hands. "I, uh, I like things...different. I like the idea of giving up control, of being...used."
Mia hummed, running a finger along Josh's arm. "Interesting. So you're a little submissive, huh? Don't worry, that's totally hot. Bethany loves when her boys are submissive."
Josh nodded, his breath hitching slightly as Mia's touch sent shivers down his spine. "Yeah, I guess I am."
"Why don't you take off your clothes for me josh?" Mia winked.
"Good boy. Let's see what you've got."
Josh took a deep breath and started to unbutton his shirt, his fingers fumbling slightly with nerves. Mia watched him, her eyes filled with curiosity and mischief. She reached out and helped him, her fingers brushing against his skin as she unbuttoned the rest of his shirt.
"That's it," she said softly, encouragingly. "Keep going."
Josh nodded, his breath coming in shallow gasps. He slipped out of his shirt and tossed it onto the floor, his eyes avoiding Mia's gaze.
She smiled, reaching out to gently touch his chest, her fingertips tracing the lines of his muscles.
"You're cute, Josh," she murmured. "A little shy, but cute."
Josh blushed at the compliment, his hands moving to his belt. He unbuckled it, his fingers shaking slightly as he undid the button and zipper of his jeans.
He pushed them down, along with his boxers, until they were bunched around his ankles. He kicked them off, standing before Mia in just his socks.
Mia grinned, her eyes roaming over his body appreciatively.
"Very nice, Josh. Now, why don't you get on the bed for me? Hands and knees."
Josh hesitated for a moment, his cheeks flaming with a mix of embarrassment and arousal. Mia saw the hesitation and nudged him gently. "Go on, Josh. You'll feel so much better once you let go."
Josh took a deep breath and climbed onto the bed, positioning himself on his hands and knees as instructed. He felt vulnerable and exposed, but there was also a thrill of anticipation coursing through him.
Bethany, now fully prepared, stepped up to the bed.
She looked at Josh, his body trembling with nerves and anticipation. "You okay, Josh?" she asked, her voice soft yet commanding.
Josh nodded, his breathing ragged. "Yeah, I think so," he managed to say.
Bethany smiled reassuringly. Remember, all you have to do is breathe and relax. Let go of any worries or fears. I've got you."
She poured some lube onto her fingers and began to gently massage Josh's entrance, circling it slowly, allowing him time to adjust to the sensation. Josh let out a small gasp, his body tensing slightly.
Then, all at once, Beth entered him.
Josh yelped at the intrusion, his body tensing. Mia, seeing his reaction, moved to his side and rubbed his back, her voice soft and soothing.
"Shh, it's okay, Josh. Breathe through it. It'll feel better soon," she cooed.
Beth paused, allowing Josh to adjust. "That's right, Josh. Just breathe. In and out. You're doing great."
Josh followed her advice, his breathing becoming more rhythmic as the initial shock subsided. He felt Beth moving slowly, her hips pushing against his ass, the strap-on going deeper with each thrust.
The initial discomfort began to fade, replaced by a growing pleasure that spread through him like wildfire. He could feel every inch of her moving inside him, filling him completely.
"How does that feel, Josh?" Beth asked softly, her voice a mix of authority and concern.
Josh took a deep breath, his body relaxing further into the sensation. "It feels... good. Really good," he admitted, his voice barely above a whisper.
Mia smiled, her hand still rubbing circles on his back. "See, Josh? I told you Beth knows what she's doing."
Beth nodded, her pace quickening slightly.
Mia went back to studying as Josh was fucked back on Beth's bed. She couldn't help but crack a smile every time she heard the freshman's squeals. He was pretty cute.
Not that it mattered. Bethany was all business tonight. She wanted to make this little freshman squeal in ways he had only dreamed about. She picked up the pace, her hips slamming into him, the sound of flesh on flesh filling the room. Josh’s moans grew louder, his body moving with her rhythm.
“That’s it, Josh. Take it like a good boy,” Bethany commanded, her voice firm yet encouraging. Josh panted, his muscles tensing as he pushed back against her, meeting her thrusts with eagerness.
Mia watched from her desk, a smirk playing on her lips.
She had heard the freshman's confession and knew he was new to this, but there was a thrill in watching him discover his own limits. "You should see your face, Josh," she commented, looking up from her book. "You look like you're in heaven."
Josh couldn't respond, his breath coming in short gasps as Bethany continued to pound into him. He could feel the pleasure building, threatening to overwhelm him. It was unlike anything he had ever experienced, and he never wanted it to stop.
Bethany could see the ecstasy on Josh's face and felt a sense of pride.
She loved watching her boys come undone, surrendering to their desires and letting go of their inhibitions. She leaned forward, her breath hot on Josh's ear. "You're doing so well, Josh. I'm so proud of you," she whispered, her voice a low purr.
Josh whimpered in response, his body trembling with the force of his pleasure. "Thank you, Beth. I... I never knew it could feel like this."
Mia grinned from her desk, her eyes glued to the spectacle unfolding on the bed. "You're doing great, Josh.
Just let yourself go," Bethany encouraged, her hands gripping his hips tighter. She could feel the tension in his body, the eagerness to let go and come undone.
Josh nodded, his body trembling with the effort to hold on. "Feels so good, Beth. Don't stop," he managed to choke out between breaths.
Bethany smirked, her hips moving faster and harder. "I won't stop, baby. I'm going to make you come so hard you'll see stars."
Mia watched, her eyes wide with fascination.
She had never seen someone so completely consumed by pleasure before. It was intoxicating, watching Josh's body writhe and twist as Bethany brought him closer and closer to the edge.
"Fuck, Beth, I'm close," Josh gasped, his body tensing up as he fought to hold on.
Bethany smiled, her voice a low growl in his ear. "Let go, Josh. Give in to it. Come for me."
Josh tried to hold back, but the sensation was too much. His body convulsed, his cock spasming as he came, his orgasm ripping through him like a freight train.
Josh let out a long, guttural moan, his hips bucking back against Beth's, his body trembling with the force of his release.
Beth smiled, her breath hot on his ear. "That's it, baby. Let it all out." She continued to move inside him, slowing her pace to let him ride out his orgasm.
Mia watched from her desk, her eyes wide with fascination. She had never witnessed anything quite like this before. The way Josh was completely consumed by pleasure was mesmerizing. She could feel her own body responding to the sight, a warmth blossoming between her legs.
When Josh collected himself, he was beet red. They all always were after getting fucked. Mia smiled at him and winked. "What a good boy you turned out to be," Mia cooed. "Look at you, all flushed and satisfied. You look beautiful when you come apart like that."
Josh blushed even deeper, his cheeks apple red. "Thank you, Mia. That was...incredible."
Bethany slowly pulled out of him, her harness making a soft suction sound as it left his body. She smiled at him, her eyes soft with satisfaction.
"You were amazing, Josh. Really took to it like a pro."
Josh grinned, his body still tingling with aftershocks. "Thanks, Beth. That was...wow.
I don't know what to say."
Bethany laughed softly, running a hand through his hair. "You don't have to say anything. Just enjoy the afterglow."
Josh nodded, his body still humming with pleasure. He looked over at Mia, who was still watching them, a slight smile on her face. "Thanks for... helping," he said, his voice still breathless. "No problem, cutie. It was fun watching you squeal."
Josh blushed again, but there was a hint of pride in his eyes. He had done something new, something daring, and it had felt amazing.
Josh looked at Bethany, his eyes filled with wonder and gratitude. I never imagined it would be like that."
Bethany smiled, her eyes warm and tender. "That's the beauty of exploration, Josh. You never know what you'll find until you try." She handed him a towel to clean up and dressed him in one of her oversized hoodies.
Mia, who had been watching the entire scene with amusement, stood up and stretched. "Well, that was quite the show. I think I need a drink after that." She glanced at Josh and winked. "You were great. By the way, I saw your underwear got a lot of cum on it when you shot out all your spunk. Here's a pair of my panties." Mia tossed a pair of her underwear to Josh. "Clean yourself up with those."
Josh caught them, his face flushing. "Thanks, Mia."
Mia laughed, "No problem, cute stuff. Now, scram. Beth and I need some alone time."
Josh nodded, pulling on the hoodie Bethany handed him and tucking his own clothes under his arm. He looked at Bethany, a shy smile on his face. I'll, uh, see you around campus, right?"
Bethany smiled warmly. "Of course, Josh.
See you around," Bethany replied, giving him a small wave as he made his way to the door. She waited until he had left before turning to Mia, who was laughing softly.
"What?" Bethany asked, a smirk playing on her lips.
"Nothing, just... that face. That look of sheer bliss. It's priceless," Mia said, still chuckling.
Bethany grinned and nodded. "I know, right? There's nothing quite like the look on their faces when they come for the first time. It's... intoxicating."
Mia nodded in agreement. "It really is.
And Josh... he was something else. Most freshmen take a while to warm up, but he was just eager and ready to go. It's like he was born to be pegged." Mia said, a playful glint in her eye.
Bethany laughed, "Yeah, he was a natural. I think we may have created a monster there. I can see him coming back for more."
Mia smirked, "Well, that's a good thing, right? More customers for you. Speaking of which, how much did you charge him?"
Mia asked, her eyes still gleaming with amusement.
Bethany shrugged, walking over to her mini-fridge and pulling out two beers. She tossed one to Mia, who caught it with ease. "Same rate as usual. You know, the special freshman discount."
Mia grinned, popping the top off her beer and taking a sip. "You're too good to them, you know that? Giving out discounts like that. You should charge them full price."
Bethany shook her head, taking a drink from her own beer. "Nah, I like giving them a little break.
Besides, they usually come back for more once they get a taste," Bethany replied, taking a swig of her beer. "Besides, I know what it's like to be a broke college student. A little discount here and there doesn't hurt."
Mia rolled her eyes playfully. "You're such a softie, Beth. You're gonna go broke with all your discounts."
Bethany just smiled, leaning back against her desk chair. "Worth it if it makes someone's day. Now, enough about the business, how are your classes going?"
Mia sighed dramatically, flopping down on her bed.