Chapter 3: The Tasting
They had five days.
Julian took the numbers. Lena took the food. That was the deal they made at three in the morning on the Lumen kitchen floor, after Eleanor's cane had tapped away down the hall, and neither of them went home for very long after that.
He set up in the empty private dining room with two laptops and a stack of binders, sleeves rolled, glasses pushed up into his hair, and pulled apart every dollar Lumen had lost in six years. The produce contract that overcharged them. The linen service billing for twice the tablecloths they used. The ancient walk-in compressor eating power like it was paid by the hour. And the real reason for the vote: a glossy offer from a restaurant group out of Las Vegas that wanted to gut the fifty-second floor and turn it into a steakhouse with a celebrity name on the door and a DJ booth where the piano used to be.
"The lease would make money," Julian said on Monday night, rubbing his eyes. "On paper. For three years. Then the novelty wears off, they renegotiate, and the best room in Chicago becomes a place where bachelor parties go to take photos of the lake."
"So we make Lumen make more money than that."
"In five days."
"In four," said Lena, "if you keep talking."
Her side was harder. She had a kitchen with a dead fryer, a crew who'd been told for years that they were about to be closed, and a chef who'd stopped believing in his own menu. So she started with the crew. She asked each of them for one dish that meant something, not a fancy one, a real one. Teodoro brought his grandmother's pozole verde. Ana brought sour cherry dumplings. Desmond, embarrassed, brought the Italian beef sandwich his father made every Sunday on the South Side. Marco said he didn't have anything, and then on Tuesday came in early with a container of smoked whitefish dip that he said was nothing, just a thing he made at home, and that made Lena close her eyes when she tasted it.
"That's not nothing," she said. "That's the first course."
On Wednesday afternoon, Denise Ward rode two buses and the Red Line to North Michigan Avenue in her transit jacket, walked into the most expensive hotel in Chicago without a flicker of hesitation, and stood at Lena's elbow in the Lumen kitchen pinching pierogi dough for three hours.
"Fifty-two floors," she said, looking out the pass window at the lake. "You know, I used to drive past this building every day on the Number 3. Never once looked up."
"Me neither, Ma."
"Well." Denise crimped a perfect edge. "Look up now."
Vivienne came on Wednesday night, after Denise had gone.
Lena was alone, testing a burnt-honey custard for the fourth time. She heard the gardenia perfume before she heard the footsteps. Vivienne stood just inside the kitchen door in an ivory coat, holding her car keys in a fist, looking at the steel and the flames and the hanging tickets as if they were a foreign country.
"Was that her?" Vivienne said. "This afternoon. In the elevator. The woman in the jacket."
Lena set down her spoon. "That was Denise."
"She smiled at me." Vivienne's voice was very even. "She didn't know who I was. She just smiled at me like I was anybody. Like I was a person on her bus."
Lena didn't say anything. She took one of the leftover pierogi from the pan, still warm, browned in butter with onions the way Denise had made them every Christmas Eve of Lena's life, put it on a small plate and held it out.
Vivienne looked at it for a long time. Then she took it, and ate it standing up, in her ivory coat, in silence. When she was done, she put the plate on the counter very carefully, as though it might break.
"This doesn't change anything," she said.
"I know," said Lena.
"Good." Vivienne turned to go. At the door, without looking back, she added, "The board members are seated by seniority. Harlan Price hates cilantro and lies about it. Margaret won't eat anything she has to cut in public." A pause. "I'm not helping you. I just don't want to sit through a bad lunch."
She left. Lena stood alone in the kitchen with the custard going cold, and then went and took the cilantro out of the second course.
The board of Ashcombe Hotels sat down at the long table in Lumen's dining room at noon on Thursday, nine people and a lake full of light.
Lena had pulled the tablecloths and let the old walnut show. She'd moved the table to the north windows, where you could see the whole curve of the shoreline. No harpist, no ice sculpture. Just plates, coming out one after the other, each one carried by the cook who'd made it.
Marco's whitefish dip with rye crackers and pickled onion. Teodoro's pozole, refined and bright, in small white bowls. Desmond's Italian beef, rebuilt as a single perfect slice of braised short rib on a crisp of bread, with a giardiniera so sharp it made a board member named Harlan Price laugh out loud. Denise's pierogi with brown butter and smoked trout roe. Ana's sour cherry dumplings in a clear, sweet broth.
With each course, the cook stood at the end of the table and said, in a few words, where it came from. Pilsen. Back of the Yards. Bridgeport. A kitchen in Bronzeville in the nineties. Teodoro's hands shook during his. By the third course, nobody's did.
Between courses, Julian stood up with his binder and did the other thing. He laid the numbers out the way you'd lay out a knife roll: clean, quick, every one in its place. The cut contracts. The repaired equipment. The private dining room booked for the holiday season, which nobody had bothered to market in years and which Vivienne's brand team had, unexpectedly and without explanation, quietly started promoting on Tuesday. A three-year projection that, if it held, made Lumen more money than the Las Vegas lease and kept every one of thirty-one jobs.
Charles Ashcombe listened with his arms folded. "Pretty food," he said, when Julian sat down. "Pretty numbers. And a line cook with a famous last name running the most visible room in the company. That's a story the press will love, right up until the first bad review."
"Then I'd better not get one," said Lena.
A few people at the table laughed. Charles didn't.
Lena turned to the kitchen door. "Last course," she said.
It was the burnt-honey custard. She'd found it on Monday, in the hallway, in a menu from 1989 that had been framed behind glass and forgotten: Burnt Honey Tart, the chef's own, served with a pinch of salt and a curl of orange. There was no recipe anywhere. She'd tested it nine times from a two-line description and a photo, until the color of the caramel matched the color in the faded picture, until the salt came in exactly when the sweetness was about to be too much.
She set the first plate in front of Eleanor Ashcombe herself.
The old woman looked down at it. She did not pick up her spoon. For a long moment she sat entirely still, both hands folded on the silver hare of her cane, and the table went quiet without knowing why.
Then she ate one bite. Then another. When she put the spoon down, her gray-green eyes were bright and wet, and she did not trouble to hide it.
"He made this," she said, to no one in particular, "the night we opened. He burned the first batch. He said he'd meant to." She looked up at Lena. "You burned it on purpose."
"Just at the edge," said Lena. "That's where the flavor is."
Eleanor was quiet for another moment. Then she turned to the table. "The vote," she said. "Those in favor of closing Lumen."
Charles raised his hand. One other board member raised theirs, glanced around, and slowly lowered it again.
"Opposed."
Eleanor raised hers first. Then Harlan Price. Then, one after another, all the way down the walnut table, until the only hand not raised was Charles's, folded back across his chest.
Margaret Ashcombe, at the far end, raised hers last. She was looking at Lena when she did it, the way she'd looked at her in that first room full of windows: frightened, almost, and something else behind it that might have been hope.
The roof of the Ashcombe was not technically open to anyone. Julian had a key.
It was dusk when they went up, the lake going violet, the city coming on one window at a time below them, the wind off the water cold enough to make Lena's eyes sting. She still had the bandana on. She'd forgotten about it hours ago. Thirty-one people had hugged her in the Lumen kitchen afterward, Marco twice, and he'd had to go stand in the walk-in for a while.
"You were magnificent," Julian said. He was standing beside her at the parapet with his hands in his overcoat pockets. "I want that on the record. I've watched people take that board apart with lawyers. You did it with a tart."
"You did it with a binder."
"The binder was supporting cast."
"The binder was great." She looked at him. "Your numbers were great. You were great. And you sat on my kitchen floor in a suit that costs more than my car, and you told me the truth when it would've been easier not to, and you're still here." She swallowed. "I'm not good at this part. I'm good at heat and timing. I don't really know what to do when it isn't on fire."
Julian took his glasses off. He folded them and tucked them into his breast pocket, slowly, and she understood by now what that meant.
"Then let me," he said quietly.
He reached up and untied the bandana. Her curls came loose in the wind, and he pushed them back from her face with one careful hand, as if he'd been thinking about doing it for a long time. Then he bent his head and kissed her.
It was slow and certain and a little unsteady, as if he'd surprised himself. Lena curled her fingers into the lapels of his coat and held on, fifty-two floors up, in the cold, with the whole city lighting up beneath them, and for once in her life didn't think about what came next.
When they broke apart, he rested his forehead against hers and laughed, low and disbelieving. "I've been very professional for three weeks," he said. "I'd like that noted, too."
"Noted," said Lena, and kissed him again.
His phone buzzed in his coat pocket. He ignored it. It buzzed again. And again. On the fourth time he swore softly, pulled it out to silence it, and then stopped.
Lena watched his face change. She had learned to read it, these past weeks: the way it went smooth and quiet when he was angry, the way his jaw set before bad news.
"What?" she said.
"Two weeks ago, I asked a friend to look into the hospital. Mercy Lakeshore. The night you were born." He didn't look up from the screen. "I didn't tell you, because I didn't think it would find anything. Hospitals make mistakes. It happens."
"Julian. What?"
He turned the phone so she could see it. A scanned document, old and slightly crooked: a bank transfer, twenty-six years old, for fifty thousand dollars. Paid to a woman named Rosalind Petrie, a night-shift nurse on the maternity ward at Mercy Lakeshore. Paid three days after the two baby girls were born.
Paid from a private Ashcombe family trust.
At the bottom, in faded blue ink, was the signature that had authorized it. Lena had seen it that very afternoon, at the head of the board minutes, sharp and slanting and unmistakable.
E. Ashcombe.
Below them, far down on Michigan Avenue, a long black car pulled away from the hotel's front doors. Lena watched it go, and thought of an old woman with her own eyes, crying over a burnt-honey tart, and of a single question she had not been ready to ask until this moment.
Not what she was owed.
Why.