Chapter 1: Building Tension
As soon as Shalem walked in the door, Mitch couldn't wait to tell him about the bizarre experience he had with the appliance repair man, Matt. "You won't believe what happened," Mitch said, his eyes wide with disbelief. "That guy actually propositioned me while he was fixing our washing machine!" Shalem's jaw dropped and he stood in shock as Mitch continued to recount the strange encounter.
As the words tumbled out of Mitch's mouth, they sounded like something straight out of a steamy movie scene. He spoke of Matt, a charming and attractive man who had confessed to hooking up with guys in the past, despite being straight. Mitch himself was married, and as Matt casually asked if his husband would mind him engaging in another hookup, Mitch couldn't help but wonder if maybe Shalem, had put Matt up to this. However, Shalem denied any involvement.
Mitch then revealed that he had asked Matt about the possibility of a threesome and to his surprise, Matt had eagerly agreed. In fact, he even gave Mitch his number in case Shalem decided to join in on the fun.
Shalem's eyes hardened as he spoke, his voice laced with an edge of possessiveness. "I wouldn't be okay with you being inside of another guy." he stated firmly. "But if you wanted to share me with another guy I that sounds hot." They talked about boundaries and what was off limits and ended up deciding that Mitch was fine with Shalem getting fucked by another guy, and Shalem was fine with anything other than Mitch entering another guy. Kissing, blowing, and touching was okay for everyone.
Mitch sat at his desk, twirling his pen between his fingers as he stared at his computer screen. He couldn't focus on work, not with the thought of Matt's toned body and big cock still fresh in his mind. Shalem had given him the green light to explore this threesome with Matt, and now it was up to Mitch to make it happen.
Without hesitation, Mitch pulled out his phone and opened the messaging app. He found Matt's number and typed out a quick message.
"Hey Matt, it's Mitch from earlier. Would you mind sending me some photo of the duct work you mentioned yesterday?"
He hit send and anxiously waited for a response. A few minutes later, his phone buzzed with a notification. It was Matt, sending a series of shirtless selfies that left nothing to the imagination. His defined chest was covered in tattoos, but what caught Mitch's attention the most was the close up of his hard cock. He couldn't wait to watch that slide into his husband's hungry hole.
Mitch couldn't help but feel a surge of excitement as he looked at the photos. This was really happening.
After a bit of back-and-forth planning, they settled on a time when Matt would be in their neighborhood for another job. Mitch would be working from home that day and Shalem would be home from work.
When the day finally arrived, Mitch found himself feeling nervous but also excited beyond belief. At exactly 11am, there was a knock on the door. Mitch quickly texted Shalem and asked him to answer it, his heart racing as he saw Matt standing on their doorstep. He told Shalem to let the repair guy upstairs to start working on the broken washing machine.