Cover of The Substitute's Christmas Cumming

The Substitute's Christmas Cumming

Read the story

2 chapters · 3828 words · Read 0 times

You are a middle aged teacher named Rachel, you are new to the state you are only a long term sub right now but want tom be a full time teacher your husband tells you to go to a christmas party to netowrk and get to know people but things go to far after you drink some of the spiked punch. Story told in second person through the eyes of rachel, the audience is rachel

Chapter 2: Unprofessional Development

The back porch was quieter, the music from inside muffled by the glass doors. Strings of white lights wound around the rafters, casting a soft, uneven glow over wicker furniture and potted ferns. It was cold, the night air seeping through the windows, but the chemical fire in your veins made you feel overheated, disconnected.

“Better?” Paul asked, his hand a firm, guiding pressure on your elbow as he steered you toward a love seat. He didn’t let go until you were sitting.

“A little,” you lied. The world was moving at two speeds: his movements were slow, deliberate, while everything else had a jittery, fast-forward quality. You gripped the edge of the cushion, the rough weave grounding you. “Just need a minute.”

“Of course.” He sat beside you, not too close, but close enough that you could smell his cologne—sandwood and something sharp. He swirled his own cup, the ice cubes clinking. “I’ve been wanting to talk to you properly, Rachel. Without a hundred kids and fire drills interrupting.”

He smiled, the kind that had put you at ease in his office. It didn’t work now. Your heart was a frantic bird against your ribs.

“The long-term sub position for Mrs. Gable ends in February,” he began, his tone conversational, professional. “But we have a permanent fifth-grade opening starting next fall. The curriculum committee thinks very highly of your methods. I think very highly of them.”

Hope, stupid and desperate, flickered through the haze. A permanent job. Security. Validation. You grasped for it. “That’s… that’s wonderful to hear. I’ve loved being here.”

“I can tell.” He leaned back, one arm stretching along the back of the love seat behind you. “You have a natural grace with them. And with the staff. It’s a rare thing.”

He kept talking. The punch in your cup was gone, replaced by water he fetched for you. The cold glass condensed in your hand. His words wove around you, compliments on your lesson plans, your classroom management, your patience. He mentioned your auburn hair catching the light in the faculty meetings, called it a distraction in a tone that was almost apologetic.

Your initial fear began to morph, softened by the persistent warmth in your blood and the relentless, focused attention. The room steadied, but into a new, strange equilibrium. His knee brushed yours as he shifted, a casual contact that sent a sharp, unexpected jolt through you.

“You’re blushing,” he observed softly, a smile playing on his lips. “It’s charming. Most people in this town are so… weathered. You have a different kind of light.”

You should move your leg. You didn’t. The touch felt like the only solid point in the spinning room. His voice was a low, pleasant rumble, detailing the school board’s needs, his influence, the specifics of the contract you so desperately wanted. Each word was a key turning in a lock. Your professional future was being laid out, and he was the architect.

His hand, resting on the couch back behind you, drifted down. His fingertips brushed the bare skin of your shoulder, just above the strap of your dress. It was a ghost of a touch. You froze.

“Sorry,” he murmured, not moving his hand. “Cold fingers.”

You swallowed, your mouth dry. “It’s okay.”

The conversation didn’t stop. He talked about budgets and curriculum standards, his thumb now making slow, absent circles on your shoulder. The dual signals were overwhelming: the rational, promising words and this illicit, creeping touch. Your mind, still fogged, struggled to reconcile them. The struggle itself was a strange, dizzying thrill.

An hour must have passed. The party noise inside had dulled to a murmur. His compliments grew more personal, less about your teaching and more about you. The way you listened. The shape of your mouth when you concentrated. He called you captivating.

And despite everything—the drugged punch, the married ring on your finger, the voice screaming danger—a part of you preened. This powerful, handsome man saw you. He wanted you here, in his district, in his circle. The attention was a drug as potent as the alcohol in your cup. It warmed you from the inside, melting the last edges of your resistance.

You felt a familiar, low clench deep in your belly. A pooling heat that had nothing to do with panic. Your breath shallowed. The brush of his thumb on your skin now felt electric, deliberate. Each casual graze of his knee against your thigh was a deliberate question.

He was describing the school’s new literacy initiative when his hand finally slid fully from your shoulder, down your arm, and came to rest on your leg. His palm was heavy, hot through the fabric of your dress, high up on your inner thigh. He didn’t look at it. He kept talking about phonics and assessment metrics.

Your whole body went taut. You were soaking wet. The slick, shameful heat between your legs was undeniable, a raw physical betrayal. Your panties were soaked, clinging to you. You were a horny slut, just like he knew you were, just like your husband had said you were and the realization made you throb.

His hand didn’t move from your thigh. The weight of it was an anchor, pinning you to the spot, to the decision you weren’t consciously making. Your body had decided. The slick warmth between your legs was a silent, screaming confession.

He finally stopped talking about school. The professional veneer evaporated, leaving his gaze dark and unreadable in the twinkling lights. He saw the conflict on your face, the rapid rise and fall of your chest. A slow, knowing smile touched his lips.

“There’s no one out here,” he said, his voice a rough whisper. It wasn’t a reassurance. It was a statement of fact. “No one is coming to check.”

His fingers pressed inward, a firm, possessive squeeze on the soft flesh of your inner thigh. You gasped. The sound was small, swallowed by the quiet porch. Your husband’s name was a ghost in your mind, formless and fading. All you could feel was the heat, the ache, the terrifying need.

He leaned in. The scent of rum and spice filled your senses. You didn’t pull back. You couldn’t. Your eyelids fluttered shut a second before his mouth met yours.

It wasn’t a question. It was a takeover. His lips were firm, insistent, prying yours apart. The taste of the punch was on his tongue, sweet and cloying, as he pushed it into your mouth. You moaned, a weak, pathetic sound from deep in your throat. Your hands came up, fluttering, and landed on the rough wool of his sweater, not pushing away but gripping, needing something to hold onto as the world dissolved.

He kissed you like he was claiming something. One hand cupped the back of your head, tangling in your auburn hair, pulling just enough to arch your neck. The other hand slid higher up your thigh, pushing the hem of your dress toward your hip. The cold air hit your damp skin, and you shuddered.

“You’ve been thinking about this,” he muttered against your mouth, his breath hot. “Since the interview. I saw it.”

You shook your head, a feeble denial lost in another kiss, deeper, filthier. His tongue mapped your mouth. You were kissing him back now, your own tongue sliding against his, hungry and complicit. The alcohol and the desire were a single, roaring flame.

“You’re so fucking wet for me,” he growled, his fingers finding the edge of your soaked panties. He rubbed the lace roughly over your clit, and your hips jerked off the couch. “Aching for it. I knew you would be.”

He tore his mouth from yours, his lips trailing down your jaw, your neck, biting the sensitive cord of your throat. You cried out. His finger hooked into the side of your panties, and with a sharp tug, the fabric ripped. The sound was obscenely loud. He didn’t remove them, just pushed the ruined lace aside.

His fingers plunged into you without warning. Two, thick and demanding, curling deep inside your cunt. You screamed, immediatly cumming like the slut you are, the sound muffled against his shoulder. Your body clenched around the invasion, a tight, velvety spasm.

“Fuck, yes,” he hissed. “Tight little married pussy. Been empty too long, hasn’t it?”

He pumped his fingers, a ruthless, steady rhythm. The heel of his palm ground against your clit with each thrust. Pleasure, sharp and debasing, ripped through you. You were babbling, words without meaning, pleas for more, for him to stop. Your nails dug into his back.

He withdrew his soaked fingers, shiny in the dim light. He brought them to your lips, smearing your own wetness across them. “Taste it,” he commanded. “Taste how much you want this job.”

You opened your mouth, your tongue licking shamefully at your own juices, the salt and musk of your arousal. He watched, his eyes blazing with triumph. Then he was unbuckling his belt, the leather rasping, the zipper a metallic shriek.

He pushed you back onto the love seat, your dress around your waist. The wicker scratched your bare ass. He fisted his cock, thick and ruddy in the cool air, stroking it once, twice, glistening at the tip. He notched the head at your entrance, pressing insistently against your swollen flesh.

“Look at me,” he ordered. You did. His face was all hard lines and hunger. “You tell anyone about this, and you’ll never work in this state again. You understand? You’re mine now.”

You nodded, a frantic jerk of your head. You were beyond words, beyond thought, a vessel of pure need. You wanted the contract. You wanted the pain. You wanted him to ruin you.

He drove into you in one brutal, deep stroke. The stretch was immense, a burning, filling invasion that stole the air from your lungs. You saw stars. He didn’t pause, didn’t let you adjust. He set a punishing pace, pulling almost all the way out before slamming back into the hilt.

The love seat creaked violently with every thrust. His hips hammered against yours. Each impact jolted through you, a mixture of searing friction and deep, punishing pleasure. He fucked you like he hated you, like he owned you, and your body adored it.

“Take it,” he grunted, his hands vise-like on your hips. “Take this cock, you needy slut. This is what you came for.”

It was. You wrapped your legs around his waist, locking your ankles, pulling him deeper. The coil in your belly tightened to a breaking point. Your cries were rhythmic, punched out of you with every inward drive. The party was a distant dream. Your marriage was a photograph burning in another room.

“I’m gonna come in this pretty married pussy,” he snarled, his rhythm becoming erratic, brutal. “Gonna fill you up. You’ll walk around with me inside you all week.”

The filthy words pushed you over the edge again. Your orgasm tore through you, violent and convulsing, your cunt clamping around his invading length in wave after wave of blinding, shameful release. You screamed into the night, a raw, broken sound.

He followed, a final, deep grind as he emptied himself into you with a low, guttural groan. You felt the hot, sudden flood inside you, a claiming. He stayed there, buried, his weight heavy on you, his breath hot on your neck.

Slowly, the world seeped back in. The chill of the air on your sweat-slicked skin. The distant, cheerful melody of a Christmas song from inside the house. The aching, throbbing fullness between your legs.

He pulled out, a slow, wet withdrawal. He tucked himself away, zipped his pants, a series of casual, efficient sounds. He smoothed his sweater. You lay there, exposed, dress rucked up, torn panties askew, his come already leaking out of you onto the wicker.

He looked down at you, his expression settling back into that familiar, charming calm. He reached out and gently pulled your dress down over your knees, a grotesque parody of courtesy.

“We’ll discuss the contract details in my office on Monday,” he said, his voice perfectly even, as if commenting on the weather. “Ten o’clock. Don’t be late.”

He turned and walked back into the glow of the party, leaving you alone in the cold, twinkling dark, the scent of pine and sex clinging to the air.

You didn’t move for a long time. The cold of the wicker bit into your thighs. Inside you, a faint, throbbing ache pulsed in time with your heartbeat, a visceral reminder of the violation that felt confusingly like invitation. Your own wetness and his semen formed a cooling, sticky trickle down your inner thigh.

You needed to stand. Your legs trembled as you pushed yourself up, your dress falling back into place, the torn lace of your panties a ragged whisper against your skin. You walked stiffly to the porch’s small sink, meant for watering plants. The water from the tap was icy. You cupped it in your hands, scrubbing at your mouth, your face, the smear on your thigh. The cold was a shock, but it didn’t cleanse.

Your reflection in the dark window was a pale smudge. You fixed your hair, smoothed your dress. The mundane actions were a shield, a rehearsal for the performance ahead. Every movement sparked a memory: the weight of his hand, the tearing sound of fabric, the brutal fullness. Your body hummed with a traitorous, residual energy.

You found your purse where you’d left it by the love seat. The walk through the living room was a tunnel. Laughter echoed, but it was muffled, underwater. Sarah waved from across the room, her mouth moving in a question you didn’t hear. You forced your lips into a smile, gave a thumbs-up, and pointed toward the door. She nodded, smiling back, already turning to someone else.

The winter air outside was a physical slap, sobering and cruel. You fumbled with your keys, your fingers numb. The drive home was a series of automatic gestures. Streetlights bled into streaks. You replayed his final words, the clinical tone. Ten o’clock. Don’t be late.

Your house was dark except for the porch light. You sat in the idling car, watching the warm glow. You could still smell him on your skin, underneath the pine and the cold. You clenched your thighs together, and the faint, sore twinge made your breath catch. You got out.

The front door clicked shut behind you, a sound of finality. “Honey? That you?” Your husband’s voice called from the living room, followed by the pause of a muted television.

“Yeah, it’s me.” Your voice sounded strange, bright and airy.

He appeared in the hallway, smiling, a book in his hand. “How was it? Make any headway?”

You dropped your purse on the console table, the gesture weary but deliberate. You turned to him, letting the practiced, victorious smile spread across your face. It felt like cracking plaster.

“It was great,” you said, the words too quick. “Better than great.”

You walked to him, your body moving with a confidence you didn’t feel, and took his hands. You looked into his familiar, trusting eyes. “You were right. Networking was exactly what I needed.”

He squeezed your hands. “Yeah? Good crowd?”

“The best.” You leaned in, kissing his cheek, hiding your face. “And guess what? Paul Abernathy pulled me aside. We had a long talk about the future.”

You pulled back, keeping your gaze locked on his, selling the lie with every fiber of your being. The throbbing between your legs was a secret rhythm underscoring your words. “He all but offered me the permanent position. The fifth-grade opening next fall. It’s mine if I want it.”

His face broke into a wide, proud smile. “Rachel, that’s fantastic! I knew it! I told you, just get in there, be yourself.” He pulled you into a hug, his arms warm and safe around you. You stiffened for a fraction of a second before melting into it, resting your chin on his shoulder, staring blankly at the wall.

“I told him I was thrilled,” you murmured into his neck. “We’re meeting Monday to go over the contract details.”

“This calls for a drink,” he said, releasing you, heading toward the kitchen. “We have that champagne in the fridge from New Year’s.”

You followed him, your heels clicking on the hardwood. “It was so easy,” you said, the script flowing now. “He said he’d been impressed from day one. Said I have a ‘natural grace’ with the staff.”

Your husband popped the cork, the sound like a gunshot. He poured two glasses, handed you one. The bubbles stung your tongue. “To my brilliant wife,” he toasted, his eyes shining. “To the new job.”

You clinked your glass against his. “To the new job,” you echoed.

You drank. The champagne was dry and sharp. It did not wash away the taste of punch. It mixed with them. You smiled at your husband over the rim of your glass, the image of happy success, while the memory of a different, darker toast echoed in your mind. To new beginnings.

“Tell me everything,” he said, leaning against the counter.

And you did. You painted a picture of a charming, professional evening. You described the punch, the lights, the friendly chatter. You crafted a flawless, boring story. You omitted the enclosed porch, the heavy hand, the tearing fabric, the brutal claiming. You omitted the contract sealed not with a handshake, but with the slow, leaking evidence you could still feel inside you.

You talked until your throat was dry. You laughed at the right moments. You were convincing. When you finally went upstairs, claiming exhaustion, he kissed you softly. “I’m so proud of you,” he whispered.

Read on DreamPress