Cover of The Unconventional Love Triangle

Romance

The Unconventional Love Triangle

Read the story

5 chapters · 36148 words · Read 0 times

Max, a 22-year-old, had a close relationship with his 27-year-old twin roommates, Haley, a doctor, and Emily, a fitness instructor. After a series of intimate encounters that began with teasing and led to sexual exploration, their relationship evolved from friendship to a more physical bond, eventually resulting in them starting a new life together abroad as a family.

Chapter 1: Introduction

Max

The warm, buttery light glows softly in the spacious open loft that I share with my two gorgeous twin sisters, Haley and Emily. The brilliant rays of the setting sun caress the hardwood floor and climb up the exposed concrete wall, painting the room in golden tones. The ceaseless cityscape view beyond the floor-to-ceiling windows never fails to catch my eye, especially now as the sun’s cresting orange orb lazily sinks into the horizon, bathing New York City in a warm afterglow.

I’m sprawled on the plush, cream-colored sofa, a glass of whiskey resting on my chest, my eyes lazily taking in the familiar skyline.

“Maximilian,” a voice snaps, disrupting my peaceful observation. My gaze flicks towards the kitchen island where Haley, my elder sister by five years, stands with her hands planted firmly on her hips. Her crisp white lab coat clashes starkly with her dark, tanned skin, a testament to her recent tropical vacation. Yet, despite the casual attire, her stern expression suggests she’s all business.

Her dark hair, still damp from the shower, is pulled back into a severe bun, and her piercing hazel eyes, framed by thick lashes, are focused intently on me. I smirk, knowing that look all too well.

“What?” I ask, feigning innocence, my voice dripping with sarcasm. “I was just admiring the sunset.”

Haley rolls her eyes, “Uh-huh. And I’m sure that’s the only thing you’ve been admiring.” She glances towards the closed bedroom door, where muffled laughter echoes. “Emily’s been in there for hours.

What exactly is she doing?” Haley asks, her brow furrowing as she crosses her arms over her chest.

I shrug nonchalantly, taking a sip of my whiskey. “Who knows? Probably trying on every outfit she owns for her date tonight.”

Haley scoffs, “She’s got a date? Again? That girl has more dates than I have patients.”

I chuckle, “Well, not all of us are workaholics, Hayls.”

Before Haley can retort, the bedroom door swings open, and Emily saunters out, her hips swaying confidently.

She’s dressed in a tight, crimson dress that hugs her curves like a second skin, the deep V-neck revealing a generous amount of cleavage. Her long, blonde hair cascades down her shoulders in loose curls, and her makeup is smoky and sultry, accentuating her bright blue eyes.

“Well, don’t you two look cozy,” she remarks, a playful smile tugging at the corners of her mouth. She sashays towards us, her heels clicking against the hardwood floor.

Haley’s eyes narrow as she takes in Emily’s appearance.

“You’re not seriously going out like that, are you? You look like a...” She stops herself, her lips pressed into a thin line.

Emily laughs, unfazed by Haley’s disapproval. “Like what, Hayls? A slut? A whore?” She turns to me, her eyes sparkling with mischief. “What do you think, Max? Do I look like a whore?”

I swallow hard, my throat suddenly dry. I put my glass down on the coffee table, my eyes roaming over Emily’s body. “You look...” I pause, searching for the right word.

“Edible,” I finally say, a smirk playing on my lips. “You look fucking edible, Em.”

Emily grins, her eyes gleaming with triumph. She turns back to Haley, “See, Hayls? Max thinks I look delicious.” She licks her lips exaggeratedly, her tongue darting out to moisten them. “Maybe I should skip the date and stay here. I could be dessert.”

Haley huffs, clearly unimpressed.

“You two are impossible,” she mutters, turning back to the kitchen. “I’m getting a glass of wine. You two can continue your little...whatever this is.”

Emily watches Haley go, then turns back to me, her eyes twinkling with mischief. “You know, it’s been a while since we’ve had some...quality time together, Max,” she says, her voice low and sultry.

I raise an eyebrow, a slow smile spreading across my face. “Oh, really? And what exactly did you have in mind?” I ask, my voice equally low.

I can feel the heat radiating off Emily as she leans in closer, her breath hot on my ear.

”I think you know exactly what I want, Max,” she whispers, her hand trailing up my thigh, her fingers brushing against my growing erection. I suck in a sharp breath, my grip tightening on my glass.

”Emily,” I warn, my voice strained. “Haley’s in the other room.”

Emily chuckles, her hand continuing its slow ascent. “So? She’s always so busy with work.

But today, it’s different. She’s home early, and she’s wearing that goddamn dress that drives me crazy. The one that hugs her curves like a second skin, the one that makes me want to rip it off her and fuck her senseless.

I watch her from the couch, my eyes tracing the lines of her body. She’s in the kitchen, pouring herself a glass of wine. Her hips sway slightly as she moves, and I can’t help but imagine them grinding against me.

She turns around, and our eyes meet. She knows I’m watching her. She knows what she’s doing to me.

The little minx. Emily’s hand reaches the bulge in my pants, and she gives it a gentle squeeze, making me groan. I put my glass down, my eyes never leaving hers, and grab her wrist, my grip firm.

“Emily,” I growl, “you’re playing with fire.”

She smiles, a wicked glint in her eyes. “I like it hot, Max.”

Before I can respond, she leans in, her lips crashing onto mine. Her tongue forces its way into my mouth, and I can taste the sweetness of her lip gloss.

I groan, my fingers tangling in her hair, pulling her closer. She grinds against me, her hips moving in slow, sensual circles, her pussy rubbing against my aching cock through the thin fabric of her dress and my jeans.

"Fuck, Emily," I mutter against her lips, my hands moving to her ass, squeezing the firm flesh. She moans, her head tilting back, giving me access to her neck. I take advantage, my lips and teeth tracing a path down her throat, nipping and sucking at her soft skin.

Emily moans, her fingers clawing at my shoulders, her nails digging into my flesh. I can feel the heat radiating from her pussy, and I know she's wet for me. I want to taste her, to feel her come undone on my tongue.

I push her back onto the couch, her legs dangling over the edge. I kneel on the floor in front of her, my hands gripping her thighs, pushing her dress up to her waist. She's not wearing any panties, and her pussy is glistening and ready.

I can smell her arousal, sweet and intoxicating, and it makes my mouth water. I lean in, my tongue darting out to lick her from her entrance to her clit, making her gasp and buck her hips.

"Max," she moans, her fingers tangling in my hair, pulling me closer. "Please."

I chuckle, my breath hot on her pussy. "Please what, Em? Tell me what you want."

She hesitates for a moment, then says, "I want you to eat me out, Max.

I want your tongue inside me, fucking me until I come all over your face."

I groan at her filthy words, my cock throbbing in my pants. I lean in, my tongue flicking out to circle her clit, making her moan and squirm. I grasp her thighs, holding her in place as I feast on her pussy, my tongue delving deep inside her, fucking her just like she asked.

"Oh, fuck, Max," she pants, her hips grinding against my face. "Yes, just like that.

Fuck, you're so good at this, Max," Emily moans, her hips bucking against my face. I can feel her pussy clenching around my tongue, her juices coating my chin. I lap her up, my tongue swirling around her clit, my fingers spreading her lips wide open.

I insert two fingers into her tight hole, curling them upwards to hit that sweet spot, making her scream. Her pussy grips my fingers, pulling them deeper inside her.

I can feel her walls tightening, her orgasm building. I add a third finger, stretching her, filling her.

"You're so fucking tight, Em," I mutter, my voice muffled against her pussy. "I can't wait to feel your pussy around my cock."

At my words, she moans louder, her hips fucking my face, riding my tongue and fingers. I can feel her body tensing, her breath coming in short gasps.

"Oh, fuck, Max, I'm gonna come," she cries out, her nails digging into my scalp.

I groan, my fingers fucking her harder, my tongue lashing against her clit. I can feel her body trembling, her pussy clamping down on my fingers as she comes undone, her orgasm ripping through her.

"Max!" she screams, her body convulsing, her pussy gushing onto my face. I lap up her juices, my tongue gentle now, coaxing her through her orgasm. When her body finally stills, I pull back, my face glistening with her cum.

Emily looks at me, her eyes glazed over, her chest heaving.

"That was... fuck, Max, that was amazing." She sits up, her dress still bunched around her waist, her pussy on full display. I can see her juices glistening on her thighs, and it makes my cock throb painfully in my pants.

I stand up, wiping my face with the back of my hand. "It tasted amazing too," I say, my voice rough. I can see Emily's eyes drop to the bulge in my jeans, and she licks her lips, a hungry look in her eyes.

"You're still hard, Max," she says, her voice sultry. "What are you going to do about that?"

I smirk, unbuttoning my jeans and pushing them down along with my boxers, freeing my aching cock. "I thought you might have some ideas," I say, my voice laced with innuendo.

Emily grins, her eyes locked onto my cock. "Mmm, I do," she purrs, getting on her knees in front of me. She looks up at me, her blue eyes gleaming with desire.

She leans in, her tongue darting out to lick the pre-cum off the tip of my cock, making me groan. She smirks, then takes me into her mouth, her lips stretching around my girth.

"Fuck, Em," I hiss, my fingers tangling in her hair, guiding her head as she bobs up and down, taking me deeper with each thrust. She looks up at me, her eyes watering, but she doesn't stop. She wants this, wants me.

I can feel the back of her throat, the muscles tightening around my cock, and it feels incredible.

I want to fuck her mouth, to use her like she's using me, but I also want to make this last. I want to savor the feeling of her lips and tongue on my cock.

"Emily," I groan, my grip tightening in her hair. "You feel so fucking good."

She hums in response, the vibrations sending tingles down my spine. She starts to move faster, her hands cupping my balls, massaging them gently. I can feel my orgasm building, my balls tightening, and I know I won't last much longer.

I pull Emily off my cock, a string of saliva connecting her lips to my glistening shaft. She looks up at me, her eyes filled with lust and confusion.

"Max, what's wrong?" she asks, her voice breathy.

I grin, holding out my hand to her. "Nothing's wrong, Em. I just want to fuck you properly. Not come in your mouth like a teenager."

She laughs, taking my hand and letting me pull her up. I turn her around, pushing her back onto the couch, her legs dangling over the edge just like before.

She gasps, her eyes wide with anticipation. I lean over her, my hands on either side of her head, caging her in. I can feel her breath on my face, her chest heaving with excitement.

"Max," she whispers, her voice barely audible. "What are you going to do to me?"

I smirk, my eyes locked onto hers. "I'm going to fuck you, Emily. Hard andslow, just the way you like it."

She shudders, her eyes fluttering closed for a moment before snapping back open, her gaze intense.

"I thought you were going to make me beg for it first," she teases, her voice laced with challenge.

I chuckle, my lips brushing against hers. "Oh, I will, Em. But first, I want to hear you moan my name. I want to feel your pussy clench around my cock as you come undone."

Without waiting for a response, I reach between us, guiding my cock to her entrance. I rub the head against her slit, coating it with her juices, making her moan softly.

Just as I'm about to push inside, a sharp voice cuts through the air, "Maximilian!" Haley stands in the doorway, her arms crossed over her chest, her eyes blazing with anger and shock. "What the hell do you think you're doing?"

Haley's voice is sharp, her eyes flicking between Emily and me, taking in our disheveled state. I can see the anger and betrayal in her gaze, and it makes my stomach twist.

"Haley, it's not what it looks like," Emily starts, her voice faltering as she quickly pulls her dress down to cover herself.

"It looks like you're about to fuck our brother," Haley snaps, her voice cold. "On our couch. While I'm in the next room."

I sigh, running a hand through my hair. "Haley, we didn't mean for this to happen.

It just... it got out of hand," I stammer, trying to find the right words to explain the inexplicable. I look at Emily, hoping for some backup, but she just bites her lip, looking guilty.

Haley scoffs, her eyes narrowing. "Out of hand? Really, Max? You're twenty-two, not twelve. And Emily, you're supposed to be the responsible one. The one who keeps him in check."

Emily's gaze drops to the floor, her cheeks flushing with embarrassment. "I'm sorry, Haley.

We didn't mean for this to happen," Emily repeats, her voice barely above a whisper. She looks up at our sister, her eyes filled with remorse. "We were just messing around, and it got... intense."

Haley's gaze softens slightly as she takes in Emily's sincere expression. She sighs, uncrossing her arms and running a hand through her hair. "I know you both didn't plan this. But you have to understand how this looks, how wrong it is."

I nod, zipping up my jeans and sitting down on the couch next to Emily, putting some distance between us.

Haley watches us, her expression thoughtful before she sighs and sits down on the armchair across from us.

"You're both adults, and I'm not here to judge or meddle in your lives," she starts, her voice calmer now. "But you need to understand that what you're doing... it's complicated. It's taboo. And it could destroy our family if things go south."

Emily nods, her eyes filled with tears. "I know, Haley. I feel terrible. I never meant for this to happen."

Haley looks at me, her gaze stern. "And you, Max?

What do you have to say for yourself?" Haley's gaze pierces me, her eyes searching for any hint of insincerity. "I... I don't know what to say, Hayls. I wasn't thinking straight. One thing led to another, and... well, you saw what happened." I glance at Emily, who looks away, her cheeks still flushed with embarrassment.

Haley shakes her head, disappointment etched on her face. "This isn't like you, Max. You're usually the sensible one.

The voice of reason. Not Emily, with her carefree spirit and impulsive nature." She pauses, her gaze shifting between us. "And certainly not like this, with the two of you together."

Emily sniffles, wiping away a tear that escapes her eye. I really am. It was just... it got out of hand so fast." She looks at me, her eyes filled with a mix of regret and lingering desire. "It won't happen again, I promise."

I nod in agreement, my voice steady. "No, it won't.

Because I'm moving out," Haley announces, her voice firm.

The words hang in the air, heavy and unexpected. Emily's eyes widen in shock, and I stare at Haley, disbelief written all over my face.

"What? Why?" Emily asks, her voice barely above a whisper.

Haley takes a deep breath, her gaze steady on us. "Because I can't live here, knowing what's happening between you two. It's... it's wrong, and it makes me uncomfortable.

I won't be a part of this, and I can't stand by and watch it happen under my own roof."

Emily's eyes widen, "Haley, no, please don't go. We'll stop, I promise. We won't let it happen again."

But Haley is resolute, her jaw set firmly. "It's not just about you two stopping, Emily. It's about me needing space, needing to get away from this... this situation.

I can't stay here, not when I know what's happening between you two right under my nose." Haley turns to leave, but Emily jumps up, grabbing her arm.

"Haley, wait!" Emily exclaims, her voice urgent. "Don't go. Please, we need to talk about this."

Haley stops, her back still turned to us. She takes a deep breath before facing us again, her expression unreadable. "What is there to talk about, Emily? I've made my decision."

Emily swallows hard, her eyes pleading. "I know you're upset, and you have every right to be. But please, just hear me out. This... this thing between Max and me, it's not just some casual fling. It's something more, something deeper."

Haley raises an eyebrow, her gaze shifting between Emily and me. "More? Deeper?

Really, Emily?" Haley's voice drips with skepticism, her arms crossed over her chest. "You expect me to believe that you two have some deep, meaningful connection? After I walked in on you about to... to fornicate on the couch like a couple of horny teenagers?"

Emily's cheeks flush, but she holds Haley's gaze steady. "I know it looked bad, and I'm sorry you had to see that. But yes, there's something between Max and me. Something real."

I sit quietly, watching the exchange between my sisters, surprised by Emily's sudden declaration.

I hadn't expected her to admit to having feelings for me, not like this, not in front of Haley. I glance at Emily, her eyes filled with a sincerity that takes me aback. She's serious. She really does have feelings for me.

Haley, however, seems unconvinced. She scoffs, shaking her head. "Real? Emily, please. You're talking about incest. There's nothing real about that."

Emily winces at the harsh word, but she doesn't back down. "It's not like that, Haley. Max and I... we care about each other.

A lot. And I think... I think we both know that what we feel goes beyond just physical attraction."

Haley's eyes narrow as she studies Emily, then shifts her gaze to me. Do you feel the same way?"

I hesitate for a moment, considering my words carefully. I do have feelings for Emily, but I'm not sure if I'm ready to label them just yet. Still, I can't deny the connection we share, the spark that ignites whenever we're together. I decide to be honest, but vague.

"Emily and I...

we have a strong connection, Haley. I can't deny that. But I don't want you to feel uncomfortable in your own home because of it. If you need space, I'll move out. That's not up for negotiation."

Haley's eyes soften as she looks at me, then at Emily. "I don't want you to move out, Max. This is your home too. But I can't... I can't be here right now, not with this hanging over my head."

Emily steps forward, her voice gentle.

"Haley, please don't go. We'll figure this out, together. As a family."

Haley looks at Emily, then at me, her expression still troubled. "I don't know, Em. I can't just pretend I didn't see what I saw."

Emily reaches out, taking Haley's hand. "I know it's not easy, Hayls. But we love you, and we don't want you to leave. We'll find a way to make this work, I promise."

Haley looks down at Emily's hand, then back up at her face. She sighs, her shoulders slumping.

I just need some time to process this. It's not every day you walk in on your twin siblings about to...well, you know."

Emily nods, understanding shining in her eyes. "I know, Hayls. And I'm so sorry. We never meant for this to happen, and we certainly didn't want you to find out like this."

Haley looks at me, her gaze searching. "Max, what do you have to say about all this?"

I clear my throat, running a hand through my hair. "I'm sorry too, Haley.

I wish we could undo what happened, but we can't. All we can do now is be honest with each other and figure out how to move forward," I say, my voice steady and sincere.

Haley looks between Emily and me, her expression thoughtful. "I appreciate your honesty, both of you. I just... I need some time to wrap my head around this. It's not every day you discover your siblings are... involved."

Emily nods, her grip on Haley's hand tightening. "We understand, Haley. Take all the time you need.

We'll be here whenever you're ready to talk," Emily says, her voice soft and understanding. Haley nods, her eyes filled with a mix of emotions - confusion, anger, and sadness - but also a hint of resolve.

"I'll stay tonight," she says finally, her voice barely above a whisper. "But I'll sleep in the guest room. I need some space."

Emily nods, releasing Haley's hand. "Of course, Hayls. Whatever you need."

Haley turns to leave, but pauses at the doorway, glancing back at us. "I expect you both to keep your hands to yourselves tonight.

And tomorrow, we'll sit down and have a proper conversation about this... situation," Haley says, her voice firm yet laced with a hint of vulnerability.

Emily and I exchange a glance, both of us nodding in agreement. "Deal," I say, my voice steady. "We'll give you space, Haley. And we'll talk tomorrow."

Haley gives us a small, tense smile before disappearing down the hallway, leaving Emily and me alone in the living room. The tension between us is palpable, a stark contrast to the charged atmosphere from earlier.

Emily breaks the silence, her voice barely above a whisper, "Max, I'm sorry about Haley. I never wanted this to happen." "It's not your fault, Em. We both got carried away." I pause, looking at her, really looking at her. Her cheeks are still flushed, her lips swollen from our kisses. "But I'm not sorry it happened. Are you?"

She bites her lip, her eyes meeting mine. "No, I'm not. I can't lie, Max. I want you.

I want you so fucking bad, Max," Emily confesses, her voice barely above a whisper. Her eyes, filled with a mix of desire and uncertainty, search mine for a reaction.

I don't hesitate. I pull her towards me, my hands cupping her face, my lips crashing onto hers. She moans into my mouth, her body melting against mine. I can feel her heart pounding against my chest, matching the rhythm of my own.

"Max," she breathes, pulling away slightly, her forehead resting against mine. "What are we doing? This is...

complicated," I murmur, my eyes scanning her face, taking in her flushed cheeks, her dilated pupils, the way her chest heaves with each breath. "But I don't want to stop, Em. Not unless you tell me to."

Emily bites her lip, her gaze locked onto mine. "I don't want to stop either, Max. But what about Haley? She's going to find out eventually, and then what?"

I sigh, my forehead still resting against hers. "I know. We'll have to tell her eventually. But for now, can't we just... enjoy this?

I can't help it, Max. You're... intoxicating." She smiles, her eyes twinkling with mischief and desire. "But we should be careful. Haley's right next door, and she's already upset."

I nod, running a hand through my hair. "You're right. We should cool off for now." I pull away from her, creating some distance between us. "But this isn't over, Em. Far from it."

Emily looks at me, her eyes filled with a mix of longing and apprehension.

"So, what now?" she asks, her voice barely above a whisper.

I reach out, gently tucking a strand of hair behind her ear. "Now, we wait. We give Haley some space, some time to process everything. And in the meantime..." I pause, a slow smile spreading across my face. "We get to know each other better. Properly."

Emily's eyes widen slightly, her cheeks flushing a soft pink. "You mean... like dates?"

I nod, my thumb gently tracing her jawline. "Exactly like dates.

No sneaking around, no stolen kisses in dark corners. I want to take you out, to wine and dine you properly. To get to know you, Emily, in a way that doesn't involve sex."

Emily's eyes widen in surprise, a small smile playing on her lips. "You want to court me, Maximilian?"

I chuckle, "Is that what the kids are calling it these days? Yes, I suppose I do. I want to do this right, Em. And that means no sneaking around, no hiding."

Emily bites her lip, considering my words. "Okay, Max.

No sneaking around, no hiding. We can't just ignore what happened," Emily says, her voice serious. We'll have to talk to her eventually. But for now, let's give her some space. Maybe this time apart will help her process everything."

Emily nods, her gaze thoughtful. And in the meantime, we can... get to know each other better."

I grin, leaning in to press a soft kiss to her lips. "Exactly. How about dinner tomorrow night?

I can cook for you," I suggest, pulled by an urge to pamper her. It's not every day I get to date my sister, and while the circumstances are complicated, I can't help but feel excited about the prospect of getting to know her better.

Emily's eyes light up at the suggestion. "You cook? I didn't know that was a skill of yours, Max."

I chuckle, "There's a lot you don't know about me, Em. Dinner tomorrow, then? Seven o'clock?"

She nods, a smile playing on her lips. "Seven o'clock.

I'll be there," Emily says, her voice soft, her eyes still locked onto mine. I can see the wheels turning in her head, the same thoughts that are racing through my own mind. This is uncharted territory for both of us, and we're navigating it together, one step at a time.

I lean in, pressing a soft, chaste kiss to her lips. "Goodnight, Em," I whisper, pulling away before I can deepen the kiss, before I can lose myself in her again.

She nods, her eyes dark with desire, but she doesn't protest. She knows we need to be careful, at least until we've talked to Haley.

"Goodnight, Max," she replies, her voice barely above a whisper. She turns and walks away, leaving me alone in the living room, my heart pounding in my chest, my body aching with desire.

I make my way to my bedroom, closing the door softly behind me. I lean against it, taking a deep breath, trying to calm my racing heart. I can't believe what's happening. I can't believe I'm falling for my sister.

The thought echoes in my mind as I lie in bed, staring at the ceiling, unable to sleep. It's not just desire anymore; it's something deeper, something I can't quite put my finger on. I've always been drawn to Emily, always felt a connection between us that went beyond siblinghood. But this... this is different. This is intense, consuming, and utterly terrifying.

My thoughts are interrupted by the sound of soft footsteps outside my door. I hold my breath, listening as they approach, then pause. There's a soft knock, hesitant yet insistent.

I sit up in bed, my heart pounding in my chest. "Come in," I call out, my voice steady despite the turmoil inside me.

The door creaks open, revealing Haley standing in the doorway, her silhouette framed by the soft glow of the hallway light. She's still fully dressed, her arms wrapped around herself as if she's cold.

"Haley," I say, my voice barely above a whisper. "Are you okay?"

She steps into the room, closing the door softly behind her. She doesn't answer my question right away, instead taking a moment to compose herself.

I can see the turmoil in her eyes, the struggle to find the right words. I pat the bed beside me, inviting her to sit. She hesitates for a moment before walking over and perching on the edge of the mattress, her back rigid, her hands clasped tightly in her lap.

"What's on your mind, Hayls?" I ask softly, my voice gentle. I can see the tension in her shoulders, the way she's biting her lower lip, a telltale sign of her unease.

She takes a deep breath before speaking, her voice barely above a whisper.

"I can't stop thinking about what I saw, Max. About you and Emily... together." She shudders, her eyes closing briefly as if to block out the image. "It's just... it's so wrong. It's incest, Max. It's disgusting."

I wince at the harsh word, but I understand where she's coming from. I reach out, gently placing a hand on her shoulder. "Haley, I know it's not conventional. I know it's taboo. But what Emily and I feel... it's not disgusting. It's real.

It's intense. And it's something we can't just ignore or shut off," I say, my voice steady and sincere. I can see the conflict in Haley's eyes, the struggle between her revulsion and her love for us. I squeeze her shoulder gently, encouraging her to look at me. "Hayls, I know this is hard to hear. Hell, it's hard for me to even say. But I need you to understand that Emily and I... we didn't plan this. It just happened.

It was like a force of nature, something we couldn't control. But that doesn't make it right, I know. I need you to try and understand, Haley. Please," I say, my voice laced with a plea for her understanding.

Haley looks at me, her eyes searching mine for any hint of insincerity. She sighs, her shoulders slumping slightly. "I'm trying, Max. But it's not easy.

It's like you're asking me to accept something that goes against everything I've been taught, everything I believe in. I mean, Max, this is... this is our family. Our blood. And you're telling me that you and Emily... that you have feelings for each other." Haley shakes her head, her voice filled with disbelief and revulsion.

I understand her reaction, I do. It's not every day you find out your siblings are involved in something so... unconventional. I take a deep breath, choosing my words carefully. "I know it's hard to wrap your head around, Haley.

Believe me, I understand. But I need you to try, for Emily's sake and mine. We care about each other, deeply. And we need your support, your understanding," I say, my voice filled with sincerity. I can see the struggle in Haley's eyes, the internal battle she's waging with herself.

She looks down at her hands, twisting the ring on her finger nervously. "I just... I need some time, Max. This is all so sudden, so unexpected. I never thought... I never imagined that something like this could happen between you two." She pauses, her voice barely above a whisper.

"I need some time to process this, Max. It's not every day you find out your siblings are... "I just can't wrap my head around it. It's... it's wrong, Max. It's incest." "I know it's not conventional, Haley. But what Emily and I feel... it's not something we can just turn off.

But I promise you, Haley, we won't act on it. Not until you're comfortable with the idea," I assure her, my voice steady and sincere. I can see the relief in her eyes, the tension in her shoulders easing slightly. "Thank you, Max. That means a lot to me," she says, her voice soft. "I just need some time to accept this, to process it. It's not easy, you know." I nod, understanding her predicament. And we'll give you that time. We won't rush you into anything.

We'll give you all the time you need," I tell Haley, my voice gentle yet firm. She looks at me, her eyes filled with gratitude and a hint of relief. Thank you for understanding," she says, her voice barely above a whisper. I squeeze her shoulder reassuringly, a small smile playing on my lips. "That's what siblings are for, Hayls. To support each other, no matter what." She nods, her eyes shining with unshed tears. I need to go to bed, Max.

It's been a long day," Haley says, standing up from the bed. I nod, understanding her need for rest. Get some sleep. We'll talk more tomorrow, okay?" I assure her, standing up as well. She gives me a small smile, her eyes filled with a mix of emotions - confusion, acceptance, and perhaps a hint of hope.

"Goodnight, Max," she says, turning to leave the room. I watch as she exits, closing the door softly behind her. I let out a sigh, running a hand through my hair.

That was... intense.

And that's exactly what I'm feeling right now. I'm lying in bed, staring at the ceiling, my heart pounding in my chest. I can't get the image of Emily out of my head - her flushed cheeks, her dilated pupils, the way her body reacted to mine. And now, with Haley's words still ringing in my ears, I'm more confused than ever.

I roll onto my side, punching my pillow in frustration. This is a mess. A big, complicated, taboo mess. And I have no idea how to untangle it.

I close my eyes, trying to block out the swirling thoughts in my head, but all I can see is Emily's face, her eyes filled with desire and uncertainty. I can still feel her lips on mine, her body pressed against me, her heart pounding in sync with my own. And now, Haley's words echo in my mind, a harsh reminder of the reality we're facing.

I spend the night tossing and turning, my dreams filled with Emily and Haley, a confusing mix of passion and guilt. When I wake up, my body is aching, my head pounding from lack of sleep.

I glance at the clock on my bedside table - it's already past nine. I groan, rubbing my eyes as I sit up in bed. I haven't slept this late in years. But then again, last night wasn't exactly a typical night.

I throw off my covers and make my way to the bathroom, turning on the shower to let the water heat up. As I undress, I catch a glimpse of myself in the mirror. My eyes are bloodshot, my hair a mess, and there are dark circles etched beneath my eyes. I look like hell.

I've spent the entire night tossing and turning, my dreams filled with Emily and Haley, a confusing mix of passion and guilt. I step under the warm shower, the hot water washing away the remnants of my sleepless night. I can't help but think about what happened last night, about what's going to happen next. I've never been in this position before, never faced a situation like this, and I'm not sure I can handle it.

I finish my shower, towel off, and make my way back to my room.

I throw on a pair of jeans and a t-shirt, running a hand through my still-damp hair. I take a deep breath, steeling myself for whatever the day might bring.

As I step out of my room, I hear laughter coming from the kitchen. I follow the sound, finding Emily and Haley sitting at the island, mugs of coffee in front of them. They're laughing about something, their earlier tension seemingly forgotten. I pause in the doorway, watching them for a moment. It's a sight I've seen a thousand times before, but today, it feels different.

There's a tension in the air, an undercurrent of unease that wasn't there yesterday. I clear my throat, announcing my presence. Both of them turn to look at me, their laughter dying down.

"Morning, Max," Haley says, her voice steady and calm. It's a stark contrast to the turmoil I saw in her eyes last night. She's put on a brave face, but I can still see the worry lurking beneath the surface.

"Morning," I reply, walking over to the coffee maker. I pour myself a cup, taking a sip of the steaming liquid.

"So, what's on the agenda for today?" I ask, trying to keep my voice casual. I can feel Emily's eyes on me, assessing, as if she's trying to gauge my mood. I avoid her gaze, focusing instead on Haley.

Haley looks at me, her expression thoughtful. "I was thinking we could all go for a run. It's a beautiful day, and it might help clear our heads."

I raise an eyebrow, surprised. Haley is not one for spontaneous exercise. She's more of a structured gym-goer, preferring the predictability of machines and classes.

But today, she seems eager to get outside, to move. I can't help but wonder if this is her way of coping with the whirlwind of emotions she's been dealing with.

"That sounds like a great idea," Emily chimes in, her enthusiasm genuine. She's always been an outdoor enthusiast, preferring the unpredictability of nature to the confines of a gym. "What do you say, Max? Ready to burn off some steam?"

I glance at Emily, her eyes sparkling with excitement. I can't help but feel a pang of guilt.

Running with Haley and Emily usually means keeping up with their breakneck pace, a challenge I relish, but today, my body feels heavy, my mind still weighed down by the events of last night and the uncertainty of what today might bring.

"Sure, why not," I say, trying to match their enthusiasm. "Let's do it."

Haley stands up, grabbing her empty mug and placing it in the sink. "Great. I'll change and meet you both downstairs in fifteen minutes."

As Haley leaves the room, Emily turns to me, her expression softening.

"Max, are you okay? You seem... distant." She bites her lip, her eyes searching mine for any hint of what I'm feeling.

I sigh, running a hand through my hair. "I'm just... processing, Em. Last night was intense, and Haley's reaction... it's a lot to take in."

Emily nods, her eyes filled with understanding. I've been thinking about it all morning. I just want to make sure you're okay."

I give her a small smile, appreciative of her concern. "I am. I just need some time to wrap my head around this.

It's not every day you find out your siblings are... involved. And I know it's not easy for you either, Max. I can see it in your eyes."

I look at Emily, her gaze filled with empathy and understanding. She reaches out, gently squeezing my arm. "We'll figure this out, Max. Together. And we'll make sure Haley's okay too."

I nod, grateful for her support. "Thanks, Em. I just hope Haley can accept this eventually. I don't want to lose her."

Emily's expression turns determined. "She won't. She loves us too much.

She'll come around eventually. She just needs time," Emily says, her voice filled with conviction. I can see the determination in her eyes, the resolve to make this work, no matter how complicated the situation may be.

I nod, hoping she's right. "I hope so, Em. I really do."

Emily glances at the clock on the wall, her eyes widening slightly. "Shit, we're going to be late if we don't hurry. Come on, let's get changed."

I follow Emily to our respective rooms, quickly changing into my running gear.

When I emerge, Emily is already waiting, her hair pulled back into a high ponytail, her body clad in tight-fitting leggings and a sports bra. She looks energetic and ready to go, her earlier concern replaced by her usual vibrancy.

"Ready?" she asks, a teasing glint in her eye. She knows I'm not one to back down from a challenge, even when my body is screaming for more sleep.

"Born ready," I reply, giving her a playful wink. We make our way downstairs, finding Haley already stretching on the sidewalk outside our building.

She looks up as we approach, a small smile playing on her lips.

"About time, you two," she teases, her voice light. It's a stark contrast to the tension that had filled the kitchen earlier, and I can't help but feel a sense of relief wash over me.

"Hey, we're not the ones who suggested this impromptu run," Emily retorts, her eyes sparkling with humor. "You know Max here needs his beauty sleep."

I roll my eyes, but I can't help but smile at their banter.

It's good to see them acting normal, even if it's just for a moment. I start stretching, mimicking Haley's movements, trying to loosen up my still-tired muscles.

"So, where are we headed?" I ask, looking between the two of them. Emily has always been the spontaneous one, ready to explore new trails and paths, while Haley prefers the familiarity of our usual routes.

Emily grins, her eyes lighting up with excitement. "I thought we could try that new trail by the park.

I heard it's beautiful this time of year," Emily suggests, her eyes sparkling with excitement.

Haley glances at her watch, her brow furrowing slightly. "That's a bit of a detour. We'll have to make sure we're back in time for our respective plans."

I raise an eyebrow, curious. "Plans? What plans?"

Haley and Emily exchange a glance, a silent conversation passing between them. It's a look I've seen numerous times before, a twin thing that often leaves me feeling left out.

"We were going to tell you later," Haley says, breaking the silence.

"Emily and I have been invited to a gallery opening tonight. It's for one of our friends from med school. We thought it'd be nice to go together, support her."

I nod, trying to hide my disappointment. I had been looking forward to spending more time with Emily, to exploring this new dynamic between us. But I understand that they have their own lives, their own plans. I can't expect them to drop everything just because I've developed feelings for Emily.

"And you're going to look stunning in that red dress you bought last week," Emily adds, a mischievous glint in her eye.

She knows how much I love that dress, and she's using it to her advantage.

Haley rolls her eyes, but I can see the faint blush on her cheeks. "Stop it, Em. You know I'm not one for public displays of... anything."

Emily laughs, her eyes twinkling with amusement. "Oh, come on, Hayls. Live a little. It's not every day we get to dress up and pretend we're not just ordinary people."

I chuckle, shaking my head at their banter. "Well, don't let me stop you two from having a great time.

I'm sure I can find something to do," I say, trying to keep my voice light. I don't want them to know how much I'm hoping they'll change their minds, that they'll decide to stay in, to spend the evening with me.

Emily looks at me, her expression softening. "You could come with us, Max. It'd be fun. You can be our plus one."

I hesitate, considering the offer. It's tempting, the chance to spend more time with Emily, to explore this new connection between us. But I also know that it might be too much, too soon.

I don't want to rush things, to push Haley too hard, too fast. I need to respect her space, her feelings, even if it means missing out on a potential opportunity to be closer to Emily.

"No, thanks, Em. I appreciate the offer, but I think I'll pass. You two go, have fun. I'll be fine here," I say, trying to keep my voice casual, nonchalant. I don't want them to see the struggle behind my eyes, the internal battle I'm waging with myself.

Emily opens her mouth as if to protest, but Haley speaks first.

"Max is right, Em. This is a work thing, and he's got his own life to live. We'll tell you all about it when we get back, okay?" She gives me a small smile, and I can see the gratitude in her eyes. She's still grappling with her feelings, and she needs time. I can respect that.

Emily looks between the two of us, her expression a mix of understanding and disappointment. "Fine," she says, her voice a little cooler than before. "But you owe me, Max. Big time."

I laugh, trying to lighten the mood.

"Deal. Now, let's get this run started before I change my mind and drag you both to some fancy art gallery instead."

Haley smiles, and I can see the tension in her shoulders ease slightly. "Sounds like a plan. Let's go."

We start running, our feet pounding on the pavement in sync. Haley sets a steady pace, her long legs eating up the distance with ease. Emily and I fall into step beside her, our breaths falling into a rhythm with our strides.

As we run, I can't help but steal glances at Emily.

Her cheeks are flushed, her eyes bright, and her laughter rings out, filling the air with a sense of joy and freedom. She catches me looking at her, and she grins, her smile wide and uninhibited. I can't help but smile back, my heart warming at the sight of her happiness.

Haley, on the other hand, is focused, her expression determined. She's always been the competitive one, the one who pushes us to our limits, to challenge ourselves. Today is no different.

Haley's leading the pack, her long legs eating up the distance with ease. Emily and I are close behind, our breaths falling into rhythm with our strides. I steal another glance at Emily, her cheeks flushed, her eyes bright. She catches me looking and grins, her smile wide and uninhibited.

We run in comfortable silence for a while, the only sounds our feet hitting the pavement and our breaths coming in steady rhythms. The cityscape surrounds us, a bustling backdrop to our morning exercise.

We turn a corner, and the park comes into view, its lush greenery a stark contrast to the concrete jungle we've been navigating. Emily lets out a whoop of excitement, taking the lead as we enter the park, her eyes scanning the paths ahead.

"Which way do you want to go?" she asks, looking back at us over her shoulder. Her ponytail sways with the movement, a few strands escaping to frame her face.

Haley slows down, her breath coming in steady pants. "Let's take the loop around the lake.

It's been a while since we've done that one," Haley suggests, her voice slightly breathless. She wipes a bead of sweat from her forehead, her eyes scanning the park ahead.

Emily nods, her grin widening. Last one to the bridge buys breakfast!" she challenges, taking off at a sprint. Haley and I exchange a glance, a silent communication passing between us. We've played this game many times before, and we both know the rules.

I take off after Emily, my legs pumping as I try to catch up to her. Haley follows suit, her competitive spirit ignited.

The three of us race towards the bridge, our laughter echoing through the park. Emily is in the lead, her lithe body cutting through the air with ease. Haley and I are neck and neck, our strides matching, our breaths coming in synchronized pants.

As we approach the bridge, Emily's lead becomes insurmountable. She crosses the finish line, her hands raised in victory, her laughter ringing out. Haley and I cross the line seconds later, our chests heaving, our bodies drenched in sweat.

"Gotcha!" Emily exclaims, her eyes sparkling with triumph.

"Losers buy breakfast!"

Haley and I exchange a look, both of us still trying to catch our breath. "You're on," I manage to say, a smile tugging at the corners of my mouth. Despite the loss, I can't help but feel a sense of camaraderie, of shared experience. This is what we do, what we've always done. We push each other, challenge each other, and in doing so, we grow stronger, both physically and emotionally.

Haley, ever the planner, pulls out her phone. "Alright, let's see what's nearby.

I'm starving," Haley says, her fingers flying over the screen of her phone. She's always been the organized one, the one who plans our meals, our outings, our lives. It's a trait that has served us well over the years, and one that I've come to rely on, even if I sometimes wish she'd loosen the reins a little.

Emily looks at me, her eyes gleaming with mischief. "You know what this means, right, Max? You're in charge of drinks. And I want something exotic.

Surprise me," Emily says, her eyes twinkling with amusement. I roll my eyes, but I can't help but smile at her teasing. I love this side of Emily, the playful, carefree one who can find joy in the simplest things.

Haley looks up from her phone, her brow furrowed in concentration. "There's a new café not far from here. It's got good reviews, and they serve breakfast all day. Sound good?" she asks, looking between the two of us.

Emily's face lights up. "Ooh, breakfast all day? Count me in!"

I nod in agreement.

"Sounds perfect. Plus, I could use a proper breakfast after that run. My stomach's been grumbling for miles." I rub my abs for emphasis, making Emily giggle.

We start heading towards the café, our earlier competitive spirits replaced by a comfortable camaraderie. Haley leads the way, her phone guiding us through the winding park paths. Emily and I walk side by side, our arms brushing occasionally, sending a jolt of awareness through me each time.

"So, what's been going on with you, Max?" Emily asks, her voice casual.

"Anything interesting happening in your life besides... you know." She glances at Haley, who's walking slightly ahead, her eyes on her phone.

I hesitate, wondering how much to reveal. I don't want to push Emily away, but I also don't want to lie to her. "Well, there is something," I admit, keeping my voice low. "But I'm not sure if now's the right time to talk about it."

Emily stops walking, turning to face me. Her eyes search mine, concern etched on her face. "Max, you can talk to me. You know that, right?

Whatever it is, you can trust me," Emily says, her voice soft yet firm. There's a determination in her eyes that I've come to recognize, a resolve that tells me she won't let this go until I've spilled my guts.

I sigh, knowing she's right. I can't keep bottling this up, not with Emily. Not with Haley, either, but that's a conversation for another time.

"Alright, but not here," I say, glancing at Haley, who's still a few paces ahead, engrossed in her phone.

"Let's find a quiet spot at the café, and I'll tell you everything."

Emily nods, understanding in her eyes. Come on, let's catch up to Haley before she gets too far ahead."

We quicken our pace, catching up to Haley just as she exits the park. She looks up from her phone, a small smile playing on her lips.

"Found the place. It's just around the corner," she says, pointing towards a quaint little café nestled between two larger buildings.

The aroma of freshly brewed coffee and pastries wafts through the air, making my stomach rumble in anticipation.

As we approach, I notice the sign above the door: "Café des Artistes." It's a charming place, with a vintage awning and a small patio filled with wrought-iron tables and chairs. A chalkboard menu hangs outside, listing an array of breakfast options that make my mouth water.

"Looks like the perfect spot," Emily remarks, her eyes scanning the menu. "I could go for some avocado toast and a fancy coffee drink."

Haley nods in agreement.

"Looks cozy. Let's grab a table inside. It's a bit chilly out here," she says, rubbing her arms to emphasize her point. We follow her inside, the warm atmosphere enveloping us as we step through the door.

The café is filled with an eclectic mix of patrons - students huddled over laptops, couples engrossed in quiet conversations, and a few solo diners lost in their books. The walls are adorned with an eclectic mix of artwork, each piece telling a story of its own.

I can't help but feel a sense of comfort in this place, a sanctuary away from the chaos of the city outside. We find a table by the window, the sunlight streaming in, casting a warm glow on the worn wooden surface.

Haley takes a seat, her eyes scanning the menu with a critical eye. Emily and I sit down across from her, our legs brushing underneath the table. I can't help but sneak a glance at Emily, her face flushed from the run, her eyes sparkling with excitement. She catches me looking and winks, a small smile playing on her lips.

I smile back, my heart doing a little flip in my chest. It's moments like these that make me forget about the uncertainty that's been hanging over us, the awkwardness that's been lingering since that night. For a fleeting moment, it's just the three of us, like it's always been.

A waitress approaches our table, her pen poised over her notepad. "Good morning. What can I get for you folks?" she asks, her voice cheerful and friendly.

Haley goes first, ordering her usual - a Greek yogurt parfait with granola and mixed berries, and a black coffee.

Emily orders next, her eyes twinkling with mischief as she looks at me. "I'll have the avocado toast with a poached egg on the side, and a chai latte. And whatever exotic drink Max is getting, I'll have one of those too," she says, her gaze never leaving mine.

The waitress turns to me, her pen poised. "And for you, sir?"

I smile, my eyes still locked with Emily's. "I'll have the same as Emily, but instead of the chai latte, I'll have a cortado.

Make it a double," I say, handing the waitress the menus. She nods, jotting down our orders before turning away to place them in the kitchen.

As she walks away, Haley looks at me, her eyebrows raised. "A double cortado? You must be feeling adventurous today."

I shrug, leaning back in my chair. "Why not? It's not every day you run into your sisters and have to face the consequences of the night before."

Emily kicks me lightly under the table, her eyes warning me to tread carefully. I nod, understanding her silent message.

Now's not the time to bring up last night. I change the subject, asking Haley about her upcoming work schedule. She launches into a detailed explanation of her upcoming shifts and on-call duties, her eyes lighting up as she talks about a new research project she's been working on. I listen attentively, happy to see her passion for her work, even if I don't understand half of what she's saying.

Emily, meanwhile, has been quietly observing us, her eyes flicking between Haley and me. When there's a pause in Haley's monologue, Emily leans forward, her elbows resting on the table.

"So, Max, you were going to tell me something earlier. About something interesting happening in your life." Her eyes are curious, expectant.

I glance at Haley, who's now sipping her coffee, her eyes on me. I take a deep breath, knowing I can't avoid this conversation any longer. "Yeah, it's... it's about the other night, Em. With you and me."

Emily's eyes widen slightly, and she looks at Haley, then back at me. "Oh," she says, her voice barely above a whisper. "You mean...

what happened between us?" Emily asks, her voice barely audible. She glances at Haley, who's now staring intently at her coffee cup, her expression unreadable. I can sense the tension rising, the weight of our secret hanging heavy in the air.

"It's okay, Em. You don't have to say anything," I say, putting a reassuring hand on hers. The waitress chooses that moment to arrive with our food, breaking the tension, albeit temporarily. She places our plates in front of us, her eyes flicking between the three of us, sensing the undercurrent of our conversation.

"Anything else I can get for you?" she asks, her voice a little too cheerful, trying to cut through the awkwardness that's settled over our table like a thick fog.

"No, thank you," Haley responds, her voice stiff. The waitress nods, leaving us to our meal, but the atmosphere at our table is far from appetizing.

Emily looks at me, her eyes searching. "So, what did you want to talk about, Max?" she asks, her voice barely above a whisper.

I take a deep breath, trying to find the right words. "I just...

I wanted to make sure we're on the same page, Em. About what happened," I say, my voice steady despite the turmoil inside me. I glance at Haley, who's been unusually quiet, her eyes fixed on her coffee cup. She seems to be lost in thought, her brow furrowed slightly.

Emily takes a small bite of her avocado toast, her eyes never leaving mine. She chews slowly, deliberately, as if buying time to formulate her response. "I think we are, Max," she finally says, her voice soft but firm. "I mean, it was... nice. Really nice.

And I don't regret it," Emily continues, her voice growing stronger with each word. "But I also don't want it to change things between us. I value our friendship too much to risk it on... whatever this is." She gestures vaguely between the two of us, her eyes flicking to Haley for a moment before returning to mine.

Chapter excerpt truncated at the edge.

Read on DreamPress