Cover of The Underlord's Proposal

The Underlord's Proposal

Read the story

23 chapters · 60173 words · Read 0 times

Exes and Fuck Buddies; a Merciless Mafia boss tries to convince His Best friend, The First Female Underlord that he'd make a Wonderful Husband.

Characters

  • Ben — A loyal and efficient member of Val's organization, often serving as her driver and confidant.
  • Enzo Marchesi — An elderly mafia boss who runs the docks, accusing Val of killing his son Massimo. He is a traditionalist who underestimates Val.
  • Theodore "Theo" Sterling — Val's uncle who raised her after her parents died, training her to be his heir. He suffered a stroke and later named Val his successor.
  • Vincent Falcone — Vincent Falcone is a 68-year-old mafia boss, silver at the temples, wide through the shoulders, with scarred hands. He is strategic and manipulative, viewing people as chess pieces.
  • Viktor Volkov — A Russian mafia boss who holds the $40 million debt Anna Bellini owed. He is pushing Lorenzo to sign with the Russians and moving in on Sterling ports, unaware that Val has the assets to pay off the debt.
  • Marcus Falcone — Marcus Falcone is Dante's chosen brother, blood Cousin who has been negotiating with the Bellini shell corporation behind Lorenzo's back, seeking an exit from his brother's control.
  • Hendricks — A tall, broad man with salt-and-pepper hair and grey eyes. He is professional and respectful, referring to Val as 'Mrs. Sterling'.
  • Kozlov — An older Russian mafia boss with ice-chip eyes and a mouth that never smiled. He voiced opposition to Val's position, suggesting women belong in the kitchen or birthing bed.
  • Meredith Sterling — Val's aunt who raised her after her parents died, but has been estranged since her uncle's funeral. She accused Val of betraying the Sterling name and hung up on her.

Chapter 2: The Neutral Ground Meeting

The warehouse sat at the edge of the Brooklyn docks like a rotting tooth, all rusted corrugated steel and windows that hadn't seen glass since the Reagan administration. Salt air clung to everything, mixing with the pervasive stench of old whiskey and older blood. The place had been a neutral ground for three decades—since before Val was born, since before her uncle had even claimed the Sterling territory. It was sacred in the way only violent men could make things sacred.

Val's heels clicked against the concrete as she walked through the loading bay doors. The sound echoed off the high ceilings, swallowed by the vast emptiness above. Gulls wheeled overhead, visible through the gaps in the roof, their cries thin and distant.

She'd changed her jacket. The oxblood wool was too nice for this shithole—she'd swapped it for a leather trench in a darker shade, almost black, that still caught the light like dried blood. Underneath, she wore a charcoal turtleneck that hid the bruise Dante had left on her neck. Her glasses were in place, rectangular frames that made her look like a professor about to deliver a lecture on the finer points of dismemberment.

The table sat in the center of the space, scarred oak that had seen more confessions than a priest. A single bare bulb swung overhead, casting jagged shadows that danced and shifted with each gust of wind through the broken windows.

Dante was already there.

Of course he was. He sat in the chair to the left of the head position—her position—like he'd been sitting there for twenty years. His dark olive skin caught the anemic light, tattoos visible at his collar and knuckles. He wore black on black, a suit that probably cost more than the warehouse itself, and his green eyes tracked Val's approach with the patience of a predator who'd already eaten.

"You're late," he said.

"I'm exactly on time." She slid into her chair, the leather creaking beneath her. "You're early."

"Couldn't sleep."

"Guilty conscience?"

"Something like that."

The bottle of bourbon sat between them, half-empty. Two glasses. One already had fingerprints on it—Dante's, from the look of the size. The other was untouched, waiting.

Val didn't touch it either. She never drank at sit-downs. Not since she was twenty-six and watched a rival boss choke on his own whiskey, poisoned by a server who'd been paid off by his own nephew. Trust was a commodity she couldn't afford.

"Ben said you wanted me here," Dante said, his voice low and rough. "Care to explain why?"

"You're the Butcher." She adjusted her glasses, letting the light catch the lenses. "When someone dumps a body in the river and calls for a meeting, it helps to have the person who does the dumping in the room."

"I didn't dump Massimo."

"I know. But Enzo doesn't."

Dante's jaw tightened. The muscle beneath his cheekbone jumped once, twice. Then he reached for his glass and took a slow sip of bourbon, his eyes never leaving hers.

"You're using me as a prop," he said.

"I'm using you as a deterrent. There's a difference."

"Feels the same from where I'm sitting."

"Then stand up."

His mouth curved. Not quite a smile, but close enough that Val felt it somewhere low in her stomach, a flutter she refused to acknowledge.

Before she could say anything else—before she could do something stupid like lean across the table and kiss him in the middle of a neutral ground—the loading bay doors groaned open.

Enzo Marchesi walked in like he owned the place.

He was sixty-three years old, with a paunch that strained the buttons of his custom suit and hair the color of dirty snow. His face was a roadmap of bad decisions and worse genetics, all jowls and liver spots and eyes that were too small for their sockets. He moved with the ponderous confidence of a man who'd never been challenged, never been hit, never been forced to kneel.

Val hated him on sight. She always did.

Behind him came two soldiers—muscle, not brains, their hands never straying far from their holsters. They took positions by the door, flanking it like the world's ugliest gargoyles.

Enzo stopped at the opposite end of the table. He didn't sit. Instead, he looked Val up and down with the kind of slow, deliberate appraisal that made her skin crawl.

"Valentine Sterling," he said, drawing out each syllable like he was tasting something sour. "I heard you were running things now. I didn't believe it."

"That sounds like a personal problem."

His lips twitched. "Your uncle was a reasonable man. A man who understood how things worked. How the world works."

"My uncle is dead."

"I know." Enzo pulled out the chair across from her, settling his bulk into it with a grunt. "I attended the funeral. Lovely service. You wore black."

"I wear black to everything."

"Yes. I noticed." He leaned back, folding his hands over his stomach. "You know, I knew your uncle for forty years. We came up together. He was like a brother to me."

Val said nothing. She'd heard this speech before, or versions of it. The old guard always wanted to reminisce, to put her in her place by invoking the legacy of the men who'd come before. They thought it made them seem wise. It just made them tiresome.

"I watched you grow up," Enzo continued. "I remember when you were just a little girl, running numbers for your uncle. Big glasses. Skinny as a whip. You always had that look in your eye, you know? That hunger."

"Get to the point."

"Patience." He raised a finger, wagging it like she was a child. "I'm getting to the point. The point is, I'm here as a courtesy. Out of respect for your uncle's memory. Because he was my friend, and I don't want to see his legacy destroyed by…" He paused, searching for the word. "…ambition."

Dante's hand closed around his glass. Val heard the faint creak of pressure, the sound of glass about to crack.

"The Marchesi family has run the docks for sixty years," Enzo said. "Your uncle knew that. He respected that. He understood that some things are older than blood, older than ambition. The docks are ours. They've always been ours. And Massimo…" His expression flickered, something ugly passing behind his eyes. "Massimo was my son."

"I know."

"He was found in the river this morning. Someone put him there."

"I heard."

Enzo leaned forward, his hands flattening on the table. "Did you put him there, Valentine?"

The room went still. Val could feel Dante's tension beside her, a coiled presence ready to strike. She could feel the soldiers by the door, their attention sharpening, fingers twitching toward their holsters.

She smiled.

"I didn't kill your son," she said. "But I know who did."

Enzo's eyes narrowed. "Who?"

"That's not how this works." Val adjusted her glasses, letting the light catch them again. "You called for a meeting. You made accusations. Now you're asking for information. That's three requests, Enzo. What are you offering in return?"

"Your life."

She laughed. It was a low, sharp sound that cut through the stale air like a blade. "You're going to threaten me in a neutral ground? In front of the Butcher?" She gestured to Dante without looking at him. "You're dumber than you look, which is saying something."

"I've been doing this for forty years, you little bitch." Enzo's face flushed, the pleasant old man facade cracking. "I've buried men who thought they could talk to me like that. I've burned whole families to the ground. And I'm not going to be lectured by some girl playing dress-up with her dead uncle's toys—"

Val was already moving.

She didn't stand. That would have been aggressive, threatening, a violation of the neutral ground protocols. Instead, she leaned across the table, close enough that she could smell the garlic on Enzo's breath, close enough that she could see the broken capillaries in his nose.

"I gutted the last man who underestimated me," she said, voice soft, almost conversational. "Beautiful man. Had a wife and three kids. Cried the whole time. I used his ribcage as a bookend. It's still on my mantel, if you want to come see it."

Enzo's face went pale.

"And the man before him?" Val continued. "He thought I was warming Dante's bed to keep my territory. Dumb fuck." She smiled with all her teeth. "I made him watch while I cut off his hands. Both of them. Then I let him try to run. He didn't get far."

Silence.

Dante's glass creaked, a thin, sharp sound in the quiet.

"And you," Val said, leaning back in her chair like she'd just shared a pleasant anecdote, "you think I'm playing dress-up. So here's my counter-offer. I'll give you the name of the man who killed your son. In exchange, you back the fuck off the docks and you never let me hear you speak to me like that again. Or—" She shrugged. "—I can skip the appetizers. We can go straight to the main course."

Enzo stared at her. His face was a mask of fury and something else—something that looked almost like respect.

"You killed Massimo," he whispered. "I know you did."

"I didn't. But the man who did has been working for you for years. He's been skimming off your shipments, and Massimo found out. So he killed him." Val pulled a folded piece of paper from her jacket pocket and slid it across the table. "His name's Frankie Delacroix. He's been your dock foreman for seven years. He drinks at the Donnelly Bar every Thursday. He's there right now, as a matter of fact, telling the bartender how he's going to take over your territory once you're too old to hold it."

Enzo's hand trembled as he picked up the paper. He didn't open it. He didn't need to.

"If you're lying…"

"I'm not."

Another long silence. Then Enzo pushed back from the table, his chair scraping against the concrete like nails on a chalkboard. He stood, slow and heavy, and looked down at Val with eyes that held a grudging, hateful admiration.

"You're not your uncle," he said.

"No. I'm not."

"You're worse."

"I know."

He turned and walked toward the door, his soldiers falling into step behind him. At the threshold, he paused and looked back over his shoulder.

"This isn't over, Sterling."

"It never is."

The doors groaned shut. The echoing silence that followed was almost deafening.

Val let out a breath she hadn't realized she'd been holding. Her hands were steady—they always were, during and after—but her heart was racing, a frantic rabbit in her chest. She reached for the bourbon, then stopped herself. Not here. Not now.

Dante hadn't moved. He was watching her with an expression she couldn't quite read, his eyes dark and unreadable.

"You had that paper ready," he said.

"I always have a paper ready."

"Frankie Delacroix isn't real, is he?"

"No." Val stood, smoothing down her jacket. "But by Thursday, Enzo will have convinced himself he imagined the name. And by the time he realizes there's no Frankie Delacroix on his payroll, he'll be too busy chasing ghosts to worry about me."

Dante shook his head slowly. "You're terrifying."

"Thank you."

"It wasn't a compliment."

"Everything's a compliment if you try hard enough."

They walked out together, through the loading bay, into the cold Brooklyn morning. The sun was fully up now, pale and weak, painting the docks in shades of gray and gold. Seagulls screamed overhead, fighting over a piece of discarded bread.

Val's car was parked at the end of the pier, a black sedan that looked like every other black sedan in the city. Ben was waiting by the driver's side, his face carefully blank.

"You okay, boss?"

"Fine. I need you to put out some feelers on Enzo. He's going to try something stupid. I want to know about it before he does."

"On it." Ben glanced at Dante, then back at Val. "You need a ride?"

"I'll take my own."

Ben nodded and slipped into the sedan, pulling out of the lot with the quiet efficiency of a man who'd learned long ago not to ask too many questions.

Val turned to find Dante inches away from her.

She hadn't heard him move. He was just there, suddenly, his body a wall of heat and muscle blocking out the wind. His jaw was tight, his hands shoved into his pockets like he was fighting the urge to reach for her.

"What?" she said.

"You know what."

"No. I don't." She tilted her chin up, meeting his eyes. "You're going to have to use your words, Falcone."

He growled. A low, frustrated sound that vibrated through the space between them.

"That little speech in there." His voice was rough, scraped raw. "The bookend. The hands. The way you looked at him like you were deciding whether to kill him or eat him."

"And?"

"And it made me hard enough to ache."

Val's breath caught. She told herself it was the cold. She told herself it was the adrenaline. She told herself any number of lies that she'd been telling herself for the last ten years.

"Everything makes you hard," she said.

"No. You make me hard." Dante stepped closer, backing her against a stack of shipping crates. The wood was rough against her spine, the smell of salt and rot filling her nose. "The way you move. The way you talk. The way you lie through your teeth like it's a religion. I've been watching you for twenty years, Val. I've been wanting you for damn near as long."

"Dante—"

"I'm not asking for anything." He braced one hand against the crate beside her head, boxing her in. "I'm just telling you what's true. You terrify me. You always have. But I'd rather be terrified with you than safe with anyone else."

She should have pushed him away. Should have reminded him that they weren't doing this—the feelings, the words, the messy shit that complicated everything. They were a physical arrangement. A pressure valve. Nothing more.

But her hands were already fisting in his shirt, pulling him closer.

"Shut up," she said.

"Make me."

She had several options. She could knee him in the balls. She could walk away. She could remind him that they had a deal, that feelings weren't part of the equation, that she wasn't the kind of woman who fell for pretty words and grand declarations.

Val pulled him down by the collar and kissed him.

It wasn't gentle. It was a collision, teeth and tongue and the sharp taste of whiskey. Dante groaned into her mouth, his hands finally leaving his pockets to grab her hips, hauling her against him with a force that knocked the breath from her lungs.

"You're fucking crazy," he rasped against her lips. "You know that?"

"You said it yourself." She bit his lower lip, hard enough to draw blood. "I'm terrifying."

"I said terrifying. I didn't say crazy."

"Same thing."

He laughed, a low, rough sound that turned into a groan when she reached between them and palmed his cock through his pants. He was already hard, thick and straining against the fabric, and Val felt a surge of something that was equal parts power and hunger.

"You want this?" she asked, fingers working at his belt.

"Fuck." He thrust into her hand, his head falling back. "Yes. God, yes. I've wanted this since you walked in the door."

"Since I threatened Enzo?"

"Since you did that thing with your glasses."

She grinned. "You're easy."

"For you? Always."

His belt came loose. She unbuttoned his pants, shoved them down his hips just enough to free his cock. It sprang out, hard and thick, already leaking at the tip. Val wrapped her fingers around it and squeezed, watching his face contort with pleasure.

"This is a public dock," she said.

"Don't care."

"Someone could see."

"Let them." He grabbed her hips and spun her around, her cheek hitting the rough wood of the crate. "Let them see who you belong to."

"I don't belong to anyone."

"You belong to me." His voice was a growl against her ear. "You've always belonged to me."

Val should have argued. Should have shoved him off, reminded him that she was a mafia boss, not some lovesick girl. But his fingers were already working at the button of her slacks, and her brain had stopped forming coherent sentences.

She heard the fabric tear. Her panties, ruined, yanked down her thighs. Then his fingers were there, sliding through her wetness, spreading her open.

"Fuck," he breathed. "You're soaked."

"Are you surprised?"

"No." He slid a finger inside her, then two, curving them up in a way that made her knees buckle. "I knew you'd be like this. Knew you'd be wet for me after watching you tear a man apart with words."

"Shut up and fuck me."

"Say please."

"I'll say you're an asshole."

"Close enough."

He pulled his fingers out, leaving her achingly empty. Then the blunt head of his cock was pressed against her entrance, hot and hard and impossibly thick, and Val bit down on her lip to keep from screaming.

Dante pushed in slowly. Infuriatingly slowly. An inch at a time, letting her feel every bit of him, the stretch, the burn, the way he filled her so completely she couldn't remember ever being empty.

"Fuck," she gasped.

"That's it." He was fully seated now, his hips flush against her ass. "That's my girl."

"I'm not—"

"You are." He pulled out, then slammed back in, hard enough to make the crate scrape against the concrete. "You're mine, Val. You've always been mine. You can pretend otherwise, but your cunt knows the truth."

Val wanted to argue. Wanted to tell him he was wrong, that this was just sex, that she didn't belong to anyone. But he was fucking her now, really fucking her, long, deep strokes that hit something inside her that made her vision white out.

"Harder," she demanded.

He obliged. One hand tangled in her hair, pulling her head back. The other gripped her hip, fingers digging into the flesh hard enough to bruise. His cock pounded into her with brutal efficiency, each thrust punctuated by a low, guttural sound that vibrated through her spine.

"Touch yourself," he ordered. "I want to feel you come on my cock."

She was already close. So close. Her fingers found her clit, slick with her own wetness, and she started rubbing in tight, frantic circles.

"That's it," Dante growled. "That's it, baby. Come for me. Show me how good I make you feel."

"Fuck—Dante—"

"I know." He drove into her harder, faster, the sound of their bodies slapping together echoing off the warehouse walls. "I know what you need. I've always known."

The orgasm hit her like a freight train. Her vision went white, her mouth opened in a silent scream, and her cunt clenched around his cock with a violence that made him roar.

"God, yes—" He came inside her, hot and thick, his hips stuttering as he emptied himself into her. "Fuck, Val. Fuck."

They stayed like that for a long moment, panting, sweating, his cock still buried inside her. The gulls screamed overhead. The wind howled through the broken windows. Somewhere in the distance, a ship's horn sounded, long and mournful.

Then Dante pulled out, slowly, and Val felt his cum start to drip down her thighs.

She turned to face him. Her lipstick was smeared, her hair a disaster, her slacks torn and damp. She looked like she'd just been fucked within an inch of her life.

She didn't care.

"You ruined my pants," she said.

"I'll buy you new ones."

"These were custom."

"I'll buy you ten."

Val reached for her purse, pulled out a tissue, and started cleaning herself up as best she could. Dante watched her, his expression unreadable.

"That speech you gave me last night," she said, not looking at him. "The one about loving me since you were fifteen."

"Yeah?"

"I didn't forget it."

"I know."

"I just—" She paused, struggling with the words. "I don't know what to do with it."

Dante stepped closer. He reached out and tucked a strand of hair behind her ear, his fingers gentle against her skin.

"You don't have to do anything," he said. "I just wanted you to know."

"That's not how it works."

"It's how it works for me." He leaned down, pressing a kiss to her forehead. "I'm not going anywhere, Val. I've been waiting for you for twenty years. I can wait a little longer."

She wanted to tell him he was wasting his time. Wanted to remind him that she wasn't the kind of woman who settled down, that marriage would compromise everything she'd worked for, that she'd rather be alone than give up her independence.

Instead, she said nothing.

Dante smiled. That rare, genuine smile that made him look twenty years younger and ten times more dangerous.

"Come on," he said, tucking himself back into his pants. "Let's get out of here before someone finds the body."

"What body?"

"The one Frankie Delacroix is about to become." He winked. "Enzo's going to kill the first man he finds with that name. It's just a matter of time."

Val shook her head. "You're a monster."

"And you love me for it."

She didn't deny it.

They walked back to their cars together, the morning sun warm on their faces. Val's phone buzzed in her pocket—Ben, probably, with an update on Enzo's movements. She'd deal with it later.

For now, she let herself have this one moment. This single, fleeting moment of peace.

It wouldn't last. It never did.

But as she slid into her car and watched Dante drive away, she found herself thinking about his words. About the possibility of something more. About the terrifying, beautiful prospect of letting someone in.

She shook her head, starting the engine.

No. She couldn't afford to think like that.

She had a territory to run. An empire to protect. And a man who'd loved her since she was fifteen, waiting for her to decide if she was brave enough to let him.

Val pulled out of the lot and headed back toward Manhattan, the city skyline rising before her like a promise.

She'd make a decision eventually.

Just not today.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI