Cover of The Unheard Liar

17 chapters · 57854 words · Read 2 times

Reborn with the memories of both her life as Alison DiLaurentis’s younger twin and the future of Pretty Little Liars, Elena wakes at twenty-one expecting the familiar Rosewood she remembers—only to discover the timeline has already changed. She’s Alison’s younger twin sister and one of the Liars’ closest friends, now a college student, but Alison has already returned from her disappearance under very different circumstances. Stranger still, Charlotte and Alex Drake are already part of the family’s orbit, sitting at the same dinner table as Alison, Jason, and Elena. Elena quickly realizes something is wrong, but she isn’t interested in becoming another A. She wants to stay out of the games, protect herself and her friends where she can, and figure out why the future she remembers doesn’t perfectly match the one she’s living. What Elena doesn’t know is that every thought she has can be heard by the people around her. Alison, Charlotte, Alex, Jason, and eventually members of their growing A network—including Mona, Wren, and Melissa—quietly begin piecing together Elena’s memories. They never tell her they can hear her. Instead, they subtly question her, steering conversations toward Spencer, Alex’s secret identity, the Liars, their relationships, and the future disasters Elena remembers. Elena innocently answers aloud while thinking far more than she realizes, accidentally revealing devastating secrets. The darker truth emerges: A isn’t merely one person. Alison and Charlotte are involved, Alex has her own place in the operation, and the network has begun pulling in the people closest to the Liars—including their partners—to control them from the inside. Spencer remains the major exception, unaware that the people around her are playing a much larger game. As Elena grows closer to her family and the people she remembers from her first life, she becomes increasingly determined not to let A consume her. She even begins developing unexpected feelings and attractions while trying to navigate a Rosewood where nothing follows the rules she remembers. Eventually, Elena discovers the horrifying truth: they’ve been hearing her thoughts all along. But by then, she’s learned enough about the people around her to fight back. She finds a way to block her thoughts, finally turning the one advantage A had over her into a weapon of her own—and for the first time, they have no idea what Elena is thinking.

Chapter 8: The Claiming

The silence after her thought echoed was the loudest sound Elena had ever heard. Her own ragged breaths. The hum of the refrigerator in the distant kitchen. The wet sound as Melissa slowly, deliberately withdrew her fingers.

Wren’s thumb still pressed against her oversensitive clit, a brand. He didn’t move it.

Melissa was the first to speak. She lifted her glistening fingers to her mouth, never breaking eye contact with Elena, and sucked them clean with a soft, obscene pop. “She loves it,” she said to Wren, her voice a hoarse whisper. “She wants to be ours.”

The words, her own naked truth reflected back at her, sent a fresh jolt of terror through Elena’s spent body. It was one thing to feel it. It was another to have it witnessed, dissected, stated as fact. She tried to scramble back, to cover herself, but her limbs were useless, liquid. Wren’s hand on her stomach pressed down, pinning her to the leather.

“Shhh,” he murmured, but it wasn’t comforting. It was the sound you make to a skittish animal you have cornered. His eyes, when she met them, were alight with a fierce, intellectual hunger. “That was it, wasn’t it? The last defense. And it fell so beautifully. We felt it go.”

“I didn’t—” Elena started, but the lie died on her tongue. There was no point. They’d been inside her body and now they were inside her head. The violation was complete.

“You did,” Wren corrected gently. He finally lifted his hand from her clit, and the sudden absence was its own kind of ache. He looked at Melissa. “We should document the state. Post-catharsis. Total neural surrender.”

“Later,” Melissa said. Her gaze was fixed on Elena’s face, tracing the tracks of tears Elena hadn’t even felt falling. “The data is ours now. It’s not going anywhere. Right now…” She leaned in, her lips brushing Elena’s ear. “Right now, we take our prize.”

Before Elena could process the words, strong hands were moving her. Wren gripped her under the arms, pulling her upright. Melissa shifted, lying back on the wide sofa and guiding Elena to lie on top of her, belly to back. The position was shockingly intimate, her naked body pressed along the full length of Melissa’s clothed one. She could feel the expensive wool of Melissa’s trousers, the silk of her blouse, the hard line of her bra strap. The contrast of her own bare skin against the fabric was dizzyingly submissive.

Melissa’s arms came around her, hands splaying possessively over her stomach, holding her close. “Just relax,” Melissa breathed into her hair. “Let him taste you. All of you.”

Elena turned her head and saw Wren kneeling on the floor between the sofa and the coffee table. He’d removed his sweater. His shirt was unbuttoned, hanging open. His eyes were dark, focused between her legs where she was pressed against Melissa. He placed his hands on the inside of her thighs, his touch firm, and pushed them apart.

The exposure was absolute. She was spread open over Melissa, offered to him. She hid her face in the crook of Melissa’s neck, a weak attempt at privacy.

She felt his breath first, warm against her dripping folds. A sob caught in her throat. Then his mouth was on her.

There was no preamble, no gentle exploration. He ate her out with a single-minded ferocity that stole the air from her lungs. His tongue was a broad, flat stroke over her entire aching cunt, lapping up her spend and her excitement. He groaned against her, the vibration traveling straight to her core.

“Fuck, she’s delicious,” he growled, his words muffled by her flesh. “So fucking wet for us. Even after coming. She’s greedy.”

His tongue zeroed in on her clit, circling the swollen nub with a ruthless, pinpoint precision. Elena’s hips jerked, but Melissa held her firmly in place, a living restraint. Wren’s hands tightened on her thighs, keeping her open. He sucked her clit into his mouth, applying a steady, devastating pressure, and Elena screamed, the sound ripped from a place of pure animal need.

Just as the sensation became unbearable, his tongue plunged inside her, fucking into her with short, deep thrusts. He was everywhere, his mouth a messy, wet, perfect violation. He alternated—sucking her clit until she saw stars, then driving his tongue inside her, tasting her deeply. Elena was babbling, a stream of filthy, desperate pleas into Melissa’s skin. “Please, oh god, don’t stop, right there, fuck, please—”

“That’s it,” Melissa coaxed, her own breathing ragged. One of her hands slid down from Elena’s stomach, her fingers finding Elena’s clit from above, rubbing tight, frantic circles in time with Wren’s thrusting tongue. The dual stimulation was impossible. It was too much. It was everything.

Wren added his fingers, pushing two deep inside her, curling them up to stroke that devastating spot. His mouth sealed over her clit again, sucking hard.

The orgasm detonated. It wasn’t a wave; it was a seismic event, shattering her from the inside out. Her body seized, rigid, a silent scream locked in her chest before it erupted in a raw, tearing cry. Her cunt clamped down on his fingers, pulsing violently, and he fucked her through it, his tongue and fingers merciless, drawing every last spasm from her until she was a trembling, sobbing wreck.

He didn’t stop.

As the last aftershocks faded, he pulled his mouth away with a wet sound. Elena gasped, desperate for respite, but his hands were moving her again. He and Melissa maneuvered her limp body like a doll, flipping her onto her back once more. Before her vision could clear, Melissa was between her legs, her elegant hands pushing Elena’s thighs toward her chest, bending her nearly double.

“Watch,” Wren commanded, his voice rough. He was standing by the sofa, unfastening his trousers, his eyes glued to where Melissa was lowering her head.

Elena watched, mesmerized and horrified, as Melissa’s tongue, that same tongue that had whispered promises and clinical observations, licked a long, slow stripe from her entrance to her clit. Melissa’s eyes were open, watching Elena’s face as she did it. Then she dove in, her technique different from Wren’s—sharper, more precise, all flickering points and clever suction.

Another climax, smaller but sharper, was ruthlessly wrung from her. Elena thrashed, but there was no escape. The coffee table dug into her shoulder. The cold glass of the wall was near her head. Melissa’s mouth was a relentless engine of pleasure-pain.

Then they switched.

Wren pushed Melissa gently aside and took her place, his mouth claiming Elena’s cunt again, drinking down the combined wetness of her and his wife’s attention. He was ravenous, his stubble scratching her tender flesh, his grip on her thighs bordering on painful.

They were a machine. A perfectly synchronized instrument of her undoing. Melissa kissed Elena’s mouth, swallowing her cries, her fingers pinching and twisting Elena’s nipples until the pain blurred into the pleasure radiating from her core. Wren fucked her with his tongue, with his fingers, his other hand reaching up to fondle her breast alongside Melissa’s.

Orgasm after orgasm was pulled from her. They lost count. She lost everything. Time, space, identity. She was just a vessel for sensation, a canvas they painted with their mouths and hands. Each peak was weaker than the last, a dwindling return on an endless investment, until her body was simply wrung out, capable only of faint, oversensitive flinches.

The final one was less a pleasure and more a neurological short circuit, a full-system failure. A silent, full-body shudder that left her staring at the recessed lights in the ceiling, seeing nothing.

Wren finally lifted his head, his chin slick and shining. He breathed heavily, wiping his mouth with the back of his hand. Melissa, whose lipstick was smeared, leaned over Elena, cradling her face.

“Any more thoughts, sweetheart?” Melissa asked, her voice tender. “Anything you need to tell us?”

Elena’s mind was a blank, static plain. The vault wasn’t just open; it was gone. The walls had been torn down by the relentless tide of physical sensation. There were no secrets because there was no self left to hold them. A single, crystalline truth floated in the void, and with the last of her energy, she focused on it, not to hide it, but because it was the only thing left.

Yes. This. Forever.

Melissa’s smile was beatific. She looked at Wren. “She’s perfect.”

Wren stood, his arousal evident, but he made no move to take her further. Not yet. He leaned down and, with a surprising gentleness, gathered Elena into his arms. He carried her away from the sofa, past the kitchen, down a short hallway. Melissa followed, her hand resting on the small of Elena’s back.

He shouldered open a door into a bedroom dominated by a large, low platform bed. The sheets were charcoal grey. He laid her in the center of it. The cool, clean cotton was a shock against her ravaged skin.

They slid in on either side of her, their clothed bodies bracketing her nakedness. Melissa pulled the duvet over them. Wren wrapped an arm around her waist, drawing her back against his chest. Melissa faced her, stroking her hair.

“Sleep now,” Melissa whispered. “You’ve done so well. The real work starts tomorrow.”

Elena’s eyes were already closing, her body descending into a profound, involuntary shutdown. In the last second before oblivion, a cold, sharp sliver of her old self, the observer, stabbed through the blissful fog.

The real work.

The words echoed in the darkening chamber of her mind. This had just been the breaking. The assessment. The audition.

As consciousness fled, she felt Wren’s lips against her shoulder, a kiss that felt like a brand. And she knew, with a certainty that was the first brick in a new, terrible foundation, that tomorrow they would start building something new in the empty space where her vault had been. And they would own every single part of it.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI