Cover of The Unspoken Agreement

The Unspoken Agreement

Read the story

10 chapters · 30692 words · Read 0 times

The story is written from the first person. I am Mike and I am madly in love with my fiancé Lisa. Lisa is a shy conservative girl who is self conscious of her weight. She knows I have always dated skinny women in the past and while I told her I like a little curves in my women she knows I prefer skinnier women. She still knows I love her and we are both madly in love. She is faithful and devoted to me. Lisa has decided to move in with me and my best friend chad while we save for our wedding. the situation is not ideal but we can save a lot of money and it gives her and chad a chance to build a friendship which is important to me. Eventually Lisa finds out that Chad only dates curvy girls and us very turned on by chubby girls. She finds out it drives him wild which makes her feel better about herself. My character Mike has strongly encouraged her to be as close to chad as possible but as they get to be closer their relationship starts pushing boundaries. Lisa bgeins dressing in more revealing clothes and pajamas around the house. They begin flirting with each other. When I confront her about it she tells me to please not be insecure about it, that Chad is harmless and to please let it happen as it really is helping her come out of her shell. As the story continues, they very slowly begin pushing boundaries more and more. She begins hugging him hello and goodbye eventually giving kisses on the cheek to eventually even kisses on the mouth. Its a very slow escalation that takes place over 10 chapters. She ends up doing inappropriate things like giving eachother massages, cuddling on the couch and even she lets him use a body scrub on her in the shower with just tiny bathing suits on which becomes underwear the next time they do it. I tell her it makes me sad, jealous and mad but she always maintains its just harmless flirting and they are just building the close bond I asked for. She demands I let it be and promises she is faithful to me but I begin to question what her definition of being faithful even means

Chapter 8: Chapter 8

The bedroom door clicked shut, muffling the distant sound of Chad humming in the living room. Lisa pressed Mike back against the cool wood, her damp hair dripping onto his shoulder. The scent of Chad’s expensive sandalwood body wash clung to her skin, sharp and intrusive. Her hands, still cool from the shower, slid under his t-shirt, fingers tracing the muscles of his abdomen. She kissed him hard, hungry, her tongue pushing past his lips before he could fully respond.

He tried to lose himself in it. Tried to erase the image of her returning flushed, damp-haired, straddling him on the couch downstairs, her soaked panties leaving dark streaks on his jeans while she breathed "Nothing happened" against his mouth. He’d felt the dampness then, too. Felt the frantic energy vibrating through her. Now, in the dim sanctuary of their room, that energy felt amplified, charged with something he couldn’t name.

She pulled his shirt over his head, tossing it aside. Her own thin camisole followed, pooling on the floor. The soft glow of the bedside lamp illuminated the curves she’d always been self-conscious about. She pushed him gently towards the bed. He stumbled back, landing on the edge, the familiar softness of their comforter beneath him. She stood before him, breathing heavily, her eyes dark pools reflecting the low light. Water droplets still glistened on her collarbone.

"Touch me," she whispered, her voice thick. Her fingers found the button of his jeans, fumbling slightly in her urgency.

His hands moved automatically, drawn to the warmth and softness of her hips, sliding up to cup the heavy weight of her breasts. He lowered his head, kissing the swell of one, then the other, his tongue tracing the sensitive skin. She gasped, arching her back, fingers tangling in his hair, pressing him closer. He felt the familiar surge of desire, a desperate attempt to claim her, to anchor himself in this physical connection that felt increasingly fragile.

He suckled hard, lost for a moment in the taste and feel of her, the rhythmic pull, the soft sounds escaping her lips. Her thighs bracketed his legs, her core pressing against his thigh. He could feel the heat radiating through the thin fabric of her panties. Still damp? He pushed the thought away, focusing on the sensation beneath his lips, the way her body responded to him.

Her breathing hitched. Her grip on his hair tightened almost painfully. Then, her voice cut through the humid air of the room, sharp and clear despite its breathlessness.

"Since you're feeding on what you prefer," she murmured, her hips grinding slowly against his thigh, "my big, heavy tits…" She paused, her fingers tracing the shell of his ear. "Then does it really matter that Chad seems to like making my pussy wet?"

Mike froze. His mouth went dry against her skin. The rhythmic pull stopped. He felt like he’d been punched in the gut.

"We are just friends," she continued, her voice dropping to a conspiratorial whisper, her eyes locked on his face, watching his reaction. Her hand slid down his chest, over his stomach, fingers hooking into the waistband of his jeans. "And it's kind of fun being his towel girl." A small, secretive smile touched her lips. "He likes to splash…" She leaned down, her breath hot against his ear. "...and what's the harm in that," she breathed, her tongue flicking against his earlobe, "if you're getting everything you need?"

The words hung in the air, thick and suffocating. The warm intimacy of seconds before shattered like cheap glass. The dampness he’d felt downstairs, the shared laughter echoing from the living room couch, the lingering scent of Chad’s soap – it all coalesced into a single, horrifying picture. Towel girl. He likes to splash.

His hands fell away from her body. The desire evaporated, replaced by a cold, sickening dread that crawled up his spine. He stared up at her, at the flush still high on her cheeks, at the dark, challenging look in her eyes that held none of her old shyness. This wasn't insecurity. This was something else. Something possessive and cruel, wrapped in the guise of playful friendship.

The silence stretched, broken only by the frantic hammering of his own heart against his ribs. The soft lamplight suddenly felt harsh, exposing. He saw the flicker of something else in her eyes then – not satisfaction, but a wary calculation, like she was gauging how far she’d pushed him, waiting to see if he’d break.

He didn't move. Couldn't move. The warmth of her body pressed against his leg felt alien now, repulsive. The question echoed in the stillness, demanding an answer he didn't possess, carving a chasm between them wider than the room itself. Her smile faltered, just slightly, replaced by a tightness around her mouth. The momentum of the night, of their intimacy, died abruptly, leaving only the heavy, charged silence and the phantom sensation of cold water splashing.

The silence stretched, thick as wet cotton in Mike’s throat. He stared at her, the flush on her cheeks suddenly garish under the lamp, the damp tendrils of hair clinging to her neck like dark question marks. Her eyes held his, unwavering, that new, sharp-edged confidence glinting – waiting. Calculating.

"You’re…" Mike started, his voice a dry rasp. He couldn’t finish. Towel girl. He likes to splash.

Lisa tilted her head, a faint, almost pitying smile touching her lips. Her hand, still hooked in his jeans waistband, gave a small, impatient tug. "Mikey," she sighed, the nickname suddenly sounding condescending. "Look. If it bothers you that much..." She leaned closer, her breath warm and smelling faintly of Chad’s spearmint gum. "...that I come out of the bathroom all wet when I bring him towels after the splashing…"

He flinched. After the splashing. Like it was a scheduled event. Like fetching towels for Chad was part of her daily routine.

"...maybe I can just take them off before I go in there?" she offered casually, as if suggesting a simpler route to the grocery store. Her fingers traced the line of his hip bone through the denim. "Chad and I can play our little splashy games..." She gave a soft, breathy laugh that sent ice down Mike’s spine. "...then I can dry off properly and get dressed before I come right back to you." Her gaze dropped deliberately to his mouth. "See? Problem solved. Efficient."

Mike felt the room tilt. The soft lamplight seemed to pulse. Take them off. Before I go in there. Play our little splashy games. The images exploded behind his eyes: Lisa, shedding clothes at the bathroom door, stepping naked into the steam-filled room where Chad waited. Water. Skin. Laughter echoing off tiles.

"It’s not a big deal," Lisa insisted, her voice softening into that familiar, coaxing tone she used when she wanted something. She shifted her hips, pressing the damp heat of her core more firmly against his thigh. The dampness felt searing now, accusatory. "Seriously, Mike. Chad’s basically seen most of me anyway." She shrugged one bare shoulder, the motion making her breast sway. "Just glimpses. Helping with sunscreen at the beach last summer. That time my robe slipped in the hall." She waved a dismissive hand. "Honest mistakes. Nothing serious is going to happen." She leaned in, brushing her lips against his stubbled jaw. "He’s just… helping me relax. Be less uptight. For us."

Mike recoiled as if burned, scrambling backwards on the bed until his back hit the headboard with a thud. The sudden movement broke her contact, leaving a cold patch on his leg where her heat had been. His breath came in short, sharp gasps. He stared at her, at this woman who wore his fiancée’s face but spoke with a stranger’s chilling logic.

"Seen most of me anyway," he echoed, the words tasting like ash. Sunscreen. Robe slipped. Splashy games. The casual betrayal in each phrase was a hammer blow. The cozy bedroom felt like a trap, the walls pressing in, the scent of sandalwood clinging to her skin suddenly suffocating.

Lisa watched him pull away, her expression hardening. The coaxing softness vanished, replaced by a flicker of irritation. "Oh, come on, Mike," she snapped, crossing her arms over her chest, her earlier vulnerability replaced by a defensive posture. "Don’t be like this. It’s harmless fun. You’re getting what you want, aren’t you?" Her eyes raked over him, lingering where his erection had flagged into numbness minutes ago. "Or were you just faking it?"

He couldn’t speak. Couldn’t process the sheer, galling audacity. The word echoed in the hollow space between them, sharp and obscene. Towel. It wasn't just a word anymore. It was a symbol, a transaction, a chilling glimpse into a world where his love was measured against Chad's splashing games. The cold phantom water wasn't a phantom anymore; it was a flood, rising fast, threatening to drown him where he sat against the headboard.

The cold phantom water wasn't a phantom anymore; it was a flood, rising fast, threatening to drown him where he sat against the headboard. He couldn't breathe past the image: Lisa, naked, stepping into Chad’s bathroom, steam curling around her. Chad’s laughter echoing off the tiles. Water splashing skin. Her casual dismissal of sunscreen glimpses and robe slips felt like tiny knives twisting deeper. "Harmless fun," she’d called it. While he drowned.

He stared at her, really looked at her. The flush wasn't excitement; it was triumph. The damp hair wasn't just from a shower; it was a trophy. The scent of Chad’s sandalwood wasn't accidental; it was a brand. She stood there, arms crossed, impatient, waiting for him to cave. To accept the unacceptable. Towel girl. Splashy games. Naked. For Chad. Dry. For him. Like flipping a switch.

His voice scraped out, raw and unfamiliar. "It... it is kind of hard," he managed, the words thick and clumsy. He gestured vaguely towards her legs, towards the dampness he knew was there, soaking through thin fabric onto his thigh just moments ago. "Having you come back... from his room...wet." He swallowed hard, the admission tasting like bile. "Like that."

Lisa uncrossed her arms, her posture softening instantly, shifting back into the coaxing fiancée. She took a small step towards the bed. "Okay, Mikey," she said, her voice gentle, reasonable. "I get it. Seeing me wet, knowing it’s from... our games... that’s uncomfortable." She tilted her head, offering a solution like a peace treaty. "So, what if I just... didn't come back wet?"

Mike blinked, a flicker of confused hope warring with the dread. "How?"

A small, practical smile touched her lips. "Simple." She shrugged one bare shoulder again. "I’d be totally naked with him." She stated it plainly, a logistical adjustment. "Just for the little time I’m in there." Her eyes held his, unwavering, devoid of any shame or hesitation. "Then," she emphasized, her voice dropping slightly, "bone dry when I come back to you." She took another step closer, the lamplight catching the faint sheen still on her collarbone. "See? Clean slate. No reminders. Just...efficient."

The simplicity of it was horrifying. Nakedness wasn't intimacy; it was just... preparation. A step to avoid messy evidence. Bone dry. Like erasing the act itself. The cold flood surged higher, icy fingers closing around his lungs. He felt the phantom splash hit his face, cold and shocking. Efficient.

He couldn't look at her anymore. The cozy sanctuary of their bedroom felt like a crime scene. The soft light exposed everything he hadn't wanted to see. He pushed himself off the bed, his legs shaky. He needed space. Air. Anything but the suffocating scent of sandalwood and betrayal hanging thick in the room.

"Mike?" Lisa’s voice held a note of sharp surprise, then irritation. "Where are you going? We were just—"

He didn't answer. He couldn't. He fumbled for the doorknob, his hand slick with sweat. The cool metal felt grounding. He yanked the door open, stumbling out into the dim hallway. The distant sound of the TV drifted from the living room. Chad’s laughter, low and easy, mingled with canned sitcom chuckles. Mike leaned against the wall outside their bedroom door, pressing his forehead to the cool plaster. Bone dry. The words echoed, hollow and final, a door slamming shut somewhere deep inside him. He closed his eyes, listening to the muffled sounds of the apartment – Chad’s contentment, the faint rustle of Lisa moving behind the door he’d just fled – feeling utterly, irrevocably adrift.

The hallway wallpaper felt cold and gritty against Mike’s forehead. Chad’s low chuckle from the living room tangled with a laugh track, a grating soundtrack to the hollow ache spreading through his chest. Bone dry. Her words echoed, stripping away any last pretense of innocence.

The bedroom door clicked open behind him, a sliver of warm light cutting across the dim hallway floor. "Mike." Lisa’s voice was softer now, stripped of the earlier edge, almost pleading. "Come back. Please?"

He didn’t turn. Couldn’t. He focused on the faded floral pattern on the wall, the faint smell of microwave popcorn drifting from the living room. His stomach churned.

"Mikey." Her hand brushed his arm, tentative. "Just... come back inside? Talk to me. Properly." The sandalwood scent wafted stronger as she stepped closer. "Don't leave it like this."

The request, so simple, felt like a steel trap. He saw Chad’s smirk in his mind, heard Lisa’s coldly practical offer: naked with him... bone dry for you. Yet the familiar touch, the softened tone, pulled at the frayed edges of his resolve. A muscle jumped in his jaw. Slowly, stiffly, he pushed himself off the wall. He turned. Her face was tilted up, eyes wide, searching his – the picture of concerned intimacy, a stark contrast to the woman who’d spoken of splashy games minutes ago. He walked past her, back into the lion's den of their bedroom, the door sighing shut behind them.

The room felt smaller, the air thick with the unresolved tension and that pervasive sandalwood. He walked mechanically to the edge of their bed and sat down heavily, the mattress springs groaning. He stared at his hands, clenched loosely in his lap, knuckles white. The damp spot on his thigh, where her wet panties had pressed earlier, felt icy cold.

Lisa didn’t sit. She stood before him, arms wrapped around herself again, but not defensively now. Guardedly. Waiting. The silence stretched, taut as a wire. Downstairs, the TV droned on, Chad’s presence a constant, unseen pressure.

Mike lifted his head. His voice, when it came, was flat, devoid of its usual ease, scraping like gravel. "To clarify." He met her gaze, forcing the words out. "Just splashing games?" He paused, needing to hear her say it. "No funny business?" Another beat. The words tasted like ash. "No intentional... private part contact?"

Lisa watched him, her expression unreadable for a moment. Then, the practiced, soothing mask slid back into place. She nodded once, firmly. "Just water. Just fun. Splashing. Like kids in a pool." She took a small step closer, her bare feet silent on the carpet. "Nothing more, Mikey. I promise. Cross my heart." She made the gesture over her chest.

He looked away, back at his hands. The phantom splash hit him again, cold and sharp. Towel girl. He likes to splash. The scent of Chad’s soap was overwhelming. His shoulders slumped, the fight draining out of him, leaving only a numb exhaustion. A weary acceptance settled like sediment. "I guess," he muttered, the words thick and hollow in the quiet room, "that's ok."

He didn’t see the faint, satisfied curve of her lips before she schooled her features. She knelt suddenly on the floor between his knees, resting her head lightly against his thigh, right over the fading damp spot. Her fingers traced idle patterns on his jeans. "Good," she murmured, her voice a low purr. "See? It’s all fine." Downstairs, the crunch of Chad eating popcorn was distinctly audible over the television’s murmur.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI