Chapter 2: The Oar
Ewan went into the bog pool up to his thighs.
Tess held the phone for him because he told her to, and because her hands needed something to do. The torch shook in a long white wobble across the black water, the heather, the green velvet, and she made herself hold it steady. He got one arm under the man's shoulders and turned him, gently, the way she'd seen people lift sleeping drunks off pub floors at closing time, and the water let go of him with a sound like a slow kiss.
The face that came up into the light was not Marcus Vane's.
It was sandy-haired and sunburnt and slack, and its eyes were half open, and its expensive sunglasses were hooked in the collar of its shirt where they'd been all evening. Tess's legs did something complicated and she sat down hard on the wet planks of the boardwalk.
"Dominic," she said. "It's Dominic."
Ewan didn't answer. He had two fingers pressed to the side of Dominic's neck and his head bowed, and he stayed like that for a long time, long enough that the rain filled the brim of the silence and ran over. Then he took his fingers away.
"He's gone," he said.
"Are you sure? You're trained. You said you were trained. Can't you..."
"I'm sure, Tess." His voice was quite steady and very tired. "He's cold. He's been in the water a while. Longer than since the scream." He laid Dominic down on the bank with his head on the heather, out of the water, and stood up, and looked at her over the body. "I need you to go back to the marquee. Find Orla. She's got the only radio on the island. Tell her to call the coastguard on the marine channel, and tell her nobody leaves the tent. Nobody."
"I'm not leaving you out here."
"Somebody has to stay with him."
"Then I'll stay and you go."
"Tess." He came up out of the pool, streaming, and crouched on the boardwalk in front of her so their faces were level. "Somebody screamed out here, and it wasn't him. Do you understand? Somebody else was out here tonight. I'd rather it was me sitting in the dark waiting for them to come back than you."
She looked at him. Water was running off his chin. The silver hoop in his ear had caught the torchlight.
"That's the most words you've said to me in a row," she said.
"Go," said Ewan. "Please."
She went.
The night before the wedding, Orla Keane had put Tess beside Ewan at dinner and Dominic Shale directly across from both of them, and by the soup course Tess had decided that the seating chart was an act of violence.
The dining room at the lodge had a long oak table and a fire at each end and windows that looked out onto nothing at all, just black glass and the sound of the sea. Candles in old bottles. Wild garlic and mussels from the island's own rocks, then lamb from the mainland, cooked by Marcus himself in Orla's kitchen in a white apron with his name embroidered on the breast, because Marcus could not bear for anyone else to cook at a party he was attending, least of all his own.
"So you bake," said Ewan, during the lamb.
"I bake."
"Bread?"
"Bread, laminated doughs, viennoiserie, the occasional cake for a woman whose husband has left her, at a discount." Tess turned her glass. "And you build boats."
"Wooden ones. Traditional. Currachs, a few yachts for people with more money than sense." He considered his lamb. "It's not that different. Patience, mostly. Knowing when to leave a thing alone."
"I'm terrible at leaving things alone."
"I'd noticed."
"You've known me eight hours."
"Nine," said Ewan. "I counted the ferry."
Across the table, Dominic laughed loudly at nothing. He'd been drinking since the pier and he had the high, bright, dangerous colour of a man who intended to make the evening about himself. Hana sat beside him in a grey sweater, eating almost nothing, her dark bob tucked behind her ears, watching the door to the kitchen every time it swung open.
"Orla," Dominic called down the table. "Orla, love. This is a beautiful spot. Beautiful. I was saying to Hana, you'd want to hold onto a place like this."
Orla looked up from the end of the table with her set smile. "I intend to, Dominic."
"Course you do. Course you do." He raised his glass to her. "The lads at the bank in Galway send their regards, by the way. They say they're looking forward to hearing from you after the weekend."
Something went out of Orla's face. Just for a moment, and only if you were watching. Tess was watching.
"How kind of them," said Orla, and rose, and went to see about the dessert.
Orla stood in the scullery with both hands flat on the cold steel of the sink and counted to thirty, which was what her mother had done, and her mother had raised six of them on this island with no electricity at all.
Nine years. Nine years of weddings and anniversaries and corporate retreats for software people who wanted to do yoga on a bog. Nine years of the roof, the pier, the generator, the slates the winter storms took every January like a tax. She'd remortgaged in the bad year, and again in the worse year, and in March a letter had come to say that her loan had been sold on to a private investment firm in Dublin. She'd looked the firm up. The managing partner had sandy hair and a sunburn and wore sunglasses in his photograph.
He'd booked his friend's wedding with her. Paid the deposit in full. Then he'd rung her in April and said, quite pleasantly, that he hoped it would all go off beautifully, because after the weekend the firm would be reviewing its position.
Orla took her hands off the sink. She checked her lipstick in the dark window. She picked up the tray of little burnt-honey tarts that Marcus had insisted on making, and she went back out to the dining room smiling at exactly the same angle as before.
After the dessert, the crew brought out the oar.
It came in on the shoulders of Bish and Fergal like a coffin, a long old wooden racing oar with its blade painted in faded blue and white, and the whole table cheered except for Tess, who didn't know what was happening, and Ewan, who had gone very still beside her.
"Tradition!" Dominic was on his feet, banging the table. "The crew oar! Every wedding, every christening, every funeral! Eight names, eight men, one boat!"
Tess could see the names now, painted along the loom of the oar in white capitals. VANE. SHALE. ROURKE. BISHOP. Others she didn't know. And one, near the blade, that had been painted over in black, so thickly that the letters stood up under it like scars under a sleeve. She could just make out an N.
One by one the crew laid a hand on the oar and drank. Marcus with a flourish. Dominic with a roar. Bish and Fergal and the others, laughing, slopping whiskey.
Then they all looked at Ewan.
He put down his napkin. He stood up. He didn't touch the oar. He said, quite quietly, "Not this time, lads," and he walked out through the terrace doors into the wind, and the door banged shut behind him.
Dominic laughed. "Same every time. Ewan's got a conscience. Don't you worry, girls, he'll be back for the speeches."
Tess found him at the far end of the terrace, by the low stone wall, looking out at the black water where the lights of the mainland were no more than a few smeared pinpricks.
"Who was N?" she said.
He didn't turn round. "Niall Brennan. Our bow man. He drowned in the Liffey the summer we were twenty-four. Night outing. River in flood. We weren't supposed to be on the water." He was quiet for a while. "There were eight of us in the boat. There's a version of that night that seven of us told the inquest, and there's the true one."
"Which one were you?"
"I was one of the seven," Ewan said. "That's the whole problem."
She stood next to him. Not touching. The wind pulled strands of her hair out of the plait and whipped them across her face, and she let it.
"I'm not going to ask," she said.
He looked at her then, sideways, the way he had on the ferry. "That's the first thing anybody's said to me all weekend that I believe."
Hana went up to the bathroom on the first floor to get away from the oar and the shouting, and when she came out, Marcus Vane was standing in the corridor.
He'd taken off the white apron. He was leaning on the wall beside the door, arms folded, and he didn't move out of her way. He didn't touch her. He didn't need to. He'd never needed to.
"I know you," he said.
Hana's mouth had gone dry. "I don't think so."
"Sure you don't. The new girl. Saturday service. The hand." He tilted his head, studying her palm where she'd closed it into a fist. "Whatever Dom's paying you to be here, I'll double it. There's a ferry at nine on Sunday. Be on it."
"He's not paying me. He's my boyfriend."
Marcus laughed, softly, as if she'd told a very good joke. "Oh, sweetheart," he said. "Is that what he told you?"
The marquee was a riot of torchlight and voices when Tess burst back into it, soaked to the skin, her shoes lost somewhere on the boardwalk. Faces swung toward her. Bridesmaids, crew, Bish with his tie round his head, Hana in her pale blue raincoat near the cake with her arms wrapped round herself, Orla with the walkie-talkie already lifted, already reading Tess's face.
And Sasha, in her wedding dress, standing alone in the middle of the dance floor with her bouquet hanging from one hand like something she'd forgotten she was holding.
"It's Dominic," Tess gasped. "In the bog. Orla, the coastguard. He's dead. He's dead and he's wearing Marcus's jacket."
The tent went silent for the second time that night.
Then the flap behind Tess lifted, and the wind came in, and with it came Marcus Vane, in shirtsleeves, hair plastered to his skull, rain running off him in sheets. Alive. Breathing hard. As if he'd been running from somewhere a long way off.
Sasha turned and looked at her husband. The bouquet slid out of her fingers and landed on the boards.
"But you're..." she said, and stopped, and every person in that tent heard her finish it anyway, very quietly, in a voice like a door closing. "You're meant to be dead."