Cover of The Wish That Changed Everything

The Wish That Changed Everything

Read the story

9 chapters · 23188 words · Read 1 times

When his girlfriend Bree suggests they take a break in their relationship, Matt makes a wish that they could be Bree's ideal couple. Matt has no idea that Bree has always wanted to be a futanari, and that she dreams of having a slutty wife.

Chapter 4: Flesh and Fantasy Merging

The air in the bedroom wasn’t just still; it was holding its breath. The only sounds were the faint hum of the desk lamp and Bree’s shallow, rapid pants. She stared down, her green eyes wide, unblinking. The strap-on was gone. In its place, jutting from the dark blonde curls above her folds, was a thick, ruddy cock. It twitched against her stomach, a pulse of visible life thrumming through a prominent vein.

“Oh fuck,” she whispered again, the words barely audible.

Matt was frozen, his hand still suspended in the air where the silicone had been. His own body felt foreign, soft in places he remembered as hard, heavy where he was used to lightness. But Bree’s transformation—this was something else. This was impossible. He watched a droplet of clear fluid bead at the tip.

“Bree?” His voice cracked.

She didn’t look at him. Her gaze was locked on the new appendage. Slowly, as if moving through water, she brought her hand down. Her fingers, with their chipped black nail polish, hovered an inch from the shaft. She exhaled sharply, a shaky puff of air, and finally touched herself.

A full-body shiver wracked her. “It’s… warm.” Her thumb traced the underside, following the vein. “It’s real. It’s really real.” There was no horror in her tone now. It was awe. A deep, reverent awe that transformed her face, softening the shock into something like rapture.

Then she laughed. It was a short, disbelieving burst of sound that broke the tension like glass. “Holy shit, Matt. Look at this.” She finally looked up, her eyes brilliant. “Do you see this?”

He saw. He saw the thick, living proof of everything he hadn’t understood. The ‘break,’ her distance, the secret she’d held so tightly it had physically manifested. A cold understanding dripped into his gut. This was what she wanted. Not him. Not the man he was. This.

“You…” he started, but the sentence died. You wished for this? It sounded ridiculous, even in his head.

Bree was exploring now, her touch growing bolder, more possessive. She wrapped her hand around the base, giving an experimental squeeze. Her breath hitched. A low, involuntary sound escaped her throat, a groan of pure, stunned pleasure. Her head tilted back against the wall, thudding softly on the mint-green paint.

“It feels… God, it’s connected. I can feel everything.” Her other hand flew to her mouth, stifling another sound. Her hips gave a shallow, reflexive thrust into her own grip.

Matt watched, a spectator in his own life. The woman he loved was pleasuring a new part of herself that had just, by some unearthly magic, sprouted from her body. His brain short-circuited, trying to reconcile the sweet, demure Bree who loved indie films and lavender tea with the woman now bucking against her own fist, her blonde hair falling in a messy curtain over her flushed face.

“This is crazy,” she moaned, but she was smiling, a wild, unfettered grin. “This is absolutely fucking insane.”

The crude intimacy of it, the raw reality, finally spurred Matt into movement. He pushed himself off the bed, his new center of gravity making him wobble for a second. The feeling of his own altered body—the weight of breasts, the curve of hips—was a constant, dull shock beneath the immediate, sharp one. He took a step toward her.

“Bree, stop.”

She didn’t stop. Her eyes slid open, glazed with a pleasure so intense it bordered on pain. “Why?” The word was a challenge, thick and warm.

“Because we need to… to think.” He gestured helplessly, a clumsy wave that encompassed her, himself, the whole fever-dream room. “This isn’t normal! This doesn’t just happen!”

“Well, it just did!” she fired back, her grip tightening. A fresh pearl of fluid welled at the tip. “It happened, Matt. To me. And to you.” Her eyes scanned his changed form, and that possessive fascination from before reignited. “Look at you. You’re so… pretty.”

The word stung. It was the wrong word. He wasn’t pretty. He was Matt. Or he had been.

“I don’t want to be pretty,” he said, the earnestness raw and childlike in the face of the surreal. “I want to be yours.”

“You are mine,” Bree said, and there was a new, dominant edge in her voice that made his stomach clench. She pushed off from the wall, standing tall on her heels. The cock bobbed between her thighs, a blatant, undeniable fact. She took a step toward him. “You’re more mine now than you ever were before. Don’t you see? This… this fits.” She reached out with her free hand and cupped his cheek. Her touch was searing. “My perfect, slutty little wife.”

The word ‘wife’ echoed in the cluttered room. It wasn’t a proposal. It was a branding. A designation.

New desires, alien and sweet as poisoned honey, flooded his brain again, responding to her words, to her touch, to the sheer authority of her presence. A part of him wanted to recoil, to scream, to demand his old body back. A stronger part, a part that felt deep and primal and right, wanted to sink to his knees. The conflict paralyzed him.

Bree saw it. Her smile turned knowing. She guided his hand, the one that had touched the transforming strap-on, and placed it on her hot, hard flesh.

The sensation was electric. For both of them. Bree gasped, her knees buckling slightly. Matt felt the life in it, the pounding pulse, the silken skin over rigid core. It was utterly, completely real.

“See?” Bree whispered, leaning her forehead against his. Her breath was sweet. “It’s okay. This is what was supposed to happen. I wanted it so much… I guess I just didn’t know how much.” She guided his hand, moving it slowly up and down. “There you go. Just like that.”

He was touching her. He was stroking her. A part of her that had never existed until twenty minutes ago. The mechanics were familiar, the context world-shattering. He looked into her eyes, searching for the woman he’d known, and saw a stranger staring back—a beautiful, terrifying stranger who owned him utterly.

Outside, the neon sign flickered, casting a crimson wash across the whiskey bottle, the crumpled bedsheets, and their joined shadows on the wall—a new silhouette, monstrous and intimate, born from stale pizza and unspoken fantasies finally spoken into being.

Bree’s other hand snaked into his hair, fisting gently. She pulled his head back, exposing his throat. “My good girl,” she murmured, and the words were a key turning in a lock deep inside him. “Now, let’s see what else this new body of yours can do.”

Her grip in his hair loosened from a fist to a cradle, her thumb stroking his temple. "Hey," she whispered, her voice dropping an octave, losing its command for a moment. "Look at me."

Matt’s eyes, wide and liquid in the faint light, focused on hers. The predatory gleam had melted into something warmer, more inviting. It was still intense, still hungry, but the edge had been sheathed. She leaned in and kissed him, not on the mouth, but softly on the corner of his jaw. Her new cock pressed against his thigh, insistently hot, but her hands were gentle.

"Just let it happen, Matt," she breathed against his skin, her lips tracing a path down his neck. "Stop fighting for a second. Please?"

A shudder ran through him, part resistance, part release. The plea, the 'please,' did what the command had not. It disarmed him. His shoulders, which had been held rigid, dropped. The strange, lush curves of his own body seemed to sigh in response, a warmth pooling low in his belly that felt entirely different from anything he’d known before. It was an answer, direct and physical, to the affection in her touch.

He made a small sound, a whimper lost in the cage of his throat.

"That's it," Bree coaxed, her hands sliding down to his hips. She turned him slowly, guiding him back toward the bed. The crumpled sheets, which had smelled of loneliness and stale sleep just an hour ago, now seemed to beckon. "Let me look at you. All of you."

As his knees hit the edge of the mattress, Matt’s gaze drifted past her shoulder. He blinked. The clutter on his nightstand—the empty whiskey bottle, a chaotic spill of coins, a forgotten TV remote—was gone. In its place sat a simple ceramic lamp with a creamy linen shade, casting a soft, golden glow. The air no longer smelled of old grease and regret.

It carried a clean, subtle scent of rain on pavement and lavender.

He stared, comprehension dawning. The sickly mint-green walls seemed deeper, calmer, a sage grey in the new light. The piled cardboard boxes in the corner had vanished, leaving a clean stretch of floor where a small, plush rug now lay. His apartment was rewriting itself, pixel by pixel, responding to some deep, silent scream within him for order, for beauty, for a space that didn’t mirror his chaos.

"Whoa," he mumbled.

Bree followed his look, a slow smile spreading across her face. She didn't seem surprised. "See? Even the room knows." She urged him down onto the fresh-smelling sheets. "You wished for things to be right, didn't you? In that scared little heart of yours."

He had. Desperately. For her to stay, for the confusion to end, for the pain of the proposed "break" to be wiped clean. He just hadn't known the cost, or the shape, of that rightness.

Her touch resumed, exploratory and patient. She traced the new swell of his hip, the dramatic dip of his waist. Her fingers were calloused from her work at the plant nursery, a rough contrast against his suddenly-silken skin. "God, your skin is like… I don't know. Something expensive." She laughed, a real, lighthearted sound that was a ghost from their past. "Sorry, that's a crap description."

The casual, familiar laugh broke another layer of his fear. A weak chuckle bubbled out of him in response. "Poetic as ever."

"I never claimed to be a poet, babe." She leaned down, her blonde hair curtaining their faces, and kissed his stomach. Her mouth was warm. "I'm just a girl with a very new, very confusing piece of equipment who thinks her boyfriend got unfairly hot."

The mundane absurdity of the statement, delivered in her normal, dry tone, was the final key. The world had ended and remade itself, but she was still Bree. His Bree. Even like this. His body arched slightly off the bed, not in escape, but into her mouth’s tender exploration. A jolt of pleasure, sharp and sweet, arrowed through him from the point of contact.

It was a type of nerves he didn't possess. Or hadn't.

"Okay?" she asked, pausing, her green eyes searching his.

He nodded, words beyond him. His hands, which had lain flat at his sides, rose. One tangled tentatively in her hair. The other reached down, his fingers brushing the fever-warm skin of her shoulder, then tracing the line of her back. He was touching her, actively, for the first time since the change. Accepting. Initiating.

The hard edge of her demand was gone, replaced by a radiant, focused heat. Her lust hadn't dimmed; it had transformed into a devouring curiosity, a worship of this new reality they were building touch by touch. She nuzzled the soft plain below his navel, her breath hitching as her own length, neglected and full, twitched against the mattress.

Matt felt his new body opening to her affection like a flower following the sun. Every whisper of her lips, every stroke of her hands, mapped a territory of sensation that was entirely novel and profoundly right. The last fortress of his old self, the one screaming this was wrong, crumbled into dust, its bricks carried away by a river of pure, physical truth.

Outside, the flickering neon sign stabilized, casting a steady, deep blue light through the now-clean window. It painted their moving bodies in cool tones, a silent audience to the pact being sealed in the transforming room. Her mouth traveled lower, and his back bowed off the bed, a gasp tearing from his lips that was neither Matt’s nor anyone else’s, but entirely, perfectly, his own.

Her mouth traveled lower, and his back bowed off the bed, a gasp tearing from his lips that was neither Matt’s nor anyone else’s, but entirely, perfectly, his own. The sound was high, clean, unfamiliar. Bree froze for a second, her breath hot against him, and looked up. Her eyes held a question.

Then they darkened with pure wonder.

“Again,” she whispered, her voice husky. “Make that sound again.”

She didn’t wait for him to comply. She lowered her mouth once more, her tongue finding a new, shocking constellation of nerve endings he could never have imagined. His hands fisted in the transformed sheets—linen now, crisp and cool—as another gasp was punched out of him. It was too much. It was everything.

Bree pulled back, panting. She wasn't looking at his face anymore. Her gaze was sweeping over the landscape of his body, illuminated in the steady blue glow. She pushed herself up on her knees, straddling his thighs, her own impressive hardness standing proudly between them. But she ignored it, for now.

“I need to see you,” she breathed. “All of you. Just… just let me look.”

Her hands began a slow, reverent inventory. They smoothed over the pronounced curve of his hip, fingertips dipping into the dramatic hollow there. She traced the new, softer line of his abdomen, her touch feather-light. “It’s like someone sculpted you,” she mumbled, almost to herself. “Out of something warm.” She leaned down, placing a soft, closed-mouth kiss just below his navel.

Every point of contact was a live wire. A humiliating, thrilling heat spread through him, pooling low. He couldn’t speak. He could only watch her face, utterly rapt, as she studied him.

She cupped the full weight of his breast, her thumb brushing over the peak. He flinched, a jolt of sensation lancing through him. Bree’s eyes flicked up to his, checking. He nodded, a tiny, desperate movement. Her thumb circled again, firmer this time, and a low groan escaped him. It was a sound of surrender.

“Beautiful,” she said, the word a solid thing in the quiet room. It wasn’t a throwaway compliment. It was a decree.

Her exploration continued, meticulous and awed. She traced the line of his collarbone, the newfound softness of his inner arm, the delicate skin of his wrist. It was as if she was memorizing him, confirming the reality of this transformation touch by touch. Her earlier urgency was gone, replaced by a devout, simmering attention.

“You feel real,” she said, her voice thick. “So real.” Her hand slid down his side, over the flare of his new hip, and came to rest on the outside of his thigh. She squeezed gently, massaging the muscle. “My god, Matt. You’re here. You’re really here like this.”

He found his voice, thin and cracked. “Is this… is this what you wanted?”

She stilled. Her eyes, which had been devouring his body, rose to meet his. The hunger in them was tempered by a shocking softness. “No,” she said quietly. He felt the word like a blow. But then she continued. “I didn’t know how to want this. I wanted… a feeling. A truth. This is that.” Her free hand came up to cradle his cheek. “You are that.”

Tears, hot and sudden, pricked the corners of his eyes. They were born from confusion, from the dissolution of his old self, from the terrifying sincerity in her gaze.

“Don’t,” she whispered, catching a tear with her thumb. “It’s okay.” She kissed his eyelids, his temples, the salt trail on his cheek. Her movements were slow, worshipful. “You’re my miracle. You know that?” Her lips brushed his ear. “My beautiful, perfect miracle.”

Her mouth found his then, and the kiss was different. It wasn't the frantic clash from before. It was deep, searching, and impossibly tender. It tasted like lavender and shared secrets. He kissed her back, his hands finally moving, tangling in her hair, pulling her closer until their bodies aligned.

She gasped into his mouth as her length pressed against his belly, hot and insistent. The contact sent a fresh, sympathetic thrum through his own altered core. He rocked against her, a slow, instinctual grind. Her breath hitched.

“Yeah,” she murmured against his lips. “Like that.” She broke the kiss to look down between them, watching the motion. Her expression was one of profound fascination. “Look at that.”

He looked. The sight of her, solid and wanting, moving against the softness of his own body, sent a dizzying rush through him. The last vestige of his old mind, the one clinging to a linear past, finally released its grip.

Bree lowered her head to his shoulder, her body moving in a steady, building rhythm. Her worship became physical, a communion of friction and heat. Her whispers were muffled against his skin. “You feel so good. So good. You have no idea.”

Her whisper hung in the lavender-scented air, a confession drowned in static. Matt felt its truth vibrate through her body, pressed against his. He had no idea. About any of it. The thought should have panicked him.

Instead, it crystallized something. His love for her wasn’t a question. It was the only solid thing left in this shifting room. If her pleasure was the compass point, he would follow it.

“Then show me,” he heard himself say. His voice was steadier than he felt.

Bree pulled back just enough to look at him. Her pupils were wide, swallowing the green of her eyes. A slow smile touched her lips. “Yeah?” Her hand slid from his cheek down to his throat, her thumb resting on his pulse. “You mean that?”

He nodded against the pillow. The movement felt decisive. His own strange sensations, the alien pleasure singing under his skin, could wait. This was about her. About making the awe on her face deepen, about answering the desperate want he saw there. He shifted beneath her, guiding her with hands that now felt purposefully gentle.

“Tell me what you need,” he said.

A laugh escaped her, breathy and surprised. “God, where to start.” She rocked her hips, a slow, experimental grind that made them both catch their breath. “This is… a lot. In a good way.” She paused, studying his face. “You’re not freaking out anymore.”

“I am,” he admitted. His heart was a wild thing against her palm. “But I’m here.”

That seemed to be enough. Her expression softened, the last tension melting from her shoulders. She leaned down, kissing him with a tenderness that felt older than the room, older than their changed bodies. It was a kiss from before the break, from before everything. It promised a future.

“Okay,” she murmured against his mouth. “Just… touch me. Like you did before. But slower.”

Her guidance was practical, anchoring him. He let his hands resume their journey, tracing the familiar yet utterly foreign landscape of her. He focused on the feedback, the hitch in her breath when his thumb circled a particular spot on her hip, the way her back arched when he traced the line of her spine. He watched her face, learning the map of her pleasure from her reactions.

His own body responded in confusing, liquid echoes. Each sound she made ignited a corresponding heat in him. It was a feedback loop, her pleasure amplifying his own strange new capacity for it.

“Here,” she gasped suddenly, grabbing his wrist. She guided his hand down, past the heat of her belly, and wrapped his fingers around her. The skin was smoother than he’d imagined, hot and alive, pulsing under his touch. “Just… yeah. Just hold it.”

He held her, feeling the weight, the vital thrum. It was intimate in a way that surpassed anything they’d done before. This was her, unveiled. Her secret, given flesh and placed in his hand.

Bree’s head fell forward, her blonde hair curtaining their joined hands. She began to move again, a slow, rolling rhythm, using his grip as an anchor. Her eyes were closed, her lips parted. She was lost in it, in the sheer physical fact of herself.

Matt watched, transfixed. His fear was gone, burned away by a fiercer fuel: devotion. He wanted to see her shatter. He wanted to be the reason.

“You feel so good,” he whispered, the words coming unbidden. He tightened his grip slightly, matching her rhythm.

Her eyes flew open, locking onto his. The green was almost black. “Don’t stop talking.”

“You’re amazing.” He stroked his thumb along a prominent vein. She shuddered violently. “Like this, you’re… Bree, you’re breathtaking.”

A strangled sound escaped her, half-laugh, half-sob. “Say that again.”

“You’re breathtaking.” He said it with conviction, pouring every ounce of his dislocated love into the words. He shifted beneath her, rising up to capture her mouth with his as his hand continued its steady, devoted work.

She kissed him back furiously, all teeth and need, her hips driving faster against his fist. The room, the transformed and tranquil room, seemed to tighten around them, holding its breath. The clean scent of rain and lavender was now underscored by salt and sweat and her.

He broke the kiss to speak against her jaw. “Let go. I’ve got you.”

It was the permission she needed. Her control snapped. A raw, guttural cry tore from her throat as her body seized, bowing back in a taut arc. He held her through it, his grip firm, an anchor in the storm of her release, his own body humming with a sympathetic, thrilling completion he didn’t yet understand.

She collapsed forward, a dead weight of trembling limbs and damp skin. Her forehead pressed into the crook of his neck, her breath hot and ragged against his collarbone. He held her, stroking her hair with his free hand, the other still curled possessively around the softening warmth of her.

For long minutes, there was only the sound of their breathing syncing, the distant hum of the city beyond the clean window. The blue light from outside painted peaceful stripes across their tangled forms.

Bree finally stirred, nuzzling into his neck. “Wow.” Her voice was a wrecked, happy thing.

“Yeah.” He kissed the top of her head.

She lifted her head, her face flushed and beautiful, streaked with the ghost of tears. She looked down between them, at his hand still resting on her, and a slow, dazed smile spread across her face. “So. That happened.”

He couldn’t help but smile back. The absurdity of it all crashed over him again, but gently now. “It did.”

She shifted, wincing slightly, and rolled off to lie beside him. She stared at the ceiling, one arm thrown over her eyes. “My brain is soup.” She turned her head on the pillow to look at him. “You’re okay?”

He considered the question. The physical shock had subsided, leaving a deep, exhausted calm. His body felt like a question mark, but his heart felt sure. “I’m with you.”

She reached over, lacing her fingers with his. Her hand was smaller in his now, another quiet shift. “Good answer.”

They lay in silence, the immensity of the change settling around them like snow. The earlier frantic energy was spent. Matt’s mind, finally quiet, began to gently probe the edges of his own new reality. The weight on his chest, the curve of his hip against the sheet—they were facts now. Less terrifying, simply present.

Bree’s breathing evened out beside him. He thought she might be falling asleep. But then she spoke, her voice soft and thoughtful in the dim blue light.

“You know,” she said, “I used to lie right here and imagine… stuff. Crazy stuff.” She squeezed his hand. “Never anything this good.”

He turned to face her, propping his head on his hand. The motion felt different, his hair falling across his shoulder. “The ‘break’,” he said, not as an accusation, but a puzzle piece clicking into place.

She met his gaze, no shame in it now. “Yeah. I was… I was gonna try to figure out how to be this. Alone. Scared the hell out of me.” She reached out, brushing a strand of hair from his forehead. “Then you had to go and… well. Here we are.”

“Here we are,” he echoed. A strange, protective warmth bloomed in his chest. She hadn’t wanted to leave him. She’d wanted to become herself, and had been willing to walk away to do it. The love he felt twisted, deepened, became more complex.

Her fingers trailed from his temple down to his lips. “Your turn,” she whispered, her eyes darkening again with a tender curiosity. “Let me see what feels good for you now.”

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI