Cover of Three Hearts

Three Hearts

Read the story

13 chapters · 23433 words · Read 0 times

Simon "Ghist" Riely and Captian John Price and their shared boyfriend James Carlson

Chapter 2: The Bet

Price's apartment swallowed them whole the moment the door clicked shut.

The study was a cavern of shadow and aged mahogany, layers of warmth that seemed to absorb sound and light. A single globe lamp cast its amber glow across the room, the brass surface etched with faded continents, some names worn smooth by years of fingers tracing routes and destinations. The walls were pinned with sea maps, their edges curling, their ink faded to sepia. Salt air clung to the fabric of the curtains despite the apartment being miles from any harbor. Two leather chairs faced each other like old adversaries, their surfaces cracked and worn, and a third—newer, stiffer—sat slightly apart from them, as if waiting to be broken in.

James stood in the doorway, dripping rain and awkwardness onto the hardwood. His hoodie clung to his thin frame, the gray fabric darkened to the color of wet slate. He shoved his hands deep into his pockets, shoulders hunching, trying to make himself smaller in a space that suddenly felt far too intimate for someone who'd only met these men twenty minutes ago on a rooftop.

"Nice place," he said, the words tumbling out too fast. "Very... nautical. Do you actually sail, or is this just, like, a maritime aesthetic thing? Because I knew a guy in college who had a bunch of ship stuff, and it turned out he'd never even been on a boat. He just really liked the movie Master and Commander. Weird dude. Dropped out sophomore year."

Price moved past him with the casual confidence of a man who owned every inch of space he occupied. He retrieved three glasses from a sideboard, the crystal catching the lamplight as he set them down with a deliberate clink. "My father was in the Navy. I grew up around maps." He didn't elaborate, didn't need to. Men like Price didn't offer their histories without reason.

"Cool. Cool, that's—" James's throat clicked. He swallowed hard. "That's nice. Family history. Very meaningful."

Ghost had positioned himself against the bookshelf, arms crossed, his broad frame silhouetted against the shelves of leather-bound volumes. He hadn't spoken since they'd left the rooftop, and the weight of his gaze was a physical thing—heavy, unblinking, tracking James's every nervous gesture.

James was acutely aware of the way his voice was too loud in the quiet room. He could hear himself rambling, could hear the desperate edge creeping into his tone, but he couldn't stop. The silence between these two men was too thick, too knowing. It felt like they could see through him, past the bravado and the tattoos, down to the trembling thing underneath.

"So, uh, what do you guys do?" James continued, gesturing vaguely with his FUCK-knuckled hand. "I mean, obviously you're not—you're not like, accountants or something. You've got that whole 'spec ops' vibe going. Is that offensive? Calling you spec ops? Because I feel like it's offensive. You probably have a very specific job title that involves classified information, and I'm over here guessing wrong and—"

"You talk a lot for someone who's clearly scared shitless."

Price's voice cut through the ramble like a blade through silk.

James's mouth stop working. The words died in his throat. He blinked, his brain scrambling to catch up, and the only thing he managed to produce was a strangled, "Excuse me?"

Price settled into one of the leather chairs with the deliberate grace of a predator circling its prey. He didn't lean back. He sat forward, elbows on his knees, the glass of scotch cradled in his hands, and his gaze was steady and unblinking. The salt-and-pepper beard caught the lamplight, but it was his eyes that held James pinned—sharp, assessing, missing nothing.

"You heard me." The words were calm, unhurried. He took a slow sip of his drink, letting the silence stretch. "You've been running your mouth since we walked through the door. Nervous energy. I've seen it before."

"I'm not nervous." James's voice cracked on the word, and he felt heat rush to his face. "I'm just—this is how I talk. I'm a talker. I'm charming."

"You're charming," Price repeated, a smile curling beneath his mustache. "Is that what you call it?"

James opened his mouth to fire back a retort that would absolutely show this guy—show both of them—that he was a force to be reckoned with, that nobody talked to him like that, but instead what came out was a defensive, "You don't know anything about me."

"I know you tripped over your own feet and blamed my partner for it. I know you called him a cunt to his face and looked like you were going to pass out when he didn't throw you off the roof." Price swirled the amber liquid in his glass, watching the way the light played through it. "I know you're scared, and you're trying to hide it by being loud."

"I'm not—"

"I bet you're not this mouthy when you're on your knees."

The words landed like a slap.

James felt every drop of blood in his body rush to his face. His mouth opened and closed, producing no sound, no words, nothing but a faint, strangled sort of squeak that he would deny until his dying day. The skin across his cheekbones burned, his ears went hot, and he could feel the pulse in his throat hammering against his collar.

"Fuck you," he finally managed, and the words came out breathless, nowhere near as defiant as he'd intended.

Ghost's lips twitched.

It was subtle—barely a movement—but James caught it. The big man's mouth curved just slightly at the corner, and there was something in his eyes that hadn't been there before. A spark of amusement. Interest.

Price leaned forward in his chair, setting his glass down on the side table with a soft click. "There it is." His voice was low, satisfied. "I was wondering when we'd see the real you."

James found his footing, trying to summon the bravado that had carried him through a lifetime of being underestimated. "The real me is tired of being talked down to by two guys I barely know. You invited me here. For scotch. Remember?"

"The scotch is a courtesy," Price said. "Not the invitation."

"What is the invitation, then?"

Price exchanged a look with Ghost—a silent communication that James couldn't parse but that sent a shiver down his spine. They moved like a unit, these two, connected by something deeper than friendship. Something shared.

Ghost pushed off from the bookshelf and crossed the room in three strides. He didn't stop until he was standing directly in front of James, close enough that James could feel the heat radiating off his body, could smell the soap from his earlier shower and something else underneath—something that was purely him. He tipped his head down, and James caught the full force of those dark eyes, the map of scars on his face somehow less intimidating up close than they'd been from a distance.

Being this close, James could see the faint lines around his eyes, the flecks of something almost golden in the brown. Could see the way his mouth was shaped, the hollow of his cheeks, the way his jaw didn't quite move when he spoke. He smelled like clean sweat and expensive soap and something that made James feel unsteady.

"You've got a smart mouth," Ghost said. His voice was rough, low, a voice that had been scraped raw by smoke and screaming and years of not letting anyone close. "Am I wrong?"

James's tongue darted out, wetting his lips. The piercing there clicked against his teeth. "I mean... maybe. Depends who's asking."

Ghost's hand came up, not to touch, just to hover close to James's face. James flinched instinctively—years of conditioned responses—but Ghost didn't pull away. He just waited, patient, watching James deliberately uncoil.

"I'm asking," Ghost said.

The air between them had changed. The room was too warm, too small, the walls pressing in. James felt his pulse in places that made him furious: in his throat, behind his ribs, low in his belly. He wanted to be affronted. Wanted to feel threatened. But somehow, under the intensity of Ghost's gaze, the only thing he felt was seen.

"I'm not scared of you," James said, and it was almost true.

"I didn't ask if you were scared." Ghost's voice dropped. "I asked if you had a smart mouth. Answer the question."

James swallowed hard. His eyes darted toward Price, who was watching with open appreciation—like he was seeing something rare unfold. Price gave him a small nod, the kind of gesture that might have passed for encouragement but felt more like permission. Like he was saying: go ahead. Show us who you are.

"I..." James's voice caught. He didn't know what came over him in that moment—maybe the scotch that had been poured and abandoned, maybe the intensity of being the sole focus of two such powerful men—but he made a decision. He straightened his spine, lifted his chin, and met Ghost's eyes.

"It's not smart," he said. "It's honest. There's a difference."

Ghost's hand finally touched him—just the tips of his fingers brushing the hinge of James's jaw. Light, barely there, a question rather than a demand.

"It's going to get you in trouble," Ghost murmured. "Somebody's going to decide they want to shut you up."

James's breath hitched. His heart was a wild thing in his chest. "Maybe I'm hoping somebody will try."

The words hung in the air between them, electric and alive. James felt the heat of his own blush spreading down his neck, into his chest. He could see the answer in the flare of Ghost's nostrils, the way his pupils dilated, the shifting of his weight.

Then Price's voice came from across the room, warm and dangerous and pleased.

"Get him over here, Simon. We're not finished with him yet."

Ghost's hand slid from James's jaw to the back of his neck, the grip gentle but insistent. He guided James toward the leather chairs—not roughly, but with a quiet authority that made James's knees weaken. When they reached Price, the older man stood, unfolding himself to his full height.

He was broader than Ghost, thicker through the chest and shoulders, and James felt small between the two of them. Trapped in the best possible way.

Price's hands came up to James's shoulders, running down his arms until he reached the hem of the wet hoodie. "This is soaked," he observed, his voice carrying a note of concern. "You're going to catch cold."

"I'm fine," James managed, though his teeth had started to chatter.

"No." Price eased the hoodie up, and James, dazed and trembling, raised his arms to let him pull it over his head. The fabric peeled away, leaving him in just a thin black t-shirt that was struggling to cover his ribs. He wasn't sure when his nipples had gotten hard, but they were visible through the damp cotton, the piercings catching the light.

Price's gaze dropped, cataloguing what he saw. The tattoos that covered both arms, curling up the sides of his neck. The silver flash of metal through his nipples beneath the clinging fabric. The slim cut of his waist, the narrow lines of his hips.

Ghost made a low sound behind him, and James felt his face go impossibly hotter.

"You've got ink," Price observed, touching the edge of a design on James's shoulder. "Where'd you get these?"

"Everywhere." James's voice was thready. "Various places. Bad decisions, mostly."

"They suit you." Price's thumb traced the pattern of a flowering briar that wrapped around James's upper arm. "I've always appreciated someone who commits to their choices." His gaze flicked up, meeting James's eyes. "Even the bad ones."

James's mouth went dry. He felt like a fish on a line, gasping, caught by two men who seemed to know exactly how to play him.

"Are you going to kiss me?" The words escaped before James could stop them, and he immediately wished he could swallow them back. "Because if you're going to—if this is what this is—you should know that I'm not—I don't—"

Price silenced him with his mouth.

It wasn't gentle. It was a claiming—hot and deep and demanding, a hand fisted in James's hair, tipping his head back. James made a sound that was half protest, half surrender, and Price swallowed it whole. The kiss tasted like scotch and smoke and something darker, something that made James's stomach flip.

"Fuck," he breathed when Price finally pulled back, his lips reddened, his eyes dazed.

"Language," Price said mildly, though his eyes were dark and pleased.

Behind him, Ghost's hands settled on James's hips, turning him slightly so he could duck his head and press his mouth to the side of James's throat. The scrape of his stubble sent a shiver down James's spine, and he gasped as Ghost's lips found the sensitive spot behind his ear.

"Now," Price said, his voice dropping to a register James hadn't heard before. "Why don't you be a good boy and tell us what you really need?"

James's brain felt like static. His body was on fire, his skin oversensitive, and every brush of their hands made him twitch. "I don't—I'm not good at being good," he admitted, the words muffled against Ghost's shoulder.

Price smiled, slow and predatory. "That's fine. We're not either."

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI