Chapter 13: Barts place
The success of Helga’s rye bread had left a golden, buttery haze over Eleanor’s world for exactly three days. She’d carried slices of the dense, tangy loaf to Millie, to her neighbor Mrs. Gable, even to the bored teenagers at the local library’s front desk. The praise was a drug, and she was blissfully high on it. So high, in fact, that she’d completely forgotten the fundamental law of her own kitchen: triumph was always, always followed by a spectacular comedown.
“We need a change of scenery,” Sera announced, bursting into Eleanor’s kitchen one Tuesday morning. She gestured with her phone at the familiar surroundings. “Your kitchen is starting to look like a stage set. The audience needs new visuals. Authenticity in a new environment.”
Eleanor, who was trying to find a matching lid for a saucepan, looked up. “What new environment?”
“Bart’s.”
The lid Eleanor was holding clattered to the floor. “Bart’s house? Sera, we can’t just invade Bart’s house.”
“He invited us,” Sera said, a triumphant smirk playing on her lips. “I showed him the analytics from the rye stream. The engagement was insane. He grunted, which I’ve learned is Bart for ‘hell yes.’ He said we could use his kitchen for the savory scone chapter. Said his oven has ‘even heat.’ Whatever that means.”
An hour later, they stood on Bart’s creaky front porch. His house was a low-slung, weathered bungalow tucked behind a riot of untamed rose bushes. It smelled of damp earth and old wood. He opened the door before they could knock, nodded once, and led them inside.
Bart’s kitchen was the polar opposite of Eleanor’s suspiciously clean one. It was a time capsule, warm and worn and utterly specific. The air was layered with decades of cooking smells—onion, garlic, bacon fat, and the faint, perpetual ghost of yeast. A collection of mismatched mugs hung from hooks under a cupboard. A faded calendar from a local feed supplier, three years out of date, was tacked to the wall. The linoleum floor was scuffed into a soft patina along the most well-traveled paths.
“Wow,” Eleanor breathed, her writer’s brain already cataloging the details. “It’s perfect.”
“It’s a mess,” Bart grunted, though he didn’t seem to mind.
“It’s got character,” Sera corrected, already setting up her tripod on the small, wooden kitchen table. “So much character. This is gold. Okay, El, you’re making the cheddar and chive scones. Bart, you’re on… ambiance duty. Just be your charming, silent self.”
Bart took up a position leaning against the counter, arms crossed, a silent, flannel-cled monument.
Eleanor unpacked her ingredients, feeling immediately off-balance. Nothing was where she expected it to be. She opened a cupboard looking for a bowl and found stacks of canned tomatoes. Another held a collection of vintage mixing bowls, but they were stacked precariously high. “Uh, Bart? Where do you keep your… you know, regular bowls?”
He pointed a thick finger towards a low cupboard near the sink. Eleanor crouched, opening it to find a jumble of ceramic and glass. She pulled out a large, speckled blue bowl, its heft feeling reassuring in her hands.
“Okay,” she said, laying out the recipe card. “Cold butter. Very cold.” She located a cheese grater after two wrong drawers, the metal shrieking in protest as she pulled it open. She began grating a stick of butter into the flour, the shreds falling like pale yellow snow. “The key is to keep everything cold. Cold butter makes flaky layers.”
She was in the zone, until she reached for the baking powder. It wasn’t in her bag. She’d forgotten it. “Oh, for heaven’s sake. Bart, do you have baking powder?”
Bart pushed himself off the counter and walked to a narrow pantry. He moved a bag of rice and a can of coffee aside and retrieved a small, rust-stained tin. He handed it to her. Eleanor pried it open. The powder inside was clumped into a single, rock-hard cake.
“Is this… still good?” she asked, hesitantly.
“Mother’s,” Bart said, as if that answered everything.
Sera zoomed in on the petrified tin. “Vintage leavening agent, folks. Hashtag Grandma’sBakingPowder. Hashtag PrayForTheScones.”
“We’ll make it work,” Eleanor said, with more confidence than she felt. She attacked the clump with a fork, creating a coarse powder. She mixed it into the flour and butter, then added the shredded cheddar and a handful of freshly chopped chives. “Now, the buttermilk.”
She reached for the carton she’d brought, giving it a shake. It sloshed reassuringly. She poured it into the flour mixture and began to mix with a fork. The dough came together quickly, but it was wet. Soggier than it should be. She frowned. “That’s too much liquid. Did I measure wrong?”
She glanced at the buttermilk carton. It was the one she’d taken from her fridge, but the ‘sell-by’ date was yesterday. She’d grabbed the old one by mistake. A slow, sinking feeling began in her stomach. She leaned in and gave the dough a tentative sniff. There it was. A faint, off note beneath the tang. Not rancid, but… tired.
“Everything okay?” Sera asked, her voice low.
“Fine,” Eleanor chirped, too brightly. “Just… a little sticky.” She dumped the shaggy mass onto Bart’s counter, which she realized too late wasn’t floured. The dough stuck to the worn wood with a soft, sucking sound. “Oh, brilliant.”
Bart wordlessly handed her a canister of flour. She dusted the counter and her hands liberally, wrestling the sticky dough into a semblance of a circle. It was a losing battle. The dough clung to her fingers, to the rolling pin, to itself. She managed to pat it into a thick, lopsided disk and cut it into wedges with a knife she found in a drawer, its handle wrapped in cracked electrical tape.
“They have… personality,” Sera offered, filming the sad, ragged triangles as Eleanor transferred them to a baking sheet.
“They look like casualties,” Eleanor muttered, wiping a floury, dough-caked hand across her forehead.
She opened Bart’s oven, a squat, avocado-green relic. A wave of dry heat rolled out. She slid the baking sheet onto the middle rack and closed the door with a heavy, metallic clunk. “Now we wait.”
The wait was agony. The familiar, comforting smell of baking pastry should have begun to seep from the oven, but instead, a different, more suspicious aroma began to permeate the kitchen. It was the smell of browning cheese, yes, but underneath it was something else. Something vaguely sour. Eleanor’s heart began to sink.
When the timer dinged, she opened the oven door. The scones had spread, not risen. They were flat, pale golden disks with dark, oozing patches where the elderly buttermilk and cheese had conspired against her. They looked defeated.
She pulled them out, setting the hot sheet on Bart’s stovetop. They sat there, steaming faintly, a testament to her perpetual two-steps-forward-one-step-back existence.
Sera was mercifully silent. Bart pushed off the counter and came to stand beside Eleanor. He looked down at the failed scones for a long moment. Then, he picked up the knife with the taped handle, sliced the least-offensive one in half, and took a bite.
He chewed slowly, his face impassive. Eleanor held her breath.
“Hmph,” he said, swallowing. He took another bite. “A bit dense.”
Eleanor’s shoulders slumped.
“But the flavor’s there,” he continued, his voice a low rumble. “The cheese is good. Chives are fresh.” He finished the wedge and looked at her, his gaze steady. “You used bad buttermilk.”
Tears pricked at the back of Eleanor’s eyes. She nodded, unable to speak.
“Happens,” Bart said. He gestured around his kitchen, at the crowded counters, the ancient appliances, the well-worn tools. “This isn’t a show kitchen. It’s a working kitchen. Things go wrong. You learn.” He picked up another scone and handed it to her. “Eat your failure. Then we’ll start over. I’ve got buttermilk in the back of the fridge. It’s good.”
Eleanor took the warm, sad scone. She broke off a piece and put it in her mouth. It was gummy. The sour note was unmistakable. It was, undeniably, a failure.
But as she stood there in Bart’s authentic, character-filled kitchen, chewing on her mistake, she felt a weird sense of peace. This was it. This was the real work. Not the magical, one-time triumph of Gertie’s rye, but the daily, messy, often-flawed practice of trying. She looked at Sera, who gave her a small, genuine smile, and then at Bart, who was already clearing the ruined scones away.
“Okay,” Eleanor said, her voice firming. She brushed the crumbs from her hands. “Let’s try that again.”
The second batch felt different from the first, slower and more deliberate. Eleanor moved through Bart’s kitchen with a new wariness, her hands remembering the sticky failure of the previous dough. She located a fresh carton of buttermilk from the cool, dark recesses of his fridge, its chill a reassurance against her palm.
“Okay, cold butter, cold hands, cold everything,” she muttered, more to herself than to Sera’s phone. She grated the butter into the flour, the metal grater biting into the hard stick with a satisfying shred. Bart watched, silent, from his post by the counter, a faint nod his only comment when she correctly used his pastry blender to cut the fat in.
She incorporated the cheese and chives, the vibrant green flecks a promise of flavor. When she poured the new buttermilk in, the dough came together with a resistance that felt right, shaggy but not wet. She turned it out onto his generously floured counter. “It’s not sticking,” she whispered, almost afraid to jinx it.
She patted the dough into a thick, neat circle, her hands confident this time. The knife with the taped handle felt solid in her grip as she scored the disk into eight clean wedges. They held their shape, looking like proper scones now, not casualties. She transferred them to the baking sheet, a line of neat, hopeful triangles.
The oven’s heat hit her face as she slid them inside. This time, the wait was filled not with dread, but a low thrum of anticipation. The first hints of baking pastry, rich and buttery, began to war with the kitchen’s permanent scent of garlic and old wood.
When the timer went off, the scones were golden-brown, with cheese bubbling at the edges and a rise that was honest, not dramatic. She pulled them out, setting the sheet on the stovetop with a clatter that sounded like victory.
Bart didn’t wait for them to cool. He broke one open. Steam billowed out, carrying the sharp scent of cheddar and the fresh, oniony punch of chive. The interior was tender, layered, a world away from the gummy failure of before. He took a bite.
“Now that’s a scone,” he said, crumbs dusting his flannel shirt.
The sound that came out of Eleanor was half-laugh, half-sob. She broke a piece off for herself. It was flaky, savory, perfect. Sera didn’t say a word, just slowly panned her camera from the beautiful, broken scone in Eleanor’s hand to the utterly relieved and triumphant expression on her face.
“We got it,” Eleanor said, her voice thick. She looked around Bart’s worn kitchen, at the faded calendar and the jumble of mismatched mugs. This was where it happened. Not in a perfect, sterile space, but here, in the beautiful, real mess.
“We definitely got it,” Sera agreed, a wide grin spreading across her face. “The people are going to lose their minds. But first,” she added, grabbing a scone for herself, “we eat.”
They stood there in a comfortable silence, the three of them, eating warm scones in a cloud of flour and steam. Myrtle, sensing a dropped crumb, thumped her tail rhythmically against the linoleum. Eleanor caught Bart’s eye, and he gave her another slow, deliberate nod. It felt like a graduation. The ghost of Helga’s rye bread and the solid, savory reality of this second-chance scone wove together in the air. This wasn't just a recipe tested; it was a lesson learned, deeply and permanently, in the bones of her hands.