Cover of Unexpected Attraction

Unexpected Attraction

Read the story

15 chapters · 8167 words · Read 0 times

A nerdy man becomes attracted to a bigger but confident woman and he does not see it coming at all in this love story.

Chapter 2: Chapter 2

The sticky warmth on Shawn’s stomach was cooling, a stark, physical reminder of what had just happened. Post-nut clarity hit him like a bucket of ice water. He stared at the ceiling, his heart still hammering a frantic rhythm against his ribs. The glow of his computer screen illuminated action figures and stacks of comics, his familiar sanctuary now feeling charged with a strange, new energy.

He had just cum for a woman he’d never met. A woman whose naked body was now saved, illicit and glorious, in his Snapchat memories. Irene. He said her name aloud, the sound foreign in the quiet room. "Irene."

His phone buzzed on the floor beside him. He fumbled for it, his glasses smeared.

A new Snap from Irene.

His thumb hovered over the icon. This was it. The moment where she’d realize he was just a loser in a messy apartment, where the digital fantasy would meet and crumble into his awkward reality. He took a breath and opened it.

It wasn’t a nude. It was a selfie of her in a bathroom mirror, her face a bit flushed, her hair a little messy, wearing a soft-looking robe. She was smiling, a real, tired, post-coital smile. The text overlay read: Well, that was a hell of a good night.

Relief washed over him so powerfully his hands trembled. She wasn’t disgusted. She wasn’t ghosting him at all. She was… happy. Blissfully so.

He typed back, his fingers clumsy and still shaking. Yeah. It was. You’re incredible.

The three dots appeared immediately. So are you. Most guys just type “nice”, tip, and disappear. You… you’re different.

Different. She kept using that word. It nestled into a hollow part of him he didn’t know was empty.

They messaged back and forth for the next hour, the conversation shifting from the raw to the mundane. She told him about her day job at a call center and the soul-crushing boredom of it. He told her about the various stories he has written. Some were ones with a hero who wasn’t brave, just stubborn. Some were rags to riches. Some were romantic. The conversation was easy, fluid. It felt real.

A few days later, the digital flirtation escalated again. It was late. His apartment was dark except for the monitor’s glow. Irene was on cam, but not working. This was private, just for him. She was wearing a tight, black lace teddy that strained against her oh so generous curves.

“You still thinking about that coffee, Shawn?” she asked, her voice a low purr through his earbuds.

“Every day,” he admitted, his voice rough. He was already hard, the image of her in that lace searing into his mind.

“Good.” She trailed a finger along the lace edge between her breasts. “Because I’ve been thinking about what happens after coffee.”

“Yeah?” He leaned closer to the screen, his breath fogging a small circle on the monitor.

“Mmmhmm. I’ve been thinking about your hands. You said you wanted to run them all over me.” She slowly peeled one strap of the teddy down her shoulder, then the other, letting the top fall to her waist. Her breasts spilled free, heavy and full, her dark nipples already pebbled. “I want to feel them. For real.”

Shawn’s cock throbbed in his sweatpants. He freed it, without a thought, wrapping his hand around the shaft, his eyes locked on her.

“Tell me what you’d do,” she commanded, her own hand cupping a breast, thumb circling a nipple.

“I’d start here,” he growled, the inhibition he usually felt melting away in the heat of her gaze. “I’d suck on these perfect beautiful tits like a baby until you were begging me to move lower. I’d bite those nipples, just enough to make you gasp.”

Irene moaned, arching her back. “Fuck, yes. And then?”

“Then I’d get on my knees.” His hand stroked his cock in a slow, steady rhythm, matching the pace of his words. “I’d push your legs apart and I’d bury my face in that sweet, wet pussy. I’d eat you out until you came in my mouth. I want to taste you, Irene. I want to drink you down.”

“Oh, God…” Her hands slid down her slightly pudgy stomach, hooking into the waistband of the teddy. She pushed it down over her hips, her thighs, letting it pool on the floor. She was completely naked now, her body a lush landscape of shadows and curves in the dim light. She spread her legs, giving him a full, unobstructed view of her glistening wet treasure. “It’s all yours, Shawn. It’s so wet for you.”

He could see the slickness gleaming on her inner thighs. His mouth watered. He pumped his cock faster, his pre-cum slicking the way. “Play with it,” he rasped. “Show me how you touch yourself when you think about my tongue.”

Irene didn’t hesitate. Two fingers plunged into her pussy, a wet, sucking sound echoing in his headphones. She cried out, her head falling back. “It’s so deep,” she whimpered, her fingers working in and out. “I can imagine it’s your cock. I want your cock so bad, Shawn. I want you to fuck me raw. Fuck me, daddy..."

The filthy words, the raw need in her voice, shattered the last of his control. “I’m gonna fuck you,” he promised, his voice a guttural snarl. “I’m gonna pin you down and pound that tight pussy until you forget your own name. I’m gonna make you scream.”

“Yes! Make me scream! Oh, shit! Oh, shit!” Her fingers moved frantically, her other hand rubbing frantic circles on her clit. Her body was taut, a bowstring about to snap. “I’m close, baby. I’m so close. Come with me. Please, come with me.”

That was all it took. The visual of her fucking herself with her own fingers, the sound of her wetness, the promise in her voice—it overwhelmed him. A raw, animal like groan tore from his throat as his orgasm ripped through him. Thick ropes of cum shot across his stomach and chest, hot and relentless.

On the screen, Irene’s back arched violently off the bed. A sharp, broken cry escaped her lips as her climax seized her, her body convulsing, her fingers still buried deep inside her as she rode out the waves of her pleasure.

For a long moment, there was only the sound of their ragged breathing. Shawn collapsed back in his chair, spent and dizzy. Irene slowly pulled her fingers from her pussy, bringing them to her mouth and sucking them clean with a satisfied, filthy smack.

“Fuck,” she breathed, a lazy, sated smile on her face.

“Yeah,” he agreed, his own voice wrecked. "Fuck... you are sexy."

She looked directly into the camera, her eyes dark and serious. “Thanks, but... Enough of this virtual shit, Shawn. I want the real thing. Meet me tomorrow. The Daily Grind cafe. 3 PM.”

No more fantasy. No more screens. This was a jump into the terrifying, exhilarating unknown.

His heart hammered against his ribs, a frantic drumbeat of fear and desire. He wiped his cum-smeared hand on his sweatpants and typed his reply, the words feeling more significant than any he’d ever written.

I’ll be there.

The next twenty hours were a blur of frantic cleaning and paralyzing doubt. Shawn scrubbed his apartment painstakingly until it smelled faintly of lemon disinfectant, a stark contrast to its usual pizza-and-dust aroma. He rearranged action figures, hid the most embarrassing comic book piles in his closet, and changed his sweatpants three times before settling on a pair of dark, well-fitting jeans and a plain black t-shirt. He stood before his bathroom mirror, adjusting his glasses.

"Don't be a weirdo," he muttered to his reflection. The face staring back looked pale and unnerved. "Don't be a fucking weirdo."

The Daily Grind was exactly the kind of place he normally avoided—too bright, too clean, filled with the low hum of casual conversation that always made him feel like an intruder. He arrived twenty minutes early, his palms slick with sweat. He chose a corner table, as far from the counter as possible, and ordered a black coffee he didn't want. Every time the door chimed, his heart leapt into his throat. What if she didn't come? What if she did, took one look at him, and turned right around?

Then the door chimed again, and he knew. She stood there, scanning the room, and the air left his lungs. Photos and webcams didn't do her justice. She was taller than he’d imagined, her curves accentuated by a simple, dark green wrap dress that hugged her waist and flared over her hips. Her hair was styled in soft curls that framed a face both confident and kind. She saw him. A slow, genuine smile spread across her lips, and she started towards his table.

"Shawn?" Her voice was the same, but richer, warmer without the digital filter.

"Yeah. Hi. Irene." He stood up too quickly, nearly knocking his chair over. He gestured to it clumsily. "Please. Sit."

She did, settling into the chair with an easy grace he envied. She set her purse down and looked him over, her gaze frank and appraising. "You look just like your profile. Maybe a little taller."

"You too. I mean, you look... amazing." The words felt inadequate. He could smell her perfume, something subtle and floral cutting through the coffee scent.

"Thanks." She smiled, a faint blush coloring her cheeks. "This is... weird, right? But a good weird."

"The best kind of weird," he agreed, feeling a knot in his stomach loosen slightly. "I wasn't sure you'd actually come."

"Are you kidding? After last night?" She leaned forward slightly, her voice dropping. "A man who talks like that doesn't get stood up."

The memory of their last video call, raw and explicit, flashed between them, charging the air. He felt a familiar heat stir in his groin. Here, in this bright, public cafe, her words felt infinitely more dangerous and thrilling.

"Was it... too much?" he asked, suddenly unsure.

"God, no." She laughed, a low, throaty sound. "It was perfect. It's all I've been thinking about." She glanced around, then back at him, her eyes darkening. "In fact, I've been thinking about it all morning. This dress? No panties. I've been wet for you since I put it on."

Shawn’s mouth went ajar. He swallowed but his mouth was dry. His cock, which had been semi-hard since she walked in, thickened painfully against his zipper. He couldn't form a sentence. He just stared at her, captivated by the filthy, confident secret she’d just shared in this completely mundane, normal setting.

"I don't really want this coffee, Shawn," she said, her voice dropping to a whisper. "Do you?"

He shook his head, mute.

"Not really," He said. "Your place is close, right? Let's get out of here."

He fumbled for his wallet, threw a twenty on the table, and stood. His legs felt unsteady. She stood too, smoothing her dress, that knowing smile still playing on her plump lips. He led her out of the cafe, hyper-aware of her presence just behind him, of the scent of her perfume, of the promise in her eyes.

The short walk to his apartment was a tense, silent bubble of anticipation. He fumbled with his keys at the door, his hands with a slight tremble. Finally, the lock clicked. He pushed the door open and stepped aside to let her in.

Irene stepped into his sanctuary and stopped, taking it in. Her eyes scanned the posters, the shelves of comics, the lingering order of his frantic cleaning. "So this is where the magic happens," she said, turning to face him.

"Yeah." Shawn said.

And then she was in his arms. There was no more hesitation. Her mouth found his, hungry and insistent. Her kiss was nothing like he’d imagined; it was better, real, all soft lips and the faint taste of her lip gloss. He kissed her back, his hands finding her hips, pulling her flush against him. He could feel the solid, delicious weight of her, the warmth of her body through their clothes.

"Fuck, you feel good," he mumbled against her mouth, his hands sliding down to grip her ass through the soft fabric of her dress. It was every bit as full and perfect as he’d dreamed.

"I need to feel you," she breathed, her hands tugging at his t-shirt. "I need your skin."

They stumbled towards his bedroom, a chaotic dance of shedding clothes. His shirt came off, her dress fell to the floor in a green pool. She stood before him in just a black lace bra, her body a breathtaking reality. Her breasts were heavy and magnificent, her stomach soft, her thighs strong. She was more beautiful than any pixelated image.

"See something you like?" she asked, her voice husky as she unfastened her bra.

"You're fucking beautiful," he growled, his gaze devouring her. He reached out, his fingers tracing the heavy curve of her breast, thumb brushing over a dark, stiff nipple. She gasped, arching into his touch.

"Bed. Now," she commanded, pushing him backward.

He fell onto the mattress, and she followed, straddling his hips. Her heat pressed against his jeans-covered erection, making him groan. She leaned down, her breasts swaying, and captured his mouth in another searing kiss. Her hands were everywhere—in his hair, on his chest, scraping lightly down his sides.

"I've wanted this," she whispered, biting his lower lip. "I've wanted to feel this cock inside me since the first time you tipped me."

She made quick work of his jeans, pulling them and his boxers down in one rough motion. His cock sprang free, hard and aching. She wrapped her hand around him, a firm, knowing grip that made his eyes roll back.

"Fuck, Irene..."

"Look at you," she murmured, stroking him slowly. "All hard for me." She shifted her weight, positioning herself above him. She guided the head of his cock to her entrance, which was slick and hot. She paused, her eyes locked on his, a wicked grin on her face. "You ready for this, daddy?"

"Please," he begged, his hips bucking involuntarily.

She sank down onto him in one slow, breathtaking motion. She was incredibly tight, a wet, velvet heat that clenched around him, swallowing him whole. A guttural moan tore from his throat. Her head fell back, a long, low cry escaping her as she took him all the way to the hilt.

"Oh, God... yes," she panted, her inner muscles fluttering around his shaft. "You're so deep."

She began to move, a slow, rolling grind of her hips that made him see stars. Her full breasts bounced with the rhythm, her hands braced on his chest. He gripped her hips, his fingers digging into her soft flesh, helping her set a punishing pace. The sound of their bodies meeting, skin slapping against skin, filled the small room.

"Harder," she demanded, her voice raw. "Fuck me harder, Shawn."

He flipped them over in one swift motion, pressing her into the mattress. Her legs wrapped around his waist, locking him in. He drove into her, again and again, each thrust hitting a spot that made her cry out. The headboard slammed against the wall with a steady, rhythmic thud.

"Yes! Right there! Don't you fucking stop!" she screamed, her nails raking down his back.

He was lost in her, in the smell of her sweat and perfume, in the feel of her body yielding to his, in the filthy, beautiful sounds she made. This was nothing like his lonely fantasies. This was real, overwhelming, and better than anything he could have written.

"I'm gonna come," he grunted, his thrusts becoming frantic, erratic. "I'm gonna fill you up."

"Do it," she gasped, her eyes wild. "Come inside me. I want to feel it."

Her own climax ripped through her, her body seizing around his cock in violent, pulsating waves. Her scream was muffled against his shoulder. The sensation was too much. With a final, deep thrust, he emptied himself into her, a hot, rushing release that seemed to drain every ounce of his being. He collapsed on top of her, spent and breathless, their hearts hammering against each other in the sudden, stunned quiet.

The weight of him was a solid, comforting pressure. Irene’s hands, which had been clawing at his back moments before, now moved in slow, soothing circles. The only sounds were their ragged breaths slowly returning to normal and the distant hum of his computer from the other room. Sweat cooled on their skin, a damp testament to what had just happened.

Shawn’s mind, usually a frantic carnival of narratives and second-guesses, was blissfully empty. There was only the feel of her warm, soft body beneath his, the scent of her perfume mixed with the musky tang of sex. He’d never been this close to anyone, not just physically. This was a different kind of nakedness.

“Hey,” she whispered, her voice raspy. “You alive in there?”

He managed a grunt, nuzzling into the curve of her neck. “Barely.”

“Good.” Her laugh vibrated through his chest. “For a minute, I thought I broke you.”

He finally found the strength to roll onto his side, taking her with him so they lay facing each other. Her hair was a wild halo on his pillow, her makeup smudged. She had never looked more real, or more beautiful. He reached out, his fingers tracing the line of her jaw, still unable to believe she was here, in his bed.

“No one’s ever… I’ve never…” he stammered, the words failing him.

“I know,” she said softly, her brown eyes holding his. “It’s okay. Me neither. Not like that.” She shifted, wincing slightly. “Fuck, you’re intense. I think you left marks.”

A bolt of panic shot through him. “Shit, did I hurt you? I’m sorry, I got carried away—”

“Don’t you dare apologize,” she interrupted, a fierce glint in her eye. She took his hand and guided it to the outside of her thigh where he could feel the faint, raised welts from where his grip had been. “I wanted every second of it. I asked for it, remember?”

He remembered. The memory of her demanding, screaming for more, made his blood heat all over again. His cock, spent and softening against his thigh, gave a sympathetic twitch.

“Yeah,” he breathed. “I remember.”

They lay in silence for a while, the afternoon light fading through the window, painting stripes across the rumpled sheets and their tangled limbs. His room, usually a place of solitary escape, felt entirely new with her in it. The Black Panther poster on the wall seemed to be watching them with approval.

“So,” she said eventually, propping herself up on an elbow. Her breast brushed his arm, and the casual contact was as electric as anything that had come before. “Was it like you imagined? When you were watching me on cam?”

He thought about the pixelated version of her, the fantasy. “No,” he said honestly. “It was a million times better. You’re… more.”

She smiled, a slow, deeply satisfied thing. “You too. The way you talk… fuck. It does things to me.” Her hand drifted down his chest, over his stomach, and wrapped around his slowly reawakening cock. “See? It does things to you, too.”

He gasped as her fingers tightened, her thumb swiping over the sensitive head. “Irene… give a man a minute to recover.”

“Why?” she purred, leaning in to nip at his lower lip. “I’m not done with you yet. I told you I’ve been wet for you all day.” She guided his hand between her legs. “See? Still soaking. I want you to fuck me again. Slow this time. I want to watch your face.”

Her directness, her absolute ownership of her own desire, obliterated the last of his hesitation. He rolled over her, settling between her thighs, which opened for him without a moment’s resistance. The sight of her beneath him, her gaze locked on his, was more intimate than anything they’d done so far.

He entered her with a single, slow, deliberate thrust, watching her eyes flutter closed and then open again, heavy-lidded with pleasure. She was so wet, so warm, so impossibly tight. He braced himself on his elbows, cradling her face.

“Look at me,” he murmured, and she did.

He set a languid, deep rhythm, a world away from their frantic first time. Each thrust was a full, measured possession. He watched the play of emotions on her face—the sharp intake of breath, the parted lips, the way her eyes lost focus for a second before finding his again.

“You feel that?” he growled, his voice low. “That’s all me. My cock buried deep inside your perfect, wet pussy.”

“Yes,” she breathed, her hips rising to meet his. “God, yes. It’s so deep. I can feel you in my stomach.”

He lowered his head, capturing one of her nipples in his mouth. He suckled hard, his tongue lashing the stiff peak, and she cried out, her back arching. The change in angle made him groan, his control fraying. He released her breast, his mouth finding hers in a messy, open kiss.

“I want to taste you,” he rasped against her lips. “I want to eat your pussy until you come on my face.”

“Do it,” she begged, her hands fisting in his hair. “Please, Shawn. I want that.”

In one fluid motion, he pulled out, eliciting a whimper of protest from her, and slid down the bed. He hooked her legs over his shoulders, pulling her center to his mouth. The scent of her, of their mixed fluids, was overwhelmingly primal. He didn’t hesitate. He buried his face in her, his tongue delving deep into her slick heat.

Irene’s whole body jerked. A shattered moan tore from her throat. “Oh, fuck! Right there! Don’t stop!”

He feasted on her, his tongue fucking her in rhythm with his fingers, which he slid inside her, curling them to find that spot that made her scream. He was relentless, driven by her sounds, by the way her thighs tightened around his head. This was power of a different kind. Not taking, but giving. Making her lose her mind.

“I’m gonna come!” she shrieked, her body bowing off the bed. “I’m gonna—!”

Her words dissolved into a guttural cry as her orgasm slammed into her. Her pussy clenched rhythmically around his fingers, her juices flooding his mouth. He drank her down, licking and sucking until her tremors subsided into weak shudders.

He crawled back up her body, his face glistening, his cock rock-hard and aching. She looked utterly wrecked, her eyes dazed. She reached for him, her arms weak.

“Inside me,” she pleaded, her voice a ragged whisper. “I need you to come inside me again.”

He pushed into her, the sensation of her sensitive, quivering walls gripping him almost too much to bear. He fucked her with short, hard, desperate strokes, his own climax coiling tight in his balls.

“Tell me,” he grunted, his forehead pressed against hers. “Tell me who you belong to right now.”

“You,” she moaned, her eyes rolling back. “I belong to you. This pussy is yours. Fuck, Shawn… fill me up.”

With a final, brutal thrust, he did. His release was a raw, pulsing rush that seemed to drain his very soul. He collapsed onto her, his body spent, his mind shattered. For a long time, they just lay there, fused together, breathing as one in the deepening twilight.

Irene was the first to speak, her voice a sleepy murmur against his ear. “So. That happened.”

Shawn huffed a weak laugh, the sound rumbling through his chest. “Yeah. It did.”

“Your roommate’s gonna be pissed about the headboard,” she said, a grin in her voice.

“I don’t have a roommate.”

“Even better.” She shifted, wincing again but smiling. “We should probably get up. I’m starving.”

The mundane statement, in the aftermath of such raw carnality, was somehow profoundly intimate. She wasn’t running. She was thinking about food. About what came next.

“I’ve got pizza,” he said. “It’s probably from last night.”

“Perfect.” She gently pushed at his shoulder. “Come on. Let’s go. You can fuck me against the fridge after we eat.”

He lifted his head to look at her, a genuine, unguarded smile spreading across his face for the first time. The world outside his apartment, with all its complexities and judgments, felt a million miles away. Here, in this messy room that smelled of sex and pizza, with this complicated, incredible woman, he was exactly where he was supposed to be.

“Okay,” he said. “Let’s go.”

Read on DreamPress