Cover of Virgin's Temptation

Virgin's Temptation

Read the story

2 chapters · 7341 words · Read 0 times

Kelly and Daniel, both virgins at 18, married young and devoutly religious, hit their first major rough patch when Kelly gets swept up in the party scene at college. One wild night, drunk and flustered by an aggressive frat guy's advances, she's moments away from cheating when Daniel bursts in, having tracked her location. The confrontation is explosive—tears, accusations, the crushing weight of almost-lost trust. But in the raw aftermath, Kelly makes a shocking offer: if Daniel feels deprived of experiences, she'll allow him a harem of women, no questions asked. The catch? He has one week to decide. Now Daniel's torn between righteous devotion and the tantalizing freedom dangling before him, while Kelly wrestles with whether her radical offer is selfless love or a twisted test neither of them is ready for.

Chapter 1: The Party and the Moment Everything Shattered

The bass from the speakers wasn’t just sound; it was a physical pressure against Kelly’s ribs, a second heartbeat that had nothing to do with her own. The basement air was thick, a soupy mix of sweat, stale cigarettes, and something chemical-sweet that clung to the back of her throat. Neon light from a flickering TV painted everyone in strokes of sickly blue and green, turning laughs into grimaces and making the walls, slick with something she didn’t want to identify, shimmer.

Her cup was half-full of something red and dangerous-looking they called jungle juice. It tasted like melted candy and regret, but it warmed the cold knot of anxiety in her stomach. This was college. This was what she was supposed to be doing.

“You look lost, freshman.” The voice was right by her ear, cutting through the music. Chad Thompson materialized beside her, all white teeth and confident smirk. He wore his fraternity letters like a crown.“Kelly, right? Daniel’s wife.”

He said ‘wife’ like it was a curious, slightly amusing title. She nodded, taking another gulp. The burn was familiar now.

“Daniel’s a good guy. Serious.” Chad leaned against the sticky pool table, his eyes not leaving her face. “Never seen him at a thing like this.”

“He’s studying,” she said, too quickly. It was true. Daniel was across campus in the library, buried in engineering textbooks. He’d kissed her forehead before she left, told her to have fun with her roommate. His trust was a heavy sweater, warm but sometimes stifling.

“Studying.” Chad chuckled, as if the word itself was a joke. “Bet you’re not studying right now.”

He took her empty cup, his fingers brushing hers. “Refill. You can’t just hold a cup all night, it messes with the vibe.” He was back before she could protest, handing her a fresh one, full to the brim.

The next hour blurred. The music got louder, the room hotter. Chad was a constant presence, introducing her to people whose names she forgot, making jokes that made her laugh a little too easily. He was everything Daniel wasn’t: loud, unpredictable, entirely of this chaotic, neon world.It was thrilling. Each sip from the cup felt like a tiny rebellion, a secret she was keeping from the version of herself who led Bible study and packed Daniel’s lunches.

They were wedged in a corner by the dying keg. Chad was telling a story, his hands animated, his knee bumping against hers. She didn’t pull away. The bump became a steady pressure. Then his hand was on her knee, warm through the denim of her jeans.

Her breath hitched. The rational part of her brain, the part that sounded like her mother, like Daniel, screamed to move it. But another part, a part she was only just getting to know, was curious. This was attention. It was specific and hungry and it was for her, not for ‘Daniel’s wife.’

“You’re not like the other girls they bring around,” he said, his voice dropping. The music swallowed his words, forcing him to lean in. His breath was hot against her ear, smelling of beer and mint gum. “You’ve got this… quiet thing going on. Makes a guy wonder what’s underneath.”

His hand slid up her thigh, just an inch. The touch was a live wire.

Everything inside her tightened. The noise of the party faded into a dull roar. This was the line. The one she’d drawn in her mind a thousand times since getting the acceptance letter. She opened her mouth, the ‘no’ forming on her tongue, a prayer and a protest all at once.

The basement door crashed open.

Light from the hallway above sliced through the murky gloom, outlining a figure in the doorway. The strobe light flashed once, twice, catching the silver band on his left hand, making it gleam like a knife-point.Daniel.

He wasn’t moving. Just standing there, his backpack slung over one shoulder, his face bleached of all color by the harsh overhead light. His eyes found hers first, a direct hit. Then they traveled down, taking in Chad’s proximity, the possessive curve of his hand on her leg, the cup clutched in her frozen fingers.

Chad’s hand jerked away as if burned. He straightened up, putting on a grin that didn’t reach his eyes. “Daniel! Hey, man. We were just—”

Daniel didn’t even look at him. He was still staring at Kelly. The betrayal in his eyes was so raw, so total, it felt like a physical shove. All the sound rushed back in—the yelling, the laughter, the relentless thump of the bass. It was obscene.

He didn’t say a word. He just turned and vanished back up the stairs, the door swinging shut slowly behind him, cutting off the light.

The silence between her and Chad was louder than the music.

“Well,” Chad said, recovering, grabbing his beer. “That was dramatic.”

Kelly was already moving, her body operating on a panic she couldn’t yet feel. She shoved her cup at Chad, the red liquid sloshing over his shirt. She didn’t care. She weaved through the crowd, apologies falling from her lips, her vision tunneling on the door.

The cool night air hit her like a slap. She gasped, stumbling on the concrete steps, her ears ringing in the sudden quiet. She scanned the empty parking lot, her heart hammering against her ribs.

Then she saw him. Halfway down the block, walking with a stiff, furious speed toward their apartment.

“Daniel!”

He didn’t turn. He just kept walking.

She ran, her flats slapping against the pavement, the world tilting dangerously from the alcohol and the adrenaline. “Daniel, wait! Please!”

He stopped. He didn’t turn around, just stood there under a yellow streetlight, his shoulders rigid. She skidded to a halt a few feet behind him, her chest heaving.

When he finally turned to face her, the look was gone. In its place was something colder, flatter. A door slamming shut.

“He was just talking,” she said, the lie weak and pathetic in the vast stillness of the night.

Daniel let out a short, hard sound that wasn’t a laugh. He looked at her for a long time, taking in her smudged makeup, her disheveled hair, the party smell that clung to her. He seemed to be memorizing it.

“Get in the car,” he said, his voice quiet. It was the quiet that scared her the most. He dug his keys from his pocket, the metal jangling in the silence. “We’re going home.”

The car ride was a tomb. The only sounds were the hum of the engine and the sharp, rhythmic click of the turn signal. Daniel’s knuckles were white on the steering wheel. Kelly stared out the window, watching the blurred streetlights, each one a silent judgment. The sweet, cloying smell of the jungle juice on her own breath made her sick.

He didn’t speak until they were inside their small apartment. The door clicked shut, a sound as final as a coffin lid.

He threw his keys on the kitchen counter. The metallic clatter made her jump. “Just talking,” he said, his voice low. He didn’t turn around. “His hand was on your fucking thigh, Kelly. Were you ‘just talking’ to that, too?”

“It wasn’t like that,” she whispered, but the protest died in her throat. The image was seared behind her eyes: Chad’s possessive grip, her own paralyzed acquiescence.

“What was it like, then?” He finally turned. The calm was gone, eroded by something darker, more volatile. His eyes were black with a hurt that had already curdled into anger. “Explain it to me. Because from where I was standing, it looked like my wife was about to get felt up by some frat-house predator in a basement that stank of vomit and bad decisions.”

“I was curious!” The words burst out of her, shrill and desperate. “I wanted to see what it was like. To be… to be like them. Just for a night. It was stupid, Daniel. It was a mistake.”

“A mistake.” He took a step toward her. The space between them crackled. “A mistake is spilling a drink. A mistake is forgetting an assignment. Letting some guy put his hands on you while you’re wearing my ring?” He grabbed her left hand, held it up between them. The gold band felt suddenly heavy, like a shackle. “That’s a choice.”

He was close now. She could smell the library on him—old paper and coffee—and underneath it, the sharp, clean scent of his sweat. His anger was a heat radiating off his skin. It should have frightened her. Part of her was terrified. But another part, a part still humming from the cheap alcohol and the adrenaline of being wanted, stirred.

This was real. This was Daniel. Not some cartoonish frat boy. This was the man she’d vowed everything to, and his fury was more intoxicating than any jungle juice.

“I’m sorry,” she breathed, but it wasn’t a plea for forgiveness. It was a trigger.

His mouth crashed down on hers. It wasn’t a kiss. It was a punishment.A claiming. There was no tenderness in it, only a furious, desperate need to erase the touch of another man. She gasped against his lips, her hands flying up to push against his chest, but the push faltered, her fingers curling into the fabric of his shirt, pulling him closer.

He walked her backwards, never breaking the kiss, until the back of her knees hit the edge of their bed. She fell onto the comforter, and he came down on top of her, his weight pinning her in a way that made her blood sing. All the preached-about purity, all the careful, gentle couplings of their brief marriage, shattered in that moment.

His hands were rough, urgent. He yanked her shirt over her head. The clasp of her bra snapped under his impatient fingers. His mouth left hers to blaze a trail down her throat, to her breast, his tongue lashing her nipple before he took it into his mouth, biting down just enough to make her cry out. The pain was bright, clarifying.

“He wanted this?” Daniel growled, his voice raw against her skin. His hand shoved between them, fumbling with the button of her jeans.“Did he? Tell me.”

She couldn’t speak. She could only arch into him, a whimper caught in her throat. He ripped her jeans and underwear down her hips in one vicious motion. The cool air on her exposed skin was a shock. He stripped his own clothes without ceremony, without care, his gaze locked on hers, challenging her to look away.

He was fully hard, his cock jutting against her thigh. There was no preamble, no softness. He drove into her in one brutal, deep stroke.

She gasped, her body stretching to accommodate him, the burn of the sudden invasion mixing with a shocking, immediate bolt of pleasure. It was nothing like before. This was raw, unfiltered. This was fucking.

“Is this what you were curious about?” he panted, pulling almost all the way out before slamming back into her. The bedframe slammed against the wall. “Huh? This what you wanted to try?”

“Daniel—” she moaned, her head thrashing side to side.

“Say it.” He hooked an arm under her knee, hiking her leg up higher, opening her wider, sinking deeper. The new angle stole her breath. “Tell me what you did.”

His thrusts were a relentless, punishing rhythm. Each one jolted through her, building a pressure that had nothing to do with tenderness and everything to do with a base, animal need. She could feel the slick heat gathering between them, her own body betraying her, responding violently to his anger. She clawed at his back, her nails digging into his skin, urging him on, harder, faster.

The room filled with the sounds of it—the slap of skin, the creak of the bed, their ragged, overlapping breaths. She was close, teetering on an edge she’d never known. It was terrifying.It was brilliant.

He lowered his mouth to her ear, his breath hot and ragged. “You’re mine,” he snarled, each word punctuated by a deep thrust. “You say your vows to me. You come on my cock.Not his. Never his. Do you understand?”

The possessiveness in his voice, the sheer, dark intensity of it, broke her. A sob ripped from her throat as the climax tore through her, violent and wrenching, clenching around him like a fist. Her vision whited out.

He followed her over, his own release a guttural shout muffled in the crook of her neck, his body pulsing deep inside her as he emptied himself.

For a long minute, there was only the sound of their heaving breaths in the dark. The weight of him was crushing, anchoring her to the bed, to the reality of what had just happened.

Slowly, he rolled off her. The physical separation felt cavernous. She stared at the ceiling, the sweat cooling on her skin, the throbbing ache between her legs a testament.

The silence stretched, thin and fragile.

In the dark, with the ghost of his touch still on her skin and the taste of the party still a stain on her memory, she spoke. The words were quiet, shattered things.

“I wanted him to kiss me,” she whispered to the ceiling. “For a second, when he leaned in… I wanted it. I thought about what it would be like.”

She confessed.

The words hung in the air, colder than any silence. Daniel didn’t move. He just lay beside her, breathing in the dark.

The silence after her words wasn’t empty. It was a living thing, thick and hot, pressing down on them in the dark. She could feel the shock radiating from him, a vibration in the mattress.

He moved.

Not away. He rolled onto his side, propping himself up on an elbow. The streetlight from the window cut a pale blade across his face, illuminating one eye, the hard line of his mouth. He looked carved from stone.

“What?”

The word was quiet.Deceptively soft.

“I said…” Her voice cracked. She cleared her throat, the sound obscenely loud. “For a second, I wanted him to kiss me.”

Daniel didn’t explode. He didn’t move. He just stared, and that was worse. His breathing had changed—slower, more controlled.

“Tell me,” he said.

“Daniel…”

“No.” His hand came up, not to strike, but to grasp her chin, forcing her face toward his. His fingers were firm, unyielding.“You opened this door. You don’t get to flinch now. You wanted his kiss.Fine. Tell me. Details, Kelly. I want every fucking detail.”

His gaze was a trap. There was no love in it now. Just a cold, forensic hunger. He wanted to see the wound. He wanted to lick it.

She felt a fresh, shameful heat bloom low in her belly. “His hand was on my leg. He leaned in. His breath smelled like gum… wintergreen. He said I had a quiet thing. That it made him wonder.”

“Wonder what?” Daniel’s thumb stroked her jaw, a grotesque parody of a caress.

“What was underneath,” she whispered.

“And what did you think was underneath, Kelly? When you sat there in your jeans, letting some stranger’s hand climb your thigh, what did you think he’d find?”

He was unzipping her, but not with his hands. With his words. She could feel them peeling her open, layer by layer.

“I don’t know,” she breathed.

“You do know.” His hand left her chin, trailed down her throat, over the pounding pulse there, down between her breasts. He palmed one, his touch impersonal, assessing. “Was it this he wanted? Did you think about his mouth here? Not mine. His.”

His fingers pinched her nipple, hard. A sharp gasp shot from her lips, pain and pleasure twisting together. Her back arched off the bed.

“Answer me.”

“Yes,” she moaned.

“Yes, what?”

“Yes, I thought about it.” The admission was a vomit of truth. “I thought about what a different mouth would feel like. I thought about… his tongue.His teeth. I was curious.”

Daniel made a sound in his chest, a low rumble of pure agony. He flung the covers back. The cool air hit her sweat-slicked skin. He knelt between her legs, his eyes raking over her naked body, splayed and used and still glistening with him.

“Show me,” he commanded, his voice rough.

“Wh-what?”

“How he would have done it. You imagined it.Show me. Pretend I’m him.”

It was a monstrous request. A corruption. Her heart hammered against her ribs. She couldn’t move.

“Now, Kelly.” The words were a lash.

Trembling, she brought her own hands up to her breasts. She touched herself where Daniel’s hands had just been, where Chad’s had never been. She skimmed her palms over her nipples, a tentative, self-conscious motion. It felt ridiculous.Obscene.

“Not like that,” Daniel sneered. “You weren’t thinking of some shy virgin touch. You were in a grimy basement. The music was loud. He was drunk and pushy. Show me that fantasy.”

A tear leaked from the corner of her eye, tracing a hot path into her hairline. She shut her eyes, trying to find the moment in the haze of neon and noise. She cupped her breasts harder, squeezing, imagining rough, unfamiliar hands. She arched her back, letting her head fall to the side, offering her throat to a phantom mouth.

“That’s it,” Daniel breathed. He was watching her, his own arousal evident, jutting against her thigh. His jealousy was a tangible thing in the room, a coppery taste in the air. “And then what? After he tasted you? After he decided he liked what was underneath?”

Her hands slid down her own stomach, over the sensitive skin of her hips. She let one hand slip between her legs. She was still swollen, wet—from Daniel, from the confrontation, from this sick, thrilling confession. She touched herself, a flinch of a touch.

“Did you imagine his fingers here?” Daniel’s voice was a gravelly whisper. “Did you imagine him finding out how fucking wet his little ‘quiet thing’ could get for a stranger while her husband was studying?”

“Yes,” she sobbed, her own finger circling the slick, tender flesh. The room spun. Shame and a dizzying, profound arousal coiled together, inseparable.

“How many fingers, Kelly?”

“I… one.”

“Bullshit.” He leaned down suddenly, his face inches from hers. “He’s a frat guy. He’s aggressive. He’s got you cornered. He’s not asking. He’s taking. He wants to feel how tight that married little pussy is. So how many?”

“Two!” she cried out. The image flashed behind her closed eyelids: Chad’s smug face, his forceful hand. “He’d use two. Rough.”

Daniel’s hand shot out, wrapping around her wrist, pulling her own hand away. He replaced it with his, pushing two fingers inside her without ceremony, deep and ruthless. She cried out, her body clenching around the invasion.

“Like that?” he grunted, fucking her with his fingers, the sound obscenely wet in the quiet room. “He’d finger you right there in the basement, wouldn’t he? With people all around? And you’d let him. You’d stand there and take it and wonder what my books tasted like.”

He was destroying it. He was taking her secret, pathetic fantasy and warping it, owning it, making it about his pain. He withdrew his fingers, glistening in the faint light, and brought them to her lips.

“Taste it,” he ordered. “Taste your fucking curiosity.”

She opened her mouth. He pushed his fingers past her lips. The taste was herself, mixed with him, salty and musky. She sucked, her eyes locked on his, seeing the furious, shattered triumph in his gaze.

He pulled his fingers free with a pop.

Then he was on her again, flipping her onto her stomach with a brutal efficiency. He dragged her hips up, folding her onto her knees, her face pressed into the pillow that smelled of them. He mounted her from behind, one hand fisted in her hair, the other guiding his cock.

He entered her in one vicious thrust, burying himself to the hilt. She screamed into the pillow, the fullness a shock, a punishment, a claiming.

“This is what you get,” he panted, pulling out and slamming back in, each drive a punctuation mark. “You get me. You get my cock in your cheating little cunt. You wanted experience? This is it. This is what happens.”

He fucked her with a frantic, driving rhythm, the bed slamming against the wall in a steady, violent beat. His grip on her hair kept her head pulled back, her spine arched, completely vulnerable. The angle was deeper, animalistic. Each stroke burned, each one pressed directly onto a nerve of pure, blinding pleasure. The crude, explicit words raining down on her mixed with the physical brutality, breaking apart the last of her guilt and reshaping it into something dark and hungry.

She was crumbling, coming apart under the assault of him, of his words, of her own confessed desires thrown back at her. The orgasm built not as a wave but as a seizure, a rending of her very self. It tore through her with a silent, violent scream, milking him, pulling a guttural roar from his throat as he followed, pumping into her, his body jerking with the force of his release.

He collapsed over her, his weight driving her into the mattress, both of them slick with sweat and spent. The only sound was their ragged, desperate breathing.

Slowly, he softened inside her. He didn’t pull away. He kept her there, pinned, his mouth near her ear.

His voice, when it came, was hollow, scraped raw.

“From now on,” he whispered, the words leaving a frost in the warm air, “you tell me every detail.Every look. Every thought. You don’t get to have a secret fantasy. I own them all. I will know every filthy thing that passes through your mind. Do you understand?”

She nodded, her face wet with tears and sweat, her body humming with a terrible, ruined completeness.

He demands details.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI