Chapter 1: To the Dollar
Jake Mercer knew the house was going to break his heart the second he saw the newel post.
It was walnut, hand-turned, the size of a man's thigh, and somebody in 1897 had carved a pineapple on top of it because a pineapple meant welcome and they had wanted the whole street to know it. Somebody in 1974 had painted it mint green. Jake stood in the front hall of 41 Linden Street with his hand on that awful green paint and felt the old wood under it, solid as the day it was cut, and he thought: mine.
Then he heard the tape measure snap shut in the parlour, and he thought: oh, hell.
"Mercer." Dana Whitlock walked out of the parlour with a flashlight in one hand and a moisture meter in the other, the way other women carried a purse and a glass of wine. "You're blocking the light."
"It's a hallway. There's no light."
"Then you're blocking the dark." She shouldered past him. She smelled like coffee and the cedar of her truck's seat covers, and her tool belt rode so low on her hips it was a minor scandal that it stayed up. "Floor joists in the parlour are original. Somebody sistered two of them with pine in the eighties. The rest are fine."
"I know."
"You've been down in the crawlspace?"
"Tuesday."
Her brown eyes went narrow. Dana had a face built for that look: wide mouth, strong brows, freckles that started on her nose and kept going, down her neck and across both shoulders, which today were bare under a grey tank top with a hole at the hem. She had knotted a faded red bandana over a heap of honey-blonde hair. A pencil was stuck through the knot. Jake had a pencil behind his ear. He was aware of the symmetry and he did not enjoy it.
"I was down there Monday," she said.
"Then you saw the same joists."
"I saw them first."
She went up the stairs two at a time. He told himself he was not watching her climb them, which was a lie, because the staircase was the best part of the house and she was on it, and a man with eyes in his head would look at both. Dana Whitlock had the kind of body that made denim work for a living. Full hips, a waist her belt sat above like a shelf, thighs that had carried drywall up three floors of a walk-up on Haywood Road while Jake watched from the sidewalk last spring and forgot what he'd come to buy. She moved like none of it was up for discussion.
He made himself look at the banister instead. Original. Loose at the third baluster. Fixable.
"Stop looking at my ass and come see this," she called down.
"I was looking at your baluster."
"That's worse."
There had been three houses this year. The craftsman on Montford, where Jake had beaten her by four thousand dollars. The brick foursquare in West Asheville, where he'd beaten her by nine hundred. And the little shingle cottage off Merrimon, where Jake had bid exactly one dollar more than Dana, because he had heard from the listing agent, who had heard from her own cousin, that Dana Whitlock always bid round numbers.
She had found out. Asheville was not a large town in the ways that mattered. She had walked into the lumber yard on Riverside the following week, waited until he was at the counter with a full cart, and said, loud enough for the whole contractors' line to hear, "One dollar, Mercer? Was that your mother's idea or did you think of it yourself?"
He'd said, "My mother would have bid two."
The guys at the counter had laughed. Dana hadn't. She had looked at him for a long, level moment, and then the corner of her mouth had moved, just barely, like it had a mind of its own and she'd have words with it later. That was the moment, if he was honest. Six months ago, in a lumber yard, holding a box of drywall screws.
He had not been honest with anyone about it, least of all her.
Ruth Calloway did not believe in real estate agents. She had said so in the handwritten notice taped to the window of the corner store: SELLING MY HOUSE. NO AGENTS. NO DEVELOPERS. SEALED BIDS BY FRIDAY. SERIOUS PEOPLE ONLY. Underneath, in smaller letters: If you are going to put grey floors in it, do not bother.
On Friday afternoon the two most serious people in the county sat on opposite ends of Ruth Calloway's horsehair sofa, each holding an envelope, while Ruth poured tea that neither of them wanted.
"Milk?" Ruth said.
"No, ma'am," Jake said.
"Please," Dana said, which Jake knew was a tactic, because he had seen her drink coffee so black it looked structural.
Ruth was small and silver-haired, with reading glasses on a beaded chain and a cardigan the colour of moss. She had a carved cane propped by her chair that she had not once used to walk. She had used it twice to point at things, once at a water stain on the ceiling and once at Jake.
"You two," she said, settling back, "have been sneaking around my yard for three weeks."
"I wasn't sneaking," Dana said. "I knocked."
"You knocked on my crawlspace door, dear. That's not knocking. That's trespassing with manners." Ruth turned to Jake. "And you sat in your truck across the street with binoculars."
"Those were for the roof," Jake said. "Your slate's in good shape on the north side. The flashing around the back chimney is shot."
"I know it's shot. My husband said it was shot in 1991." Ruth held out a spotted hand. "Envelopes."
They handed them over. Jake watched Dana not watch him. She sat with her back very straight and one leg crossed over the other, a boot swinging slightly, the frayed hem of her jeans riding up to show a sliver of freckled ankle. He had bid four hundred and six thousand dollars. It was every dollar he could put his hands on and a few he'd have to borrow from his own future. He had not bid a round number, and he had not bid a number ending in one. He had sat at his kitchen table at two in the morning and asked himself what the house was worth to him, not to the market, and he had written that down.
Ruth opened Dana's envelope first. She read it, and her eyebrows went up a fraction. Then she opened Jake's, read it, and put both pieces of paper side by side on the coffee table.
Then she laughed. It was a surprisingly dirty laugh for a woman in a moss cardigan.
"Well," Ruth said. "Isn't that something."
Dana leaned forward. Jake leaned forward. Their heads nearly knocked over the coffee table. On the left, in Dana's square block capitals: $406,000. On the right, in Jake's slanted carpenter's hand: $406,000.
To the dollar.
"That's not possible," Dana said.
"It's very possible," said Ruth. "I'm looking at it."
"Did you tell him?" Dana turned on Ruth, then on Jake. "Did you call her cousin? Did you call my cousin?"
"I don't know your cousin."
"Everyone knows my cousin."
"I didn't call anybody." Jake was still staring at the numbers. It was such an ugly, specific figure. Four hundred and six. He'd landed on it because it was the price of the house plus what he figured it would cost to save the porch, and that was what he'd been willing to lose. "How did you get to four-oh-six?"
Dana looked at him like he'd asked her bra size in church. Then, grudgingly: "Market value as-is, plus the porch."
"The whole porch?"
"The whole porch. I'm not putting composite on a Queen Anne, Mercer, I'm not an animal."
Ruth was enjoying herself enormously. She stirred her tea and let the silence go on long enough to be cruel.
"I could ask you both to bid again," she said finally.
"Yes," said Dana, at once.
"Yes," said Jake, a beat later, though he had nothing left to bid with, and something in Dana's jaw told him she didn't either.
"But I won't." Ruth set down her spoon. "I've had fifty years in this house. My husband restored that blue room upstairs with his own hands the year we married, and it's the only room in the place anybody ever finished. I was not going to sell it to a developer who'd paint it grey. I was not going to sell it to some couple from Charlotte who'd call it a project. I wanted somebody who'd go down in the crawlspace on a Monday." She nodded at Dana. "Or sit in a truck with binoculars for a whole afternoon to look at my flashing." She nodded at Jake. "Turns out I can't choose. So I won't. I'll sell it to both of you, at four hundred and six, or I'll sell it to nobody and leave it to the Methodist church."
"The Methodists will put grey floors in it," Jake said.
"They will," Ruth agreed placidly. "And vinyl siding."
Dana had gone a little pale under the freckles. "Mrs. Calloway. With respect. I don't do partners."
"I'm aware, dear. I read about your divorce in the paper. It was very tidy of you." Ruth turned her attention to Jake, and her eyes were bright and blue and not at all like an eighty-one-year-old's. "And you don't either, I'd guess. You don't look like a man who lets anybody hold the other end of the board."
He didn't. He'd built his business alone, worked alone, slept alone more than he liked to admit. He opened his mouth to say no.
Dana said, "Fine."
He looked at her. She was looking at the two pieces of paper on the table, not at him, and there was a muscle working at the hinge of her jaw.
"Fine," she said again. "Fifty-fifty. Split the purchase, split the work, split the sale. Six months, in and out. I take the kitchen and the baths, he takes the porch and the trim, we fight about everything else."
"I don't want the porch and the trim," Jake said. "I want the kitchen."
"You can't have the kitchen."
"Why not?"
"Because you'll put an island in it."
"It needs an island."
"It needs a pantry, Mercer, it's a Victorian, they had pantries for a reason." She finally turned to look at him, and up close her eyes were the brown of good coffee and twice as strong. "You want this house or not?"
He wanted the house. He wanted it more than any building he'd ever stood inside. He also wanted, very badly and for six months now, the woman glaring at him across Ruth Calloway's coffee table, and the idea of half a year of both, in the same rooms, under the same leaking roof, was either the best thing that had ever happened to him or a slow-motion construction accident.
"I want it," he said.
"Then shake," said Ruth, sounding delighted.
Dana held out her hand. Jake took it. Her palm was warm and rough across the base of the fingers, a hammer callus right where his own was, and her grip was the firm, no-nonsense squeeze of a woman who had closed a lot of deals with men who'd expected her to be dainty about it. He squeezed back. Neither of them let go first. It went on a second too long, then two seconds, then long enough that Ruth cleared her throat.
"You'll be out by Christmas," Dana told him, not letting go.
"You'll be begging me for an island by Thanksgiving."
"I'd sooner sleep in the crawlspace."
"That can be arranged."
Ruth picked up her tea. "There is one more condition," she said, "and I'll have my lawyer put it in writing so neither of you can weasel. The house gets finished. All of it. If either one of you walks away before it's done, for any reason at all, the one who stays gets the whole thing. Every board."
Dana's hand tightened in his. He felt it, the little jolt of it, and saw her understand at the same moment he did: Ruth Calloway hadn't sold them a house. She'd locked them in a room together and thrown the key in the creek.
"Then I guess nobody walks," Dana said quietly.
"I guess not," said Jake, and finally, carefully, let her go.
His palm still felt the shape of hers all the way home.