Chapter 2: House Rules
The rules got written on a napkin at the Over Easy Diner at six-forty on a Monday morning, because Dana said if they didn't have rules by the time the coffee came, she'd kill him with a butter knife before the dumpster arrived.
"Rule one." She uncapped a paint pen from her shirt pocket. The napkin already had a smear of primer on one corner. "Nobody touches the other one's tools."
"Agreed."
"I mean it. If I find you using my impact driver I'll put it somewhere you'll need a surgeon to retrieve it."
"I don't need your impact driver. I have an impact driver."
"Your impact driver is older than my truck."
"My impact driver," Jake said, "has character."
She wrote RULE 1: HANDS OFF in block capitals. Her handwriting was like her: square, unapologetic, no wasted ink. The waitress came with two mugs and Dana took hers black and drank half of it in one go without flinching.
"Rule two," Jake said. "Music alternates by day."
Dana looked pained. "What do you listen to?"
"Old country. Some bluegrass."
"Of course you do." She wrote it down anyway. "Mondays, Wednesdays, Fridays are mine."
"What's yours?"
"Nineties hip-hop and audiobooks about shipwrecks."
He thought about that for a second and decided he liked her more, which was inconvenient. "Rule three. We each draw a kitchen. Ruth picks."
"Ruth will pick mine."
"Then you've got nothing to worry about."
"Stakes," she said, pen hovering.
"Loser stands on the front porch and says 'You were right' loud enough for the Hendersons next door to hear."
"The Hendersons are deaf."
"Then loud enough for Mrs. Henderson's hearing aid."
Dana's mouth did the thing again. The traitor corner. She wrote it down. Then she sat for a moment with the pen against her lower lip, which was full and chapped from working outside all fall, and Jake found that he had stopped breathing in a way that was not dignified for a man of thirty-six.
"Rule four," she said, and wrote it before she said it, so he read it upside down as it appeared: NOTHING HAPPENS IN THE BLUE ROOM.
He looked at it for a while. Then he held out his hand for the pen.
She gave it to him, eyebrows up. He turned the napkin around and, under her capitals, in his slanted carpenter's hand, wrote: unless we both say so.
Dana read it. Her cheeks went a shade pinker under the freckles, and she took the napkin back and folded it in half and tucked it into her bra, right there in the diner, like a woman putting away a receipt.
"Contract's signed," she said. "Eat your eggs, Mercer. We've got a wall to kill."
Demolition week was the best week of Jake's year, and he resented that it was also the week he learned what Dana Whitlock looked like with a sledgehammer.
He'd known, in theory. He'd seen her work from across a street. He had not been in the same room as her when she set her feet, rolled her shoulders, and put a nine-pound hammer through a plaster-and-lath wall from 1897. The first swing went through like the wall owed her money. The second took out a section the size of a door. Plaster dust rose around her in a cloud, gold in the light from the bay window, and she stood in it breathing hard with her bandana half off and grinned at the hole like it had told her a joke.
"God, I love this part," she said.
He said nothing, because he had forgotten how.
She wore old denim overalls that week, one strap always sliding off her shoulder, a tank top underneath that went from grey to white to grey again under the dust. When she bent to haul a chunk of lath into the wheelbarrow the overalls pulled tight across the full curve of her hips and Jake had to go outside and look at the porch for a while. When she reached up to knock plaster off a ceiling joist her tank top rode up and showed a strip of soft belly, pale and freckled, and the dark dip of her navel, and he dropped a pry bar on his own foot.
"You good?" she called.
"Fine."
"You're limping."
"I'm walking with character."
She laughed at that. It was the first real laugh he'd got out of her, loud and low and surprised, and he limped back to his side of the house feeling like he'd been handed a medal.
They were good together. That was the worst part. They worked like two people who'd been doing it for years. She'd call out "Header" before he'd even seen the beam, and he'd already have the jack under it. He'd start to say "Watch the" and she'd already be stepping over the nail. By Wednesday the dumpster was full and they'd found three things: a bricked-up fireplace in the dining room, a green glass soda bottle from 1922 inside the wall, and a love letter from a man named Harold to a woman named Bess, folded into a square and tucked behind the parlour door frame.
"'My darling,'" Dana read aloud, sitting on an overturned bucket in a shaft of dusty sunlight. "'I cannot stop thinking about your ankles.'"
"Bold of Harold."
"It was a different time. Ankles were a lot." She kept reading, and her voice changed. Went a little quieter. "'I know your father thinks I am a fool and a carpenter, and I am both, but I have built this house for you with my own two hands and I will build you a better one if you ask.'"
She folded it up. Jake was standing very still in the doorway with a crowbar.
"Huh," she said, not looking at him. "Carpenters."
"We're a known risk."
"Apparently." She tucked the letter into her overalls bib, right next to wherever she'd put the napkin, and stood up and went back to work.
The kitchen plans went to Ruth on Thursday.
Dana's was gorgeous. He could admit that. She'd drawn it on graph paper with an architect's scale: a butler's pantry where the old one had been, open shelving, a deep farmhouse sink under the window that looked out on the back garden, and a long scrubbed worktable down the middle where an island would have gone, so the room kept its Victorian bones. Jake's was nearly identical, except for the island, which he had drawn as a solid walnut block on turned legs to match the newel post, with a deep drawer for knives and a curved end so you could sit there with coffee and talk to whoever was cooking.
Ruth looked at both plans for a long time on her horsehair sofa, while Dana and Jake stood at either end of the coffee table like duellists.
"Well," said Ruth. "Hers is more correct."
Dana didn't quite pump a fist.
"And his is the kitchen I'd have wanted," Ruth said. "Harold built Bess a table she could sit at while he cooked. It's in the attic. You'll find it if you look."
Dana's face did several things at once.
She stood on the porch at five o'clock that afternoon with her hands on her hips and said, loud enough for Mrs. Henderson's hearing aid and possibly the Hendersons' cat: "YOU WERE RIGHT."
Mrs. Henderson, at her kitchen window, waved.
"That was gracious," Jake said.
"I'm a gracious woman. I'll also be building the pantry, and it'll be the best pantry in the state, and you'll weep." She went back inside, and he followed her, and that was how they ended up in the old pantry together with a single work light and a tape measure, figuring out how deep the shelves could go.
The pantry was narrow. Four feet across, maybe less, lined on one side with old shelving they hadn't torn out yet. Dana stood at the back wall with the end of the tape. Jake stood at the doorway holding the case. "Thirty-one and a quarter," he read.
"That's not right. Bring it here."
He came in. There wasn't room to come in. He came in anyway. She took the tape out of his hand and checked it against the shelf and he stood there in the warm, dusty, plaster-smelling dark with the curve of her hip about an inch from his thigh. She was sweaty from the day. Her tank top clung to the full, heavy swell of her breasts, and the overall strap had slid off her shoulder again, and the freckles there went on and on, down into the shadow of the fabric, a constellation he had no business wanting to map with his mouth.
"Thirty-one and a quarter," she said quietly.
"Told you."
"You did." She didn't move. She looked up. In the narrow light her eyes were very dark. "You've got plaster in your hair."
"So do you."
She reached up and brushed at his hair, slow, and her fingers went from his hair to the back of his neck and stayed there. He put his hand on the shelf beside her head. Not on her. Beside her. He could feel the heat coming off her body and the old wood under his palm and his own heartbeat in his teeth.
"Rule four," Dana said, barely above a breath.
"We're not in the blue room."
"That's a technicality."
"I'm a carpenter. Technicalities are all I have."
She laughed, very softly, and the laugh moved her breasts against his chest and both of them went still. Her fingers tightened on the back of his neck. She tipped her face up. He bent his down. There was no space left in the pantry at all, there were maybe two inches between his mouth and hers and he could taste the coffee on her breath, and he thought about Harold and Bess and ankles and the fact that nobody walks, and he waited, because the napkin said both of them, and she hadn't said.
The work light died.
It went out with a pop and a fizz. The pantry went black. Dana made a sound that was half a curse and half a laugh, and her hand slid off his neck and down his arm, and then she was squeezing past him in the dark, her body sliding against his for one long, unbearable second, hips and breasts and the warm, solid weight of her, and then she was out in the kitchen and there was cool air where she'd been.
"Breaker," she said, a little hoarse. "I'll get it."
He stood in the pantry and pressed his forehead against the shelf.
When the lights came back on she was on her phone, by the back door, frowning at the screen. She turned it around to show him the weather app. A wall of green and yellow was crawling up from the south, the radar animation boiling over three states.
"Tropical storm," she said. "Remnants of. Four inches of rain starting tomorrow night, and we've got a hole in the back roof the size of your ego."
"We tarp it."
"We tarp it, and somebody stays here and empties the buckets." She looked at him across the torn-up kitchen, chin up, a smudge of plaster on her cheekbone, and he couldn't tell if what was in her face was a challenge or a question. "The blue room's the only room with a working radiator."
"Then I guess," Jake said slowly, "we'd better flip for it."
"Don't need to flip." She put the phone in her back pocket. "I'm staying. Question is whether you are."