Cover of Cribbage and Confessions

Cribbage and Confessions

Read the story

7 chapters · 7448 words · Read 1 times

Best Friends, Natalie and Tim, both in the 40's, have been friends for most of their lives. While visiting Natalie at her home on the Colorado River they decide to play a game of cribbage for high stakes. The loser has to be the other one's slave for 24 hours. Although they have experimented with each other they have never taken things beyond vanilla sex. Natalie knows that Tim secretly wants to be dominated by a strong female. She knows his deepest fantasy is to be tied to the bed and made to cum inside a woman's pussy and then have her show it to him and make him eat it. She also knows he wants to be teased beforehand, telling him that he can get out of it simply by not getting hard. She say his penis is a lie detector and if it gets hard it means he wants to do what he is being asked. The game goes back and forth and she can tell Tim desperately does not want to lose or his secret will be revealed. In the end Natalie wins and makes Tim's fantasy come true beyond his expectations. Natalie has already talked with Tim's wife before the trip and has been given permission to use Tim any way she sees fit, even bringing another female in to humiliate Tim even more. They both think Tim has had this fantasy too long and doesn't really want to do it but they are sick of hearing about it and want to teach him a lesson.

Chapter 4: The Taste of Submission

The silence after the river’s hum was absolute, broken only by the frantic rhythm of Tim’s own heartbeat in his ears. He remained on his knees, the plush bedroom carpet now a scratchy prison against his skin. The taste of Natalie was still a sharp, intimate memory on his tongue, a flavor that had curdled into something like shame.

Roxanne’s hand, which had been a firm, guiding pressure on the back of his head, now slid away. He dared to lift his gaze, his vision blurry. She stood over him, a silhouette of effortless power against the soft lamplight. She wasn’t looking at him. She was looking at her own reflection in the large, ornate mirror, adjusting a strand of her dark hair with a critical eye.

“You’ve made a mess of him, Nat,” Roxanne remarked, her voice a smooth, amused alto. “He’s practically vibrating.”

Natalie, now reclined against the headboard with a silk pillow tucked behind her, gave a lazy shrug. She traced a finger along her lower lip, her eyes glinting with a predator’s satisfaction. “He asked for a lesson. I’m just making sure it sticks.” Her gaze shifted to the armchair by the window. “Isn’t that right, Carol?”

Carol hadn’t moved. She sat perched in the plush chair, one leg crossed over the other, a half-empty glass of white wine cradled in her hand. She watched the scene not with passion, but with the detached interest of a scientist observing a lab specimen. The flicker of the jasmine candle danced in her dark eyes.

“He’s certainly attentive,” Carol said, her tone dry. “More attentive than he is when I ask him to take out the recycling.”

A weak, choked sound escaped Tim’s throat. It was meant to be a protest, a plea, anything. It came out as a whimper.

“Oh, don’t start,” Roxanne sighed, finally turning her attention back to him. She placed a single, perfectly manicured finger under his chin and tilted his head up. Her eyes, a startling shade of hazel, scanned his tear-streaked face, his trembling lips. “You got what you wanted. You’ve been fantasizing about this for years, haven’t you? Being used. Being told what to do.” She leaned in, her voice dropping to a conspiratorial whisper that was somehow more terrifying than a shout. “Is it living up to the hype, Tim?”

He couldn’t speak. He shook his head, then nodded, a frantic, useless motion.

“Use your words,” Natalie commanded from the bed. It wasn’t a shout. It was colder, harder. A bank manager correcting a subordinate’s report.

“I… I don’t know,” Tim managed to gasp.

“You don’t know?” Roxanne echoed, feigning shock. She straightened up, her hands on her hips. “After all that effort? Natalie deserves a better review than that.” She glanced around the room, her eyes landing on Carol’s vanity. A slow, wicked smile spread across her face. “I think we need a clearer perspective. Carol, honey, hand me that full-length mirror from the corner. The cheval one.”

Carol arched a slender brow but set her wineglass down without a word. She moved across the room, her petite frame seeming to glide. The mirror was tall, framed in dark wood. She wheeled it over with a soft rumble of casters on the hardwood floor, positioning it directly in front of Tim.

“On your feet,” Roxanne said.

Tim’s legs were leaden, his muscles protesting as he pushed himself up. He stood, swaying slightly, and faced the mirror.

What he saw made his stomach clench. A man in his early forties, pale and soft, stood stripped to his briefs, his hair disheveled, his eyes wide with a wild cocktail of terror and arousal. He looked small. He looked pathetic. Behind his reflection, he could see the tableau of the room: Natalie, goddess-like on the bed; Carol, resuming her seat with a fresh sip of wine; and Roxanne, circling him like a shark.

“Look at yourself,” Roxanne said, her voice right by his ear. She placed her hands on his shoulders, her touch burning through his skin. “This is the man who wanted to be dominated. This is the secret self you hid from your wife. Take a good, long look. This is your fantasy made flesh.”

Tim tried to look away, to close his eyes, but Roxanne’s fingers dug in. “Eyes open. You wanted this reality. Now own it.”

Natalie swung her legs off the bed and padded over, coming to stand beside Roxanne. She studied Tim’s reflection, then his real, trembling form. “He still doesn’t fully believe it,” she mused, as if diagnosing a mechanical fault. “He thinks there’s a safe word. He thinks this is a game with rules.” She leaned in, her blonde hair brushing his shoulder. “The only rule, Tim, is that you have no rules. Your wife gave you to me. You are mine to play with. And I’m inviting my friend to play, too.”

Roxanne’s hands left his shoulders. He heard the soft rustle of clothing behind him. A zip. A slide of fabric. He stared, paralyzed, at the mirror as Roxanne, in his peripheral vision, stepped out of her jeans. Then she moved in front of him, blocking his view of anything else.

She was wearing only simple black lace now. She was breathtaking, and her confidence was an armor he could never pierce.

“You said you didn’t know if it was living up to the hype,” Roxanne said, her voice low and direct. “Let’s find out. Get on your knees again.”

The command was absolute. His body obeyed before his mind could formulate a rebellion. He sank down, the carpet once again grating against his skin. The world reduced to the scent of jasmine, the sight of Roxanne before him, and the terrible, thrilling weight of the women’s expectations.

Natalie crouched down beside him, her presence a radiating heat. “You’re going to show Roxanne the same… enthusiasm… you showed me.” Her hand rested on the back of his neck, not pushing yet, just resting. A promise. “And you’re going to look in that mirror the entire time. You’re going to watch what you are.”

Tim’s eyes lifted, dragged against his will to the cheval glass. In its surface, he saw Roxanne from behind, her dark hair cascading down her back. He saw Natalie beside him, a blonde angel of judgment. And he saw himself, on his knees, poised at the edge of an abyss he had begged to visit.

Roxanne glanced over her shoulder at his reflection, a sly smile on her lips. “Well?” she said, her tone light, almost conversational. “Clock’s ticking, banker boy. Show me what that expensive education bought you.”

Natalie’s hand pressed down, firm and inexorable.

The last thing Tim saw before he was guided forward was his own eyes in the mirror, wide with the horrified, thrilling understanding that this was only the beginning. The muffled sound that followed was not a sob, but a surrender, swallowed whole by the quiet, perfumed air of the room, as Carol took another slow, deliberate sip of her wine and watched, her expression unreadable.

The muffled sound that followed was not a sob, but a surrender, swallowed whole by the quiet, perfumed air of the room, as Carol took another slow, deliberate sip of her wine and watched, her expression unreadable.

Natalie’s hand was a cold vise on the back of his neck, its pressure absolute. “You’re thinking,” she whispered into his ear, her breath hot. “Stop thinking. Just fucking do it. Lick her like you mean it, or I’ll hold you here all night.”

Tim’s world narrowed to the scent of her, musky and sharp, and the overwhelming closeness of skin. He tentatively extended his tongue, a pathetic flicker against her.

“Pathetic,” Roxanne stated, not looking back. She shifted her weight, a slight, deliberate adjustment. “You tongue a pussy like you’re apologizing for it. Like a timid little mouse. Is that what you are, Tim? A mouse?”

A hot wave of shame crashed over him. He tried again, pushing his face forward, attempting a broader, wetter stroke.

It wasn’t enough.

“For Christ’s sake,” Natalie sighed, the patience evaporating from her voice. Her fingers tangled in his thinning hair, gripping fistfuls close to the scalp. She didn’t yank. She simply applied steady, undeniable force, pulling his head forward and locking it in place. “Open your mouth. Wider.”

He obeyed, a moan trapped in his throat.

SHE FORCES HIS FACE.

Roxanne rocked back against him, a slow, grinding pivot that sealed his mouth and nose flush against her. His eyes, wide and watering, stared blindly at the mirrored reflection of his own obscene submission—the desperate bulge of his briefs, the tense hunch of his shoulders, Natalie’s commanding posture beside him. He couldn’t breathe through anything but her. The taste flooded him, a bitter, intimate salinity that was entirely foreign and violently personal.

“There,” Roxanne hummed, a shudder of pleasure running through her. “Finally. Suck on it. Properly.”

He moved his tongue in a frantic, sloppy rhythm, driven by the need for air as much as by command. The sounds were grotesquely wet, echoing in the quiet room. Saliva dripped from his chin onto his chest.

“See the mirror, Tim?” Natalie cooed, her voice a parody of sweetness. “Look at yourself. Look at what you needed.” His gaze, hazy with panic, was dragged back to the glass. “You’re a cunt-licking little puppet. And we hold the strings.”

Carol spoke from her chair, her tone flat, analytical. “His ears are bright red.” She took another sip. “I’ve never seen that before.”

“Humiliation does that,” Roxanne said, her voice tight with concentration. She began to move in a more deliberate rhythm, fucking his face with shallow, demanding thrusts. “Oh yeah, that’s it. Get your nose in there too, you fucking pervert. Smell it. That’s the smell of your fantasy, isn’t it? Drink it in.”

The violation was complete, immersive, a sensory drowning. He was a tool for her pleasure, an object. The realization, instead of breaking him, sent a jagged bolt of electric shame straight to his groin. He groaned against her, the vibration eliciting a sharp gasp from Roxanne.

“Fuck, he’s getting off on this,” Natalie laughed, a sound of genuine delight. She reached around and roughly palmed the front of his briefs, feeling the rigid, traitorous hardness there. “Jesus, Tim. You’re rock hard from being used as a human face towel. Your wife is right there.”

The juxtaposition was devastating. Carol’s clinical observation, Natalie’s cruel joy, Roxanne’s grinding dominance, and his own unwilled, furious arousal—it collapsed upon him. His hips bucked involuntarily against Natalie’s hand.

Roxanne pressed back harder, holding him deep for a long, unbearable moment where black spots danced at the edges of his vision. Then she pulled away with a wet, obscene sound.

Tim gasped, dragging in ragged whoops of jasmine-scented air, strings of saliva and her slickness coating his lips and chin. He hung his head, trembling violently, unable to look at anyone.

Roxanne turned around. Her eyes were dark, predatory. She looked down at him, at the mess on his face, and then at the clear tent in his briefs. “He doesn’t get to come from that,” she said to Natalie, her voice decisive. “That was just for me. For us.”

“Absolutely,” Natalie agreed, releasing him. She stood, brushing a stray hair from her cheek. “Stand up.”

He stumbled to his feet, legs nearly giving way.

Roxanne closed the distance between them. She didn’t touch him with her hands. Instead, she raised one bare foot and placed the sole against the soaked fabric of his briefs, applying a firm, grinding pressure. “This,” she said, watching his face contort, “is a problem. You don’t earn an orgasm by being a piece of meat. You earn it by being useful.” She pushed, a sharp, dismissive shove that sent him stumbling back a step. “Clean yourself up. The bathroom. Now. Don’t you dare touch yourself.”

He fled, the order a merciful escape. The cool silence of the marble bathroom was a shock. He caught his reflection in the mirror—a wild-eyed, flushed stranger with a glistening, filthy chin. He turned on the tap and scrubbed his face with cold water until his skin burned, trying to erase the smell, the taste, the sight of himself in the cheval glass.

But it was inside him now. He leaned on the sink, shuddering, hearing the low murmur of their voices from the bedroom. He was trapped in the sanctuary of soft hues and lavender scent, and the lesson, he understood with a cold, sinking clarity, was far from over. The momentum of their design was still carrying him forward, toward whatever came next.

The momentum of their design was still carrying him forward, toward whatever came next. He pressed his damp forehead against the cool glass of the bathroom mirror, the water from the sink still dripping from his chin onto the pristine marble. From the bedroom, he heard a low exchange of words, a ripple of laughter that felt like needles against his skin. It was Carol’s laugh, but sharper than he’d ever heard it.

“Do you think he’s jerking off in there?” Natalie’s voice carried, clear and mocking.

“He wouldn’t dare,” Roxanne replied. A drawer opened and closed. “But we’ve warmed him up. He’s pliable. It’s time for the main event.”

A cold, new dread seeped into his bones. Main event. The words implied a finale, but the tone suggested an escalation. He had thought the abyss had a bottom. He was wrong. The handle of the bathroom door turned, not with a force, but with a quiet, inevitable certainty. Natalie stood there, already dressed in a silk robe, her expression unreadable.

“Out,” she said, not raising her voice. “Don’t make us drag you.”

He followed, his bare feet soundless on the floor. The bedroom seemed different, charged with a new and terrible anticipation. The cheval mirror had been angled differently, framing the bed. Carol was no longer in the chair. She stood by the window, her back to the room, looking out at the dark ribbon of the Colorado River far below. Roxanne was by the bedroom door, which was now slightly ajar. She leaned against the frame, listening to something in the hallway.

“She’s just parking,” Roxanne said, glancing at her phone. “Right on time.”

“Who?” The word tore from Tim’s throat, raw and desperate.

Carol turned from the window. Her face was serene, but her eyes were like chips of flint. “The one person you never wanted to see you like this.” She walked toward him, stopping just a foot away. She reached out and smoothed the collar of his shirt, which he’d never put back on, a grotesque parody of wifely care. “You begged me for this life, Tim. You showed me the websites, the videos. You cried when I said it was sick.” Her hand dropped. “So I’ve decided to give you exactly what you wanted. Full transparency. No more secrets between us.”

The footsteps in the hallway were hesitant, familiar. A light knock on the doorframe.

Roxanne pushed the door open fully.

SHE BRINGS IN HIS WIFE.

Elise stood there, frozen in the aperture. She was still in her sensible work blouse and skirt, her purse strap clutched tightly in her hand. Her face, usually arranged in expressions of mild concern or listless contentment, was a mask of incomprehension. Her eyes darted from Roxanne’s knowing smile to Natalie’s cool appraisal, to Carol’s detached posture, and finally, irrevocably, to him.

To Tim, standing in his stained briefs, his hair wet, his entire body broadcasting a recent and degrading use. The scent in the room—jasmine, sex, her own husband’s shame—hit her. He saw her nostrils flare, saw the understanding click into place, shattering the confusion into a million sharp, painful pieces.

“Elise,” he whispered. It was a plea, a prayer, a sob.

“What…” she began, her voice airy, lost. “Carol said… there was an intervention. That you were… unwell.”

“He is unwell, darling,” Carol said, her voice soothing, lethal. “He’s sick with need. We’re treating him. Come in. Close the door.”

Roxanne guided Elise in with a gentle hand on her back that was utterly inescapable. The door clicked shut, a sound of finality. Elise flinched.

“Look at him, Elise,” Natalie said, pointing a casual finger at Tim. “Really look. This is the man who shared your bed, who made your morning coffee. This is his truth. He gets hard from being forced to eat another woman’s cunt. He whimpers. He obeys.”

Elise’s hand flew to her mouth. Her eyes were huge, swimming with a hurt so profound it seemed to physically shrink her.

“It’s not… it’s not like that,” Tim choked out, the lie withering under the evidence saturating the air.

“It’s exactly like that,” Carol corrected, moving to stand beside Elise. She spoke softly, intimately, as if sharing a secret. “He asked me to do this. He needed to be broken. He needed an audience for his filth. And you, my dear, are the most important audience of all.”

“I don’t… understand,” Elise stammered, tears beginning to cut tracks through her makeup.

“You don’t have to understand,” Roxanne said, her earlier amusement gone, replaced by a cool, executive efficiency. “You just have to participate. That’s the treatment. Your husband’s sickness requires a collective cure.”

“No,” Elise breathed, stepping back, hitting the door. “I’m leaving.”

Natalie was there in an instant, a firm hand on her arm. “You’re not.” It wasn’t a threat, just a fact. “Your marriage is a fiction. Your husband is a pathetic, jacking-off slave to his own degradation. The only thing left is to see how deep the sickness goes. For both of you.”

Roxanne walked to the bed and picked up a small, black remote. She pressed a button. A low, mechanical hum filled the room as the headboard parted slightly, and two sturdy leather cuffs, which had been hidden in the ornate woodwork, unfolded. They were waiting.

“Tim,” Carol said. “On the bed. On your back.”

He looked at Elise, at her shattered visage, and his own shame reached a suicidal zenith. He couldn’t move.

“Now,” Natalie said, her voice cracking through the room like a whip.

His body, trained now, betrayed him again. He crawled onto the silk sheets, the fabric chilling against his skin. He lay back, the overhead light a blinding interrogation lamp.

“Elise,” Carol said, taking her hand. Her touch was gentle, her words a venomous balm. “He needs to see that you see. He needs to know that his fantasy has consumed everything, even you. Especially you.” She led the resisting, sobbing woman to the side of the bed. “Hold his hand. Watch.”

Roxanne secured Tim’s left wrist into a cuff. Natalie took the right. The leather was cold, unyielding. The click of the buckles was obscenely loud. He was spread-eagled, utterly exposed, his erection a blatant, traitorous flagpole against his stomach.

Elise’s trembling fingers found his. Her grip was lifeless, cold.

Roxanne stood at the foot of the bed, looking down at him. She slowly undid her robe, letting it fall. She was magnificent and terrible. “You wanted a show, Tim? You wanted your secret life?” She climbed onto the bed, straddling his thighs, her weight pinning him. “Now your wife gets to watch you fuck it.”

She didn’t guide him into her. She reached back, her hand wrapping around his shaft, and he gasped at the touch. She angled him, notched the head of his cock against her opening, and held him there, a teasing, unbearable pressure. She looked over at Elise, whose face was a monument to despair.

“Watch your husband, Elise,” Roxanne commanded. “Watch him become mine.”

She sank down onto him in one slow, inexorable slide. Tim cried out, a strangled sound of absolute, ruined pleasure. She was impossibly tight, impossibly hot, a velvet vise drenched from her own enjoyment of his torment. She took him to the hilt, her body accepting all of him.

“Oh, fuck,” he moaned, his head thrashing side to side. He couldn’t escape the feeling, the sight of her riding him, or the shattered reflection of his wife’s eyes.

“That’s it,” Roxanne purred, beginning to move, a slow, grinding rock that milked his length. “This is your cure. This is your truth. You’re just a cock attached to a shame spiral.” Her pace quickened, her hips snapping with a brutal, efficient rhythm. The wet, slapping sounds of their connection filled the room, a vulgar soundtrack.

Elise made a small, animal noise. Her hand went limp in his.

“Look at her, Tim,” Natalie whispered from her post by his wrist. “Look at what you’ve done.”

His eyes, blurred with pleasure-pain, found his wife’s. The love that had once been there was gone, scorched away, replaced by a horrified, empty witnessing. He was fucking another woman, powerfully, desperately, right in front of her, and his body was screaming toward a climax.

“I’m… I’m gonna…” he stammered, the warning torn from him.

“No you’re not,” Roxanne grunted, driving down harder. “Not until she helps.” She looked straight at Elise. “Come here. Kiss him. Let him taste you while he fucks me.”

Elise recoiled. “No.”

“Do it,” Carol’s voice cut in, flat and final, from the foot of the bed. “Or I will ensure you never get a single penny, and every person in your life will know exactly what your husband is and what you allowed. This is the price of staying. This is the price of leaving. Participate.”

Sobbing openly now, Elise was pushed forward by Natalie. She bent over, her tears falling onto Tim’s face as she pressed her lips to his. They were cold, salty, unmoving. He kissed her back, a pathetic, begging gesture, even as his hips pistoned upwards to meet Roxanne’s plunging descent. The dissonance was atomizing—the sacred memory of his wife’s kiss violently spliced with the profane, gripping heat of the woman impaled on his cock.

Roxanne’s breath became ragged. “God, you’re a good little fuck-toy, aren’t you?” She rode him with punishing force, her muscles clamping around him. “You’re gonna come when I tell you. You’re gonna come inside me, and your wife is gonna watch it happen. And then,” she gasped, her own climax nearing, “then she’s gonna clean you up. With her mouth.”

Elise tore her lips away with a wretched cry.

Roxanne’s body went rigid. A sharp, guttural shout was ripped from her throat as she came, her internal muscles pulsing around his shaft in rhythmic, violent waves. The sensation tore Tim’s last shred of control to shreds.

“Now!” Roxanne screamed, slamming down onto him one final time. “Come for me, you bastard! Come!”

The order detonated him. His back arched against the restraints, a raw, tearing shout erupting from his chest as his orgasm erupted, deep inside her, a surrendering flood that felt less like pleasure and more like the expulsion of his very soul. He spasmed, helpless, a puppet thrashing on its strings.

For a moment, there was only the sound of ragged breathing and the scent of spent sex. Roxanne climbed off him, slick with their mingled fluids. She looked at Elise, who was staring at Tim’s softening, glistening cock, at the evidence of his ultimate betrayal now leaking onto his skin.

“Your turn,” Roxanne said, her voice hoarse but firm. “You know what to do. Clean your husband up.”

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI