Cover of Double Trouble

Double Trouble

Read the story

36 chapters · 56353 words · Read 1 times

A man has an unusual condition where he has two average sized penises, but only one ever becomes erect, the second penis is almost vestigial. The man's wife finds some strange pills online which she thinks will fix the man's penises and allow both penises to get erect, as she has a fantasy of being penetrated by both penises at once. The pills work, however not only do both penises get hard, they start slowly growing larger.

Chapter 8: Meanwhile

The fluorescent hum of Harold’s office seemed louder than usual, a relentless buzz that mirrored the frantic static in his head. Columns of numbers blurred on the spreadsheet before him, dissolving into the memory of tangled sheets and hot skin. Brenda, astride him, her red hair wild, back arched, taking him impossibly deep. Both of him. His breath hitched, a dry click in his throat.

He’d spent decades pretending the smaller one wasn’t there. A shameful secret tucked away. A biological footnote. But last night… the pills Brenda found… Christ. It hadn’t just gotten hard. It had become a cock – stiff, demanding, flooding his senses with alien, overwhelming sensation as it pushed relentlessly into Brenda’s tight ass while his familiar shaft was buried deep in her slick cunt. The memory of her desperate cries, the wet, obscene sounds of her body stretched beyond belief, the sheer, impossible fullness she described… it ignited a furnace in his groin.

A familiar, heavy throb started low in his belly, centered on his main cock. But then… another pulse, distinct, sharper, lower down. A separate heat. Harold froze, fingers hovering over the keyboard. No. Not here. Panic flared, cold and sharp. He shifted subtly, trying to angle himself away from the open doorway of his cluttered office. Stacks of audits formed precarious walls, but they offered little true privacy.

He squeezed his eyes shut, trying to conjure tax codes, depreciation schedules, anything mundane. Instead, Brenda’s voice echoed: Fuck me with both of them, Harold! Stuff me full! The phantom sensation of her inner walls clenching down on both shafts simultaneously, the intense, burning stretch around the smaller one as it seemed to… thicken? He’d felt it, hadn’t he? After, when he’d touched it – swollen, hot, impossibly rigid, feeling less like the inert nub he knew and more… substantial.

The twin surges of blood were undeniable now. A familiar pressure built along his usual length, straining against his briefs and trousers. But beneath it, riding the same wave of arousal, the smaller one was hardening too. Not a tentative stiffness, but a fierce, insistent rigidity pushing forward, trapped against fabric, demanding space. It felt larger. Thicker than last night? His rational mind screamed it was impossible, hallucination, but the blunt pressure against his thigh was terrifyingly real. He could feel them both distinctly – the familiar heft of his main cock, and now, unmistakably, another hard ridge pressing up beside it.

"Harold? You okay? You look a little flushed." Carol from Payroll stood in his doorway, holding a manila folder, her head tilted. Her gaze, flickering downwards before snapping back to his face, confirmed his worst fear.

He snapped his knees together, heat flooding his cheeks, burning the tips of his ears. "Fine! Just… warm. Bit of a headache." The lie sounded brittle. He focused intensely on the spreadsheet, willing the numbers to make sense. Shrink. Please, just shrink.

Carol hovered, unconvinced. "Right. Well… these are the revised expense reports for the Henderson account. Needs your sign-off before EOD." She placed the folder on the least cluttered corner of his desk. Her eyes darted down again, just for a split second. "That suit’s looking… snug today, Harold. Big lunch?" She offered a weak, slightly uncomfortable smile.

Harold felt like crawling under his groaning desk. Snug. She’d seen it. Seen the impossible bulge. The outline of two distinct pressures straining the wool blend of his trousers. Humiliation washed over him, cold and slick. Decades of careful concealment undone by a pill and his wife’s insatiable fantasy. "Uh, no. Just… just sitting funny." He shifted again, an awkward, futile attempt at camouflage.

Carol’s smile faltered. "Okay. Well… get that headache sorted. Sign-off by five?" She backed out quickly, her steps hurried.

The moment she disappeared, Harold was on his feet. He snatched a random file – camouflage – and practically bolted from his office, head down, ignoring the questioning look from Marty at the next cubicle. The walk to the men’s room felt endless, every step jostling the twin erections trapped against his leg. The awareness was excruciating. The main cock’s familiar, heavy ache. The smaller one’s insistent, almost angry pressure. He could feel them independently, two distinct points of rigid heat.

He slammed into the thankfully empty restroom, locking himself in a stall. Leaning back against the cool metal door, he fumbled frantically with his belt buckle, button, and zip. He shoved trousers and briefs down to his knees. The humid air of the restroom hit his exposed skin. He looked down.

Jesus Christ.

Both were fully, fiercely erect. Gloriously, terrifyingly hard. Just like last night. Maybe… maybe more so? His main cock stood thick and proud, flushed dark, veins prominent. And beside it, nestled against the base, the smaller one – impossibly rigid, jutting upwards at a slight angle. It wasn’t vestigial anymore. Not even close. It was a solid, undeniable cock. Thickening at the base, tapering slightly, the head swollen and dark. It looked… larger. Significantly larger than it ever had been before the pills. Thicker than his thumb now? Substantial. Not monstrous, but undeniably functional, undeniable present. The sight stole his breath.

He reached down, fingers trembling. He touched the smaller one first. The skin was hot silk over iron. He traced its length. Solid. Unyielding. He wrapped his fingers around it. A jolt of pure, electric sensation shot through him. It wasn't just sensitive; it felt vital, connected deep within him. He gave it an experimental stroke. A low groan escaped him. The sensation was overwhelming, alien but intensely pleasurable – a direct line to his spine. Precum beaded thickly at its tip.

He shifted his grip, wrapping his other hand around his main cock. Familiar heat, familiar weight. He began to stroke them both slowly, savagely. The double sensation was mind-blowing. The rough pleasure of his familiar shaft, the sharp, intense feedback from the smaller one. He imagined Brenda again, not just imagining, but needing this. Needing both.

"Fuck," he breathed, the word ragged. He pumped faster. One hand working the thick, familiar length, the other jerking the smaller, hotter shaft with equal fervor. His hips bucked involuntarily. The mental image consumed him: Brenda on her knees, taking his main cock deep in her mouth while he pushed the smaller, growing one into her ass. Or her riding him, impaling herself brutally on both at once, screaming as they stretched her beyond reason. The phantom feel of her hot, tight cunt milking one shaft while her ass clenched fiercely around the other.

He focused on the smaller cock. Gripping it tighter, stroking it faster, fixating on the shocking reality of its rigid heft. Brenda’s ass. The thought was incendiary. The memory of her tight ring of muscle yielding, burning, stretching around it as it grew thicker inside her. Had it truly gotten larger then? Was it getting larger right now? The base felt thick, solid, anchored.

He panted, sweat beading on his forehead. The dual stimulation was too much. Pressure built, immense and undeniable. He squeezed both shafts, fingers slippery with precum. "Oh god, Brenda… taking both my fucking cocks…" he gasped.

The orgasm ripped through him, violent and consuming. His main cock pulsed wildly, thick ropes of cum splattering the tile wall in front of him. Simultaneously, the smaller cock erupted in fierce, staccato spurts – less volume, but intense, focused jets that added to the mess. The dual release was shattering. Pleasure didn't just peak; it exploded from two separate epicenters within him, merging into a wave of ecstasy that made his legs tremble and his vision blur. He slumped against the stall door, gasping, both cocks still throbbing in his hands, utterly spent but still rigid. Still hard. Unbelievably hard.

He stayed like that, breathing hard, staring at the evidence of his climax on the wall. The silence of the restroom pressed in. The fluorescent light buzzed. He looked down again at the twin erections, slick and gleaming. They hadn't softened. Not an inch. The smaller one pulsed faintly in his grasp, a living thing. Solid. Insistent. Undeniably larger than it had been just days ago.

Reality crashed in, cold and stark, cutting through the fading haze of pleasure. This wasn't a temporary effect. This was… happening. Changing. Growing. The pills had unlocked something, and it wasn't stopping. His heart hammered against his ribs, a frantic drumbeat of fear and a terrifying, exhilarating thrill. Brenda’s fantasy wasn’t just real; it was escalating.

He hastily cleaned himself and the wall with wads of rough toilet paper, hands shaking. Tugging his clothes back into place was a struggle against the persistent, impossible hardness straining the fabric even more obscenely. He couldn't go back to his desk like this. Carol’s awkward stare burned in his memory.

He needed to get home. He needed to see Brenda. He needed to know what the fuck was happening to his body before it exploded. Or before someone else saw. Fuck the Henderson account. Fuck the paperwork. He pushed out of the stall, avoiding the mirror over the sinks, and walked quickly, purposefully, towards the exit, clutching that useless file like a shield. The urgent, dual ache between his legs propelled him forward.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI