Chapter 1: The Marble Insult
The scaffolding came down from the Callahan house on the first Monday in March, and by Tuesday Cornelia Ashbury had ordered every curtain on the front of her own house drawn shut.
"It is the glare," she told the butler. "I will not have it in the drawing room."
Grace, at the breakfast table with the Times folded beside her plate, did not point out that the glare was the sun, which had been coming in the drawing room windows since her grandfather built the house in 1849, and which had only become offensive now that it bounced off nine thousand square feet of white Italian marble across Fifth Avenue.
She had watched the thing go up for two years. First the old Delancey brownstone and its neighbour had vanished in a week of dust. Then came a hole, and teams of drays, and men shouting in Italian and Irish on the scaffolds at dawn. And now there it stood, gleaming like a wedding cake that had decided to become a bank, with a mansard roof, a carved frieze of fruit and leaves along the cornice, and a pair of bronze lamps at the door the size of church bells. It had cost, according to her mother's friend Mrs. Van Alst Lowe, two million dollars. According to her mother it had cost the neighbourhood its dignity, which could not be bought back at any price.
"The Callahans," Cornelia said, buttering a piece of toast with a precision that would have done credit to a surgeon, "have sent cards again."
"How many does that make?"
"Four. One from Mrs. Callahan. One from Mr. Callahan. One from Mrs. Callahan announcing that she is at home on Thursdays, as though anybody had asked. And one from the son." She made the last word sound like a stain. "I have returned them all."
"Unopened?"
"Naturally unopened. I do not know these people, Grace, and I do not intend to. The man laid track across Nebraska and his wife's father sold potatoes in Pittsburgh, and now they think they can put up a palace opposite my door and be invited to dinner." She set the knife down. "You will not speak to any of them. If you meet one in the street, you will look at something else. If one speaks to you, you will not hear."
"What if one of them is on fire?"
"Then you may send for the fire brigade," said her mother, "without introducing yourself."
Grace had a secret, and it was not a romantic one. It was a building.
For three years she had spent two afternoons a week at the Bleecker Street Free Reading Room, which occupied four rooms over a hatter's shop and smelled of wet wool and gas and glue. Mr. Ambrose Teague, who had kept it for thirty years on charity and stubbornness, let her mend bindings and keep the lending ledger. On a cold evening there was not a chair to be had. Shop girls came straight from the cutting floors with their shawls dripping. Old men came in to read the papers for warmth. A cab driver named Feeney was working his way through the whole of Dickens, two pages a night, moving his lips. There were never enough books, or enough lamps, or enough hours, because the rooms closed at seven, and most of the people who needed them most did not leave work until six.
Then, in January, old Miss Hester Vane had died at the age of ninety-one and left a corner lot on Second Avenue to the Ladies' Free Library Committee, "for the erection of a library free to every citizen of New York, without distinction." The committee was chaired by Cornelia Ashbury. The committee had hired Mr. Ezra Pruitt, who had designed half the churches on Murray Hill and was very, very old. And Mr. Pruitt had produced a drawing of a dark brownstone fortress with arrow-slit windows, a reading room that closed at sunset, and a separate side entrance marked, in his elegant copperplate, Ladies and Persons of the Working Class.
Grace had looked at that drawing for a long time in her mother's study. Then she had gone up to her room and found her dressmaker's tape measure.
On the third Saturday in March she told her mother she was going to Bleecker Street, which was true eventually, and took a horsecar downtown with Delia, her mother's maid and her own fiercest ally, who carried a sewing basket and an opinion on everything.
The lot was a wide, muddy rectangle of brick rubble and dead weeds on the corner, with a tenement on one side and a German beer garden on the other, and on the far side of it, a man was measuring it with a chain.
He was crouched in the mud, pegging one end of a long steel surveyor's chain with a stake. He was broad through the shoulders and dressed in a plain grey tweed suit that had seen weather, and his hat was off, and his sandy hair was blowing all over his head. He had a pair of folding brass spectacles on his nose and a notebook in his teeth.
"Miss Grace," Delia murmured. "There's a fellow."
"I can see there's a fellow, Delia." Grace lifted her chin and stepped onto the lot. She had not come all this way to be put off by a surveyor. Mr. Pruitt must have sent him. She would simply measure the east side, which nobody was standing on.
She had her tape out and a stone on the end of it and had paced off twenty feet when the man called, around the notebook, "You'll want to watch the... ah."
Grace's boot went into a hole full of black water up to the ankle.
The man came across the rubble at a run, took the notebook out of his mouth, and stopped, plainly at a loss as to whether a gentleman offers his hand to a lady standing in a puddle on a vacant lot without an introduction. Grace solved it for him by stepping out on her own with as much dignity as one wet boot allowed.
"There was a cellar there," he said apologetically. "Old Vane stables. I've marked it on my plan, if that's any consolation."
"It isn't," said Grace. "Are you Mr. Pruitt's man?"
Something flickered across his face. "I'm nobody's man this morning. I'm only curious." He looked at her tape measure, and then at her, and his eyes behind the brass spectacles were very blue. "You're measuring it with a dressmaker's tape?"
"You're measuring it with a chain."
"A chain is what one measures land with."
"And a tape is what one measures with when one hasn't been invited to bring a chain." Grace wound it up briskly. "What are you curious about?"
He hesitated, then held out the notebook, open. It was full of quick, exact pencil sketches: the lot from every corner, the angle of the sun scribbled in arrows, the tenement windows that overlooked it, the width of the sidewalk. On one page he had drawn the beginning of a building. It was nothing like Mr. Pruitt's fortress. It had tall arched windows all along the Second Avenue front, and a wide flight of steps up to a single door.
"There's a plan for a dark brownstone keep with windows like arrow slits," he said. "I saw it. I happen to think a library ought to be the brightest building on the street. People should be able to see the lamps from a block away and know it's open. This side faces south and west, so you'd put the reading room here, along the front, and get light until evening. Gas for after dark. Nobody should have to read Dickens by a candle stub in nineteen-hundred, or whenever the thing's finished."
Grace stared at him. Then she pointed. "Here," she said. "On the ground floor, by the door. You'll want a long rack with hooks, for the shawls. The women come in from the cutting floors with wet shawls, and they have nowhere to put them, so they keep them on and drip on the books. And you've got a counter here, but it's too high. Half the people who borrow books can't see over a counter that high, and they don't like to ask."
The man was writing, fast. "What else?"
"It has to stay open until nine. Not seven. Nine. And there must be one front door for everyone." She heard her own voice rising and did not stop it. "No side entrance for ladies and the working class, as if reading were something to be done round the back like delivering coal."
He looked up from the notebook. For a moment neither of them said anything at all, there in the mud with the beer garden's empty tables behind them and Delia pretending to examine a dead weed.
"One door," he said quietly. "Yes. Obviously. I don't know why I didn't see it."
"Because you've always been allowed through the front," said Grace.
He laughed, startled, a warm, unguarded sound. "That's fair," he said. "That's entirely fair. May I keep the rack and the counter and the door? I'll give you credit."
"You can't give me credit, I don't know your name."
"Then I'll put you down as Miss Tape Measure."
"In that case you are Mr. Chain." She was smiling, she realised, the way she had not smiled since the Pruitt drawing. She checked her father's watch, pinned at her waist, mostly to have something else to look at. "I'm late for Bleecker Street. Good morning, Mr. Chain. Mind the cellars."
"Good morning, Miss Tape Measure," he said. "Mind them yourself. I'll put a fence round that one."
When she looked back from the corner, he was standing in the middle of the empty lot with his notebook, looking at the place where a door would be.
She thought about him all through the afternoon at Bleecker Street while she mended the spine of a Pickwick Papers for Mr. Feeney the cab driver. She thought about him in the horsecar home with Delia teasing her in Irish. She was still thinking about him at six o'clock, coming down the stairs in her dinner dress, when the doorbell rang.
The butler opened it. Grace stopped on the landing.
Mr. Chain stood on the Ashbury doorstep in evening clothes, bareheaded under the gaslight, with an envelope in his gloved hand. He had brushed his hair. It had not helped. Behind him, across the wide dark avenue, every window of the white marble palace blazed with light.
"Mr. William Callahan," the butler announced to the hall, in the voice of a man reading out a death notice. "With his mother's compliments, madam. Mrs. Callahan begs to deliver her invitation in person, since the post appears to have trouble finding this house."
From the drawing room doorway, Cornelia Ashbury said, without raising her voice, "Shut the door, Barnes."
But before the door closed, Will Callahan lifted his eyes past the butler and up the stairs, and saw Grace on the landing in her blue silk, her hand frozen on the banister, and he went perfectly still.