Chapter 3: Where the Door Goes
Grace stood up. Her knees were not steady, so she put one hand on the back of her chair, and with the other she checked her father's watch, though she could not afterwards have said what time it was.
"They are Mr. William Callahan's drawings," she said. "The ideas in them are mine. The coat rack, the counter, the hours. The door." She made herself meet her mother's eyes. "Mr. Pruitt's design has a side entrance for ladies and persons of the working class, Mama. I couldn't bear it. So I found someone who could draw what I couldn't, and he did, and he never once asked for anything in return."
Eight society ladies held their teacups in mid-air. Mr. Pruitt made a noise like a kettle. And Maude Callahan, in violet silk at the end of the room, put her gloved hand to her diamonds and said, with dawning wonder, "Will? And the Ashbury girl?"
Cornelia set the drawings down on the table, very gently, as if they might break.
"This meeting is adjourned," she said. "Barnes, the Callahans are leaving."
Her mother did not shout. Cornelia Ashbury had never shouted in her life. She stood in the middle of Grace's bedroom with her back to the window and her hands folded at her waist, and her silence was worse than any shouting.
"How long?"
"Since March. Tuesdays, at Bleecker Street. Delia was there every minute, and Mr. Teague. Nothing improper ever happened."
"Nothing improper." Cornelia's voice was very quiet. "You conspired with that family behind my back for three months, in a room over a hatter's shop, and in front of my committee, in my own drawing room, that man laughed and asked where we got his son's drawings. And you tell me nothing improper happened. Grace, I have been made ridiculous across the street."
Grace thought of the long table laid for twenty-four. The candles burning down. The twenty empty chairs.
"I sat beside you that night," she said. "At the dinner. Do you remember?"
Her mother's chin moved, very slightly.
"I will always sit beside you, Mama. I'll sit beside you at every table in New York for the rest of your life, empty or full. But I can't live in a house with the curtains drawn because a building across the street is too bright. Papa wouldn't have. He used to take me down to the docks on Sundays to watch the ships come in, every flag in the world. He said New York was the only city that started over every morning." Her voice cracked and she let it. "That library should be the brightest building on Second Avenue, and I don't care whose name is on it, and neither would he."
For a long moment Cornelia Ashbury looked at her daughter. Then she looked down at the cameo of her husband at her throat, and touched it once, and went out without a word, and shut the door very softly behind her.
Across the avenue, Maude Callahan was in raptures.
"It's perfect. It's better than perfect. The Callahan Free Library, designed by my own son, and the Ashbury girl's fingerprints all over it. Cornelia will choke." She paced the length of the dining room, past the forty empty chairs. "We'll lay the cornerstone with a ball. I'll have the Lowes. I'll have the Delafields. I'll have the Mayor."
"Good work, son," boomed Augustus from the far end of the table. "Got to hand it to you. That's the first useful thing your drawing's done for the family. Now you've had your fun, I want you at the Erie office on Monday."
Will put down his knife and fork.
"No, sir," he said.
His father's spade beard lifted. "What did you say?"
"I said no." It came out steadier than he expected. Will had been saying yes, sir, at this table for twenty-eight years, and it turned out that the other word had been waiting the whole time, like a door in a wall nobody used. "I'm an architect. I trained for six years in Paris. I designed every carving on the front of this house and you think it was a man from Philadelphia. It's not a hobby, and I'm not going to the Erie office, not on Monday or any other day. And the library won't carry our name, Mother. That was never the point."
There was a silence long enough for the chandelier to tick. Maude opened her mouth, then closed it.
Then Augustus Callahan leaned back in his chair and looked at his son down the whole length of the table, the way Will imagined he had once looked at a mountain range he intended to put a railroad through.
"Everybody told me I was a fool to build west of the Missouri," he said slowly. "Said there was nothing out there but grass and weather. I did it anyway." He picked up his fork. "How much do you need?"
It took the rest of the summer to make peace, and in the end it was not made in a drawing room.
The mothers fought it out in public. Maude told a reporter from the Herald that her family was building the finest free library in America. Cornelia wrote a letter to the Times explaining, in four crisp paragraphs, that the land belonged to the Ladies' Free Library Committee and always would. The papers called it the Battle of the Books. The lot on Second Avenue went back to weeds, and in August a goat from the beer garden moved onto it and showed every sign of staying.
So on the last Tuesday in September, on a cold wet night, Mr. Ambrose Teague sent out two invitations to an evening meeting at the Bleecker Street Free Reading Room, one to Mrs. Ashbury and one to Mrs. Callahan, and each lady was given to understand that the other had declined.
They arrived within a minute of each other, at a quarter to eight, and met at the top of the stairs. Maude in a crimson cape. Cornelia in black, with an umbrella like a sword. They stopped, face to face, under the dripping skylight.
"Mrs. Callahan."
"Mrs. Ashbury."
And then Mr. Teague was bowing them through, into the reading room, before either could turn round, because there was simply nowhere else to go. Every chair was taken. Shop girls sat on the floor along the walls with their wet shawls drying in the gaslight, reading. Old men shared newspapers. Mrs. Brennan from the cutting floor stood on tiptoe at the counter to hand back a novel. Mr. Feeney the cab driver had reached the last chapter of Bleak House and was reading it with his finger under the line and tears running openly into his moustache. Nobody looked up at the two richest women on Fifth Avenue standing in the doorway in their furs. Nobody had time.
Grace stood at the back by the window. Across the room, by the shelves of engineering manuals, Will stood with his hands in his pockets and did not look at her, because they had agreed not to, and because if he did he would not stop.
Cornelia and Maude stood side by side for a very long time.
"There's nowhere to sit," Maude said at last, almost to herself.
"No," said Cornelia. "There never has been."
Grace came forward then, with the drawings rolled under her arm. She unrolled them on the counter in front of both women, and Will came to the other end and held down the corners. "The Hester Vane Free Library," Grace said. "It was her land. It should carry her name, and nobody else's, over the door. The Ashbury Committee will govern it. The Callahan gift will build it. Both names will be cut into the cornerstone, in letters of exactly the same size."
"And the architect's name," said Cornelia unexpectedly. She did not look at Will. "Cut properly, in full. One does not hide good work."
"With a sunflower," said Maude. She swallowed, and her diamonds trembled. "He's always hidden it. He shouldn't have to."
There was a pause. Then Maude said, "Callahan first, of course, since we're paying."
"Ashbury first," said Cornelia, "since it is our committee."
"Alphabetical," said Mr. Teague from his corner, without opening his eyes. "A comes before C, ladies. I've kept a lending ledger for thirty years, and it's never yet started a war."
Maude Callahan looked at Cornelia Ashbury. Cornelia Ashbury looked back. Then, in the middle of the crowded wet reading room, Maude began to laugh, a big, unladylike, Pittsburgh laugh, and Cornelia's mouth, after a visible struggle, did something it had not done in public since 1860.
"Very well," Cornelia said. "Alphabetical. But the sunflower goes on top."
They broke ground on a clear cold night in October, after the speeches were done and the reporters had gone home, and the lot on Second Avenue was strung all over with surveyor's twine stretched between wooden stakes, the whole outline of the library drawn on the bare earth like a plan on paper.
Delia stood at the corner under the lamp with her arms folded. "Five minutes," she said. "I'm counting. And I'll not be telling your mother."
"Thank you, Delia."
"Don't thank me. I'll be telling his."
Will lifted a lantern and they walked the lines together, stepping carefully over the twine, while he showed her where everything would go. Here the reading room, all along the front, where the light came in until evening. Here the rack with its long row of hooks. Here the counter, three inches lower than a tall woman's wrist. Grace walked beside him in her ink-blue coat, with her hands warm in her muff and her breath smoking in the cold, and the lamps of the beer garden glowing across the way, and she found she could not speak.
At the front of the outline he stopped, where two stakes stood a little apart, with a gap in the twine between them.
"And here," said Will, "is the door."
Grace stepped into the gap. She stood in the doorway of a building that did not exist yet, on the bare earth, with the whole bright city behind her, and turned to look at him.
"One door," she said. "For everyone."
"For everyone." He set the lantern down on the frozen ground. His voice was not quite steady. "Grace. I've been in love with you since you walked into that cellar hole in March and told me my counter was too high. I measured your wrist in April and I still have the number written in my notebook, and I look at it, which is absurd, it's a number, I'm an architect, I know perfectly well what a number is. I have nothing to offer you that your mother won't hate. I can't promise she'll ever let me through your front door."
"Then build me another one," said Grace.
She reached out of the doorway and took hold of the lapel of his coat, just below the little enamel sunflower, and he bent his head, and she kissed him there, on the threshold of the brightest building on Second Avenue, with the lantern burning at their feet and the twine trembling in the wind.
"That," said Delia loudly from the corner, "is six minutes."
They took separate cabs uptown, two blocks apart, and got down on opposite sides of Fifth Avenue at exactly the same moment, by accident, and stood for a second on their own doorsteps with the whole wide street between them, and looked.
Then Grace went into the Ashbury house, and Will went into the white marble palace, and on both sides of the avenue, at the same instant, a curtain twitched and fell back into place.