Chapter 2: Pie at Five
"You're loving it to death," said Sam.
It was five in the morning on my third day in Blue Hollow, and I was elbow-deep in pie dough. The diner was dark except for the light over the prep counter and the blue glow of the walk-in's thermometer. Outside, the fog was back, pressed up against the windows like it wanted to come in for coffee.
"I'm being thorough," I said.
"You're being a cement mixer. Pie crust is like a bird. You hold it too tight, you kill it." He reached past me, took the bowl, and tipped my dough onto the floured counter. It came out in one sad, shiny lump. "See that? That's a hockey puck. That's what happens when you talk the whole time you work it."
"I wasn't talking the whole time."
"You told me the entire plot of a movie about a dog who becomes mayor."
"That's a great movie."
"It's not a real movie, Nell."
"It's a real movie in my heart." I took the bowl back. "Show me again."
He sighed, the long-suffering sigh of a man whose uncle had taught him to make pie at this exact counter and who had never expected to pass it on to a runaway in a borrowed apron. Then he showed me again. Flour and salt in the bowl. Cold butter and colder lard cut in with two knives until it looked like gravel. Ice water a spoonful at a time, stirred with a fork, the dough just barely coming together, still shaggy, still uncertain about its life choices.
"Stop there," he said. "That's it. That's the whole secret. Stop before you think you should."
He had his reading glasses on, because his uncle's recipe cards were written in pencil in a hand like a seismograph, and every time I glanced at him he pushed them up his nose with a floury knuckle and looked at me like he was daring me to say something.
On the first morning I'd said, "Those are cute."
He'd said, "They're prescription."
"They can be both."
He'd taken them off and put them in his pocket and squinted at the cards for an entire hour rather than let me see him in them again. This morning they were back on. I counted that as a victory. I didn't say a word. I counted that as personal growth.
My second crust came out of the bowl in a soft, crumbly mound that held together when he pressed it with his palm. He looked at it. He looked at me.
"Huh," he said.
From Sam Hollis, I had learned in three days, "huh" was a standing ovation.
Blue Hollow did not run on time. It ran on pie.
The cream pies went in the case at six, the fruit at seven, and by lunchtime the chess pie was gone and someone was always sorry about it. I learned that Mr. Abernathy had been a lineman for the power company for forty years and could tell you which storm had taken out which pole on which road in which decade. I learned that the Pruitt sisters, Loretta and Fay, had not spoken to each other for most of the eighties over a casserole dish, and now spoke to each other constantly, mainly about everybody else. I learned that Junie Calloway's idea of a progress report on the minivan was to come in, order a slice of buttermilk, look at me for a long, thoughtful moment, and say, "Part's coming."
"From where?" I asked her, on day three.
"Lexington."
"Lexington is an hour away."
"Long hour," said Junie, and ate her pie.
Nobody asked me where I'd come from. Nobody asked what I did. Loretta Pruitt asked if I was single, and when I said yes she looked straight at the grill, where Sam was flipping pancakes with his back to us, and said, "Well, isn't that interesting," in a voice you could have heard in Tennessee. Sam dropped a pancake. Fay told her to hush.
And somewhere in there, without anybody announcing it, a mug appeared on the hook by the register. Heavy white diner china, like all the others. But this one had a strip of masking tape on it, and on the tape, in blunt black capitals, it said NELL.
I found it on the morning of day four. I stood there holding it for long enough that Dot came over to see what was wrong.
"Oh, he does that," she said, very casually, pouring coffee into it for me. "Gives everybody their own mug. Junie's got one. Mr. Abernathy's got one." She paused. "Took him about two years to give Mr. Abernathy one, mind you."
I drank my coffee out of my mug and didn't look at the grill. I could feel him not looking at me, too. It was like standing next to a radiator.
On the fourth night, I turned my phone on.
I sat on the edge of the bed in the flat above the diner, with the window unit rattling and the moths bumping softly against the screen, and watched the notifications pour in like water through a broken dam. Two hundred and six missed calls. Texts from Tasha, which got shorter and kinder as they went on, until the last one said only: Keep the van. Love you. Call when you can. Texts from my mother. Texts from people I hadn't heard from in years who had seen the news.
And at the top, a voicemail from Marcus. Four minutes long.
I listened to it with my eyes closed.
"Lyra. Hi. It's me." His voice was tired, and careful, and not angry, which was worse. "Okay. Listen. We told everyone you've got a throat infection. We pushed Nashville and Charlotte. People are mostly being nice about it. Mostly. The label is not being nice about it. They're saying breach. They're saying if you're not on stage in Atlanta on the thirtieth, they walk. And Lyra, the renewal's on the table, and I need you to know what's in it before you decide anything." A pause. Paper rustling. "The no-relationships clause is still in there. They want you single for the whole album cycle. Two years. No public anything. They say it's for the brand. I fought it. I lost." Another pause. "I'm not going to tell you what to do. I know you think I would. Just, please. Call me. I don't need to know where you are. I need to know you're okay."
I put the phone face down on the quilt.
Then I texted him: I'm okay. I'm safe. I'll call before Atlanta. I promise.
Then I turned the phone off again and sat there in the dark for a long time, listening to the moths, and to something else I hadn't noticed at first.
Somebody was playing guitar.
The back steps of the diner went down from the flat to a strip of gravel and a picnic table and, beyond that, a field full of fireflies that went all the way to the tree line. Sam was sitting on the bottom step with an old acoustic guitar across his knee, the kind with the varnish worn pale where a forearm had rested on it for decades. He wasn't playing anything I knew. It was slow and simple, a handful of chords going round and round like a creek over stones, and he was humming under it, low and rough, the kind of voice that sounds better at night.
I sat down on the top step. He didn't stop, so I didn't move.
The tune came round again. And again. And somewhere around the fourth time, without deciding to, I started to sing along. Not words. Just a harmony line above his, a third up, sliding where his slid, the way I used to sing with my granddad on the porch in Ohio before anyone had ever heard my name.
The guitar stopped.
The fireflies went on blinking. A whip-poor-will called out in the trees. Sam turned round on the step and looked up at me, and I couldn't see his face very well in the dark, but I could feel him looking.
"You can sing," he said.
"A little."
"That wasn't a little." He turned the guitar over in his hands. "That was Nashville."
There was a long silence. I came down three steps, until I was sitting just above him, close enough to see the moonlight on the worn spot of the guitar.
"Have you been?" I asked. "To Nashville?"
"Lived there four years." He played a single chord, soft, and let it ring out. "Went down with a singer. Carly-Jo Raines. We grew up two roads apart. She was going to be a star, and I was going to play guitar behind her, and we were going to get married in the church in town and come home every Christmas." He said it flat, like reading out a menu. "She got signed. The label said she'd sell better without a boyfriend in the picture. She agreed with them. I found out from a press release."
"Sam."
"It's fine. It was a long time ago." He set the guitar down on the step beside him. "What wasn't fine was two years later, when she came home with a camera crew for one of those 'back to my roots' specials. Walked into this diner with six people and a boom mic while my uncle was dying in the flat upstairs. Filmed the pie case. Filmed my uncle's grill. Told the camera she used to sit at that counter and dream." His jaw worked. "Never asked. Never called. Never came up the stairs to see him."
The window unit rattled above us. My heart was going very fast.
"That's why," I said. "No cameras. No fans."
"That's why." He looked up at me. "Whatever you're running from, Nell, I don't need to know. I meant that. But I'm not doing it again. I'm not having that world pull into my lot."
I opened my mouth. This was it. This was the moment Dot had warned me about, the moment where I said, Sam, my name's not really Nell, or rather it is, but it isn't the one you'd know.
He was looking at me with those faded-denim eyes. Waiting. Like he already knew there was something, and was giving me the chance.
"Teach me that song," I said instead. "The one you were playing."
Something moved across his face and was gone. Then he picked up the guitar again.
"It hasn't got words," he said.
"Then we'll find some."
We sat out there till past midnight, and he taught me the chords, and I didn't find any words, not that night. But I went upstairs with my fingertips aching and the tune still going round in my head like a creek over stones, and I lay awake in the dark knowing exactly what a coward I was.
The next day, at the height of the lunch rush, Earl the trucker came in, sat at the counter, ordered his cheeseburger with an egg on it, and propped his phone up against the napkin dispenser to watch the news.
He had the volume all the way up. Earl was a little deaf.
"...still no word from pop superstar Lyra Vance, who has now missed three shows on her record-breaking world tour. Her team cites illness, but sources close to the label say the singer has not been seen since..."
I was carrying a tray of sweet teas. I did not drop it. I would like that noted. I set each glass down very carefully in booth five, and smiled at the family in booth five, and turned round.
On Earl's phone, there was a photograph of me. Platinum wig, silver jumpsuit, arms flung wide on a stage in front of a sea of lights.
"Ain't that something, Sam?" said Earl, holding the phone up toward the grill. "Biggest star in the world, and she just up and vanished. Says she could be anywhere."
Sam turned from the grill with the spatula in his hand. He looked at the phone for a long moment. Then his eyes travelled past it, over Earl's shoulder, down the length of the counter, to where I was standing with an empty tray held against my chest like a shield.
He put the spatula down.
"Dot," he said. "Watch the grill." And then, to me, in a voice so quiet the whole diner went still to hear it: "Nell. Back steps. Now."