Chapter 3: Front Porch Rules
The screen door banged shut behind us, and the noise of the diner dropped away, and it was just the gravel and the picnic table and the field going gold in the afternoon heat.
Sam walked to the bottom of the steps and stopped with his back to me. He put his hands on his hips. He looked at the tree line for a long time.
"I'm sorry," I said. "Sam, I'm so sorry. I was going to tell you. I nearly told you last night. I nearly told you the first morning, but you said no fans, and I thought if you knew, you'd..."
"I know," he said.
"...put me back on the road, and I didn't have anywhere else to... What?"
He turned round. He didn't look angry. He looked tired, and something else, something I couldn't read.
"I know who you are," he said. "I've known since the first morning."
I sat down on the step. My legs made the decision without me.
"You sat on that stool," he said, "and a laminated pass fell out of your hoodie pocket and landed by my foot. Big silver thing on a lanyard. Had your face on it. Said ALL ACCESS on it in letters the size of my thumb." He pulled open the pocket of his apron and took it out and held it up, turning slowly on its lanyard in the sun. "I put it in the drawer by the register. I've been carrying it round since you started on the counter so Dot wouldn't find it and frame it."
"Dot knows," I said faintly.
"Of course Dot knows. Dot knows when it's going to rain three days before the clouds do." He came up two steps and sat down on the one below me, the pass dangling between his knees. "Everybody in that room in there probably knows, except Earl. Earl doesn't know what day it is."
"Then why," I said, "why didn't you say anything? Why did you let me stay? After Carly-Jo, after everything, why would you let me anywhere near your diner?"
He was quiet for a while. A grasshopper landed on the step between us and thought better of it.
"Because you walked in at five in the morning," he said slowly, "looking exactly like she looked the night before she signed. Like somebody who'd forgotten what her own name sounded like." He turned the pass over in his fingers. "I couldn't do anything for her. I figured maybe I could give you a week where nobody wanted anything off you."
My throat closed up.
"I wasn't angry that you were famous," he said. "I don't care that you're famous. I was waiting for you to tell me. Every night on those steps. I kept thinking, tonight she'll say it." He looked up at me, and there it was, the thing I hadn't been able to read. It was hurt. "I'm not her, Nell. I'd have kept your secret. You didn't have to keep it from me."
"I know," I said. "I know that. That's why I couldn't." I pressed the heels of my hands against my eyes. "You're the first person in nine years who looked at me and saw somebody who was bad at carrying plates. You know how rare that is? Everyone I meet sees Lyra. You saw Nell. And I thought, the second I tell him, she's gone. And I liked her. I liked being her. I liked..." I stopped.
"Liked what?"
You, I didn't say. Your terrible uncle's handwriting. The mug with my name on it. The way you say huh.
"The pie," I said.
He looked at me for a long moment. Then he stood up, and put the pass on the step beside me, and went back inside without a word, and the screen door banged behind him.
I stayed out on the steps for a long time. When I finally went back in, braced for whatever was waiting, the lunch rush was over, and Earl was paying at the register, and the Pruitt sisters were standing on either side of him like a pair of very small, very determined bouncers.
"Now, Earl," Loretta was saying. "You didn't see anybody in here today but us."
"And Dot," said Fay.
"And Dot. And that nice girl Nell, who's from Ohio and does the counter."
Earl looked from one sister to the other. Then he looked down the counter at me, and I watched it slowly dawn on him, and watched him look back at the Pruitt sisters, and do some quick arithmetic about the rest of his life in this county.
"Saw who?" said Earl, and put on his hat, and left.
Dot came over and put my NELL mug in my hands, full of coffee, and patted my cheek. Behind her, Junie was sitting at the end of the counter with a slice of buttermilk pie.
"Part came in," Junie said, without looking up.
"When?"
"Tuesday."
"Junie, it's Friday."
"Uh-huh." She ate a forkful of pie. "Didn't seem like you were ready to go."
I stood there in the middle of Hollis's Diner, holding my mug, surrounded by people who had known exactly who I was for most of a week and had gone on calling me Nell, and I started to cry, finally, all the crying I hadn't done on the road from Cincinnati. Dot gathered me into her pink uniform and her cloud of hairspray and said, "There, now. There, now," and over her shoulder, through the pass-through window, I saw Sam at the grill, not cooking anything, just standing there with his head down and his hand flat on the steel.
That afternoon, I went upstairs and turned on my phone and called Marcus.
Friday night was picking night.
I'd heard about it all week. By seven, the gravel lot was full of trucks, and the porch that ran along the front of the diner was crowded with folding chairs and coolers and people I'd poured coffee for. Mr. Abernathy had a fiddle. One of the Coulter brothers had a banjo. Someone's aunt played the washboard with a pair of thimbles, and she was better at it than any percussionist I'd ever toured with.
Sam wasn't playing. He was behind the counter, wiping things that were already clean.
I waited until the music had gone round twice and the light was going pink over the field. Then I stood up from the back step where I'd been sitting, walked to the front of the porch, picked up Dot's empty pie tin from the railing, and held it out.
"I'm going to sing something," I said. "I'd be grateful if nobody filmed it."
There was a little silence. Then Loretta Pruitt put her phone in the pie tin. Then Fay. Then everybody, one after another, until the tin was a heap of phones and Dot took it from me and sat down on it.
I'd spent the afternoon at the kitchen table in the flat with a pencil and the back of an order pad. I hadn't written a song on my own in three years. The label had writers for that. Rooms full of them, in Los Angeles and Stockholm, who knew exactly what a hit needed. This one didn't have a hook. It had a creek over stones, and four chords, and words I'd found at last.
I didn't have a guitar. So I started without one.
"There's a light on the porch at the end of the road," I sang, "where nobody knows what I'm worth. There's a mug with my name in a stranger's hand, and it's the first thing that's fit me since birth."
The porch went quiet.
I sang the second verse, about pie crust and holding things too tightly. And somewhere in the middle of it, behind me, I heard the screen door open and close, and a chair scrape, and then the guitar came in under me. Slow and simple, round and round, exactly the chords from the back steps. I didn't turn round. I didn't need to. I knew the worn place on that guitar where his arm rested.
When I got to the end, I sang the last line twice, and the second time he sang it with me, low and rough, a third below.
Nobody clapped for a second. Then everybody did, and Mr. Abernathy stamped his foot on the boards, and Dot took her glasses off and wiped her eyes with a napkin.
That was when the black car pulled into the lot.
Marcus got out in his navy suit in the August dusk, holding both his phones, looking like a man who had driven down from Lexington through an hour of corn and wasn't sure he'd survived it. Every head on the porch turned.
"Is this trouble?" said Sam, quietly, behind me.
"No," I said. "I asked him to come."
Marcus came to the bottom of the porch steps and stopped. He looked at me in my overalls and borrowed apron, with my real hair down and no make-up, and his face did something complicated.
"You look good, Lyra," he said. "You look like you."
"I'll do Atlanta," I said. "I'll finish the tour. Every date. I owe that to the people who bought tickets, and to Tasha, and to you." I took a breath. "But I'm not signing the renewal with that clause in it. If they want two more years of me, they get all of me. And some of me lives here now."
Marcus looked at me for a long moment. Then he looked past me, at Sam, who was standing with the guitar in one hand and his other hand, I realised, very lightly on my shoulder.
"They might walk," said Marcus.
"Then let them walk."
Marcus closed his eyes. And then, to my complete astonishment, he laughed.
"Thank God," he said. "I've hated that clause since the day they wrote it." He held up one of his phones. "I'll call them in the morning. Atlanta's Tuesday. I'll send a car Sunday." He looked at the porch, at the heap of phones under Dot, at the folding chairs and the fiddle and the pie. "Is that peach?"
"Chess," said Dot. "Sit down, honey. You look like you drove through Lexington."
It was nearly midnight when the last truck pulled out of the lot. The fireflies had gone up into the trees. Sam and I sat on the front steps under the porch light with the guitar between us, and for a long time neither of us said anything.
"Sunday," he said finally.
"Sunday."
"And then six weeks."
"Six weeks. Then it's done. Then I come back and find out if I can make a crust without a supervisor."
"You can't."
"I know. I'll need one." I looked at him. "Sam. I'm sorry I didn't tell you."
"I know." He turned toward me on the step. The porch light caught the faded blue of his eyes, and the cord of those ridiculous glasses round his neck, and for once he didn't look grumpy at all. "I'm sorry I made you think you had to keep it."
"You were very scary about the cameras."
"I was very scary about a lot of things." He was quiet a moment. "I'm less scared now."
And then he reached over and took my hand, on the front steps of Hollis's Diner, under the porch light, with the moths bumping softly against the bulb above us. He held it carefully, like it was a crust he was trying not to overwork, and I held on to him and thought, quite clearly, that I had sung in front of sixty thousand people and never once felt anything as loud as this.
After a while he squeezed my fingers, just once, and laughed under his breath.
"Huh," he said.
"Is that good?"
"That's a standing ovation, Nell."
On Saturday morning, I walked down to Junie's garage with my NELL mug full of coffee. The minivan sat in the bay with its hood up, gleaming, fixed, with a full tank.
"Junie," I said. "I need a favour."
She looked up from under a truck.
"I'm going to need you to un-fix that by Sunday," I said, "so I have an excuse to come back for it."
Junie looked at the minivan. She looked at me. Then she wiped her hands slowly on a rag, and for the first time all week, she grinned.
"Honey," she said. "That part could take weeks."