Cover of The Attorney's Dilemma

The Attorney's Dilemma

Read the story

5 chapters · 12149 words · Read 1 times

Mara Henderson, a normally decisive lawyer, is confused. At a recent party, she found herself attracted to her friends Mike and Casey. But which one she wonders while on the way to visit them at their apartment. Their mutual friend Jan, tagging along, just wonders: why not both?

Chapter 5: Freedom from Want

The heavy scent of sex, coffee grounds, and damp earth from the plants hung in the warm air of the apartment. Mara lay sprawled across the rumpled sheets, limbs entwined with Mike’s and Casey’s. Sweat cooled on their skin. Mike snored softly, one arm flung possessively over Mara’s waist, his face buried in the crook of Casey’s neck. Casey traced idle patterns on Mike’s shoulder, her dark eyes half-lidded, a satisfied exhaustion in every line of her body. The silence was thick and comfortable, punctuated only by their breathing and the distant hum of the city outside.

Jan stretched languidly beside them, a feline arch of her freckled back. "Shower," she announced, her voice raspy. "Sticky." She slid out of the tangle of limbs with surprising grace, her bare feet padding silently across the floorboards towards the small bathroom.

Mara watched her go, the sight of Jan’s taut ass and the sway of her fiery hair sparking a low ember within her. The shared intimacy, the raw, consuming pleasure of being taken by Mike while Casey watched and touched herself, then Jan’s demanding mouth… it had forged a new constellation between them, thrilling and terrifying. She felt a pull towards the redhead, a need to chase that playful chaos. "Hold that thought," Mara murmured, disentangling herself carefully from Mike and Casey. Mike grunted in his sleep, his hand searching blindly for a moment before finding Casey’s hip. Mara slipped off the bed, following Jan into the cramped hallway.

The bathroom was tiny, already filling with steam. Jan stood under the spray, her head tilted back, water plastering her short red hair to her skull, highlighting the constellation of freckles across her shoulders. The air was thick with humidity and the clean scent of cheap soap. Mara stepped into the stall, the warm water hitting her skin like a benediction. The confined space forced them close, slick skin sliding against slick skin.

"Couldn't resist, huh?" Jan grinned, turning, her eyes bright even through the steam. Her hands immediately found Mara’s waist, pulling her flush. "Seeing me all wet and naked?" Her voice was a low purr that vibrated against Mara’s collarbone as Jan leaned in, capturing her mouth in a deep, probing kiss. Her tongue was hot and insistent, tasting of whiskey and something uniquely Jan. Mara moaned into it, her hands sliding down Jan’s slippery back to cup her ass, fingers digging into the firm muscle. Water sluiced over them, plastering Mara’s dark hair to her neck.

Jan’s mouth moved from Mara’s lips to her throat, biting gently, then lower, sucking a hard nipple into her mouth. Mara gasped, arching her back, pressing her breast deeper into the heat. Jan’s free hand dipped between Mara’s legs, fingers finding her clit instantly, slick with more than just water. She rubbed tight, fast circles, her thumb pressing hard. "That’s it, Counselor," Jan breathed against her wet skin. "Getting all hot for me again?" Her fingers slid lower, two pushing deep into Mara’s cunt with practiced ease. Mara cried out, her knees buckling slightly, but Jan held her up, fucking her with strong, rhythmic thrusts while her mouth worked Mara’s nipple. The sensations were sharp, immediate, amplified by the confined heat and the relentless pressure of Jan’s touch.

Then, cutting through the rush of water and Mara’s ragged breathing, came another sound. Low, rhythmic gasps. A familiar, breathy sigh – Casey’s. Followed by a deep, guttural groan – Mike’s unmistakable rumble. Then the unmistakable sound of skin slapping against skin, wet and frantic. Thwap… thwap… thwap…

Mara froze, Jan’s fingers still buried deep inside her. She strained to listen over the shower’s spray. "Are they…?" she panted.

Jan lifted her head, water dripping from her nose and chin, a wide, knowing grin spreading across her face. She didn’t stop her hand; her fingers curled upwards, pressing against Mara’s G-spot. "Sounds like Picasso found Mike’s cock again," Jan chuckled, the sound low and rich. "Fuck, listen to him grunt. She’s probably riding him raw."

The sounds intensified – Casey’s high, keening cry, Mike’s wordless growl, the frantic pounding echoing from the bedroom just down the hall. It sent a fresh jolt of heat straight to Mara’s core, mingling with the pleasure Jan was expertly wringing from her. "Jesus, don't they ever quit?" Mara gasped, her hips rocking instinctively against Jan’s hand. "We just… hours ago…"

Jan’s grin softened into something almost tender. She leaned close, her lips brushing Mara’s ear, her fingers still pumping slowly inside her. "That’s how I know they’re a true pair, Mara," she whispered, her voice barely audible over the water and the distant fucking. "Doesn't matter who else shares their bed, who else fucks them or gets fucked by them… they always circle back to each other. Always. It’s… fundamental." She punctuated the last word with a sharp curl of her fingers that made Mara cry out again, her inner walls clenching tight around Jan’s hand. "See? Even hearing it gets you off."

It did. The raw evidence of Mike and Casey's primal connection, happening mere feet away while Jan expertly worked her body under the hot spray, was intensely erotic. Mara came with a sharp, shuddering gasp, her thighs clamping around Jan’s wrist, her orgasm washing over her in powerful waves that left her trembling. Jan held her, steadying her, her fingers gentling as Mara rode it out.

As Mara caught her breath, leaning heavily against the tiled wall, Jan slowly withdrew her hand. She turned off the water. The sudden silence felt loud, amplifying the sounds from the bedroom – Casey’s rhythmic gasps now building towards a crescendo, Mike’s low, encouraging growls.

Jan grabbed two towels, handing one to Mara. "I should head out soon," she said, briskly drying herself. The playful glint was still there, but a hint of underlying fatigue touched her eyes. "Got other people to… help," she added, a familiar, cryptic edge to her voice. "This magic shit takes it out of me. Need to recharge."

Mara toweled herself off, the terrycloth rough on sensitized skin. "Let me drive you home, Jan," she offered, concern momentarily overriding the post-orgasmic haze. "It's late."

Jan shook her head, pulling on her worn jeans and a faded band t-shirt. "Nah. I'll be fine. Promise." She fastened her bra with quick, efficient movements. "Don't need a minder, Counselor."

"You sure?" Mara pressed, stepping closer. "I am your ride." The logistical reality felt grounding.

Jan met her gaze, her eyes holding that unnerving depth again. "Positive. Cab’s easy." She smiled, and somehow, Mara believed her. Completely. The lingering doubt about Jan's "helping" dissolved, replaced by an irrational certainty that Jan could navigate the night unscathed. "Go back to them," Jan said softly, nodding towards the bedroom door, from which Casey’s cries had just peaked in a loud, shuddering wail, followed by Mike’s triumphant shout. "Sounds like they’re just warming up again."

Mara, still gloriously naked and damp, watched as Jan quickly pulled on her boots. The redhead moved to the bedroom door, pushing it open gently. Mara followed, leaning against the frame.

Mike lay on his back, breathing heavily, glistening with sweat. Casey was collapsed half on top of him, her dark hair fanned across his chest, her body still trembling. Both were blissfully spent, for the moment. Jan walked in, leaned down, and placed a soft, lingering kiss on Casey’s damp temple. Casey hummed contentedly, barely stirring. Jan then moved to Mike, kissing his cheek. He blinked sleepily, managing a drowsy, goofy smile. "Night, Red."

"Night, guys," Jan whispered. She caught Mara’s eye, gave her a final wink and a small wave, then slipped silently out of the apartment, closing the door softly behind her.

The sudden quiet felt profound. Mara looked at the tangled, sated forms of Mike and Casey. Mike lifted his head, his kind eyes finding hers. He patted the empty space on the bed beside him. "C'mere," he murmured, his voice thick with sleep and satisfaction.

Casey shifted, lifting her arm in invitation, her eyes dark and warm. "Yeah, Counselor. Plenty of room."

Mara crossed the room, the floor cool beneath her bare feet. She slid between them, the sheets still warm from their bodies and their recent, frantic coupling. Mike’s arm immediately draped over her waist, pulling her close against his solid warmth. Casey nestled against her back, one leg hooking over Mara’s hip, her breath warm on Mara’s shoulder blade. Mike’s other hand found Casey’s arm where it rested across Mara’s stomach, his fingers lacing with hers.

Surrounded, held, the scent of sex and sweat and them enveloping her, Mara felt a profound sense of belonging settle deep in her bones. The promise of the night, thick with passion and tangled intimacy, hummed in the air around them as they drifted towards sleep, a shared breath in the warm, messy sanctuary of their bed.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI