Cover of The Best Man's Last Card

Romance

The Best Man's Last Card

Read the story

3 chapters · 6232 words · Read 0 times

A brother's best friend romance under the Greek sun. Thea Kostas has spent seven years pretending she doesn't notice Declan Hale, the Irish engineer her family adopted at Sunday dinner and her brother Nikos would walk through fire for. Now Nikos is getting married on Paros, and a booking mix-up puts Thea and Declan in neighbouring rooms of the same whitewashed annex for a week. Forced proximity, a secret crush, a boat trip that strands them at sea and a stack of speech cards Thea was never meant to read turn a slow burn into a confession. Declan has always kept the line. Will he say it before the last toast, or let her go for good?

Characters

  • Declan Hale — A structural engineer from Cork who has been Nikos's best friend and the Kostas family's honorary son for seven years. He is best man, and he has spent all that time treating Thea as the one person he is not allowed to want.
  • Nikos Kostas — Thea's older brother, the groom, and Declan's best friend. Everyone assumes he would never forgive either of them.
  • Priya Raman — Nikos's bride, an anaesthetist who notices everything and says about a third of it.
  • Thea Kostas — A Boston pastry chef and the younger sister of the groom. She has been quietly in love with her brother's best friend for seven years and has decided this wedding week is when she finally gets over him.
  • Yiayia Eleni — Thea and Nikos's grandmother, born on Paros, who calls Declan 'the Irish one' and has opinions about his appetite.

Chapter 1: The Annex

The ferry from Piraeus was ninety minutes late, which by Greek standards is practically early, and by the time it backed into Parikia harbour the sky had gone the colour of apricot jam and I had eaten every almond in my bag.

I'd texted my brother from the top deck. Nikos sent back a thumbs-up, and then, four minutes later: Can't get away. Priya's mum found a problem with the chairs. Someone's coming for you.

Someone. I had a long list of people I hoped that meant, and a short list of people I hoped it didn't, and the short list had one name on it.

He was leaning against a dusty white pickup at the end of the quay, arms folded, sunglasses pushed up into his hair, reading his phone as though eight hundred tourists hadn't just poured off a boat in front of him. Declan Hale. Six foot three of Irish engineer, my brother's best friend for seven years, the man my mother still introduced as "our Declan" at parties, and the single most inconvenient person in my life.

I considered getting back on the ferry.

"Theodora," he said, without looking up.

"Nobody calls me that."

"Your yiayia does."

"My yiayia is eighty-three and has earned it." I stopped in front of him and dropped my duffel at his feet, partly so I'd have something to do with my hands. "Where's Nikos?"

"Arguing with a man about chair sashes." He finally put the phone away and looked at me properly, and I felt it all the way down to my sandals, which was exactly the problem and had been the problem since the first Sunday dinner he'd ever come to, when he'd eaten three helpings of my mother's pastitsio and then washed every pot in the kitchen without being asked. "You look well."

"I look like I've been on a boat for five hours."

"That too." He picked up my bag before I could reach for it. "Come on. There's been a development with the villa."

The development, it turned out, was that the villa my brother had rented for the wedding party had seven bedrooms and the wedding party had nine people in it, and somebody, and Declan was very careful not to say who but his face said Nikos, had forgotten to count.

"So there's an annex," Declan said, swinging the pickup around a hairpin bend at a speed I didn't love. Below us the coast unrolled in white cubes and blue doors, fishing boats knocking together in the little harbour of Naoussa, a line of tavernas with their tables set right on the edge of the water. "Down the garden. Two rooms, one bathroom, a kitchen the size of a shoebox. Your mum and dad are in the main house with your yiayia. Priya's family took the top floor."

"And who's in the other annex room?"

He changed gear. He didn't answer.

"Declan."

"I offered to stay in the town," he said. "There's a guesthouse by the harbour. Nikos wouldn't hear of it. He said, and I'm quoting, 'It's Thea, man, it's not like it's a stranger.'"

Of course he did. In my brother's head I was still the sister who stole the last slice of everything and borrowed his car without asking, and Declan was his brother in every way but blood, and the idea that either of us could be anything other than safe in a room together had genuinely never crossed his mind.

It had crossed mine. It had set up a summer house in mine.

"Fine," I said. "Do you snore?"

"I've never had a complaint."

"That's not the same as no."

The corner of his mouth went up. He kept his eyes on the road.

The annex was beautiful, which made it worse. It sat at the bottom of a terraced garden full of lemon trees and bougainvillea, a low white box with a flat roof and a blue door and a tiny terrace looking straight over the water. Inside, two bedrooms opened off a kitchen where you could stand at the sink and touch the stove and the fridge without moving your feet. The walls were so thin I could hear him put his watch down on the nightstand.

I unpacked quickly. I'd brought too many dresses and not enough sense. On the bottom of the case, wrapped in a tea towel, was a tin of the koulourakia I'd baked at the restaurant at four in the morning before my flight, because I'd known my yiayia would ask and because when I'm nervous I make things with butter in them.

Declan was in the kitchen when I came out, trying to work the espresso pot.

"You're putting the coffee in the wrong part," I said.

"I'm not."

"You are. That's where the water goes."

He looked at the pot, then at me, and handed it over with the dignity of a man surrendering a sword. I fixed it. He watched me do it, leaning on the counter, and the kitchen was too small for him to lean anywhere that wasn't eighteen inches from my elbow.

"How's the restaurant?" he asked.

"Good. Busy. The new chef wants me to put lavender in everything."

"Is that bad?"

"Lavender in moderation is lovely. Lavender in everything is like eating a grandmother's drawer."

He laughed, a short surprised sound, and I wished I didn't still keep a running count of the times I'd made him do it. I put the pot on the flame and opened the tin.

He reached in. I slapped his hand.

"Those are for Yiayia."

"She won't miss one."

"She counts them. She'll know it was you. She already thinks you're too thin. She'll take it as a cry for help."

"I'm not too thin."

I didn't look at him, because I'd seen him at the beach in Gloucester last August and I had views on the subject, and none of them were fit for a kitchen this size.

"Have one," I said. "One."

He took one. He ate it in two bites and closed his eyes, and I had to turn around and stare very hard at the coffee pot.

"Thea," he said, "if you ever leave that restaurant, I'll fund the bakery myself."

"You'd go broke. I'd make you eat every failure."

"I know," he said, and there was something odd in his voice, and when I turned back he was looking out the little window at the water and not at me at all.

Dinner was at the main house, which meant it was loud. My mother cried twice before the main course. My father and Priya's father discovered a shared hatred of the Yankees and became best friends over the grilled octopus. Priya, unflappable in a pressed green sundress with pockets, ran the seating plan from her phone like a field marshal. Yiayia Eleni sat at the head of the table in her black dress and enormous sunglasses, though the sun had set an hour ago, and pointed her walking stick at whoever she wanted to speak next.

She pointed it at Declan.

"The Irish one. Come. Sit."

He went and sat. Everybody does.

"Eat," she told him, and loaded his plate.

"Yiayia, he's had two plates."

"Two plates is for birds." She patted his arm. "When are you marrying?"

There was a beat of quiet at our end of the table. Nikos, opposite me, snorted into his wine.

"Not any time soon, Mrs Kostas," Declan said.

"Why not? You're handsome. You have a good job. You build bridges."

"Car parks, mostly."

"A car park is a bridge that has given up," Yiayia said, which made no sense, and she said it with total conviction, so everybody nodded. "You need a wife. A Greek wife. She will feed you."

"He's fine, Yiayia," Nikos said. "Declan's married to his spreadsheets."

"Spreadsheets do not cook." Her sunglasses swivelled, slow as a lighthouse, until they landed on me. I felt the hair on my arms stand up. "Theodora cooks."

"Okay," I said brightly. "Who wants more salad?"

Nikos laughed so hard he had to put his fork down. "Thea and Declan. Can you imagine? They'd kill each other in a week. Dec, mate, you'd last a day. She'd make you alphabetise the spice rack."

"I alphabetise my own spice rack," Declan said mildly.

"See? You'd fight about the order."

Everybody laughed. I laughed too, a little late. Across the table, Priya was not laughing. She was looking at me over her gold-rimmed glasses with an expression I'd seen her use on surgeons who claimed they'd washed their hands.

I passed the salad to nobody.

I couldn't sleep. The meltemi had picked up after midnight and it worried at the shutters, and every time it dropped I could hear the creak of his bed through the wall, the shift of a big man trying to get comfortable on a mattress built for a smaller country.

At one o'clock I gave up. I pulled a long cardigan over my sleep shirt, took a towel, and went down the stone steps at the bottom of the garden to the cove.

It was a scrap of a beach, barely a beach at all, a crescent of pale pebbles between two arms of rock, the water black and silver under a moon that was almost full. I swam at home every morning before service, lengths in a chlorinated pool beneath a gym in Somerville, and there was nothing in the world like the Aegean at night, cold enough to make you gasp and so clear you could see the moon on the pebbles six feet down.

I swam out to the rocks and back twice. When I came in, he was sitting on the steps.

"Christ," I said, standing in the shallows. "You scared me."

"You scared me first. I heard the door go. I thought someone was breaking in."

"So you came to fight a burglar in your socks?"

He looked down at his feet. He was in fact wearing socks, grey ones, and a T-shirt with the logo of a concrete supplier on it, and he'd brought a torch he hadn't switched on. "I'd have improvised."

I came out of the water and he held out my towel without being asked, at arm's length, his eyes politely fixed on a point somewhere over my left shoulder. I wrapped myself up. We stood there for a minute, the wind snapping the edge of the towel, the water whispering on the stones.

"Nikos asked me to keep an eye on you this week," he said.

That stung more than it should have. "I'm thirty, Declan."

"I know how old you are." He said it quietly, and something in the way he said it made me look up. He was still looking at the sea. "I told him you'd hardly need it. He said it wasn't about you. He said it was about the waiters."

I laughed despite myself. "The waiters?"

"Apparently the waiters on this island are very charming. He has concerns."

"Do you have concerns?"

He took a moment too long to answer. "I have a speech to finish," he said, and stood up. "Don't swim alone at night. The current changes round those rocks."

"Is that an engineering opinion?"

"It's a me opinion," he said, and went back up the steps, and didn't look back, and I stood dripping on the pebbles feeling like someone had handed me a gift and then taken it back before I could open it.

The annex light was still on when I got back. He'd gone to bed; his door was shut. On the tiny kitchen table, next to my tin of biscuits, which now had one fewer in it than when I'd left, lay a stack of white index cards held together with a rubber band.

The best man's speech.

I didn't mean to read it. I want that on the record. I meant to move it so I could put the kettle on, and the rubber band was old and it snapped, and the cards fanned out across the table under the lamp.

Most of them were exactly what you'd expect. Met Nikos at the firm's induction. Both wore the same tie. He told me I was holding the drawings upside down. I was not. Then a story about a parking garage in Quincy. Then something about Priya, careful and funny and kind.

The last card was different. The handwriting was smaller, and it had been crossed out and rewritten so many times the paper was soft.

The truth is, I've been in love with someone in this family for a long time, and I've never said it, because

It stopped there. Just stopped, mid-sentence, like he'd put the pen down and walked away from it.

I read it four times. Then I gathered every card back into a stack, in order, and put the broken rubber band on top, and went to my room, and lay on the narrow bed listening to the wind and the slow tick of his old watch through the wall.

Someone in this family.

There were exactly three single women in my family on this island. One was my yiayia. One was my cousin Marina, who was engaged to a dentist in Thessaloniki.

And one of them was me.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI